Female dancers and actresses have had an elusive place in history until recent gender studies began to unveil women's works in the public sphere of the past. In her new book, Moira Goff provides us with vivid images of a dancer-actress of eighteenth-century England, adeptly placing the sparse pieces of information into a mosaic. The Incomparable Hester Santlow: A Dancer-Actress on the Georgian Stage stands as one of the invaluable studies of women's history, and traces the life and career of Hester Santlow in the web of the personal affairs and turbulent events of the London theatres.
This book is a complete rewriting of Goff's doctoral thesis, Art and Nature Join'd: Hester Santlow and the Development of Dancing on the London Stage, 1700–1737 (University of Kent at Canterbury, 2000), which aimed to identify Santlow's achievements as a dancer and her contributions to English stage dance during a period when the style of theatrical dancing was undergoing radical change, by virtue of the innovations of John Weaver, John Rich. and others. In this book Goff turns her focus to Hester Santlow herself, and illustrates a woman of talent, wit, and intelligence by examining her acting roles, portraits, and notations of the dances she performed, as well as the records of theatre personnel, advertisements of performances, and eyewitness accounts. Goff aptly portrays the dancer-actress as a woman through the characters Santlow played and the words of her contemporary critics, along with detailed descriptions of her hairstyles and costumes as well as her physical features in the iconographic sources. As Goff herself describes it, the book is “closer to a chronicle than an analysis” of Santlow's theatrical contributions (ix), and its ten chapters are constructed in such a way as to draw a picture of each stage of her life and career and present them chronologically.
Hester Santlow came from an obscure background, but seems to have been reasonably well educated. She made her dancing debut as an apprentice to the theatrical dancer René Cherrier at the Theatre Royal in Drury Lane in 1706, when she was still in her early teens. Immediately she distinguished herself as an excellent dancer and collaborated with the major choreographers on the London stage. In 1709 she made her acting debut at Drury Lane and thereafter developed an acting career in tandem with that of dancing. She bore a daughter, Harriot, with James Craggs, who later became one of King George I's leading ministers, but this relationship and her parenthood were no obstacles to her stage career. She continued to perform throughout the period when competition between Lincoln's Inn Fields Theatre (run by John Rich) and Drury Lane (to which Santlow belonged) became fierce, and when John Weaver's ideas of “Dramatic Entertainments of Dancing” were being realized on the stage. Several years after her relationship with Craggs had ended, she married Drury Lane's leading actor and comanager, Barton Booth. The London theatres developed pantomime entertainments, and Mrs. Booth too was involved in these productions. Following the death of her husband in May 1733, she decided to leave the stage in September of the same year. Her only child, Harriot, was married into the social rank of the Craggs, as were Harriot's children, thus making Hester Booth a mother and grandmother within an extended aristocratic family where she remained much loved until her death in 1773.
Goff's comments throughout the book are often speculative, which is inevitable given the interpretative methodology she has chosen in order to make the most of the scanty information available, but she is at times more affirmative than the speculation upon intangible matters might suggest. How can it be “obvious,” for example, that James Craggs was Santlow's “first lover” (48), when documents exist that insinuate she was a mistress of the Duke of Marlborough before her relationship with Craggs began (32)? Similarly, Goff's comment on George Anne Bellamy's account of Barton Booth's mistress is hardly persuasive. Why does Goff dismiss Bellamy's sympathetic account of the mistress's tragic death around the time of Booth's marriage to Santlow as “highly embellished and extremely unreliable” just because “[t]here is no other evidence for this incident” (96)? Goff's strong objection is perplexing, given that there are “conflicting accounts” of the end of this liaison, as she herself points out (95).
While deeply impressed by the author's ability to draw vibrant images of a historical figure from limited sources, as a dance researcher I am disappointed by her discussions of notated dances. Goff describes dance events (steps and spatial movements) of all the notated dances that are known to have been performed by Santlow, but a series of events does not illuminate the essence of a choreography by itself. From statements such as “L'Abbé apparently responded directly to the complexities of the music, and the abilities of his dancers” (40), or “[Santlow's] surviving notated dances … record the sophistication and musicality of her dancing” (163), the reader would expect analytical evidence, which is unfortunately absent in this book. On the other hand, Goff offers valuable information to conjecture the unnotated choreography of Santlow's popular dances, such as “Dutch Skipper” (11), the “French Peasant” (53), “Myrtillo” (78) and “Hussar Dance” (113), by skillfully linking them with the extant musical sources and notated dances.
The glossary of dance terms is composed with Goff's economical words based on her interpretations, rather than quotations from the treatises of Rameau and Tomlinson, as the reader might presume from her footnote (165, n. 1). This is a sensible decision, as the quotations would be lengthy, and the definitions of steps are disputable in themselves. This book is undoubtedly a result of the author's dedication and fascination with the charming theatrical figure of Hester Santlow. It is a unique testimony to the eighteenth-century English society that allowed this woman of exceptional strengths and abilities to realize the scope of her artistic and social achievements.
