Fred Botting and Catherine Spooner's Monstrous Media/Spectral Subjects is a fine collection of essays examining the relationship between Gothic narratives and technology, with a particular eye towards the ways that new media create continuities and disruptions in storytelling. Part of a series of works curated by the International Gothic Association, this volume began as a number of papers from the association's Ninth Biennial Conference in 2009. As such, the chronologies, subjects and analytical approaches of the essays vary widely, and the works defined herein as ‘Gothic’ range from well-known classics such as Robert Louis Stevenson's Strange Case of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde (1886) to Jaume Balaguerò and Paco Plaza's widely underappreciated modern horror film Rec (2007). A similarly broad range of technologies is also more or less examined throughout, although the emphasis is often on narrative analysis rather than technological history.
The collection of eleven essays is foregrounded by an introduction from the editors, in which they state that the volume's aim is to examine how technological innovations give new life to old monsters, while at the same time these technologies become haunted, or ‘gothicized’, by the spectres they capture and make newly visible. Responding as many have to the Enlightenment discourse that scientific rationalism moves Western civilization away from superstition and myth, Botting and Spooner argue that ‘[t]he emergence of new technologies, the marvels of modernity and science, is intimately bound up with the production of monsters and ghosts’ (p. 1). The interplay between other-worldly beings and technology in the essays that follow is a reciprocal process of imagining and reimagining, of making the unreal real and the real uncanny, of Promethean tech emboldening deeply felt human anxieties, and of these hauntings becoming literal ghosts in machines.
Divided into three sections, the essays are roughly grouped by media: text, audio and film. Because of the wide diversity of topics, none of the sections form a cohesive narrative and each essay could stand alone from the context of the larger project at hand. Each section does, however, have its standouts. In the first – ‘Between image and text’ – literary scholar Elisabeth Bronfen offers a seemingly far-fetched, but brilliantly executed, reading of First World War-era poetry and film alongside George Romero's 2007 zombie movie Diary of the Dead. While those familiar with modern horror readily understand Romero's first work, Night of the Living Dead (1968), as being intimately connected to both the racial upheaval of the late 1960s and the Vietnam War, his more recent works retain their power as political commentary in the face of ongoing US and European conflicts in the Middle East. As Bronfen explores through both text and film, the figure of the zombie – or the destroyed body reborn – is both a consuming monster and a warning of the horror of wartime violence. Further, the technologies through which we encounter war have changed dramatically through the twentieth and twenty-first centuries, and thus, Bronfen argues, the war dead have also haunted and spoken to us through new and different forms.
The second section – ‘Sounding spectres’ – offers two strong essays on the power of music – and the ability of musicians – to subvert normalized expectations of musical sound and melody in ways that create deeply haunted and haunting soundscapes. ‘The earth died screaming: Tom Waits's Bone Machine’, by Steen Christiansen, argues that the monstrous is found in the way that Waits's discordant music causes a ‘breakdown in intelligibility’ between the recording and the listener (p. 73). Christiansen asserts that through an auditory awareness of spatiality; the appropriation and exaggeration of ‘rasp’ vocal tones associated with the working class, blackness and masculinity; and entropic layerings of noise produced from non-traditional practices of playing common instruments as well as his own found-object instrument ‘the conundrum’, Waits's music subsumes the listener in an audile haunted house.
Likewise, Dean Lockwood examines how industrial and social decay in 1970s Britain influenced the work of post-punk band Throbbing Gristle (TG). In his essay ‘Ghosts of the Gristleized’, Lockwood claims that TG sought to ‘place audiences in an experimental relation’ to what he terms ‘affective post-industrial futures’ (p. 88). For TG, ‘gristleization’ was both a material technology – custom-built, black-box modules through which the sounds of their instruments were filtered – and a performative practice that centred improvisation rather than composition. Both essays are important interventions in the visually centred historiographies of technology and horror and powerfully argue for the insidious ability of audio to create phantasmagoric, haunted internal landscapes in the listener. Further, they remind the reader that ‘technologies’ are not just material artefacts but also developed and embodied practices and forms.
In the final section – ‘Moving media’ – Agnieszka Monnet examines the power of personal witnessing allowed through hand-held recording technologies, a technique that has now become well trodden in modern horror, in her piece ‘Body genres, night vision, and the female monster: REC and the contemporary horror film’. By looking at one of the more recent iterations in the point-of-view/fictional-documentary/found-footage genre, Balaguerò and Plaza's 2007 film Rec, Monnet centres the technology of a hand-held video camera in creating particularly haunting engagements between audience and narrative. Importantly, Monnet revives the 1999 film The Blair Witch Project from the dustbin of parody, reminding the reader of the revolutionary nature of this kind of film-making that uniquely positions a particular piece of technology between the subject of the film and the terrifying other. Consciously emphasizing the camera lens sharpens and hones the intimacy between victim and monster in these films. The viewers are confined to the range of physical sight that the technology allows for, and the play between visibility and invisibility, as well as the nature of noise capture reminiscent of home videos in these films, creates deeply uncomfortable affinities between the viewer and the haunted, and often violently attacked, narrator. The ability of films of these kinds to terrorize the audience relies on an assumed familiarity with the video recording device. The horror narrative is formed around and through the presence of the camera.
While these essays touch on topics that have been well examined in the history of science and technology – the co-production of practices of viewing and imaging technologies, the ubiquitous cultural affiliation of inscription and preservation technologies with mourning and haunting, and the relationship between technology and biopolitics à la Foucault – few of the authors place their work in direct conversation with even canonical science studies texts (Stephen Curtis's ‘You have been saved: digital memory and salvation’ being the only notable exception). As such, historians of science and technology previously unfamiliar (or unconcerned) with either Gothic or horror studies may find these essays falling too far afield in the realm of literary or film criticism for their particular uses. There is no reason, however, why any number of these essays could not appear on a syllabus examining a range of topics in both the history of technology and media studies. Further, while the work as a whole does more to bring discussions of the history of technology into Gothic studies than Gothic studies into the history of technology, this collection is a refreshing examination of the ways technologies can create, enhance or become possessed by human fears that does not centre solely on science fiction narratives. These authors remind us that, despite the growth of techno-optimism, no amount of technological advance can ever make us safe from those things which go bump in the night. In many ways, technology's ability to hone and amplify these bumps makes them all the more terrifying.
