Walter van Beek's The Dancing Dead is a remarkable testament to a career spent in great part working in Kapsiki communities in the northern Mandara Mountains of Cameroon. Since the 1970s, his research in and writing about this region has illuminated a variety of aspects of Kapsiki lifeways, including their symbolic systems, the relations between blacksmiths and non-smiths, marriage practices and gender roles, and the symbolism of beer in Kapsiki society. His accessible and absorbing The Kapsiki of the Mandara Hills, which focused on the complex relationships between Kapsiki men and women, has been virtually the only anglophone ethnography on this important area of Central Africa. Now, 25 years later, van Beek has returned with a second, equally fascinating, English-language ethnography of the Kapsiki and their Higi compatriots in Nigeria.
The Dancing Dead examines Kapsiki and Higi ritual systems, perhaps the most spectacular of which are the structures of ritual and mourning that surround the deaths of individuals, and which figure in the book's title and cover image. However, its range is wider than that. It includes three primary sections, the first of which provides necessary historical and cultural background, while the second and third discuss ‘rituals of dwelling’ and ‘rituals of belonging’ respectively. Rituals of dwelling include a complex set of beliefs and sacrifices that position Kapsiki/Higi individuals, households, and communities in a challenging social landscape inhabited by persons both human and non-human. Such positioning of people in the landscape is everywhere a salient issue in the densely populated and domesticated northern Mandara Mountains. Rituals of belonging, on the other hand, figure in the life-cycles of Kapsiki and Higi people themselves, and include those rituals associated with birth (with particular attention to the birth of twins, an event fraught with potential and hazard), with marriage and initiation, and finally with death. Needless to say, these two categories of ritual are intimately linked, through a set of common symbolic associations and through their positions in a cycle that works on annual and longer rhythms.
Through the book, van Beek integrates detailed ethnographic descriptions of these central elements in Kapsiki/Higi society with a broader theoretical discussion of how ritual works in that society. He notes, first, that Kapsiki/Higi ritual involves elements of both imagistic and doctrinal modes of religiosity, to use Harvey Whitehouse's differentiation between low-frequency/high-intensity religious experiences that persist as memorable events in a person's life, and high-frequency/low-intensity experiences that are reinforced through repetition and learning of doctrinal systems. Like most traditional African religious systems, Kapsiki/Higi does not have a formal, centralised doctrinal structure, and the assumption is frequently made that such religious systems function almost entirely in the imagistic mode. Van Beek observes, however, that some Kapsiki/Higi rituals are somewhat repetitive and involve activities that also take place in everyday life; they have lower emotional investment, and he relates their performance to relatively straightforward cognitive inversions of the natural world. Such rituals make up an important element in his category of rituals of dwelling, while rituals of belonging are rather more imagistic, involving greater emotional involvement, activities, and behaviours not found in everyday life, greater specialisation, and more complex and demanding cognitive systems.
These theoretical claims certainly make sense upon reading, and as noted van Beek weaves them closely and convincingly through his ethnographic observations. He is also careful to note that these two categories of Kapsiki ritual are not mutually exclusive – and that, for that matter, there are elements of ritual, like cursing, that do not fit into this dichotomy and are not extensively treated in this book. In my experience as an archaeologist working in other Mandara societies further to the north, the distinction between those rituals (often of sacrifice) associated with everyday activities like communal eating and drinking and the more spectacular life-cycle rituals seems to make a great deal of sense. On the other hand, ancestors play a greater role in ritual activity in the northern communities I am familiar with than they appear to among the Kapsiki/Higi. This illustrates the cultural diversity that we see among the many small montagnard societies in the northern Mandara, an observation with which I am sure van Beek would agree. While reading this book, I continually encountered observations and interpretations that resonated with my own experiences in the area. One particular strength of the book is that van Beek's decades of fieldwork in the region allow him to depict the variable transformation of Kapsiki/Higi ritual systems in their encounter with the truly doctrinal religious systems of Christianity and Islam, and in doing so he provides the reader with a vivid description of the dynamism of this society.
The Dancing Dead is a pleasure to read. Van Beek writes gracefully and engagingly, and his affection and respect for the Kapsiki and Higi people with whom he has lived and worked is evident on every page. This is the kind of book, and the Kapsiki and Higi are evidently the kind of people, that will capture the attention of sometimes-reluctant students in anthropology courses, and make them think about complex cultural systems quite different from their own. It will equally reward Africanist historians, anthropologists, and archaeologists with a greater professional background in the area and/or the topic. It should be read by anyone with an interest in this part of Africa, or in the functioning of ritual systems more generally.
