Hostname: page-component-7b7567c8c-7pwfn Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2026-11-16T16:19:29.065Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false

Turbulent entrainment in viscoelastic fluids

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  19 January 2022

Hugo Abreu
Affiliation:
LAETA, IDMEC, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
Fernando T. Pinho
Affiliation:
CEFT, Faculdade de Engenharia, Universidade do Porto, Porto, Portugal
Carlos B. da Silva*
Affiliation:
LAETA, IDMEC, Instituto Superior Técnico, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisboa, Portugal
*
†Email address for correspondence: carlos.silva@tecnico.ulisboa.pt

Abstract

Direct numerical simulations (DNS) of turbulent fronts spreading into an irrotational flow region are used to analyse the turbulent entrainment mechanism for viscoelastic fluids. The simulations use the FENE-P fluid model and are initiated from DNS of isotropic turbulence with Weissenberg and turbulence Reynolds numbers varying in the ranges $1.30 \le Wi \le 3.46$ and $206 \le Re_{\lambda }^{0} \le 404$, respectively. The enstrophy dynamics near the turbulent/non-turbulent interface (TNTI) layer, that separates regions of turbulent and irrotational flow, includes a new mechanism – the viscoelastic production – caused by the interaction between the vorticity field and the polymer stresses. This term can be a sink or a source of enstrophy in the turbulent core region of the flow, depending on the Weissenberg number, and contributes to the initial growth of the enstrophy in the viscous superlayer, together with the viscous diffusion, which is the only mechanism present for Newtonian fluids. For low and moderate Weissenberg numbers the scaling of the TNTI layer is similar to the scaling of TNTI layers for Newtonian fluids, but this is no longer the case at high Weissenberg numbers where the enstrophy tends to be concentrated into thin vortex sheets instead of vortex tubes. Finally, it is shown that the substantial decrease of the entrainment rates observed in turbulent flows of viscoelastic fluids, compared with Newtonian fluids, is caused by a reduction of the surface area and fractal dimension of the irrotational boundary, originated by the depletion of ‘active’ scales of motion in the fluid solvent caused by the viscoelasticity.

Information

Type
JFM Papers
Copyright
© The Author(s), 2022. Published by Cambridge University Press
Figure 0

Table 1.Physical and computational parameters of the reference (Newtonian – ‘Newt.’) and viscoelastic DNS. Variables with superscript ‘${0}$’ are taken at the HIT instant before the start of the SFT simulation, while variables without this superscript correspond to the instant used in the analysis (computed inside the turbulent core region): Weissenberg number ($Wi$); initial (HIT) Weissenberg number ($Wi^{0}$); maximum relaxation time of the polymer molecules ($\tau _p$); Reynolds number based on the Taylor scale ($Re_{\lambda }$); initial (HIT) Reynolds number based on the Taylor scale ($Re_{\lambda }^{0}$); initial (HIT) root-mean-square (r.m.s.) velocity fluctuations ($u^{0}$); initial (HIT) integral scale ($l^{0}$); turbulent kinetic energy ($K$); solvent viscous dissipation rate ($\varepsilon ^{[s]}$); polymer dissipation rate ($\varepsilon ^{[p]}$); Taylor micro-scale ($\lambda$); Kolmogorov micro-scale ($\eta$); initial (HIT) maximum effective wavenumber ($k_{max}$) normalised by the initial Kolmogorov micro-scale ($k_{max} \eta ^{0}$). SI units have been used for all dimensional quantities.

Figure 1

Figure 1.Turbulent volume fraction ($Vol_T$) as function of the vorticity magnitude threshold $|\omega |$, for all the DNS used in the present work, at the instants used in the subsequent SFT analysis. The vertical lines represent the detected thresholds for each case, obtained with the second derivative method i.e. ${\rm d}^2 Vol_T / {\rm d}|\omega |^2 (\omega _{th}) = 0$ (see main text for details).

Figure 2

Figure 2.Top view iso-surfaces of the IB, detected with the vorticity magnitude equal to the selected threshold ($|\omega | = \omega _{th}$) for all the DNS used in the present work, at the instant used in the analysis: (a) Newtonian reference case; (b) $Wi = 1.30$; (c) $Wi = 1.89$; (d) $Wi = 2.81$; (e) $Wi = 3.46$.

Figure 3

Figure 3.Sketch of the procedure used to compute the conditional statistics in relation to the position of the IB for the Newtonian reference simulation. (a) Contours of enstrophy in a $(x,y)$ plane showing the entire flow domain. The IB is represented by a solid dark line, which separates the TR and the IR flow regions; (b) magnification of a flow region near the TNTI layer showing the IB (solid dark line) and the IB interface (dashed white line). The figure shows also the local axis (normal to the local IB) that is used to collect the flow statistics in relation to the IB position. The origin of this axis coincides with the IB ($y_I = 0$) and the coordinates with $y_I>0$ and $y_I<0$ correspond to the turbulent and irrotational flow regions, respectively. The figure shows also that points from a nearby hole of non-turbulent flow within the turbulent region are not accounted for in the conditional statistics of the turbulent region.

Figure 4

Figure 4.Conditional mean profiles of (a) vorticity magnitude $\left \langle \sqrt { \omega _i \omega _i} \right \rangle _I$ and (b) (normalised) trace of the conformation tensor, $\left \langle C_{kk} \right \rangle _I / (L_{p})^2$, as a function of the distance from the IB position, for all the DNS used in the present work, at the instant used in the analysis.

Figure 5

Figure 5.Conditional enstrophy budgets for all the simulations used in the present work, obtained by averaging all the terms in (4.1) in relation to the distance from the IB as described in § 3.2.1: thin/solid/dark line – total variation ($T_{\varOmega }$); long dashed/blue line – enstrophy production ($P_{\varOmega }$); dashed/green line – viscous diffusion ($D_{\varOmega }$); dotted/magenta line – viscous dissipation ($\varepsilon _{\varOmega }$); solid/red line – viscoelastic production ($V_{\varOmega }$). The IB is located at $y_I/H=0$ and the non-turbulent and turbulent regions are at $y_I<0$ and $y_I>0$, respectively. The distance from the IB ($y_I$) is normalised by the size of the initial turbulent region $H$: (a) Newtonian (reference) case; (b) $Wi = 1.30$; (c) $Wi = 1.89$; (d) $Wi = 2.81$; (e) $Wi = 3.46$.

Figure 6

Figure 6.The p.d.f.s of the several terms governing the enstrophy transport equation (4.1) for the viscoelastic simulations with $Wi=1.30$ (a–c) and $Wi = 3.46$ (d–f), at several locations within the TNTI layer: (a,d) at the VSL (in the point of maximum enstrophy viscous diffusion); (b,e) at the TSL (in middle of the region of growing enstrophy production); and at the turbulent core region (c,f).

Figure 7

Figure 7.The j.p.d.f.s of enstrophy variation ($T_{\varOmega }$) and enstrophy viscous diffusion ($D_{\varOmega }$) at the VSL for the simulations with (a) $Wi=0$ (Newtonian), (b) $Wi=1.30$ and (c) $Wi = 3.46$. The variables are centred and normalised by their r.m.s. values. In these and all the other j.p.d.f.s of this paper the lower limit of the iso-lines displayed corresponds to the level $10^{-5}$, and the j.p.d.f.s are normalised so that $\iint p (x,y)\,{{\rm d}\kern0.06em x}\,{{\rm d}y} =1$.

Figure 8

Figure 8.The j.p.d.f.s of enstrophy variation ($T_{\varOmega }$) and enstrophy production ($P_{\varOmega }$) at the turbulent superlayer (TSL) for the simulations with (a) $Wi=0$ (Newtonian), (b) $Wi=1.30$ and (c) $Wi = 3.46$. The variables are centred and normalised by their r.m.s. values.

Figure 9

Figure 9.The j.p.d.f.s of enstrophy variation ($T_{\varOmega }$) and viscoelastic production ($V_{\varOmega }$) at the IB for the simulations with (a) $Wi=1.30$ and (b) $Wi = 3.46$. The variables are centred and normalised by their r.m.s. values.

Figure 10

Figure 10.The j.p.d.f.s of enstrophy variation ($T_{\varOmega }$) and viscoelastic production ($V_{\varOmega }$) for the simulation with $Wi=1.30$, at the VSL (a); TSL (b) and turbulent core region (c). The variables are centred and normalised by their r.m.s. values.

Figure 11

Figure 11.The j.p.d.f.s of enstrophy variation ($T_{\varOmega }$) and viscoelastic production ($V_{\varOmega }$) for the simulation with $Wi=3.46$, at the VSL (a); TSL (b) and turbulent core region (c). The variables are centred and normalised by their r.m.s. values.

Figure 12

Figure 12.Conditional mean profiles of the terms in (4.1) showing the extent of the VSL, TSL and the total extent of the TNTI layer, for the simulations with: (a) Newtonian fluid; (b) $Wi=1.30$; (c) $Wi=3.46$. The colours and line types for each term are the same as in figure 5 e.g. the viscoelastic production ($V_{\varOmega }$) is represented in solid/red line.

Figure 13

Table 2.Mean thickness of the VSL $\left \langle \delta _{VSL} \right \rangle$, TSL $\left \langle \delta _{TSL} \right \rangle$ and the total extent of the TNTI layer $\left \langle \delta _{TNTI} \right \rangle$, for the simulations with Newtonian and viscoelastic fluids analysed in the present work. The several mean thicknesses are normalised by the size of the initial turbulent region ($H$) and by the Kolmogorov micro-scale ($\eta$).

Figure 14

Table 3.Mean entrainment velocity $\left \langle v_{n} \right \rangle$, surface area of the IB $A_{IB}$ and flow rate $Q_l$, for all the simulations carried out in the present work. These quantities are also shown when normalised by the Kolmogorov velocity $u_{\eta }$ and length scale $\eta$, computed inside the turbulent core region, and also with the initial (HIT) r.m.s. velocity $u^{0}$ and integral scale $l^0$.

Figure 15

Figure 13.(a–c) A single line of the upper IB for the Newtonian case in a fixed spanwise plane ($z$) and showing entire extent in the $x$ direction ($L_x$) (a), followed by the same curve obtained after filtering the vorticity magnitude with a box filter with $\Delta _f/\Delta _x = 8$ and $64$ (b,c) respectively. Bubbles and islands are removed from the curves prior to the computation of the total surface area of each IB. (d) Fractal characteristics of the IB for the present DNS of Newtonian and viscoelastic fluid obtained with the ‘filtering method’ (de Silva et al.2013; Krug et al.2017; Mistry et al.2017; Balamurugan et al.2020). Here, $A_{IB}$ is the total area of the (upper and lower) IB surfaces and $A_0 = L_x \times L_z$ is a reference area. The filter size $\Delta _f$ is normalised by the grid size $\Delta _x$ and the figure shows results (for all the simulations) for filter sizes equal to $\Delta _f / \Delta _x =$ 2, 4, 6, 8, 12, 16, 24, 32, 48, 64, 96, 128, 192 and 256. The vertical lines show the locations of the Kolmogorov, Taylor and integral scales (these values are taken from the Newtonian reference simulation). The fractal dimension is obtained from the exponent of the power laws computed with the points between the Taylor and integral scales. The solid dark line has a slope of $-0.3$ which corresponds to a fractal dimension of $D_f = 2.3$ for the surface defining the IB in the Newtonian case. Smaller values of the fractal dimension are recovered for the viscoelastic cases.

Figure 16

Figure 14.Top view of the iso-surfaces of the IB – obtained using the selected vorticity magnitude threshold – for all the simulations carried out in the present work: (a) Newtonian; (b) $Wi=1.30$; (c) $Wi=1.89$; (d) $Wi=2.81$; (e) $Wi=3.46$. The IB is coloured by the magnitude of the entrainment velocity $v_{n}$. Negative values mean that the fluid at the IB is moving into the irrotational flow region.

Figure 17

Table 4.Mean entrainment velocity $\left \langle - v_{n} \right \rangle$ decomposed into its several contributions defined in (6.4), computed at the IB, for all the simulations used in the present work. Negative values mean that the fluid at the IB is moving into the irrotational flow region.

Figure 18

Figure 15.The p.d.f.s of the entrainment velocity $v_n$, and of its several contributions defined in (6.4) computed at the IB: (a) Newtonian; (b) $Wi=1.30$; (c) $Wi=1.89$; (d) $Wi=2.81$; (e) $Wi=3.46$. Negative values mean that the fluid at the IB is moving into the irrotational flow region.

Figure 19

Figure 16.The j.p.d.f.s between the entrainment velocity $v_n$ and several of its contributions for the simulation with $Wi=3.46$: (a) enstrophy production contribution $V_P$, (b) enstrophy diffusion contribution $V_D$, (c) enstrophy dissipation contribution $V_{\varepsilon }$, (d) viscoelastic production contribution $V_V$.

Figure 20

Figure 17.The j.p.d.f.s between the enstrophy production ($P_{\varOmega }$) and enstrophy diffusion ($D_{\varOmega }$) for the simulation with $Wi=3.46$ at two closely spaced locations: (a) IB; (b) VSL.