In Life: Organic Form and Romanticism, Denise Gigante makes the bold claim that the most powerful and fertile cultural movement of the late eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries was the product of a fundamental shift within the life sciences, from an understanding of the types and forms of life as distinct and preformed, to an insistence on the inherent power of life to shape itself. For Gigante, vitalism ‘generated Romanticism as a wide-sweeping inquiry into the phenomena of life’ (p. 39), while Romanticism itself is the impulse behind vitalist biology writ large. According to Gigante, ‘The implications of [vitalism] across many strands of culture at the end of the eighteenth century, when the paradigm change from a Christian cosmology to a world of self-shaping matter took place, were vast’. To identify this as a ‘paradigm shift from God to nature’ (p. 29) as Gigante does would have surprised (and appalled) many of her key Romantic spokesmen, while her argument that ‘cellular biology killed off the unifying principle of Romanticism’ (p. 36) in the 1830s seems similarly overstated. Gigante seems torn between lamenting the end of vitalism and Romanticism and hailing their regeneration. As a result, she tends to exaggerate unnecessarily both the finality of their passing and the resemblances between nineteenth-century vitalism and twenty-first-century developmental biology and medicine.
Gigante's thesis may be overstated, but it remains highly suggestive. Her exploration of the intersections between Romanticism and vitalism might in principle shed light on both the history of science and Romantic poetry. As she remarks, in an age of polymaths conducting investigations both experimentally and through language, ‘Natural philosophers and poets were on a relatively even playing field when it came to discovering and representing “the character of all life and being”’ (p. 24). As it is, Gigante wisely holds off from advancing the claim that Romantic poetry informed the scientific debates themselves. The one poet she cites at any length who had the cultural prominence to exercise such influence is Samuel Taylor Coleridge, but it is as a theoretician rather than as a poet that Coleridge features within the book. Instead Gigante concentrates on four case studies, each centring on a single long poem by a different poet. Christopher Smart's Jubilate Agno existed in a single manuscript known only to a very small circle. William Blake's Jerusalem, like his other illuminated books, circulated barely more widely; only five copies are known to have been printed in his lifetime. Percy Bysshe Shelley had to die before a publisher would consent to print ‘The Witch of Atlas’, and even then his Posthumous Poems (1824) were suppressed on his father's insistence. Even Keats, whose poem Lamia is the subject of Gigante's fourth case study, did not within his own lifetime achieve anything like the prominence accorded to him by poets and critics since his death. Gigante characterizes Shelley as writing ‘from the center of the Romantic Zeitgeist’ (p. 228). Whatever the geometry of the Zeitgeist, all of these poets wrote more or less from the margins of their culture as a whole.
Gigante's choice of case studies, then, directs us to see vitalism reflected in and refracted through Romantic poetry, rather than Romantic poetry as shaping vitalist biology itself. Gigante suggests that, for the Romantic poet, a poem ought to be a living, self-shaping organism. She persuasively argues for this ‘epigenesist’ poetics as a key to enriched readings of Jubilate Agno and Jerusalem. This ideal of poetry is manifest in the form of the works themselves: in the unbound leaves of Smart's manuscript which cannot comfortably be arranged into a final, linear sequence; in the interplay of text and illustrations in Blake's book; and in the long, free verse lines the two poets devised to break free from conventional expectations of rhyme and metre. It is manifest too in the playful suggestiveness and punning of Smart's poem, drawn out well although perhaps overenthusiastically by Gigante, and in the complex interrelations of the different allegorical characters of Blake's prophetic myths, explored in the richest and most thoroughly convincing chapter of the book.
Epigenesist poetics manifest themselves in a different way in the figure of Shelley's Witch, while both the Hermaphrodite in his poem and the title character in Keats's Lamia are for Gigante embodiments of monstrosity, explained as resulting from an excess of vitality. Gigante's attempts to situate these poems within the vitalist debate are less persuasive. This is partly because their verse is tightly and deliberately structured, undermining such claims as, ‘As Lamia explodes in all the colors of excessive vitality … she breaks free formally from the straightened pattern of neoclassical couplets and the mechanism of allegorical romance that would presume to contain her’ (pp. 209–210). The couplets, simply, remain unbroken. If these poems obstinately refuse to conform to Gigante's expectations of a vitalist aesthetic, the Hermaphrodite and Lamia herself resist the attempts to read them as embodying monstrosity in terms derived from the vitalist debate. Crucially, Gigante misses the key point that the life of mythic beings cannot be contained within biological parameters, even monstrous ones. To remark that Lamia's ‘monstrosity, vitalist in nature, would not have been possible in the mechanistic world of Newton’ (p. 212) is to fail to recognize that Keats's poem depends upon Lamia's very impossibility, for all that she is indeed ‘exceedingly beautiful and excessively vital’ (p. 210).
In the introduction to her book, Gigante argues for a Coleridgean hermeneutics of analogy in place of a historical method that tries to establish firm homologies. In the end, her approach is only partly persuasive. Failing in her ambition to revolutionize our conception of Romanticism and to reassert a Romantic conception of life, Gigante succeeds nonetheless in introducing the fruitful and highly suggestive concept of an epigenesist poetics.
