No CrossRef data available.
Published online by Cambridge University Press: 01 February 2004
As scholars have recently underscored the efficacy in using the family as a lens for studying Middle Eastern societies, Kamran Asdar Ali's Planning the Family in Egypt: New Bodies, New Selves is a timely and most welcome addition. Ali, a Pakistani doctor and anthropologist, uses contemporary Egypt as a case study to demonstrate how family-planning programs attempt not only to reduce unwieldy populations but also to turn those populations into individual, decision-making citizens for the state's benefit. Yet this is not a top-down narrative, for Ali is also interested in highlighting the varied responses of Egyptian citizens to family-planning initiatives and how their reactions are shaped by their individual perceptions.
The book is divided into three parts. In the Introduction and first part of the book, which includes a chapter on the history of Egyptian family-planning programs and another on the recent re-orientation in policies that allows for individual consent and choice, Ali demonstrates his excellent grasp of theory from a variety of disciplines. He engages with many of the arguments that dominate recent debates in anthropology, demography, history, and women's and gender studies to situate his own theoretical departures. He views his greatest contribution as extending beyond Lila Abu-Lughod's formulation of three zones of theorizing within Middle Eastern anthropology (segmentation, harem, and Islam) by locating the production of knowledge in the construction of new subjects. Family-planning programs such as Egypt's allow Ali to investigate the construction, but not necessarily the implementation, of new bodies, new selves, and new notions of individuality.
Based on fieldwork conducted in urban and rural Egypt in the early 1990s and a variety of sources including survey reports, family-planning campaigns, counseling sessions, and oral interviews, the second part of the book (chaps. 3–6) focuses on the lived experiences of poor women whose bodies family-planning programs seek to control. The Foucauldian influence on Ali's work is clear as examples of power—as well as resistance—dominate this section. Because Egyptian women are viewed as politically and socially weaker than men, they represent the “backwardness” of the masses, and thus are the principal targets of contraceptive campaigns. Although little emphasis is placed on men's contraception, Ali argues that family-planning programs cannot be understood solely through the construction of individual choice for women. Thus, he devotes Chapter 6 to examining notions of male virility and potency and how the bodies of men are conceptualized in family-planning discourse. The third part of the book, which includes a chapter on secular women's groups and another chapter on Islamist organizations, contrasts competing socio-political discourses on population policy in an effort to emphasize the larger context of family-planning choices. Ali contends that women's groups mobilize arguments about reproductive rights to hold the state responsible for providing safe and affordable health services for women. Islamists, by contrast, offer an alternative view of the family and nation, challenging the morality of the state in promulgating family planning.
Four sets of actors appear throughout Ali's narrative: the Egyptian state, often represented through President Husni Mubarak's rhetoric blaming the masses for draining the state's infrastructure; the international (read, Western) agencies that fund family-planning programs; the local non-government organizations (NGOs) that mediate between the former two; and the Egyptian poor, mostly women, the intended targets of all of the above. Ali skillfully describes the perceptions, roles, and objectives of these various actors. However, he ascribes agency only to the international organizations and individual Egyptians. According to Ali, it is international agencies such as the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), the single largest donor to Egypt's family-planning program, that largely dictate the agenda of population control. As a promoter of an orthodox demographic theory that views population growth in underdeveloped countries as an impediment to modernization, USAID correlates low living standards in poor countries to high birthrates and seeks to isolate the poor as individuals who would act rationally if given contraceptives. Although Ali acknowledges that the Egyptian state resisted this demographic approach until the 1980s, ultimately it was forced to succumb when USAID threatened to stop funding. The reader, however, is left to wonder why the state resisted and how it articulated family-planning policies before the 1980s. Unfortunately, Ali reduces this more interesting story to a single paragraph. Similarly, Ali argues that while the mediating role of NGOs are often portrayed as crucial in pressuring governments to adhere to international standards, local Egyptian NGOs also succumb to USAID, which almost exclusively funds those NGOs that endorse its policies.
Ali's sympathy ultimately lies with the Egyptian poor, who hold the real agency in his story. Although international donors affect the Egyptian state's family-planning programs, and local NGOs help these donors shape people's ideas and behavior, they often fail in their attempts to persuade poor women of the benefits of family planning. Rather, Ali critiques their imposition of individuality on these women, many of whom see their bodies as part of a broader social world and whose contraceptive choices are influenced by a variety of factors that family-planning policy does not take into consideration.
Because racist and classist population-control advocacy that blames the poor rather than the state for social ills is not limited to USAID in Egypt, it would have been useful if Ali had more systematically situated the Egyptian case in an international context and drawn comparisons with other population-control movements that seek to limit the growth of minorities and the poor in “Third World” nations, and even within Western nations, to demonstrate how the Egyptian case is unique. My only major criticism of this well-documented and theoretically informed study, however, is perhaps an unfair one to make of an anthropologist seeking to locate the production of knowledge in the present. Because Ali is quick to draw linear comparisons between the late-19th–early-20th-century Egyptian colony and the current Egyptian nation-state, his approach often lacks historicity. For example, Ali frequently compares contemporary debates on women, motherhood, and domesticity among today's Egyptian elites with late-19th-century reformers, claiming that the only major difference is that the latter sought only to improve their own class, while the former seeks to do so for the masses. The present Egyptian state is also portrayed as derivative throughout his work. Ali views the current regime and its elites as not only wholeheartedly appropriating Western discourses on modernity and population control but replicating the colonial discourses of their predecessors, albeit with minor differences. In a study that is otherwise so nuanced, this rather linear narrative of the state and its elites is a bit frustrating. Despite this minor misgiving, however, Ali has produced an extraordinary and much needed case study on reproduction, sexuality, and gender in the Middle East. Replete with extensive footnotes and a rich bibliography and index, this book is an invaluable new addition to the field. It is a useful contribution to senior undergraduate and graduate courses on gender and anthropology, and, one hopes, to other disciplines beyond the field of Middle Eastern studies.