This now two-year-old monograph was conceived initially as a 2002 Princeton University doctoral dissertation; it has been generally well received by scholars of the Crusades. The author's topic is the untidy encounter of two worlds: that of the “Franks” (the catch-all term used by Near Easterners for the Latin Catholic conquerors) and that of local Christians over whom the Latin warriors held sway. The latter world was itself untidy, encompassing three substantial currents of eastern Christianity: defined on Christological grounds, these were the Melkites (Greek Orthodox), Jacobites (Syrian Orthodox), and Armenians, along with smaller divisions, notably, the Maronites of the Lebanese mountains and the Nestorians, concentrated much farther east (only some of whom came under direct Latin rule). The scope of the book is fairly narrow in terms of its topic and chronology, but its lasting merit lies in its offering a rare perspective on early Crusader history and, thus, modern historiography of the Crusades.
MacEvitt takes issue with two long-held views of Latin rule in the Levant. The older of these, driven largely by French colonial-era scholarship, saw a highly tolerant and integrated Crusader East. MacEvitt is particularly keen to dispel the second, later view, which, in reaction to the earlier views of French historiography, posited a “segregationalist,” even “apartheid,” model (p. 21). This approach was ill conceived on several grounds not only in seeing Latin rule as driven by contemporary European patterns of heresy, schism, and persecution but also for leading generations of historians to treat the Frankish Levant as emblematic of an emergent medieval Europe. Neither model holds in MacEvitt's view. To replace them, he argues for a more subtle approach, one that takes the nuances of Crusades history far more into account. The effort is to recognize the highly variegated nature of this religious and political history. It was a history, he argues, in which Frankish rule was conducted most often in practical, day-by-day and highly localized terms. (After all, the territories of Latin rule were in some respects as varied as the Christian populations with whom they interacted.)
To describe the approach of the Frankish aristocrats to their subject communities, MacEvitt introduces the notion of “rough tolerance” (hence his subtitle; pp. 21–22). He admits to the difficulty of pinning down a definition of the phrase; by “rough,” one takes him to mean not only that the Frankish rulers employed coercion when needed but also that they often made things up as they went along. The notion, though, seems clear enough, and, for the most part, one is convinced. MacEvitt demonstrates clearly that Frankish princes generally allowed their different Christian subjects to practice religion as they saw fit, even extending patronage to local, non-Latin churches. He brings useful archeological evidence to bear in making his case (pp. 124–30). This reader would have appreciated more consistent references to “rough tolerance,” as there are stretches of the book where the phrase seems to disappear, but again, in general terms it serves a useful purpose in organizing a rather chaotic history.
Other readers have expressed particular and quite appropriate appreciation for MacEvitt's treatment of the history of Latin Edessa (Chapter 3: “Images of Authority in Edessa, 1100–1150”). It is indeed an excellent discussion, in large part for taking up a chapter of Crusader history that has usually moldered in Jerusalem's shadow. Following the initial conquest, Edessa was ruled briefly by Baldwin I of Boulogne—founder of the County of Edessa and its prince from 1098 to 1100—then, for a much longer period, by Baldwin II (both men went on to rule in Jerusalem). The consolidation of Latin rule meant, of course, a confrontation with Armenian lords and their forces. MacEvitt demonstrates that, despite overall success in this regard, Latin aims were mostly driven by immediate rather than ideological (or sectarian?) concerns; the Franks usually conducted themselves on a give and take basis with the local church and palace elite. The lessons learned remained “a reference library” (p. 98) for Frankish rulers in Palestine, even when Edessa's short stint as Frankish territory came to an end.
MacEvitt ends his discussion with the turn of the 12th century. If it is a somewhat abrupt closing, MacEvitt justifies it by noting that even before Salah al-Din's reconquest of Jerusalem (1187), the era of “rough tolerance” was giving way to a less open-minded, more sharply edged environment. At least two emergent patterns were clear by century's end. The first was a Byzantine campaign of ecumenism, announced by Manuel I. Komnenos in the cycle of wall mosaics that figured among his renovations of Bethlehem's Basilica of the Nativity (1169), which aimed to create “a unified Byzantine world in the Mediterranean” (p. 159). The second pattern was largely the result of the Byzantine policy: a heightening of identity politics across the region, particularly within the Armenian and Jacobite churches. A stated quest for unity, recognized by all parties involved as a bid for supremacy on the part of Constantinople, led to more sharply edged boundaries among the Christians of the Levant by the 13th century.
The book is appropriate for upper-level teaching, particularly at the graduate level; it will need to be accompanied by more introductory readings, as MacEvitt presumes a good deal of background knowledge of the First Crusade and its aftermath. As a work of revisionism, it is clearly argued and defended, and the historiographical pitfalls are plainly marked. The book includes useful commentary throughout on the various traditions of medieval Near Eastern Christian historiography.
