Muslims make up approximately 5% of the European population, and by 2050, one out of ten Europeans is projected to be Muslim (https://www.pewforum.org/2017/11/29/europes-growing-muslim-population/). Scholars have examined the integration challenges these minorities face, particularly the discrimination they experience in their host countries’ labor markets. But Europe's Muslim population also represents a new political constituency, one that can vote, organize, protest, and run for office. How does this new constituency integrate into the European political landscape? More generally, under what conditions do established political parties incorporate new groups that challenge their ideological position? In Dilemmas of Inclusion: Muslims in European Politics, Rafaela Dancygier tackles one of the most pressing problems facing liberal democracies today: the political inclusion of groups whose socio-economic preferences do not neatly align with existing political and ideological frameworks. By doing so, she captures the tradeoffs that animate the philosophical and policy debates posed by multiculturalism, those that pit values such as gender equality against multicultural recognition.
Dancygier's objective is to explain how Europe's established political parties—from the Labour Party in the UK to Germany's Social Democrats—respond to Muslim voters, noting that such responses vary widely from outright exclusion to directly courting the Muslim vote. To explain this variation, Dancygier explores the electoral incentives that shape the short-term strategies of political parties, particularly of the Left, which is ideologically committed to diversity and inclusion. Her theoretical argument is that citizenship regimes, electoral institutions, and electoral geography interact to determine how pivotal the Muslim vote is. If it is trivial, exclusion prevails. When it grows but Muslim inclusion threatens to alienate too many of the party's core voters, parties continue to appeal to a primarily non-Muslim majority electorate and choose symbolic—or token—inclusion. When they expect net vote gains from catering to Muslim constituents who are now pivotal, parties pursue vote-based inclusion.
Empirically, Dancygier pursues a multifaceted strategy, weaving together evidence drawn from a variety of sources to build her theoretical case: she leverages a unique panel dataset of individuals in the UK to examine how people respond to a growing Muslim presence in their municipality; she collects and analyzes party manifestos to investigate parties’ positions on Muslim representation; she builds her own dataset of Muslim descriptive representation across cities and parties in Austria, Belgium, Germany, and Great Britain to identify the conditions under which we are likely to see the political inclusion or exclusion of Muslims. The result is a series of robust quantitative analyses that provide a compelling account of the causes and consequences of party strategies of inclusion. Additionally, Dancygier is masterful in weaving in and out of narratives that ground the quantitative analyses, making this book both academic and accessible.
Dancygier's core theoretical insight is that the pressure for meaningful vote-based inclusion is highest where minorities are most problematic for the party's core ideology. This happens for two reasons.
First, immigrant geographical sorting creates ethnic urban enclaves that are ideal for political mobilization but also are more traditional and religiously observant. Indeed, Muslim migration to Europe occurred in the 1950s and 1960s, a time of high demand for low-skill manufacturing labor from the developing world. This labor demand selected for migrants from poor and tight-knit villages who left precisely to remit money home. Eventually, these tight-knit community structures incentivized chain migration, creating urban enclaves ripe for block mobilization. But the ethnoreligious communities that comprise these enclaves are also more traditional, creating a classic multicultural dilemma for left-wing parties ideologically committed to both inclusion and gender equality: these political parties include ethnic minorities with the expectation that block voting will turn out the vote in their favor, but what makes block voting possible is precisely its tight-knit community structure and the influence of traditional community leaders. As a result, these new pivotal players are more socially conservative in their views on religion, sexuality, and gender roles, than are Muslims as a whole as well as the party's non-Muslim base. Here, a short-term electoral strategy conflicts with the party's ideological identity.
Second, this pattern of Muslim settlement increases the public salience of issues like gender equality, pushing non-Muslims who share this space with Muslims toward more progressive attitudes. To show this, Dancygier relies on the British Household Panel Study, a treasure trove of panel data over two decades (1991–2011). This dataset follows the same representative sample of individuals over time, allowing Dancygier to observe changes in British political and social attitudes as the Muslim population grows. Quantitative statistical analyses confirm that individuals living in close proximity to these growing ethnic enclaves adopt more socially liberal views over time. As a result, the two processes—sorting and polarization—set the scene for a key electoral trade-off: a party seeking to integrate this new and growing Muslim constituency risks alienating its non-Muslim core.
How does this dilemma play out across Europe? Here, Dancygier relies on a combination of cross-national and subnational analyses to explain variation in inclusionary strategies across countries, but also within countries and across parties. At the cross-national level, Dancygier shows that restrictive citizenship regimes and electoral laws in Austria and Germany keep the Muslim vote small and trivial. By contrast, permissive institutions in Belgium and Britain generate strategies of inclusion. For example, British wards with larger Muslim populations, higher population density, and lower socioeconomic deprivation see greater vote-based inclusion: these are places where the Muslim vote is likely to be pivotal due to its size, and where traditional Muslim community leaders have the ability to court this vote through their ethnic network. At the same time, lower soecioeconomic deprivation decreases the risk of backlash from the white working class, making Muslim inclusion a winning short-term strategy. But this comes at a cost to the party: by relying on ethnic enclaves to draw votes, the party relies on ethnic rather than class-based or partisan attachments between candidates and voters, undermining party loyalty in the long-run.
Dancygier further highlights a second dilemma of inclusion, the need for parties to weigh the goal of religious parity against that of gender parity. When parties court the Muslim vote, they are more likely to nominate more traditional male candidates who can deliver these votes; but when the Muslim vote is less pivotal, or when parties fear backlash from their traditional constituencies, they pursue symbolic inclusion instead by nominating female Muslim candidates. Female Muslim candidates, especially if they do not wear a headscarf, signal assimilation and secularism in ways that male Muslim candidates cannot. They are therefore better equipped to appeal to secular, cosmopolitan non-Muslim voters, but less well positioned to represent the enclave vote.
Dancygier illustrates this variation both cross-nationally and subnationally. In Austria and Germany, where institutions limit the pivotality of the Muslim vote, political parties can pursue symbolic inclusion, featuring more Muslim female candidates. Here, gender inclusion happens at the expense of Muslim inclusion. But in highly-urbanized Belgian municipalities, the number and list placement of female Muslim representatives drops as the percentage of elected Muslims increases. Here, Muslim inclusion happens at the expense of female inclusion.
The book is a theoretical and empirical tour de force. Not only does it contribute to key contemporary debates about diversity and inclusion, it challenges common narratives and assumptions about Muslims in Europe. For example, by leveraging variation in Muslim community characteristics across European countries, Dancygier shows that Muslim minorities are neither monolithic nor withdrawn. Additionally, by focusing on patterns of migration and settlement, Dancygier highlights the key role that electoral geography—and not any inherent cultural or ethnic characteristic of Muslims—plays in shaping the type of Muslim community parties encounter in any given locality.
But this book's implications travel well beyond the question of Muslim integration in Europe. At its heart, this is a book about how parties adapt to a changing constituency. The story of Muslim political inclusion in Europe is relevant for understanding minority representation in American politics, particularly for uncaptured groups such as Latino and Asian American populations. It also echoes our understanding of ethnic politics in parts of the developing world in Africa and South Asia, where parties often rely on ethnic entrepreneurs to mobilize ethnic constituencies as a block. In short, the book is a key contribution to scholarship on comparative ethnic politics, minority representation, and immigrant integration, with much to say about contemporary debates surrounding multiculturalism, and with implications for the future of the Left.
