Hamid Naficy's recent four-volume history of Iranian cinema has arrived at a remarkable moment in the story of the global reception of Iranian film. Beginning in the 1990s, Iranian art cinema became highly celebrated on the global film festival circuit and in film criticism. Perhaps the most triumphant mark of this success occurred in 1997 when Abbas Kiarostami's film Taʿm-i gilas (Taste of Cherry) won the Palme d’Or at the Cannes Film Festival, a first in the history of Iranian cinema. The first decade of the 21st century then saw the proliferation of scholarly work on Iranian cinema, which was considered an important “new” national cinema, and one that was emblematic of what came to be known as global auteur style. In 2012, Asghar Farhadi's wildly successful film, Judaʾi-yi Nadir az Simin (A Separation) garnered Iran its first Academy Award (for best foreign language film), which in turn generated a new wave of global interest in contemporary Iranian cinema. Yet amidst this increasing attention on Iranian cinema, scholarly research has remained almost exclusively devoted to films made after the 1979 revolution. With the exception of M. Ali Issari's Cinema in Iran: 1900–1979 (London: Scarecrow Press, 1989), English readers have had little access to information on prerevolutionary Iranian cinema, or indeed on the broader landscape of the Iranian film industry. In fact, the existing field of Iranian cinema studies, while boasting significant works such as Negar Mottahedeh's groundbreaking book, Displaced Allegories: Post-Revolutionary Iranian Cinema (Durham, N.C.: Duke University Press, 2008), could nevertheless give the unassuming reader the notion that “New Iranian Cinema” emerged out of nowhere. But to say that the main accomplishment of Naficy's books is to remedy this shortcoming would be to undermine their importance in establishing the field anew. Throughout these four volumes, Naficy provides an exhaustive and unprecedented unpacking of the many histories, genres, moments, and texts that together define Iranian cinema.
Across the four volumes, Naficy tackles the vexed question of Iran's relationship to modernity via the history of cinema. The books conceive modernity as key to understanding this history, arguing that it affected the film industry “structurally by modernizing its mode of production and reception” but also by “inscribing modernity as content and style, and as sensorium” (vol. 1, p. 9). In his treatment of this relationship, Naficy recognizes both ruptures and continuities as they have occurred across the history of Iranian cinema, thereby further separating his project from works that conceptualize cinema as having been shaped by one single factor, namely the 1979 revolution.
Within each of the volumes, which are organized around broad historical periodizations (e.g., artisanal era, industrializing years, Islamicate period, globalizing era), Naficy explores areas as diverse as the development of genres (e.g., filmfārsī), institutional politics, formal strategies (such as those employed in the dissident mauj-i nau, or New Wave films), obscure movements (such as the documentary shorts of the 1960s on traditional Iranian arts), and industry statistics, to name but a few. In order to accommodate this broad span of topics, the longer chapters are divided into subsections. The scope of the project presents both difficulties and welcome challenges for even the most primed reader. On the one hand, the number of themes and their corresponding methodologies (e.g., close textual analysis, industry studies, etc.) make it somewhat difficult to hold every aspect of the argument together. This form of organization necessitates that some topics get rather brief investigation, a point that Naficy often humbly acknowledges, offering these as fruitful areas of study for younger scholars. On the other hand, the extensive research, combined with Naficy's use of numerous methodologies, opens up the field of Iranian film studies and demonstrates the impossibility of confining the field to one approach or narrative.
Another notable merit of the books is the meticulousness of Naficy's research. Drawing on newspapers and magazines, film archives, interviews with filmmakers and industry figures, policy papers from institutions such as the Ministry of Culture, visual ephemera such as film posters, spectatorship statistics, as well as existing research and film criticism in Persian that has rarely been utilized in English language scholarship, Naficy presents a detailed, almost encyclopedic vision of the history of Iranian cinema. At times, and particularly when drawing from interviews with filmmakers and industry figures, this goal of comprehensiveness results in an emphasis on “facts” and capturing “reality,” which is common to other works in the field, rather than on opening up the history of Iranian cinema to questions. It is also important to note that while Naficy is primarily a scholar of Iranian cinema, he was an active organizer of various cultural programs featuring Iranian film and art long before the heyday of the late 1990s. His research as well as this personal history with Iranian cinema are documented in detail in the books and supported by extensive visuals. These documents are effective in “lengthening” the history of Iranian cinema as an object of study in the Anglo-American academy.
The four volumes of A Social History of Iranian Cinema constitute a landmark achievement in a field that is still, in many ways, working to determine the problems, concepts, and modes of analysis that it deems most crucial. Although it calls itself a “social history,” Naficy's project will surely engage researchers and students seeking to augment the political and social dimensions of Iranian cinema with analyses of form, industry practices, and the relationship between cinema and other arts. In this regard, the books encapsulate how the study of Iranian cinema necessitates an interdisciplinary methodology. For students of Iranian cinema, I can think of no better place to begin than these four volumes. The sheer expansiveness of Naficy's project is a testimony to the untold narratives, theoretical paradigms, and concepts waiting to be found in the ongoing history of Iranian cinema.
