Egypt's political economy continues to offer scholars a rich case from which to theorize about the “development of underdevelopment” more generally. Goldberg's book is a masterful, detailed exploration of the regulatory policies, economic theories, and business interests that underpinned Egypt's specialization in high-quality cotton fiber during the first half of the 20th century. Chowdhury's volume focuses on the contemporary period and draws on class analysis and postmodernism to critique the exclusionary aspects of Egypt's turn toward neoliberalism. These works employ different approaches and highlight distinctive findings but converge in their emphasis on the social costs and human deprivation that have accompanied Egypt's development trajectory.
Goldberg presents an intriguing revisionist account of Egypt's economic development from the late 19th through the first half of the 20th century, expanding upon earlier political-economy studies of this period by Charles Issawi, Bert Hansen, Roger Owen, and Robert Vitalis. The volume puts forward new interpretations about why development outcomes diverged so significantly among countries reliant on fiber export sectors in the early part of the 20th century. A great strength of this book is that Egyptian regulatory interventions are compared with those of Japan (raw silk), Germany (rayon), the American South and California (cotton), and Central Asia (cotton). In doing so, Goldberg convincingly undermines some of the most widespread and simplistic formulations in the literature on comparative development. He takes particular aim at two: that state “weakness” and lack of capacity explain adverse development outcomes and that cheap labor is a comparative advantage in fostering industrialization. Goldberg turns both arguments on their heads and in doing so offers a book that should be of great interest to scholars of comparative politics and development in general as well as those interested in the political economy of the Middle East.
The central thesis of the book is that Egyptian political and economic elites successfully constructed a reputation for Egyptian cotton as the “world's best” through a variety of public and private regulatory interventions but at the cost of sustaining a demand for illiterate child labor. Goldberg charts how Egyptian elites—a diverse lot of growers, ginners, traders, government advisors, administrators, and entrepreneurs—coalesced in “coalitions of influence” to produce sophisticated administrative policies and institutions. These regulatory interventions included ensuring uniformity in cotton seed, harvest, and bales, creating new financial institutions such as futures markets, establishing investment incentives and cartels in associated industries, and restructuring labor markets.
Goldberg argues that many of these policies achieved their intended objectives, enhancing the reputation of Egyptian cotton in order to create a niche in the global fiber market. However, the very success of these interventions also helped entrench perverse outcomes, most notably, maintaining incentives for the widespread use of child labor. Goldberg argues that Egyptian elites failed to exclude children from labor markets through regulation, in large part because the production of high-quality cotton relied on the use of child labor. Although labor regulation under Nasser's regime belatedly excluded children from working in public-sector industrial enterprises, he shows that these interventions were not designed to eliminate child labor in other sectors, particularly agriculture.
For Goldberg, Egypt's path to economic “involution” cannot be attributed to weak state capacity but rather to sustained regulatory interventions that reinforced the position of illiterate, ill-paid child labor as a central feature in Egypt's production of high-quality agricultural goods for international markets. This form of comparative advantage, however, made it increasingly difficult for Egypt's elites either to desire or envision restructuring factor endowments to eliminate illiteracy and child labor, a problem that remains unresolved in Egypt today.
This schematic presentation of the central argument does not capture the wealth of detail and analysis that Goldberg brings to his historical material. The book progresses chronologically and thematically around significant transformations in Egyptian economic thought and regulatory practice, from the colonial period through the early labor legislation of the Nasser regime. Some of the subjects examined in this book are significantly understudied in comparative political economy, such as the workings of commodity markets. In a noteworthy chapter, Goldberg explores the evolution of the spot and futures markets for cotton in Alexandria. Established by private brokerage houses owned primarily by European and resident minorities, these commodity markets were later regulated by the state, influenced by new regulatory coalitions articulating notions of economic nationalism.
Goldberg's book further offers several new historical interpretations on issues considered settled. For instance, significant declines in aggregate cotton yields during the early 20th century have been portrayed by contemporary historians as evidence of an ecological crisis, brought on by British imperial neglect in investing in drainage systems for perennially irrigated fields. Goldberg shows that, ironically, the narrative of ecological crisis was originally employed by British officials to highlight their commitment to modernizing Egyptian agriculture in the face of what they argued was local mismanagement and overexploitation. Both the colonial and nationalist versions of the ecological crisis narrative, Goldberg argues, underplay the significant role of Egyptian elites in constructing the colonial economic order. Goldberg further shows that the significant decline in cotton yields was largely the result of Egyptian growers shifting from long-staple to extra-long-staple cotton varieties. Long-staple cotton commanded a higher price per unit even as it produced smaller aggregate yields.
The text throughout draws on a variety of underutilized historical sources. One such source is the interwar writings of Egyptian economists in Arabic, French, and English. Goldberg's presentation of discussions among Egyptian economists regarding Keynesian approaches to state intervention reveals that these individuals held a sophisticated understanding of Egyptian development challenges.
Moving to the contemporary period, Chowdhury's book takes aim at Egypt's turn toward neoliberal development policies, drawing on her experience as a participatory research consultant for the United Nations Development Programme. Her goal is to apply class analysis and postmodern theorizing to uncover “alternative,” participatory forms of development, a promise not fully realized in the book. She situates her work in the broader field of postmodern studies as part of a critique of what she sees as the homogenizing discourses and exclusionary economic practices of modern capitalism.
Chowdhury frames the book in terms of interrogating different notions of economic participation. She argues that neoliberal approaches to economic development are premised on a narrow understanding of economic participation as access to markets. In contrast, she argues for thinking about forms of economic participation that promote labor ownership and recognize diverse, noncapitalist forms of production and sustenance. The author suggests that participatory research strategies (such as participatory rural appraisal, rapid rural appraisal, agro-ecosystems analysis, and applied anthropology) offer a practical mechanism to develop context-specific, local knowledge of diverse economic practices by fostering dialogue between local communities and experts. These research techniques, for Chowdhury, hold the potential to move away from the positivist assumptions of neoclassical economics and exclusionary implementation of top-down development planning. This potential is not fully demonstrated in the text through either applications of such methodologies or reporting of field studies and might constitute an interesting avenue for Chowdhury to explore in future work.
This book is a revised dissertation and, like many such works, offers a dense theoretical introduction before moving to case studies of tourism development and protest in Luxor and of small-scale rotating savings and credit associations in Cairo. The opening theoretical section presents labor theories of participation (which rely heavily on Marx's distinction between necessary and surplus labor) in order to generate a framework for classifying the diversity of noncapitalist activities in “modern” economies. These diverse economic practices are then associated with social processes of identity formation, cast here as movements of local resistance against modernization and Westernization.
The author's interpretation of everyday economic practices as “hidden transcripts” of resistance proves problematic. The author does not elucidate linkages between economic practices, class differentiation, and communal mobilization; eliding everyday economic practices with identity-based collective action obscures some interesting possibilities for distinction and analysis. Chowdhury's reliance on theories of surplus value further means that self-ownership of labor is treated as more significant than other facets of work, such as risk management, wage level, and the possibilities of collective action offered by participation in hierarchical, corporate organizations. One outcome is that self-employment in the informal sector is regarded somewhat nostalgically as a kind of resistance to capitalism.
The case-study chapters rely heavily on previous accounts of tourism and exclusion in Luxor by Tim Mitchell and Lila Abu Lughod, among others, and the material on popular neighborhoods in Cairo and savings associations draws on previous research by scholars including Diane Singerman and Hoda Hoodfar. An overview chapter covering Egypt's political economy and economic participation precedes the case studies and similarly draws on well-known scholarly work. The material in all of these chapters is presented lucidly and with a clear focus on the exclusionary character of Egypt's development trajectory, particularly for the rural and urban poor.
The chief contribution of Chowdhury's book is its emphasis on the importance of analyzing class formation and differentiation when evaluating claims about participation in the economy. This is an underappreciated subject in Middle Eastern political economy, and the volume should be of interest to scholars interested in informal sectors, urban and rural political economy, and economic participation.
