This book is ostensibly aimed to analyze the complex relationship between the Ottoman Committee of Union and Progress (CUP) and various Ottoman communities during the Second Constitutional Period (1908–18). Unfortunately, it has literally no organization and lacks a real research question. Even its introduction, which is a compilation of impertinent pieces of information and ends abruptly with an awkward paragraph describing how the Belgian ambassador to the Sublime Porte saved the lives of the Armenian revolutionaries who had attempted to assassinate Sultan Abdülhamid II in 1905, does not help the reader to discern what indeed is the topic of the study. Only with the help of the title and chapter headings can the reader, albeit dimly, perceive that this is supposed to be a study of the relationship between various Ottoman ethnic and religious communities and the Ottoman Committee of Union and Progress.
Without a meaningful introduction and conclusion (the epilogue haphazardly patched at the end of the book produces additional confusion instead of providing analysis) the reader finds himself or herself lost in a sea of apparent irrelevant statements, factual errors, inaccuracies, extended quotes coming out of the blue, and crude misinterpretations of historical phenomena. The chapters are put together unsystematically and seem to have been written independently. No common thread links them; they go wherever random quotes or scattered anecdotes take them. As a natural result, the chapters, each ostensibly discussing the relations between the CUP and the Albanians, Arabs, Armenians, Greeks, and Jews, neither make any original statements nor provide any meaningful analyses.
Ahmad's randomly chosen sources provide a gallimaufry of unrelated information. Because the book and its component chapters lack an organizational, let alone theoretical, thread, the nature of the sources inevitably determines the shape of the narrative. The sources used in the study are not sufficient to make any original contributions. Frequently cited British and US documents, randomly quoted newspaper columns and journal articles, and general books help Ahmad only recycle worn-out clichés and promote the obsolete theses of official Turkish history. Whereas it is unimaginable that any serious author would write a book on British history by relying on German and Italian archival documents, until the last quarter of the past century many Ottomanists in Western academia produced works in precisely this way. (This is by no means to suggest that solid scholarship on Ottoman history was wholly nonexistent in the West during that period.) Ahmad seems to have been unaware that this genre expired long ago. Today any serious scholar who wishes to examine the relations between the CUP and, for instance, Albanians or Arabs should consult with the rich files in the Prime Ministry Ottoman Archives. There is no way around this, as unfortunate as it may be for the remaining members of the old school. Likewise basing itself heavily on British and secondary Turkish sources, the book can make pretense to describing the multiple complex relationships only from the points of view of British and Ottoman state officials. The study fails to give the other parties any genuine voice. As a result, it provides an extremely state-centric perspective throughout. Moreover, the heavy use of diplomatic correspondence and political memoirs leads the author to touch only on political aspects of the relationships and ignore socioeconomic and cultural aspects.
Ahmad's book serves as a time capsule that takes the reader back to the 1960s. In addition to its major organizational and theoretical flaws, it contains an abundance of factual errors. Some of these are simple mistakes caused by carelessness. For example, we learn that at a meeting held in August 1908 “the Bulgarians were represented by Sandinski and Cernopoyef . . . the Armenians by . . . Sahirkiyan” (p. 11). It is not difficult to figure out that these figures were Sandanski, Chernopeev, and Shahrigian. Many other mistakes apparently derive from Ahmad's limited knowledge of Ottoman history, however, and these may lead the reader to reach erroneous conclusions. For instance, the sentence maintaining that “the Tanzimat reforms (1839–76) had an impact in the province of Albania” (p. 56) does not make any sense since no such province ever existed in the Ottoman Empire. Likewise, it is disconcerting to see Ahmad, who published a book on the CUP in 1969, asserting that “in 1889 the Ottoman dissidents formed a secret organization in Paris, the CUP” (p. 6). As is very well known, the organization in question was established in Istanbul at the Imperial Medical Academy in 1889, and adopted the name of CUP almost six years later.
In addition to its multitude of factual errors, the book is rife with poorly formulated statements and ill-defined concepts that only further exasperate the reader. A good example is as follows: “In the Ottoman Empire the Albanians did not constitute a millet” (p. 56). Surely they did not because they could not. Needless to say no “ethnic” group such as Arabs, Armenians, Greeks or Turks constituted a millet since the term in that use meant “religious community” (as Ahmad states on p. 2). Thus, for instance, the “Greek” millet was not solely composed of ethnic Greeks but of the Greek Orthodox Christian subjects of the empire, and thus included ethnic Arabs, Macedonians, and Bulgarians among others. Similarly, Catholic Armenians were not members of the “Armenian” millet, which consisted of followers of the Armenian Apostolic Church.
Ahmad's comments on the CUP on pages 115–16 further reveal that in addition to not knowing where the organization was originally founded, he has very little knowledge of its internal workings, ideological proclivities, and strength before 1908. Unfortunately, the information that he gleaned from British reports and various newspapers does not help him reach a better understanding of the CUP after 1908 either. This misunderstanding prompts him to reconstruct the CUP erroneously as a weak organization that “had no recognized leadership” (p. 115). As a result, he downplays the importance of the organizational cult that overrode personal leadership in the CUP. This misunderstanding also compels Ahmad to deemphasize the importance of the CUP's policies and the way in which they were implemented. Hence he, in between lines, tells us not to take the portrayal of the CUP in Arab or Armenian nationalist scholarship seriously. According to Ahmad the CUP was such an ineffectual and uncoordinated organization that it could not design and carry out efficacious policies. It is jarring to see Ahmad, who totally disregards Ottoman archival sources and the CUP's own correspondence, claim that “most scholars writing on this period are unable to use Ottoman sources and have only a cursory knowledge of late Ottoman history,” and thus they make arguments “on false premises” (p. 115). In fact, it is nobody but Ahmad who, with his perfunctory familiarity with Ottoman history, puts forward such preposterous opinions. He further regurgitates stock clichés of the Turkish nationalist historiography. For instance, he emphasizes that “the non-Muslim communities, and later the Arabs, provided suitable clients for the Great Powers to manipulate” (p. 4). As a consequence, Ahmad draws a relationship between the weak Ottoman government that could not force its governors to deport the Armenians and non-Turkish nationalists serving the interests of the imperialist Western powers. Ahmad writes, “though Armenian nationalist activity in Anatolia was a factor in the Porte's passing the relocation law, the more immediate cause was the Entente landing at the Dardanelles.” Likewise, he suggests that “the Armenian population . . . of Istanbul was not relocated. . .because it was not considered revolutionary or nationalist.” (p. 81). “A peace could have been negotiated at any time in 1915 or 1916,” he adds, “and [the] deportees might have been allowed to return their homes” (p. 83). Alas, Ahmad would have us believe, Armenian nationalism, Western imperialism, and the prolongation of World War I prevented the deportees from returning to their homes much to the dismay of the CUP leaders.
The multifarious and fundamental shortcomings of Ahmad's book render stylistic issues unimportant. Still, a few words should be said about the large number of misspellings. A good portion of the Turkish names are written incorrectly. Ahmad uses Turkish characters like many scholars writing on Ottoman and Turkish history. This, however, results in a host of misspelled words. Just a few examples: Sahsi/Şahsî, anasir/anasır, Kaynarcı/Kaynarca, Kazim/Kazım, Ilyas/İlyas, Nazim/Nazım, Pirincizade/Pirinçcizade Manısalı/Manisalı, tesebbüs/teşebbüs.
The sole contribution of Ahmad's book is its illustration of the flaws—once all too typical—of Ottoman historiography in the past century. It is simply astonishing that a book manifesting all these faults can still be published in 2014 as if the scholarship has made no improvements in more than half of a century. Indeed, thankfully perhaps, very few books could render such a service.
