An odd truth about ubiquitous things is that they tend to be invisible, everywhere, and thus seemingly nowhere. And, one might add, often inaudible as well. Popular music around the world, for example, thrums relentlessly in ears that hear it as too coarse, rustic, market-driven, or simply mundane for comment, no less scholarship. This explains why ethnomusicologist Andrew Weintraub, through a history of dangdut, introduces his own discipline to Indonesia's “most popular music” more than forty years after the genre was born. Dangdut Stories joins other strong anthropological writing on Indonesian popular music (Brent Luvaas's work comes to mind), but this is the first monograph-length genre study of dangdut, as well as its first musically detailed treatment in English. Dangdut Stories has important repercussions for the study of Asian popular music, as well as for the analysis of regional cultures and their relationship to the supranationalist state.
The book's structure is deceptively simple. At one level, it is a linear history proceeding from the musical antecedents of dangdut in the 1930s to its first possible examples alongside orkes melayu in the 1950s, from its coinage and ascendance in the 1970s to its popular peak in the 1990s, and on through its stylistic diversification in the present. For undergraduates in particular, this setup will be a friendly on-ramp to the material. The chronological approach, however, also serves a trenchant critical point: dangdut is musically cosmopolitan, very much a stylistic global blend, despite the fact that ideologues have incessantly claimed it as the organic product of a singular, mythologized Indonesian identity. Weintraub's carefully told history puts the lie to such essentialism. In chapter 4—the book's most potent—Weintraub posits three modes of articulation between dangdut music and “the people,” the latter encapsulated by the slippery term rakyat. In the first mode, dangdut is said to be a natural emanation of the experience of lower-class Indonesians. In the second, dangdut is used as the local channel par excellence for transmitting moral messages to the masses. In the third, dangdut is made symbolic of an authentic Indonesian identity that emanates from poverty but that ultimately produces middle-class identity.
In each of these three modes of articulation, the uneven, contentious history of dangdut is obscured, papered over by the all-too-familiar nationalistic discourse of authentic belonging. Dangdut, parallel to regional popular music in many places (certainly not only Southeast Asia, although Thai luk thung is an obvious regional analogue), has been again and again conscripted as an ideological symbol by Indonesian politicians, Islamic religious leaders, and other power holders. This conscription involves bleaching parts or all of the music's hybrid stylistic origins, including Indian film music, American pop, and Quranic recitation, and recasting dangdut as ahistorically Indonesian. Out the other end comes a genre apparently defined less by creative practice than by its relationship to political projects. Thus the value of Dangdut Stories as a political intervention: the genre history that becomes invisible whenever dangdut is linked to the rakyat as if by natural law can only be revealed by a slow, careful tracing.
The word “stories” in the title, in my reading, refers not to Weintraub's research methodology, which is only partly ethnographic, but precisely to such an emphasis on discourse—both that of dangdut's narrative song texts and of the constructed stories of Indonesianness into which the music has been folded. Readers searching for thick description of songwriting, studio recording, concerts, and artists' lives in dangdut may need to search elsewhere. But there is plenty of critical depth nevertheless.
Finally, representing musical detail is a continuing challenge for ethnomusicologists, both because live performance stretches the limits of transcription and because staff notation is frequently illegible to nonspecialists. Dangdut Stories responds to this challenge in two ways: first, by illustrating song structure, poetic arrangement, and rhythm with simple tables; and second, by referring the reader to a companion website that includes a selection of audio and video examples. These examples are helpfully marked by an icon each time they are discussed in the text. By and large, the examples are official studio releases rather than clips collected by Weintraub, but the reader or course instructor can also quite easily use online streaming sites to find more media, including live footage of nearly every major artist discussed in the book. The degree of musical detail in Dangdut Stories is quite high, which will be helpful for readers with musical expertise. But music is simultaneously represented in ways that will make the book accessible to Asianists, anthropologists, and others.
