In his recent book Piracy, Adrian Johns provides the most accessible and comprehensive history of Anglo-American intellectual-property piracy to date. It is an ambitious undertaking, as it must be to span nearly 500 years of history, and Johns has done an excellent job marshaling the sprawl into a book that is easy to digest. The body of research is vast, and a significant portion of it comes from the author's own investigation of primary sources. As a consequence, novices and experts alike will learn much from this book.
The book's most broad-based contribution to the literature on this subject has been to demonstrate that infringement and questioning of intellectual property have existed, and been in tension with one another, for hundreds of years; not in fits and starts, or sporadically, as some might have assumed, but nearly as a constant refrain.
Piracy proceeds chronologically and begins, not surprisingly, with what Johns calls the invention of piracy. He traces the concept to the introduction of the moveable-type printing press in England circa 1471, and then recounts how the Company of Stationers—the guild which governed the book trade in London starting in 1557—found itself managing exclusive printing rights. Where there were rights, there undoubtedly would be wrongs. But as Johns notes in a subsequent chapter (chap. 3), it was not long before the so-called pirates articulated normative defenses for their actions, most visibly in the late seventeenth century. Chief among them was the enlightenment of the public. Others more broadly decried intellectual property as a restraint on free trade. Yet the view that prevailed in the early eighteenth century, at least for a time, was that a limited monopoly was necessary to encourage authorship and enlightenment.
This tension—between rights holders and those who exploit their works without consent but purportedly with noble intentions—is a theme that Johns sustains throughout the remainder of the book, albeit through different narratives and periods, and sometimes with respect to different intellectual properties. But the book also explores, from its historical perspective, other themes with modern-day parallels. In chapter 4, for instance, Johns describes the means by which inventors could prove the priority of their innovations over those allegedly made by others, and in a manner outside the bounds of the ordinary patent system, by registering their works with the Royal Society of London. Johns walks us through the procedure by recounting a dispute between two inventors who each claimed he had discovered and perfected a method to desalinate water. Such technology, if it actually worked, would have greatly advanced seafaring.
Other chapters tell equally intriguing tales. Concerns about the authenticity and the danger of pirated medicines are treated in chapter 5, where Johns also reveals that the advisability of patenting medicines and their processes was at issue as early as 1698. Today, of course, the patentability of medicines remains a deeply controversial matter in developing and least developed countries. Johns also explores the protectionism fostered in Ireland and the United States (chaps. 7–8, 11) in the eighteenth century and nineteenth century, respectively, by their refusals to extend intellectual-property protection to works created abroad. In recent years, similar accusations have been directed at China for its purported failure to enforce laws it already has on the books. The similarities are striking.
Moving to the late eighteenth century (chap. 6), Johns discusses a legal battle in which the booksellers of London and Scotland argued over the existence vel non of a perpetual copyright for books. Whereas certain copyright holders claimed that such a right existed as a matter of common law, and independently of a statute enacted in 1710 which seemingly created durational limits, others claimed that any such right, if it ever existed, had been preempted by the statute. Though Johns does not expressly make a connection in this chapter to modern events, it is not difficult to find one. Many of the arguments made in 1769 and 1774 are repeated today by those who oppose or support Congress's discretion to extend the duration of copyrights to any length, so long as it remains less than forever. Congress's decision in 1998 to extend copyrights an additional 20 years, and the Supreme Court's opinion to uphold it, stand as a recent example of the continuing relevance of such debates.
Staying in the eighteenth century, Johns next investigates and questions the true value of intellectual-property protection by presenting the case study of Ireland, which until 1801 had no copyright legislation whatsoever (chap. 7). For over one hundred years, books from England and elsewhere were reprinted in Ireland with impunity and no apparent shortage. Books authored and published domestically were also legally unprotected. Johns asks, “If literary property and rules of authorship were so central to enlightenment, why did the Irish model,” which had no such rules, “not collapse into chaos and ignorance?” (147). He further posits that the example of Ireland “puts to the test all conventional views conjoining print, property, and progress” (ibid.). Though Johns's description of the affairs in Ireland is accurate and well told, this is one part of his book where his account does not squarely support his inferences.
It is difficult to draw reliable conclusions from Ireland as the “land without property,” as Johns calls it, largely because of its proximity to Great Britain. Great Britain had enjoyed copyright legislation in its modern form since 1710, and England, Wales, and Scotland more primitive forms of rights long before then. As a consequence, the unwavering, and indeed increasing, production of books in Ireland before 1801 may best be explained not by the fact that intellectual property was unimportant, but by the fact that authors knew their works would still be protected in the major markets of England, Wales, and Scotland. Tellingly, as Johns notes, “Dublin was never the center for authorship that London was” in the eighteenth century (151). One must therefore wonder whether the counterfactual—viz., robust legal protection in Ireland for written works before the year 1801—might have fostered greater creative output.
The remainder of the book carries the story from the Victorian era to the present day. Some of what appears in the book reaffirms that disputes over intellectual property are recurring. The fights of the eighteenth century have reappeared, on a regular basis, in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Though the names may have changed, along with the technologies, at bottom many of the concerns remain the same. But Johns separates the wheat from the chaff and highlights more modern developments that also deserve our attention. We learn, for example, that patents for inventions were strongly contested in the late nineteenth century, and that efforts to abolish them in toto came close to succeeding (chap. 10). One reform concept that appears in narratives across several chapters, and that remains a hotly contested topic today, is an effort to replace the remedy of injunctive relief with compulsory licensing (chaps. 10, 12, 14). Johns's book also features treatments of both the use of private-trade associations to police infringement (chap. 12) and the move of piracy into the home with the advent of technologies such as audio- and video-cassette recorders (chap. 15). He closes by focusing on digital technologies challenging intellectual property.
Johns deserves much praise for reminding us of our own history. But what can we learn from that history as we confront these latest technological developments? The book, for the most part, asks us to draw our own conclusions. Johns does not take sides, which is not surprising, given that the history supports a range of conclusions. A reader might conclude, for instance, that current debates over intellectual property and “piracy” are overheated. We have been through this before and are likely to live through it again without making radical changes to the intellectual-property system. But just as plausible is the view that history can no longer offer much useful guidance. Technological improvements have developed at an exponential pace in the last several decades alone, and the lessons of even twenty years ago may be outdated. Whatever view one holds on contemporary intellectual-property debates, that view will be a better informed one for having read Piracy.
