Manuel Anselmi has produced an insightful analysis of ideology under the Chávez government, paying particular attention to its implementation in the Bolivarian education system. The book is structured into three sections, opening with socio-historical and theoretical analyses of revolutionary Bolivarian thought, before turning to an empirical study of how the ideology takes root in the structures and everyday activities of a number of Bolivarian schools in Lara State. Overall, Anselmi succeeds in identifying the central components of Hugo Chávez's ideological project, and in highlighting the great importance attached to education by the current government. The argument he makes in the closing case study, however, is significantly less convincing. This is largely due to insufficient empirical data, which leaves him making speculative inferences rather than drawing firm conclusions. The book is also characterised by a number of rough edges, such as inaccurate translations – ‘costumes’ is repeatedly used where ‘customs’ was surely intended (p. 73) – and limited dialogue with current theorists of ideology. Engagement with the work of Ernesto Laclau and Slajov Žižek, for example, would have benefited Anselmi's study.
One of the work's strengths lies in its examination of how an ideology constructed by the post-colonial Venezuelan establishment during its nation-building phase – what the author calls ‘Classic Bolivarism’ – was transformed into what he terms ‘Revolutionary Bolivarism’ by the radical guerrilla movements of the 1960s. Excluded from the Pact of Punto Fijo after the overthrow of the dictator Marcos Pérez Jiménez in 1958, revolutionary leftists in Venezuela sought to develop a civic–military alliance that would chime with the country's population. Anselmi shows how this led figures such as Douglas Bravo to reject the Marxist-Leninist orthodoxies of the time in favour of a ‘Tercer Camino’, a Third Way. Although this position still drew on the work of communist luminaries such as Marx, Mao and Lenin, it fused their thinking with the theories and symbols of Venezuela's own revolutionary past: Ezequiel Zamora, Simón Bolívar and Simón Rodríguez, Bolívar's teacher. While the political cult of Bolívar promoted by the Venezuelan state looked to the past in order to create a national identity, Anselmi demonstrates how revolutionary Bolivarians switched their orientation towards the future: ‘Revolutionary Bolivarism, instead, refers to something that is yet to be accomplished, it is marked by a utopian expectation that derives from both the Enlightenment and the socialist traditions’ (p. 24). This transformation later became central to Chávez's political theology, as popular interpretations of Bolívar were reworked in line with the late president's evolving ideology.
In addressing the theoretical foundations of Bolivarian thought, Chávez's Children outlines the diverse elements that form a highly heterogeneous ideology: the deployment of a nationalist discourse, the emphasis on race in a country which has always denied its importance, and the educational pedagogy of Rodríguez. Chávez's use of religion, however, is only mentioned in passing, which is arguably a significant oversight. Nonetheless, the components Anselmi identifies are undoubtedly central to the late president's ideology, which, as the author points out, is envisioned by Bolivarian thinkers in a Gramscian sense: ‘revolutionary Bolivarians, especially intellectuals and leaders, tend to use the term ideology positively, rather than in the traditional Marxist sense of “false consciousness”’ (p. 68).
This component is most evident in the effort to use education as a means of transforming subjectivities. Anselmi underlines how the work of Carlos Lanz, a radical educational theorist, became central to Bolivarian education policy. Lanz views the school as an embryo of revolutionary transformation, arguing that its bureaucratic structures, pedagogical programme and overall ethos should produce a model of the future society. The author describes how class consciousness, participatory democracy and patriotism were principles built into the 1999 Proyecto Educativo Nacional, thereby modelling the Bolivarian school as ‘an actual ideological stronghold, serving as the dynamic center of all local political and social initiatives’ (p. 104).
Although Chávez's Children does a good job of outlining the central components of Bolivarian thought, Anselmi's attempt to test the impact of these policies on schoolchildren is less successful. Comparing the attitudes of children in Bolivarian schools with those in private schools was a sensible strategy, but his over-reliance on the use of in-school surveys means that the reader is left wondering whether it is really the schools that engender the attitudes he uncovers, or simply the backgrounds of the children who attend them. Children in Bolivarian schools, which tend to be based in poorer areas, believe in fairness (p. 133), think ‘being Bolivarian’ is a good thing (p. 134) and, in comparison to children from private schools, are more likely to think that Venezuela is a fair and united country (pp. 136–7). Yet there is nothing in the research methodology that proves these attitudes come from schooling, rather than from children's general exposure to ideology from their parents, peers, the media or the wider social worlds they inhabit. Without some contextualisation of these claims within a broader analysis of social attitudes, for example through extended interviews or ethnographic methods, Anselmi can only make inferences from his findings.
The author's claims are also undermined by sweeping generalisations about barrio residents. The following remark is particularly revealing: ‘In fact, barrios are very dangerous. The inhabitants usually adopt an aggressive and individualistic lifestyle and a high percent (possibly as high as 40 percent though estimates are difficult) live on crime: drugs, theft, robbery and even commissioned murders' (p. 124). This statement is completely uncorroborated, resembling more of a discriminatory slur than serious scholarly research. If it was this attitude that dissuaded Anselmi from conducting research with barrio residents, then it prevented him from accessing a wealth of knowledge on how ideology works in everyday life.
In sum, Chávez's Children provides a useful summary of the history and evolution of Bolivarian ideology, but its weaknesses lie in its attempts to uncover how this ideology is understood, practised or contested by the general population. If nothing else, this serves as a reminder that further research on everyday life in Bolivarian Venezuela should be a central goal for scholars interested in the country.
