The constructivist turn in international relations (IR) has spawned a plethora of writing seeking alternative pathways to mainstream realist and liberal thinking. However, few studies have extended constructivist thinking to the Middle East with an explicit recognition both of the political specificity of the region and the confluence of strategic and symbolic dimensions of actor rationality. Jihad for Jerusalem is a bold foray into that terrain. Straddling two fields of inquiry, IR and Middle East studies, the book's principal aim is to offer “a new theory of agency” that bridges rational and interpretative approaches to international action. Based on the assumption that agency remains an undertheorized area in IR, Khan proposes “rational constructivism,” an amalgam of the ideas of contingency and mutual constitution, rationality, and epistemological pluralism. The three key questions guiding the study are: “When are agents' choices shaped completely by structural factors, and when do agents act in a manner that challenges structural imperatives? Is there a difference in the nature of agents (identity) that makes them act differently under similar structural conditions?” (p. 10).
In setting up his framework of analysis, Khan distinguishes between stable and contested systems. “In stable systems, structures are strongly constitutive, and in contested systems agents are highly transformative” (p. 204). What sets this study apart from conventional constructivist accounts is the author's recognition of the salience of strategic thinking to agency. Unlike constructivists, who fall into either the rational or the interpretative camp, Khan stresses the need for both explanation and understanding in IR, deploying “both positivist methods and interpretative techniques . . . free from the insidious influence of the postmodern rejection of science” (p. 115–16).
The lynchpin of this study is a conception of agency that includes three elements: rationality, identity, and power. Khan accepts the rationalist assumption of an “innate” rational capacity in human beings. In turn, he takes identity as a social construction but one that is also “existentially necessary.” Power has a dual nature, causal and constitutive. Khan's principal claim is that actors “always face the dilemma of acting according to their identity and values (symbolic choices/action), or according to their capacity (strategic choices/actions).” He further distinguishes between core and instrumental interests; the former are essential for the actors' self-conceptions, and the latter are substitutable. Jerusalem provides the fulcrum to assess the validity of his theory of agency, one resting on an integration of its structural and symbolic dimensions, particularly the transformative character of agency.
The book is almost evenly divided into two major parts. Khan devotes the first part, consisting of the first four chapters (101 pages), to building his alternative explanation of the role of identity in IR, providing a “genealogy of agency.” The second part examines the centrality of Jerusalem in the symbolic economy of four major states: Israel, Iran, Saudi Arabia, and Jordan. Each country receives a chapter and the book's conclusion addresses “the future of Jerusalem.” Khan uses metaphorical language to characterize his cases, describing Israel as a tiger, Iran as a cub, Saudi Arabia as a paper tiger, and Jordan as a mouse. The choice of Jerusalem allows Khan to explore the interplay between symbolic and strategic choice given the historical and political importance of the city to these national actors. Throughout his study, Khan applies a modernist lens to understand the Middle East, exemplified by the following statement:
The contemporary Middle East remains a highly contested political arena, a region where modernity has failed to completely establish its hegemony. Constitutive institutions of modernity such as the nation-state, secularism, individualism, democracy, and economic rationality have failed to root themselves as deeply and firmly here as they have in North America, East Asia, and Europe. A combination of modernity, artificial nation-states, authoritarianism, secularism, vestigial traditions, and cultural and religious practices and institutions all co-exist (p. 103).
Khan builds his analysis around the assumption of an overdetermined religious character of the Middle East. However, he relaxes this assumption between a strictly essentialist account of identity, one overlaid with religion, and a more constructivist image of the symbolic character of his four cases. Although the two registers remain separate, the case material gives Jihad for Jerusalem parsimony.
Jihad for Jerusalem is principally aimed at an IR audience, although IR students of the Middle East will find the book provocative in explaining/understanding the divide between the rhetorical excess of state actors and their actual choices with regard to foreign policy in the region. Furthermore, the diversity of the four cases gives the comparativist a tool to overcome the strictures of area studies. Although generally familiar to the specialist, the empirical detail in the case studies is nicely reworked in accordance with a theory of agency. Jihad for Jerusalem is a welcome addition to the social–scientific literature in IR and the Middle East.
