Oxford Handbooks seek to publish “essays from leading figures in the discipline” and to “give critical examinations of the progress and direction of debates, as well as a foundation for future research.” The editors define the aim of the handbook as the filling of a gap between richly illustrated introductory textbooks and the professional literature that is usually focused on specific problems. The volume seeks to be a “compendium of new technical, scientific, literary, and theoretical approaches to the study of Roman sculpture.” Additionally, the editors intend to provide a volume on Roman sculpture in English for both students and scholars (2). The handbook presents 41 contributions on different aspects of Roman sculpture. The editors’ introduction states the goals and organization of the volume, as well as the direction of future research. The work is divided into six parts, each section containing five to eight contributions without footnotes (which would certainly have helped the reader at some points) but with bibliographies by chapter. The structure of the articles is similar: an introduction defining the subject and the aim of the chapter, sometimes with a short summary of the state of research, an outline of the most important topics, methodologies, and a conclusion. A larger number of illustrations would have provided a better visual aid for the reader.
Part I: Collecting, conservation, and display
Unconventionally, the editors decided to begin with “Collecting, conservation, and display”, which is discussed in five articles, including practices of collecting and conservation in Europe and North America, as well as current trends in display of ancient objects in museums and the benefit or advantage of three-dimensional scanning and modelling of sculpture. E. Bartman opens with the history of collecting from the 15th c. onwards. At that time the provenance of a statue was normally of no importance for the collector. The pieces frequently had a succession of owners. Bartman highlights the role of the papacy in collecting ancient art, especially in the 14th c. The foundations of the Vatican's Belvedere collection were laid by Pope Julius II in the early 16th c. Increasing interest in antiquity led to the unearthing of sculptures such as the Laocoon group, the Dirce group, and the Heracles Farnese, named after the Farnese family, who, like the Barberini and Borghese families, established collections of antiquities in the 17th c.
J. Podany treats conservation and restoration, discussing the two approaches: to preserve a statue “as it is” or to restore it “as we think it might have been.” His main focus is on restorations from the Renaissance up to the 20th c. and on today's preferred approach, which is to leave a statue “as is.” He cites a statue of a god in the Dresden Albertina that underwent different manners of restoration in the 19th c.; all the restored elements have now been removed and today the statue appears just as it came to light. Alternative methods of non-interventionist restoration are discussed, including computer modelling. Podany elaborates a different approach in scholarship to the value of a non-restored statue as a historic monument and a work of art.
American collections of sculptures and of casts are H. Mallampati Gleason's theme. The interest in collecting for private cast collections began in the 18th c.; universities and academies developed only later, following the American Revolution. Among the best known are the collections of the New York Institute of Fine Arts and of the Boston Museum of Fine Arts. Later on, several elite universities established cast collections for study purposes. The author highlights the role of Italy as a source country and the consequences of its new law on acquisitions for American collections in the early 20th c. The author also underscores the educational value of a cast collection and of collections of original Greek and Roman sculpture. In addition, sociopolitical aspects of involvement with classical civilizations are emphasized in the article. Museums founders who were aiming to promote education for all social classes made major contributions, as in the case of C. C. Perkins with the Boston Museum of Fine Arts.
The challenge of reaching visitors from all fields is discussed by J. Powers as she considers changes in the policy of displaying objects. New ways of exhibiting ancient art include, for example, aspects of figure types, thematic compositions, juxtaposing different kinds of objects, and even explaining to visitors the scientific approach of archaeologists and museum curators. B. Frischer praises the advantages of 3-D digital models of statues (as opposed to casts). He offers a short overview of the development of 3-D data capture from the 1950s onwards. What is good for data collections and study purposes, however, may not necessarily be good for display purposes or for conveying the idea of an original statue. In fact, a cast may distort the idea of an original, even though it is useful for study purposes.
Part II: Production and distribution
The substantial Part II deals with production and distribution in all its facets and in an uneven order, ranging from quarries and sculptors, via processes of re-carving and the role of copying Greek sculptures in Roman times, to clay figurines, polychromy, and finally transport, distribution, and workshops. It begins with an examination of the role of marble quarries in antiquity and of marble analyses by P. Pensabene, E. Gasparini, and M. Carlucci. Analyses to distinguish the origin of white marbles have become indispensable. The authors discuss the administration of quarries under imperial control from the Augustan era onwards, although private local quarries existed too. Contextual examinations such as historical, archaeological, economic, social, and political aspects have to be considered as well, as the authors rightly maintain.
Roman sculptors are the focus of A. Claridge. She emphasizes techniques for working marble, as well as tools, figure types, and models, and demonstrates how sculptures were copied. She also discusses the different meanings of workshops. Craftsmen either worked in the quarries or in an officina at the site where statues were finished before they were installed. In addition, she provides an “all-inclusive” overview of the professionals, their status, their (mostly Greek) origin, and the value of their work, often demonstrated by inscriptions naming either the sculptor or the patron. Greek citizens predominate in the inscriptions. The high prestige of Aphrodisian sculptors outside Asia Minor is proven by travelling craftsmen.
The well-known practice of re-use and re-carving of ancient sculpture is treated by E. R. Varner, who discusses representative examples from Augustan times down to late antiquity, especially portraits, where signs of re-carving are easily recognizable. The value of Roman copies for a better understanding of original Greek bronzes and how Roman sculptors operated is well known. The next chapter (C. C. Mattusch) highlights Roman bronze sculpture in written sources. The finds from the Villa dei Papiri at Herculaneum are of inestimable value for contextual analyses of bronze figures and for a study of finishing methods such as gilding in Roman times. The elder Pliny introduced the successful bronze sculptor Zenodorus and passed down the techniques of bronze casting. Mattusch describes the process of casting a bronze statue, underlining her observations with helpful drawings. Another non-marble group of objects, namely terracottas, is studied by A. Erlich. Most terracottas are figurines; a few larger figures are also preserved. The production of clay figurines has already been well explored, as have contextual questions. Erlich focuses on production centers across the empire, elaborating on regional iconographic and typological peculiarities.
The extended analyses by V. Brinkmann and others on the polychromy of sculptures in recent years have demonstrated the important need to understand colored white marble sculpture.Footnote 1 Here, M. B. Abbe summarizes the results, concentrating on artistic evidence for painted sculpture. A gemstone in the Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, shows an artist is sitting in front of a portrait, painting the hair and the face of a sculpture. The use of colored stone and porphyry which did not need to be painted is discussed in the context of polychromy, as are bronzes.
B. Russell discusses the transport and distribution of sculpture in both unfinished and finished states. Itinerant workshops and craftsmen were common and they probably accompanied partly finished statues to their final destination. Shipwrecks and their cargo have enlarged our knowledge of the subject, as the author points out.
Part III: Styles and genres
Part III contains a mixture of contributions on style and genres, again discussing the value of Roman copies, both sculpture and portraits. Another group deals with different topics, from archaism in Roman sculpture and the Egyptian style to the characteristics of Late Antique sculpture. First comes a theoretical discussion by M. D. Fullerton on applications and limitations of style. Going back to Johann Joachim Winckelmann and the more differentiated view of Otto Brendel, Fullerton tries to define style in Roman sculpture. This is a difficult task since a “regression” across the centuries down to Late Antiquity is evident, by comparison with the development towards stylistic “perfection” in Greek sculpture from Geometric to Hellenistic times. Fullerton points to well-known stylistic traditions, for example, the naturalistic element in Republican Rome and the ideological element in Imperial sculpture, the latter making possible the attribution of sculpture to a particular emperor.
N. T. De Grummond focuses on the characteristics of Etruscan sculpture. She highlights the role and influence of Etruscan artists who came to Rome, using sources such as Pliny and Livy. The expressive style of the human figures and monumental sculpture made by Etruscan artists who worked at Rome is striking. The early forms of the tunic and toga are linked to early Roman Republican dress; as a result, identifying Roman and Etruscan is no longer a point of discussion. The same is true for realistic portraiture. A theme in Etruscan art in the 3rd c. BCE is the depiction of processions; this led to a tradition in Roman triumphs.
Several scholars have recently considered ideal sculpture and copies of Greek sculpture, arguing also for the value of Roman sculpture as such. Here, A. Anguissola interprets Roman statues as inventive creations, rather than as copies of Greek prototypes in the sense of reproductions. The importance of contextual analysis is exemplified by Greek caryatids as the prototypes and Roman copies in the Forum of Augustus and at the Villa Adriana. Similar discussions arise with respect to portraiture and replicas, especially of emperors and their families. The aim of replicas is comparable to a copy, but the intent may be different, depending on the display context and interaction with the viewer. Individual physiognomic variations introduced by provincial artists have to be considered, as S. Wood underlines.
Monumental reliefs are discussed by M. Grunow Sobocinski and E. Wolfram Thill, consciously avoiding the terms “historical” or “state” reliefs. They discuss the limits in the interpretation of monumental reliefs, but largely leave aside the context of a historical point of view. One has to consider, however, that the historical point of view is not necessarily disturbed by adding, for example, allegorical or divine figures to the images of historical personae. The section on chronology and distribution demonstrates the difficulty of rejecting the term “historical” when most of the monumental reliefs have an evident historical context in Rome or the provinces. Difficulties also arise when the archaeological context is lacking and when modern topographic contexts distort the ancient point of view. The authors state the need for more contextual studies and analyses of monumental reliefs, but those have indeed been a feature of scholarly research for many years.Footnote 2
L.-A. Touchette links the terms “archaism” and “eclecticism” in Roman art to the phenomenon of the transfer of Greek art to the Roman sphere. She assigns terracottas an important role in this transfer, especially as viewed by German scholars. A similar phenomenon is treated by M. Swetnam-Burland with respect to the Egyptian style in numerous Roman works. Historical events and the growing relationship between Rome and Egypt led to a greater interest in Egyptian religion and culture. The same issues arise with respect to expensive Egyptian stones, which point to wealthy customers.
Part III ends with a chronological leap forward as C. Witschel focuses on the characteristics of sculpture of the 3rd to 6th c., and especially on changes and continuity in the production and use of sculpture. This topic has been increasingly dealt with in recent years by publications which demonstrate new and different approaches to sculpture in Late Antiquity that encompass the characteristic styles, the re-working of Roman sculptures, and signs of iconoclasm.Footnote 3
Part IV: Spatial and social contexts
Part IV, containing eight contributions on contextual questions of space and social phenomena, begins with B. Longfellow's discussion of the architectural settings of Roman sculpture. Not only does the sheer quantity of sculpture and statues displayed in public spaces emphasize the importance of the self-representation of emperors and their family members, as well as other honorific individuals, but the often over-lifesize sculptures in baths, nymphaea, and elsewhere also point to an espousal of megalomania. This sheds light on a social phenomenon: the juxtaposition of ideal and portrait statues reflects social ideas, as the author rightly points out.
M. M. McCarty discusses religious dedications, including sculptures, reliefs, and other artefacts. The local or regional aspect of dedications and votives is demonstrated with regard to types, dress, and signifiers within ritual contexts. E. K. Gazda analyzes domestic displays of sculptures with a focus on private and social settings and on various traditions. Sculptural evidence from the villa at Oplontis is considered, as well as the sculptural display at Punta Epitaffio, Baiae, and both are then compared to traditional displays in villas in Campania and in the provinces. Social aspects relating to the owner, regional traditions, and ‘contemporary fashions’ could also have found a place in her discussion.
B. Ewald focuses on private funerary monuments with sculptural decoration. He illustrates the development from the late 1st c. BCE to the 3rd c. CE by citing particular examples. He refers to five classes of funerary monuments: reliefs, altars, urns, kline monuments, and sarcophagi. The function of funerary monuments and the status of the images and the personae (e.g., whether the individual was still alive when the monument was executed), bringing in evidence from Greek culture, has been much discussed. The phenomenon suggests a retrospective point of view: deceased persons and individuals who were still alive were shown together on a funerary monument to commemorate life with the now-deceased individual. This phenomenon may also have been caused by an unforeseen death and the desire to commemorate the family member. Ewald adds a consideration of social aspects and the issue of patronage with respect to the different classes of monuments.
S. L. Tuck deals with inscribed statue bases for portrait statues and the information that the inscriptions provide (the statues are mostly not preserved). These inscriptions convey important information about the individual honored, the dedicator, and the historical and local context. Tuck differentiates between individual patronage and displays of imperial families by way of the dedication of sculptures at Perge by Plancia Magna and various sculptures at Ephesus, as well as some dedications at Rome which focus on the tituli. The numerous statue bases and inscriptions from Aphrodisias are missing in this context (Asia Minor does receive a chapter later in the book) and the important database from the University of Oxford on the last statues of antiquity is not cited among the databases of inscriptions.
B. Kellum studies elite patronage and the imperial messages of sculpture down to Late Antiquity. She assumes that the evidence of iconoclasm on statues in public places served the comfort of Christian visitors by covering up, for example, the genitals. This is also discussed in the chapters by Witschel and Kristensen. Social aspects of Roman sculpture are likewise addressed by L. H. Petersen through juxtaposing elite and non-elite patronage and the ways in which messages were communicated. However, the term “non-elite” should be defined more specifically with regard to the profession of different kinds of patrons or social groups.
In addition to elite patronage, gender aspects of Roman patronage in sculpture are considered by E. D'Ambra and F. Tronchin. Although an abundance of female sculptures exists, women held a minor social role. The authors rightly emphasize the groundbreaking work of R. Bianchi-Bandinelli and N. B. Kampen in this regard;Footnote 4 both addressed different social aspects of non-imperial female representation, which included portraits and statues of heroines, as well as depictions of women at work, wooden dolls, and hermaphrodites, to name just a few examples.
Part V: Regions and provinces
Part V, on sculpture in the provinces, encompasses more or less all regions of the empire except the northeast (e.g., Pannonia and Dacia). K. Cassibry provides an overview of sculpture in the northern provinces and Britain. She emphasizes the influence of the Romans and the different styles of the sculptures, permitting a specific regional characterization due to the work of indigenous sculptors and craftsmen. She presents new approaches in the evaluation of regional sculpture as a result of cultural change at a local level.
Investigating Hispania and Gallia Narbonensis, A. Jiménez and I. Rodà highlight the indigenous sculptural tradition created by several local workshops in the Republican period. Greek influence on the east coast of the Iberian peninsula was limited to the main centers of commerce. Local style is evident, especially in funerary sculpture down to the 2nd c. CE. Decoration in houses increased after the second half of the 1st c. CE. During the 2nd c., marbles imported for imperial monuments came to be a sign of Romanization, reflecting a close relationship with Rome.
The importance of Roman influence in north Africa is shown by F. Baratte and N. de Chaisemartin. Illustrating the various approaches to Roman sculpture, from those following in Greco-Roman traditions to those displaying indigenous elements (e.g., Punic stelae), the authors aim to present the variety of the sculptural landscape: Greco-Roman sculpture encompassing religious and mythological sculpture, portraits, monumental reliefs, and sarcophagi, as well as local and indigenous sculptures. The prevailing use of imported Proconnesian marble in roughed-out forms suggests specific orders by individual customers. Attic and Roman workshops are attested working on the decoration of public buildings. Finished sculptures were imported but foreign sculptors also came to Africa and trained local craftsmen.
Roman sculpture in Greece mostly consists of ideal sculpture, imperial and private portraits, and funerary sculpture. It points to the continuing strong tradition of sculptural production. Numerous copies of Archaic, Classical, and Hellenistic statues in various types were displayed in public and private, testifying to highly creative workmanship, as M. C. Sturgeon notes. Many of the works were described by Pausanias and survive in replicas found in Italy, especially in villas. The amount of sculptural decoration present in Greece can be imagined on the basis of recent finds. Itinerant workshops and workshop activities are attested.
D. Y. Ng treats Roman sculpture in Asia Minor, a region with an outstanding number and high quality of finds. Scholars agree that a ‘Hellenistic’ aura continued to be present in sculpture of the Roman period. The important role of local elites in erecting statues is evident, often thanks to surviving inscriptions. The chapter mainly focuses on sites. Topics treated include contexts (e.g., the influence of the Second Sophistic), sculptural programs, portraiture, and sarcophagi (with an emphasis on Aphrodisias); workshop traditions linked to marble quarries are also considered.
Roman sculpture in Egypt is discussed by C. Riggs. She highlights an enthroned statue of Horus with well-preserved traces of color. Settings, subjects, and the meaning of sculpture for society in Roman Egypt are all treated, including depictions of statues on lamps and coins. There is also a short overview of sculptural materials, with several different types covered.
T. M. Weber considers sculpture in the Near East (defined as Syria, the Levantine region, Saudi Arabia, Yemen, western Iraq and southeast Turkey). The chapter is divided into short sections focused on the material, beginning with metal. The majority of pieces are of imported marble or are imported sculptures, contrasting clearly with those of local workmanship and local stone (e.g., basalt or limestone). As mentioned above, further studies of sculptural material in the Near East and other provinces could have provided a better understanding of the overall organization of the profession and of the movement of works of sculpture into and back from the provinces.
Part VI: Viewing and reception
Finally, Part VI covers various questions of the reception of sculptures (e.g., in Latin literature) and theoretical approaches on the viewing of sculpture. The display of sculpture in antiquity, images of sculptures in various media, and interactions between humans and sculpture are likewise discussed in this part, which is completed by an article on iconoclasm. This section would also have fit in Part I to compare the approach to sculpture in antiquity and in modern times. M. Squire considers sculpture in literature through three key works: Cicero's Letters, Pliny's Natural History, and Quintilian's Education of an Orator. Critical and detailed views of the characteristic and stylistic features of elite sculptors such as Polycleites and Praxiteles provide insight into how sculpture was perceived in Roman society.
J. Trimble addresses reception theory of Roman sculpture in antiquity. She considers four scholarly approaches: the theory of two members of the “Constance School,” H. R. Jauss and W. Iser, and sociohistorical studies on the power of images and the viewer's perception.Footnote 5 The focus of Jauss and Iser lies in the interaction of the work with a viewer, at the level of the viewer's expectations. This theoretical approach can be illustrated, for example, in portrait statuary, by juxtaposing individual portraits with generic or idealized bodies, or juxtaposing movement with a static position. Setting and display evoked social status; they also played a significant role in the perception of sculpture by the intended audience. The basic question is: What was a sculpture intended to communicate to the viewer? This question encompasses iconography, style, typology, material, setting, and patron, among other issues. Each place or each work has therefore to be discussed in its specific setting and context. By contrast, how are we able to evaluate art or sculpture which was not on public display? The challenge is to find different approaches for judging and understanding sculpture.
J. Shaya investigates ancient analogues of today's museums. She emphasizes different public places and buildings where sculptures were displayed and which had functions similar to those of museums. She also discusses methods of acquisition, the organization of collections, contexts of display, construction of images, epigraphic frames, cultural heritage, and identities. In many ways there are analogous issues for today's museums.
Statues shown on gems, tableware, coins, mosaics, and paintings are analyzed by E. M. Moormann. They often provide additional information – for example, on lost works, types, taste, polychromy, settings, and architectural landscapes. The variety of information conveyed by paintings and mosaics is highlighted with examples from the Vesuvian region and the northern provinces, which show how statue types were disseminated to different contexts. Also discussed is the phenomenon of animated and “living statues” in the sense of figures on two-dimensional objects which cannot be recognized as statues but which appear as images of “living” figures (e.g., two-dimensional mythological figures which in some cases are treated as living [648–49]).
E. E. Perry treats several aspects which are discussed earlier in the volume but she focuses mainly on human interaction with statues. Primarily, she extracts information from literary sources regarding the use of statues during ritual celebrations and processions. Statues which functioned as talismans are subsumed in a section discussing rituals (bathing, clothing, feeding). She addresses the handling of statues in a procession or during lectisternia (religious banquets), as well as miraculous phenomena such as the evocatio, prodigies, and expiations. Lastly, she considers the interaction of visitors with portraits and imperial statues, reactions to and against statues, and imperial statues serving as sites of asylum, as well as the reaction of viewers to the display and removal of imperial images.
T. M. Kristensen treats the oft-studied phenomenon of iconoclasm, connected, on the one hand, with damnatio memoriae and, on the other, with religious conflicts. He addresses visual abuse and verbal desecration equally. The difficulty of fixing the date and context of iconoclasm is also mentioned. Kristensen points to the necessity for meticulous documentation of such sculptures.
This large volume aims to illustrate clearly and directly the chief issues for students and younger scholars who seek a contextual overview of the complex topic of Roman sculpture, an objective which, generally speaking, it meets. The choice of authors represents a mélange of young and established scholars. Although a handbook does not aim to provide an all-encompassing discussion of the complex field of Roman sculpture, some aspects – such as evidence of itinerant workshops, and contexts of display in different building types, which would include iconography as well – could have enriched the volume. In short, the handbook reaches a broad audience of both specialists and students, providing a fine overview of the complexity and significance of Roman sculpture. It gives a very distinctive view of the contexts and complexity of Roman sculpture while making clear the necessity of further studies in the field. It can be highly recommended.
