In their book on social policy in Britain since 1979, Evans and Williams choose to focus on the rules and outcomes of policies rather than provide another ‘deconstruction of discourse’. Their emphasis is upon income-related policy – tax, social security and occupational welfare. Inevitably, this takes them into aspects of other policy areas such as housing and education, but their concerns here remain confined to income-related issues such as housing benefit, educational maintenance allowance and student loans.
The authors want to move beyond a tendency of both policy and analysis to compartmentalise our lives into artificial segments, and instead seek to provide a comparative ‘cradle to grave’ analysis with a whole lifetime approach. Comparisons between different welfare regimes are made by asking the question: ‘What would the outcomes have been if the policies in place at this particular point in time had stayed still?’ The particular points in time that they have chosen are 1979 (representing ‘Old Labour’), 1997 (for the ‘New Right’) and 2008 (for ‘New Labour’). Their simple question masks a number of complex methodological issues.
Evans and Williams base their comparative analysis upon a consideration of three hypothetical family types: the Meades (with median income), the Lowes (with income of less than 50 per cent of the median) and the Moores (with income of two times the median). At times they extend their analysis by reference to two other family types – the Nunns and the Evans-Moores. To enable their comparisons to highlight differences in the policy regimes, they need consistency in their family types, which inevitably means that they are unable to consider the ways that policies interact with the social diversity that characterises a real life population.
The first part of their book sets the scene for their substantive analysis. Chapter 2 provides an overview of UK policy changes since the 1970s, within the context of the formation of the post world war welfare state in the 1940s. It is followed by a chapter on economic and demographic change over the 30-year period.
The second part of the book provides a comparative overview of the impact of tax and benefit policies upon key life stages for the three family types. A chapter on childhood presents income profiles which show that families on benefits fared best in 2008 and worst in 1979, yet when the value of benefits is expressed relative to wages the picture is almost reversed. This points to the significance of the growth of wages compared with benefits over the 30-year period. Chapters on working age include one on taxation in which we are reminded of how different things were in 1979 when the starting rate was 25 per cent, the basic rate was 33 per cent and the top rate was 83 per cent. Income tax rates have decreased over the period, yet, when one factors in increases to council tax and national insurance, the total tax payable by the Meades has remained fairly consistent. In a chapter on working age risks due to sickness and unemployment, the authors show that when benefit income is expressed as a proportion of previous income after housing costs, the Meades fared best in 1979. The ensuing fall in the value of benefits relative to wages accounts for a progressive worsening of their position. The improvement for the Lowes in 2008, from a low point in 1997, is largely due to increases in the child-related transfers.
In the final part of their book, Evans and Williams attempt to join all this analysis up using their lifetime opportunities and incentives simulation (LOIS). A methodology chapter discusses their ability to factor in some of the key changes in behaviour over the 30-year period (e.g. the age of marriage, first house purchase and first child, changes to patterns of work and care and changing life expectancies). They are also able to take into account policy maturation and inflation, but although they repeatedly point to the significance of the shift from a progressive income tax to regressive indirect taxation, this is not something that they are able to include in their modelling.
Their aim is to answer three questions: firstly, how do taxes paid and benefits received compare in the 1979, 1997 and 2008 regimes; secondly, how do outcomes for income compare – both over the lifetime and relative to contemporary incomes; and, thirdly, what is the impact upon inequality over the lifetime and between the regimes. Unsurprisingly, there are no simple answers. The outcomes for the Meades are remarkably consistent, largely because they gain from the growth in the economy and in earnings since 1970, although they are best off retiring under the 1979 provisions, when pensions were linked to earnings. The Moores are the clear gainers, mainly because of improvements in their earnings and reductions in direct taxation. The Lowes are the losers, especially in 1997 when compared to 1979. An initial consideration of taxation and benefit transfers makes 2008 their best policy regime, but the picture changes significantly if periods out of work are factored in. The year 1979 is considered to be the best overall regime as far as child poverty protection is concerned, although 2008 fares well when both parents are in work. Inequality, as measured by the gap in disposable incomes, is highest in 1997 and lowest in 1979 and 2008 when the position of the Lowes is helped by the minimum wage and tax credits whilst the position of the Meades is worsened by high house prices.
This brief overview, and illustrative sample of some of the findings, does not do justice to the vast amount of painstaking analysis contained within this book. There are over 100 figures and an additional 20 tables, most of which are the result of original calculations, which will provide a rich source for furthering the study, teaching and analysis of social policy.
