For casual observers German banking is synonymous with large universal credit banks—household names such as Deutsche Bank or Commerzbank. But the German banking system is much more nuanced and diverse. It incorporates a variety of different types of banks and financial institutions, and has a rich institutional history. This history is highlighted in Schlüsselereignisse der deutschen Bankengeschichte.
The book presents a hefty survey of German banking. Written mostly by established researchers in the field of banking and financial history, it focuses on individual institutions as well as key events, and highlights strategic moments of institutional change. Each of the 34 chapters covers a specific case or theme and stands as an example for the larger patterns of the historical progression. Spanning 500 years of banking history, the volume begins with a chapter on the 1488 Fugger credit to the Hapsburg Monarchy (Mark Häberlein, Chapter 1), follows the emergence and demise of several German private and commercial banks (e.g., Markus A. Denzel, Chapter 3; Andreas Thier, Chapter 5; and Richard H. Tilly, Chapter 14), chronicles important institutional changes (e.g., Oliver Volckart, Chapter 2 and Dieter Ziegler, Chapter 12), focusing on postwar changes in German banking in the latter third, and ends with the 2007–09 financial crisis (Bernd Rudolph, Chapter 34).
The chapters vary in length between 8 and 26 pages, but are generally short (most are around 12 pages) and concise. The book follows chronological ordering, so the reader can trace the emergence of banking in Germany over time, but it can also be read chapter by chapter. In fact, the very helpful introduction by the editors suggests an alternative reading pattern: The reader could follow specific topics, for example the development of mortgage credit by reading chapters 10 (Elke Pfnür) and 15 (Thomas Hartmann-Wendels), or focus on German savings banks — Sparkassen — by reading Chapters 7 (Thorsten Wehber), 16 (Christian Dirninger), and 33 (Hans-Peter Burghof).
The strength of this book surely lies in the breadth of its coverage. For the sake of space, I will refrain from summarizing all chapters, but let me highlight some, which I think are exemplary for the whole volume. The German financial system traditional rests on three pillars: private banks, savings banks, and credit cooperatives. Focusing on the third pillar, in Chapter 8, Peter Gleber tells the history of smaller credit unions, built on the principle of self-help, which emerged alongside the large commercial and private banks in the nineteenth century. In Chapter 9, Timothy Guinnane explains that these credit unions were especially successful in rural areas since they operated locally and took advantage of superior information provided to them through the village structure.
The birth of the well-known universal banks is discussed in Chapter 11. On the example of the Commerz- and Disconto-Bank in 1870, Burhop traces the emergence of commercial banks that replaced private banks as the main universal banks in the last third of the nineteenth century. Large macroeconomic events discussed in the book include the German hyperinflation of the 1920s (Carl-Ludwig Holtfrerich, Chapter 17), the 1931 banking crisis (Albert Fischler, Chapter 19), reconstruction after World War II (Dieter Lindenlaub, Chapter 22; André Steiner, Chapter 23; and Joachim Scholtyseck, Chapter 24) as well as the introduction of the Euro (Otmar Issing, Chapter 31). Important is the critical discussion of German banking under the Nazi regime in Chapter 21 (Harald Wixford) and the role of Jews in Chapters 4 (Peter Rauscher) and 20 (Ingo Köhler).
The book certainly succeeds in providing a general overview. Furthermore, the extensive bibliography at the end of the text serves as a great launching pad for future research. The book holds appeal for general interest readers that want to broaden their knowledge of Germany's banking history, but is also a valuable resource for researchers interested in specific themes that can draw on individual chapters. Given the breadth of its coverage, at times the book sacrifices depths of specific topics. For example, more than one chapter could have addressed the challenges presented by the unification of the European market and the introduction of the Euro. But the tradeoff between breadth and depth is always the key challenge for such a volume and overall the scales here are balanced well. Similarly, some chapters remain descriptive rather than analytical, but given the long time span, the vast amount of information covered, and the lengths of the individual chapters this is understandable.
The only real regret is that the book is published in German and therefore only accessible to a German-reading audience. It remains a goal for the future to expand the international knowledge of Germany's rich and diverse financial history.
