Politics might be understood as all talk—what do politicians do, after all, but engage in a verbal contest to mobilize support, demolish opponents, expound principles, and identify options? Now that the role of mass parties as the means of aggregating opinion within collective debates has diminished, leaders, always significant, have become the central actors in our understanding of the political world. Much of the debate about leader-central, personalized politics swings on the way leaders are said to frame our understanding of contemporary challenges and what to do about them. Michael Foley, for example, argues that the premier’s capture of the rhetoric of unity and conciliation is essential to the leadership portfolio (The British Presidency, 2000).
Dennis Grube’s argument is that although the rhetorical leadership of prime ministers has been pushed to the center of modern government, there has been insufficient attention to the ways it functions or to the institutional opportunities and constraints within which it must operate. Further, he insists that it be understood not simply as a process of rallying and persuasion but as integral to governance itself, the motivating force within “the networks that make government work” (p. 16). He sets out to address these deficiencies by systematically comparing and contrasting prime ministerial rhetoric within four Westminster jurisdictions: the United Kingdom, Canada, Australia, and New Zealand.
Grube is alert to (and informative about) indicators of cultural difference within these jurisdictions, but his delineation of shared rhetorical patterns persuasively demonstrates the master “scripts” on which successful prime ministers must call in the exercise of leadership. This is an illuminating exercise in historical institutionalism, and one especially attuned to the consistencies within majoritarian democracies. Institutional and political necessities, it seems, override our belief in distinctive traditions and social identities.
The author presents case studies of fundamental elements of the leadership portfolio: extraparliamentary performance, satisfying prime ministerial expectations, campaigning, policy narratives, intervention in subnational jurisdictions, and defining a legacy and consistency across government (including in relationship to managing mandarins). Drawing on myriad individual and cross-national instances, he plausibly constructs schematics (institutional patterns in performance as world leader, party leader, local member, policy advocate, etc.; p. 58) and heuristics (for example, composite elements of prime ministerial narratives for policy change; p. 101). This not only alerts us concerning how we should analyze leadership speech but also might serve as a primer for the aspiring prime minister or the canny speechwriter, though Grube is quick to say that the patterns he identifies arise not from conscious plans but organically from institutional necessities.
The interpretation is closely related to political time: While each of the previous elements imposes particular demands, what can be said will vary according to different points in the electoral cycle: “during elections, during policy debates or when leaving office … prime ministers say what they are expected to say because their range of rhetorical choices is constrained” (p. 21). Nevertheless, the effective leaders are those who can make creative use of the rhetorical possibilities available within the leadership portfolio. And there are striking examples confirming the obverse of Grube’s argument: The leader who fails to adapt to rhetorical demands of the leadership portfolio will be destroyed, no matter how good he or she is in “governing,” as was manifest in the downfall of Australian Prime Minister Julia Gillard, though her case is not discussed in this book.
Grube’s systematic, forensic, and methodical analysis is admirably suited to clarifying a field in which there have been many intimations of the significance of speech to contemporary leadership, but little enough done to begin the work of comprehensive empirical analysis. His enterprise is to be applauded. This is a book from which any student of leadership will benefit. Inevitably, in clearing the ground, he opens up potential sightlines on the limitations of his exercise: one constantly responds, “Ah yes, I see that now, but … ” For me, three dimensions demand more nuanced analysis.
First, the argument is supported by brief excerpts of multiple speeches, by various leaders, chosen to illustrate a point. Only in the discussion of policy narratives is there more lengthy exposition, and nowhere is there a detailed deconstruction of the ways in which a landmark speech works. While the process successfully illustrates the structures Grube wishes to expose, there is something missing: There are key differences that cannot be demonstrated in this way. For instance, Tony Blair and John Howard can, with the author’s method, be shown to be performing within the same constraints for particular purposes at specific times in the electoral cycle, but in using only excerpts, Blair’s capacity as an inspirational leader and Howard’s typical mode—dogged and methodical rather than inspired—are lost to view. We cannot see, then, the differentiation between Blair’s capacity, through rhetorical inspiration alone, to salvage his administration (and leadership) from the results of his haphazard, ad hoc, and sometimes chaotic methods of government and Howard’s incremental, process-oriented discourse, even though both can be broken down into the schematics Grube expounds.
Second, even though Grube points out that for prime ministers “the opposition” is always “the villain in the piece,” this is, for him, a subsidiary element. He pays insufficient attention to the dark arts of rhetoric, the fact that these may have little connection to future governance but might be enormously important. For instance, arguably Australian Prime Minister Paul Keating won the 1993 federal election—one that every commentator insisted was “unlosable” for opposition leader John Hewson, given that Labor had been governing for a decade and Keating’s poll support was low—entirely by destroying Hewson and his plans. The highlights of this forensic demolition are still accessible on YouTube. This was not about governance—Keating had tried that with big ideas about cultural renaissance, national training schemes and Asian engagement, but they failed to turn the tide. Instead, in his own words, he “threw the switch to vaudeville,” with remarkable results. In so doing, he broke the mold so assiduously delineated by Grube.
Third, the conflation of rhetorical leadership and governance is unconvincing. Grube points out that theories of governance arise because conventional ideas of government and formal administrative practice fail to capture what is now a networked policy domain, including legislative, public sector, private enterprise, market-oriented, think-tank, lobbying, voluntary sector, and other actors. It cannot be a command-and-control system, but “the importance of rhetorical leadership [is] to keep these networks moving. … [The prime ministers’] framing of reality not only defines a policy problem but also effectively shackles the entire governance network to it in that form” (p. 16). This depends on showing that all of the actors within the network are responsive to the prime minister’s rhetorical lead. Yet even Grube’s cases show that this is not always so. His chapters on policy narratives and on intervention in subnational jurisdictions include instances where “the narrative” failed to move the network: Kevin Rudd’s ambitious health reforms, for example. In such cases, even though a dominant narrative was achieved, the author concedes, it was not enough. Still, he argues, “they do illustrate the rhetorical options and constraints within which prime ministers can operate” (p. 128). Indeed, but that is not the same as showing that words and action are inexorably linked, that governance is yoked to rhetoric.
Briefly, Grube makes a beneficial contribution to our understanding of the ways in which institution, role and political timing shape political rhetoric. His cross-jurisdictional framework persuades us that common imperatives related to these factors are more influential than local traditions or domestic political culture. This constitutes a significant elaboration on earlier work on the leadership repertoire. Yet leaders can still stretch the bounds he so carefully maps—to be more or less inspirational in their ability to “perform” the shared formula, or to be more or less concerned with destruction of an opponent as a means to victory rather than with policy or governance. In fact, the assertion of “rhetorical governance,” while worthy of consideration in the terms Grube establishes, is overstated: The leader narrative does not, we see, consistently “shackle the governance network” in the manner intended.
