She Hath Been Reading: Women and Shakespeare Clubs in America invites the reader inside the meetings, scrapbooks, performances, dinner parties, and charitable works of the more than five hundred women's Shakespeare clubs in the United States between 1880 and 1940. At the intersection of the history of Shakespeare in the United States and accounts of American women's clubs, Katherine West Scheil offers a persuasive new narrative about the reading of Shakespeare and its impact on women's lives and communities. Scheil's meticulous archival research demonstrates that Shakespeare clubs not only fostered women's intellectual development and critical thinking skills, but also functioned as sites for social transformation and political action. Looking beyond performances of the Bard in professional theatre and outside the use of Shakespeare in educational institutions, Scheil intervenes in the history of Shakespeare in America, writing a history of Shakespeare as “material for inspiration, adaptation, community building, and the life of the mind for ordinary readers in ordinary places” (122).
Scheil's engaging study of “ordinary readers” asserts that a canonical author like Shakespeare does indeed have meaning beyond institutions of power and privilege. The Shakespeare club readers she investigates are women from diverse social classes and various racial backgrounds, in both urban and rural settings, who employed the literary practice of “booktalk” to find meaning through multiple conversations in different contexts (42). Clubwomen found meaning in Shakespeare in many ways, including preparing discussion questions and quizzes on Shakespeare's plays, adapting Shakespeare in spoofs and satires, writing and publishing criticism in periodicals, impersonating characters, and debating heroines like Katherine and Portia as role models. She Hath Been Reading follows reader-response theory and recent work in book history to extend the concept of reading beyond the private sphere and farther than communal club meetings to include public community activities. Scheil's broad definition of reading therefore applies to such Shakespeare club activities as holding formal dinners honoring Shakespeare, establishing public Shakespeare memorials and parks, supporting local educational charities and libraries, and promoting women's suffrage.
Scheil depends on archives of club materials for these diverse examples of women's engagement with Shakespeare. Patchy club recordkeeping leaves the evidence uneven at times, and Scheil admits that her examples are representative, not exhaustive (xiv). Some clubs get more attention than others, with the Dallas Shakespeare Club, the Portia Club of Avon, Illinois, and the Ladies' Coterie of Topeka, Kansas, serving as key examples. Scheil crafts her narrative with painstaking research into Shakespeare club records and ephemera, personal diaries and letters, the programs of formal Shakespeare memorial dinners, discussion questions in American Shakespeare Magazine, women's essays in Shakespeariana, and notices posted in Shakespeare Association Bulletin. She also supplies a notated list of the hundreds of Shakespeare clubs in the United States during the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries, providing a valuable resource for scholars interested in American literary clubs, or readers curious about local women's history.
She Hath Been Reading begins (in Chapter 1, “Reading”) with an overview of the reading practices of clubwomen, focusing on how the concepts of reading and booktalk challenge the boundaries between private and public. Reading Shakespeare created an intellectual space in the home, whereas discussions at club meetings introduced women to criticism and Shakespeare studies, broadening their intellectual community. Scheil demonstrates that club debates about Shakespeare's heroines allowed women to “‘talk back to’ Shakespeare,” grappling with issues of sexuality, gender, and social roles (45). The book's second chapter, “The Home,” examines the role of reading Shakespeare in women's domestic lives, both how the clubs brought Shakespeare into the home and how reading Shakespeare brought “women out of the home, through civic engagement, philanthropic work, and public activism” (63). Scheil relies on the diaries of clubwomen, as well as on club scrapbooks and banquet programs, to argue that incorporating domestic cooking and crafting skills into club activities helped create a safe space that encouraged imaginative and dialogic identification with Shakespeare's women (75). The next chapter, titled “The Outpost,” looks beyond urban centers to Shakespeare clubs in small towns and rural communities. Here Scheil contends that women in frontier towns assumed responsibility for morality and social stability, and consequently used Shakespeare clubs to build community, advocate literacy, and civilize the West. Although this chapter provides a welcome discussion of literary culture in remote locations often ignored by literary history, it could benefit from a more rigorous examination of the Shakespeare clubs' idealized notion of civilization. In “Shakespeare and Black Women's Clubs,” the book's final chapter, Scheil investigates how black women's clubs recognized the cultural power of canonical authors, and read Shakespeare as part of a larger commitment to education, empowerment, and upward mobility. Scheil acknowledges that “the paucity of materials on black women's clubs leaves many questions unanswered” (103); for example, she is unable to determine how clubs discussed racial issues in specific Shakespeare texts. Nevertheless, this chapter serves as an invitation to other scholars to explore further this unexamined corner of African American literary history.
Scheil's analysis speaks to scholars of Shakespeare, women's literary history, and the women's club movement in the United States. Occasionally she assumes her reader is already knowledgeable of these histories, leaving explanations to the endnotes—teachers may need to provide context before assigning reading. Theatre scholars will appreciate Chapter 1's discussion of how women's clubs performed Shakespeare, using techniques such as writing satires, reading aloud in dialect, and cross-dressing to test social roles and experiment with gender identity. She Hath Been Reading demonstrates that long before Barbara Garson satirized the Johnson administration in MacBird! or Paula Vogel addressed feminism and social class in Desdemona: A Play about a Handkerchief, the “ordinary readers” of America's clubwomen found transformation and empowerment through Shakespeare.
