This is not a conventional study of Roman artefacts, and nor is it intended as such. Rather than dividing material by types or functional categories, Swift draws on perspectives from design and craft theory, and the chapters explore the creation, use and experience of objects. Readers looking for a more general introduction to Roman material culture would be well served by the excellent volume edited by Lindsay Allason-Jones, Artefacts in Roman Britain: Their Purpose and Use (2011).
S.’s focus is on Roman Britain and the Western provinces, with some Egyptian material also included. Although use is made of experimental work and consultation with craft-practitioners, the main strength is the extensive and detailed first-hand study of objects in museum collections across Europe. This has allowed S. to investigate design aspects that affect function and user experience, as well as wear traces which can reveal the (sometimes unexpected) ways in which objects were actually used.
The four main chapters are entitled ‘Function’, ‘Behaviour/Experience’, ‘Users’ and ‘Production and Users’. ‘Function’ explores the relationship between objects’ forms and their patterns of use. While all objects have affordances that incline people towards specific uses, S. follows B. Preston (in P. Graves-Brown (ed.), Matter, Materiality and Modern Culture (2000), 22–49) in distinguishing between the ‘proper function’ (intended by the maker) and the ‘system function’ (how objects were used in practice). For example (19–22), early Roman round-bowled spoons are best suited to eating or serving from curved-sided vessels, but S. established that many have flat wear-patterns on the bowl. This suggests they were actually often used against a flat surface, possibly to measure out specialised commodities such as spices. To investigate these more nuanced aspects of function, S. compares affordances apparent in the design and handling properties of objects with their use-wear (spoons and rings, 19–31), context (shears, 56–99) and the end-products that tools were used to make (pens, 31–56). The study of pens and their relationship to written scripts is particularly elegant, showing how incremental changes and adaptations can have far-reaching and unintended consequences.
The second chapter, ‘Behaviour/Experience’, considers how the material properties of objects shaped, and were shaped by, social behaviour and cultural traditions, for example how drinking-horns supported particular modes of drinking (103–9). Issues of taste and smell are also addressed for spoons, strigils and styli (110–13), where the materials chosen would have affected the sensory experience of using these objects. S. proposes this as a way to approach discrepant experience between elites and non-elites but, as she acknowledges, it is hard to move beyond simple description.
‘Users’ explores assumptions about intended users, and how the design of objects may have functioned to include or exclude particular groups (such as left-handed people), and to either maintain or challenge social norms. The most powerful case study (150–90) considers the relationship between motifs on finger-rings and Roman life-courses and gender identity. Correlations between particular motifs and ranges of internal ring-diameters (combined with evidence from texts, visual sources and burials) suggest which designs might be associated with men, women or children. Many of the conclusions are unsurprising, but this is nevertheless a fruitful example of how different strands of evidence can be combined, and finding creative ways to study objects which lack context.
The final main chapter, ‘Production and Users’, examines the relationship between production processes and user experience, especially in terms of standardisation, scale of production and material constraints. The production of two main object types is considered: dice (203–11) and mould-blown square-sided glass bottles (211–27). Dice were previously addressed in the ‘Behaviour/Experience’ chapter, where it was noted that many examples, especially in bone, are ‘flat’ (having one shorter axis) which generally makes it more likely that a 1 or a 6 will be thrown, affecting the experience of game-play. In this chapter, S. argues that the preponderance of ‘flat’ dice was a largely unintentional consequence of the form of the bones used and the standard production process. This can thus be seen as an example of the ‘agency of materials’, where factors beyond human control affect the final design. Likewise, it is argued that while particular glass vessels relate to standard measures attested in texts, they are often slightly inaccurate due to variations in wall thickness. While these arguments are undoubtedly sound, these variations seem unlikely to have had a big impact on society, or even the experience of individuals beyond what has already been discussed in previous chapters.
Through this book, S. seeks to contribute to two main strands of research: Roman social history and theoretical frameworks surrounding artefact-human interactions. She undoubtedly succeeds on both counts, but the real strength of the book is in the latter sphere. In terms of the contribution to Roman studies, a key element is the use of ordinary provincial objects to consider reproduction of (and challenges to) Roman cultural practices among non-elites (rather than focusing on the elite spheres of inscriptions, sculpture and mosaics). The reader is often left wanting more in these areas: How important would standard measures have been to the people who bought liquids in glass bottles? What was the wider social role of the games of chance in which dice were deployed? Each of these topics could merit a book in its own right. What S. has produced is a unique contribution to material culture studies which provides a set of tools for thinking with and about everyday objects. It is rare to find such sensitive and nuanced theoretical discussion combined with a grounded focus on archaeological data, and S.’s book deserves to be widely read.
