Teknophagy (τεκνοϕαγία), or child-eating, is an apt subject for tragedy.Footnote 1 It introduces the theme of miasma, it escalates violence and epitomises the destructive family feuds that Aristotle prized as the most suitable stories for tragedy.Footnote 2 Therefore, unsurprisingly, the teknophagies of Thyestes and Tereus were dramatised in three fifth-century tragedies, all of them preserved only in fragments: Euripides’ Thyestes, Sophokles’ Thyestes (Β) and Sophokles’ Tereus. What is surprising is the appearance of plays by the same titles in the comic tradition, including Tereus plays by Kantharos (C5 BC), Anaxandrides (C4 BC) and Philetairos (C4 BC) along with Diokles’ Thyestes (Β) (late C5 BC to early C4 BC). Therefore, this study will first consider how Tereus’ teknophagy was adapted to mythical burlesques, to then consider how comic adaptations of Thyestes’ teknophagy influenced Seneca's Thyestes.
Of course Thyestes and Tereus are not the only comedies with clear tragic precedents; there are for example four Orestes, two Agamemnon and five Medea comedies.Footnote 3 However, the Thyestes and Tereus stories are exceptionally gruesome as they both present a father made to eat his sons unknowingly. The Thyestes myth includes several components: Atreus’ wife Aërope has an affair with his brother Thyestes.Footnote 4 In revenge, Atreus kills Thyestes’ sons and feeds them to him which,Footnote 5 in many versions, provokes a reversal of the stars.Footnote 6 After the feast, Thyestes rapes his estranged daughter Pelopeia to beget his avenging son Aigisthos, which is emphasised in the Agamemnon tragedies.Footnote 7
By contrast, Tereus’ myth is more self-contained: King Tereus rapes Philomela, the sister of his wife Prokne, and cuts out her tongue so she cannot expose his crime. Philomela then weaves a tapestry to tell her sister the story,Footnote 8 whereupon the sisters resolve to kill Itys, Tereus' and Prokne's child,Footnote 9 and feed him to Tereus in revenge,Footnote 10 after which they metamorphose into birds.Footnote 11
In both cases it is not immediately obvious how these stories could fit into a comedy. These titles are but a sample of a fragmentary tradition of mythical burlesque, a genre that seems to have flourished at the start of the fourth century in which the stories of heroes are developed into comic plots.Footnote 12 Nesselrath and Rau have each considered how Aristophanes mocks tragedy in his traditionally comic settings, a technique described by Manuwald as paratragedy,Footnote 13 with particular attention to Euripides’ influence on comedy.Footnote 14 Dobrov has since pursued a similar methodology to chart comic developments between Aristophanes and Menander.Footnote 15 By contrast, Taplin has focused on the iconographic evidence phlyax vases offer for the performance of mythic burlesques as an art form in their own right, rather than as a transition from Old to Middle Comedy.Footnote 16 More recent studies have applied Taplin's approach to literary evidence to reconstruct this tradition by considering isolated fragments to help establish the content and terminology of the genre.Footnote 17
As a result, scholars have distinguished a subgenre of mythic burlesques as tragicomedies that specifically mocked tragic presentations of the myths themselves, not least because three authors of mythic burlesque actually wrote separate plays entitled Komoidotragoidia. Footnote 18 The term, however, remains a controversial one; Silk deems komoidotragoidia ‘an abortive experiment in classical Attic comedy’, yet takes issue with the prefixing of tragedy as a superior genre in the compound ‘tragicomedy’, inherited from Plautus’ famous assertion that his Amphitryo is a tragicomoedia.Footnote 19 Polarising the genres in this way undermines the diversity of ancient performance by measuring tragicomedy against Taplin's distinct standards of either fifth-century tragedy or comedy rather than the interplay of the two, which seems to have made it so popular in the early fourth century.Footnote 20 Moreover, since in Latin the ‘c’ in tragicomoedia simply elides more fluently when ‘tragic’ is prefixed, as is particularly clear in the uncontracted tragicocomoedia in Plautus’ manuscript, this term need not prioritise tragedy as Silk presumes.Footnote 21 Therefore, Plautus’ Amphitryo is a mythic burlesque playing on tragic themes and content, rather than presenting a tragedy with a comic happy ending, in the manner of Euripides’ escape-tragedies.Footnote 22 Nonetheless, Silk's notion of prefixing as prioritising can be applied to the Greek terms for, although the elision of tragoidia and komoidia could phonetically work either way, Greek consistently fronts forms of comedy: hilarotragoidia,Footnote 23 paratragoidia,Footnote 24 komoidotragoidia.Footnote 25 This consistent prefixing and variation of comic terminology suggests that whilst the subject-matter of all these forms was tragic, the presentation of humour and stage conventions were taken from very specific forms of comedy.
However, whilst scholars acknowledge that in the fourth century Greeks merged tragic and comic genres, there is no case study on the remaining fragments of a potential tragicomedy to see how it may have worked. Accordingly, in the rest of this article I shall argue that the teknophagy episodes of the Tereus and Thyestes burlesques parodied Sophokles’ and Euripides’ tragic adaptations of the same myths in komoidotragoidia, presenting comic cannibalism which Plautus himself later mocks:
scelestiorem cenam cenaui tuam
quam quae Thyestae quondam aut posita est Tereo.
(Rud. 508f.)The dinner of yours that I ate was more criminal than the one that was once given to Thyestes or Tereus.Footnote 26
To that end, we will first take Tereus as a case study for considering how fourth-century burlesques presented teknophagy in tragicomedy, because the myth emerges in both Attic tragedy and comedy along with three fragmentary Tereus burlesques. Having considered the treatment of Tereus’ teknophagy, we will turn to the sparser evidence for Thyestean comedy in Diokles’ testimonia and fragments of Aristophanes’ Proagon. This will allow us to determine how paratragedy, and therefore tragicomedy, may have reshaped tragedy, by comparing the comic fragments to Seneca's Thyestes.
Fragments of the Feasts
Before we can consider how a father feasting on his children could be presented in comedy, we must establish if the feasts were in fact the mythic episodes portrayed in the now fragmentary Tereus and Thyestes tragedies. According to the hypothesis in papyrus fragment P.Oxy. 3013,Footnote 27 Sophokles’ Tereus (468–414 BC)Footnote 28 included all of the events listed in our introduction.Footnote 29 As with Thyestes, Aristophanes incorporates Tereus into his comedy, in this case having Tereus appear as a hoopoe in Birds, with specific reference to Sophokles’ Tereus.Footnote 30 Therefore Aristophanes draws on a tragic precedent to enhance his Birds, a comedy that does not pursue a mythic plot, but does provide a model of tragic parody for later mythic burlesques. Teknophagy is also prominent in the fragments of the Tereus comedies: for example, Kantharos’ Tereus is also named Ἀηδόνες (The Nightingales), referring to the metamorphosis triggered by the feast,Footnote 31 Anaxandrides’ Tereus explicitly mentions the teknophagy and Philetairos’ Tereus refers to offal.Footnote 32
By contrast Thyestes’ myth provides at least three possible plotlines. Thus the general consensus is that Sophokles wrote three Thyestes plays; the first treating Thyestes’ affair with Aërope (Α), the second relating the Thyestean banquet (Β) and the third detailing Thyestes’ incestuous conception of Aigisthos with his daughter Pelopeia (Γ), so that their son may avenge the feast.Footnote 33 This model separates the narrative into plays using Thyestes’ relocation: one ending at Thyestes’ exile before the feast as punishment for his adultery with Aërope, one ending with Thyestes’ flight after the feast and one picking up on events after the feast when Thyestes retreats to Sikyon. Since Thyestes was later deemed the eponymous hero of each of Sophokles’ plays, Thyestes’ departures provide a natural closure to the first two tragedies before he finally arrives in Sikyon in the third tragedy. Though Sophokles could have covered Thyestes’ final exile, Thyestes’ feast was most likely the subject of one of Sophokles’ three plays because it is the result of his adultery with Aërope and the impetus for raping his daughter Pelopeia in Sikyon.
Like Sophokles, Diokles allegedly wrote at least two plays on Thyestes’ myth, as indicated by a testimony of his Thyestes (Β), so he presumably dealt with the central issue of the feast:
Διοκλῆς, Ἀθηναῖος ἢ Φλιάσιος, ἀρχαῖος κωμικός, σύγχρονος Σαννυρίωνι καὶ Φιλυλλίῳ. δράματα αὐτοῦ Θάλαττα, Μέλιτται, Ὄνειροι, Βάκχαι, Θυέστης β΄…τὸ δὲ Θάλαττα ἑταίρας ὄνομά ἐστιν, ὡς Ἀθήναιός ϕησιν.
(Suda δ 1155)Diokles: of Athens or of Phlia, poet of Old Comedy, a contemporary of Sannyrion and Philyllios. His plays are: Thalatta (Sea), Bees, Dreams, Bakkhai and Thyestes Β… Thalatta is the name of a hetaira, so Athenaios says [567c].Footnote 34
Diokles’ comic adaptation of Thyestes’ feast is all the more likely if we consider the influence of Euripides’ Thyestes (before 425 BC).Footnote 35 Euripides is regularly considered a model for mythic comedies because his escape-tragedies end happily and his plays were reperformed in Southern Italy in the fourth century,Footnote 36 where mythic burlesques gained popularity.Footnote 37 Diokles’ Bakk h ai (C4 BC) follows Euripides’ Bakk h ai (405–400 BC) and exploits the same cross-dressing scene,Footnote 38 which suggests that Euripides’ Thyestes also influenced Diokles’.
Whilst I refer to Sophokles’ Thyestes Β as ‘Thyestes Feast’ on the basis of circumstantial evidence, Euripides’ Thyestes features the feast more patently. The final fragment of the play includes the cataclysm, which Euripides consistently associates with the brothers’ feud. In Orestes, the cataclysm is caused by Thyestes’ theft of the fleece,Footnote 39 asserting Atreus’ kingship and initiating Thyestes’ exile, but in Elektra and Iphigenia in Tauris the cataclysm is used as a gloss to represent the feast itself.Footnote 40 In Euripides’ Thyestes fr.397b the sequencing of the aorist ἔσωσα (‘I saved’) indicates that the saving of the house has been achieved; the imperfect ἱζόμην (‘established myself’) suggests by contrast that Atreus establishing his rule is an ongoing endeavour. The shift in aspect and absence of the historic perfect tense suggests that the feast is in the recent past, thus was the action of Euripides’ Thyestes, as opposed to recollecting events before the tragic action as Collard's translation proposes:Footnote 41
ΑΤΡΕΥΣ
δείξας γὰρ ἄστρων τὴν ἐναντίαν ὁδόν,
δόμους τ᾿ ἔσωσα καὶ τύραννος ἱζόμην.
(Eur. 397b Kannicht)Atreus: Having shown the contrary course of the stars, I saved my house and established myself as ruler.
This all serves to suggest that the feast was the focus of Euripides’ Thyestes. In addition, as Bergk points out,Footnote 42 Aristophanes’ Proagon (422 BC)Footnote 43 parodies the feast of Euripides’ Thyestes, which had been produced shortly before.Footnote 44 Therefore not only did Euripides’ Thyestes present the feast; but Aristophanes also parodied Euripides’ Thyestes in a comedy about promoting tragedies, and apparently staged Euripides as a character.Footnote 45 As a result, Aristophanes is able to capitalise on the tragic feast to comic effect, as food is typically a genre-marker of comedy. In doing so, Aristophanes turns to his favourite tragedian, Euripides, to play with generic conventions. Had Diokles adapted Thyestes’ feast in one of his Thyestes burlesques he would have had a precedent to work from.Footnote 46
Unfortunately Diokles is the only comedian credited with a Thyestes and we have nothing more than a testimony for Thyestes Β, which indicates that Diokles wrote two Thyestes plays. So, to understand how teknophagy may have been adapted for mythic comedy, we must turn to Tereus before considering how tragicomic devices may have influenced subsequent tragedy such as Seneca's Thyestes. With the content of the mythic comedies and the tragic predecessors established as far as possible, we can now investigate the fragments more closely and consider how teknophagy could be funny, by examining how Aristophanes peppers his comic plots with tragic references and comparing how the mythic burlesques travesty tragic plots with comic humour.Footnote 47
Tereus
When turning to the Tereus comedies, the evidence is direct, not circumstantial. Of course, Tereus’ most famous appearance in extant comedy is his role as the hoopoe in Aristophanes’ Birds, where reference to Tereus’ teknophagy is sidelined in favour of the visual humour of his character. The cannibalism motif is then transferred to Peisetairos who eats his fellow bird citizens at the end of the play: transforming carnivorism into cannibalism.Footnote 48 But Kantharos’ Tereus is listed amongst Dionysia victors as Ἀηδόνες (The Nightingales) which suggests that, unlike Aristophanes’ Birds, it featured Tereus’ feast as the impetus for Prokne's, Philomela's and Tereus’ metamorphoses into birds.
The surviving fragments of Kantharos’ play do suggest a focus on the women. The first flatters one of the sisters as an Athenian noblewoman, perhaps appealing to an Athenian audience at the Dionysia:
γυναῖκ᾿ Ἀθηναίαν καλήν τε κἀγαθήν
(Kanth. 5 Kassel and Austin = Photios [b, z] α 466)a beautiful and noble Athenian lady
However, this could of course be undermined by the appearance of the woman on stage, or the comments that follow; indeed, fr.6 suggests a more sordid flattery:
Κυδωνίοις μήλοισιν ἴσα τὰ τιτθία
(Kanth. 6 Kassel and Austin = Ath. Deipn. 81d)breasts like Cydonian apples
Given that Philomela is the sex object of the myth, the rape victim and not the wife, it follows that if Kantharos’ fragment describes an onstage character, she is Philomela. Tereus’ story invites gender jokes because those killing and cooking his son are Tereus’ betrayed wife Prokne and her sister Philomela whom he raped.
By contrast, in Aristophanes’ Birds, it is Tereus’ wife Prokne who is sexualised by being acted by a mute flute girl, reflecting her metamorphosis into a nightingale through birdsong.Footnote 49 Romer makes a clear case for Prokne appearing as a flute girl on practical grounds, namely that she might play her flute to express birdsong, whilst Zweig convincingly identifies Prokne as a heavily eroticised hetaira actress rather than a drag actor.Footnote 50 Here the mutilated victim Philomela never appears, while Prokne answers Tereus’ call and receives guests with him, ignoring the issue of the revenge feast. There is no mention of Tereus having eaten Itys despite the fact that this triggered their metamorphosis, though the absence of this story is made conspicuous by Euelpides, who claims the couple are living like newlyweds (ζῆτε νυμϕίων βίον, ‘living the life of newlyweds’).Footnote 51 This of course highlights the fantastical nature of Aristophanes’ Cloudcuckooland where Prokne and Tereus share their comic happy ending despite the violence that triggered their metamorphosis. Thus Aristophanes capitalises on the bird form to present sexual comedy and glosses the cannibalism as carnivorism,Footnote 52 subverting the marital discord that traditionally causes Tereus’ cannibalism to the marital harmony suggested by the cooking of bird citizens for Peisetairos’ wedding feast.Footnote 53 Kantharos, however, applies the same sexual comedy, most likely to Philomela, in a plotline including Tereus’ cannibalistic feast.
Given that Kantharos’ Tereus/Nightingales told Tereus’ myth, it follows that Prokne was less sexualised than her sister Philomela whom Tereus lusts after: whilst a mute hetaira could have played Philomela after Tereus had cut out her tongue, the storyline demands that Prokne plot the feast aloud. Consequently Kantharos’ Prokne could not be a mute flute girl as Aristophanes’ had been. There is also evidence of a conversation with Prokne about her marriage, which suggests she spoke in turn:
καὶ πρότερον οὖσα παρθένος
ἀμϕηγάπαζες αὐτόν.
(Kanth. 7 Kassel and Austin = Photios [b] α 1301)And before, when you were a maiden, you would embrace him lovingly.
This contrasts courtship and marriage, inviting the comic stereotype of the dissatisfied wife. Again attention turns to the sexual discord between Prokne and her unfaithful husband, but in Kantharos’ fragment Prokne is directly addressed and thus invited to speak, whereas in Aristophanes’ Birds she cannot.
The speech of tragic characters is then parodied in Kantharos’ play:
ἁμαξιαῖα κομπάσματα
(Kanth. 8 Kassel and Austin = Photios [b, z] α 1118)wagon-sized boasts
So whilst Aristophanes mocks elevated tragic language by having Tereus not only speak in a tragic style but also claim to have civilised the birds with language, here Kantharos explicitly mocks elevated tragic diction in his burlesque.Footnote 54 Of course we cannot determine whose words are being criticised here as they could apply to any tragic character in a comic setting. But what this fragment does make clear is that the comedy is based not only on the mythic plot itself, but also on its tragic presentation; Kantharos’ Tereus is a tragicomedy in both plot and tone. So although little survives of the feast itself, the evidence suggests that satirising tragic presentations of a gruesome story makes the humour accessible.
Turning to Anaxandrides, we have more direct evidence of how Tereus’ feast was parodied, and dialogue from Tereus himself (marked as speaker ‘B’):
(A.) ὄρνις κεκλήσηι. (Β.) διὰ τί, πρὸς τῆς Ἑστίας;
πότερον καταϕαγὼν τὴν πατρώιαν οὐσίαν,
ὥσπερ Πολύευκτος ὁ καλός; (Α.) οὐ δῆτ᾽, ἀλλ᾽ὅτι
ἄρρην ὑπὸ θηλειῶν κατεκόπτης.
(Anax. 46 Kassel and Austin)A: You will be called the cock.
B: Why, by the Hearth? Because I devoured the wealth of my forefathers like that fine fellow Polyeuktos?
A: Not at all, but because you, a male, have been henpecked by females.Footnote 55
Here the metamorphosis is explained away as a nickname, in stark contrast to the staged hoopoe and nightingale of Aristophanes. Rationalising the fantastic is a common device of mythic burlesque and here it suggests that the visual comedy of the metamorphosis was absent, allowing for greater emphasis on the crimes leading up to the feast and the feast itself.Footnote 56 Indeed, Tereus glosses the teknophagy as the consumption of ancestral property (οὐσίαν), dehumanising his son Itys. Many observe the monetisation of children in mythic burlesque, claiming that in Ephippos’ Geryones Kronos’ eating of his children is not literal, but instead he sells the children to feed himself as Aristophanes’ Megarian does in Akharnians.Footnote 57
However, Itys is identified not simply as material ‘wealth’ but as ‘ancestral wealth’. So whereas in Akharnians and Geryones children have a material value, in Anaxandrides’ Tereus Itys is valued as a legitimate male heir. Thus Anaxandrides travesties the tragic issue of succession by valuing Itys in the tragic sense as an heir and in the comic sense as a material asset. The synthesis of comic material wealth and tragic ancestral wealth is completed with a contemporary reference, as Polyeuktos featured in Demosthenes’ near-contemporary oration.Footnote 58 The dispute there focuses on the allocation of one daughter's outstanding dowry payment to the defendant and the relinquishing of the other daughter's dowry by her betrothed uncle; thus the ancestral wealth of tragedy is undercut with ancestral wealth in contemporary Athens.Footnote 59
So although, unlike Kronos, Tereus typically eats his child unknowingly as a punishment, and therefore according to the logic of his myth he cannot sell Itys, the teknophagy seems to be glossed as a loss of his son as an asset. The reference to Polyeuktos undercuts the tension between the symbolic wealth of tragedy and the material wealth of comedy. This tension between the symbolic and the literal is immediately reiterated in Tereus’ invocation of the Hearth, which is where the ἀμϕιδρόμια ritual for the newborn child took place but also where the family might meet for meals.Footnote 60 Thus Tereus’ invocation aptly conflates the symbolic and practical social functions of the hearth, as he has just figuratively ‘eaten’ his own child.
The punchline then displaces the cannibalism, suggesting that the women have consumed (κατεκόπτης) Tereus, rather than Tereus having eaten Itys. The verb κατακόπτω is typically used to suggest the butchery of animals and people.Footnote 61 Wilkins’ translation of κατεκόπτης as ‘pecked to bits’ imposes bird imagery, to continue the rationalisation of the bird metamorphosis; the attack on Tereus renders him a cockerel henpecked by women.Footnote 62 This association is set up in context, but the typical use of κατακόπτω to cut down animals recalls Prokne's and Philomela's butchery of Itys, as suggested by Olson's translation: ‘reduced to mincemeat by females.’Footnote 63 Though this disrupts the logic of the joke as an aition for the bird metamorphosis, it accurately reflects the displacement of the cannibalistic feast. In either translation the violence of Prokne and Philomela is diminished to emasculate Tereus, as is suggested in Aristophanes’ Birds:
ἅτε γὰρ ὤν γενναῖος ὑπό τε συκοϕαντῶν τίλλεται,
αἵ τε θήλειαι πρὸς ἐκτίλλουσιν αὐτοῦ τὰ πτερά.
(Av. 285f.)He's pedigreed, you see, so he gets plucked by swindlers, and the women keep plucking out his feathers too.
Anaxandrides’ surviving joke on Tereus’ teknophagy alludes to the perversity of the feast by referencing the hearth, but it also relies on the dehumanisation of Itys as ‘wealth’ and the displacement of Itys’ physical butchery for the feast to Tereus’ figurative butchery by Prokne's and Philomela's revenge. Here Anaxandrides plays on Sophokles’ tragic precedent by explaining the metamorphosis and presenting a tragic royal's view of parenthood, objectifying the son as an heir. Yet at the same time Anaxandrides uses the mythic plot to set up more familiar, Aristophanic jokes on contemporary family disputes and gender.
Like Kantharos’, Anaxandrides’ fragments put a focus on female status and sexuality:
ἀλλ᾽ οἷα νύμϕη βασιλὶς ὠνομασμένη
μύροις Μεγαλλείοισι σῶμ᾽ ἀλείϕεται.
(Anax. 47 Kassel and Austin)But like someone referred to as a royal bride,
she anoints her body with Megalleian perfumes.
This either suggests a low-status woman is beautifying herself as Prokne or Philomela might, or suggests the only way in which Prokne fulfils expectations as a royal bride, in contrast to her more attractive sister Philomela, whom Tereus then rapes. Although the significance of the specific perfumer Megallos cannot be traced,Footnote 64 the Athenian origin of Megallos’ perfume distinguishes the Athenian Prokne or Philomela from Tereus, the barbaric Thracian, a distinction that Sophokles used to emphasise Prokne's loneliness in Thrace through her tragic monologue.Footnote 65 The use of this perfume to distinguish Greeks and barbarians re-emerges in Strattis’ burlesque of Medea, as Medea sends ‘perfume such as Megallos never produced’ (μύρον τοιοῦτον οἷον οὐ Μέγαλλος πώποτε ἥψησεν) to the Corinthian Glauke as a bridal gift.Footnote 66 Anaxandrides, like Strattis, uses perfume to distinguish Greek brides from barbarian villains, but unlike Strattis uses this to signal the sexual availability of the new bride by focusing on its application over the body.
The final fragment of Anaxandrides is more elusive, but again introduces a sexual motif and the presence of birds:
ὀχευομένους δὲ τοὺς κάπρους
καὶ τὰς ἀλεκτρυόνας θεωροῦσ᾿ ἄσμενοι.
(Anax. 48 Kassel and Austin)They enjoy watching the boars
and the hens being mounted.
Here the animals are livestock and the reference to chickens specifically reflects Anaxandrides’ rationalisation of Tereus’ metamorphosis by presenting him as the henpecked cock; the boars perhaps add another form of sexual innuendo. Given the fragmentary nature of the Tereus plays we have examined so far, we cannot suggest that the feast was altogether sidelined in place of sexual comedy. But in contrast to the all-male Thyestean feast, in which Aërope must have already been killed or exiled, Tereus’ teknophagy involves female characters, inviting sexual innuendo and gendered comedy in a way that Thyestes’ feast does not.
Philetairos also took on teknophagy in his mythic burlesque of Tereus, as his fragments reveal a banquet setting:
Φιλέταιρος δ᾿ ἐν Τηρεῖ δύο ὕδατος πρὸς τρεῖς ἀκράτου. λέγει δὲ οὕτως·
πεπωκέναι δοκεῖ τὸν κατὰ δύο
καὶ τρεῖς ἀκράτου.
(Phil. 15 Kassel and Austin = Ath. Deipn. 10.430)Philetairos in Tereus (mentions) two parts water to three parts unmixed wine. He says that:
He seems to have drunk a combination of two parts (water)
and three parts unmixed wine.
(tr. Olson [Reference Olson2006])The subject is Tereus, the only male diner at this feast, but with no reference to cannibalism. A more direct reference to the bloody nature of the feast occurs in the following fragment:
ἑξῆς εἰσεκομίσθη ταγηνιστὰ ἧπατα περιειλημένα τῶι καλουμένωι ἐπίπλωι, ὃν Φιλέταιρος ἐν Τηρεῖ ἐπίπλοιον εἴρηκεν
(Phil. 16 Kassel and Austin = Ath. Deipn. 3.106)Footnote 67Immediately, fried livers were brought in wrapped in what is called epiplous (omentum), which Philetairos in Tereus calls the epiploion.
(tr. Olson [Reference Olson2006])Like Kantharos, Philetairos includes omentum (ἐπίπλοιον), a choice cut of meat that is typically used as a casing for other foods.Footnote 68 Here the humour draws on the omentum's anatomic and culinary functions as stomach casing and food casing, creating a grotesque mise en abyme when eaten by Tereus.Footnote 69 But the mixed wine and the delicacy of the omentum also suggest a lavish banquet befitting the tragic royals, juxtaposing the luxury of their feast with the grotesque irony of omentum as innards within innards.
Thyestes
Far from sanitising or omitting the gore of a cannibalistic feast, comic adaptations seem to revel in its physical, visceral nature. Aristophanes’ Proagon presents a comic actor parodying a tragic actor, who is in turn role-playing Thyestes, and is thus disgusted by pig snout, having seemingly eaten his own children:
ἐγευσάμην χορδῆς ὁ δύστηνος τέκνων·
πῶς ἐσίδω ῥύγχος περικεκαυμένον;
(Ar. 478 Kassel and Austin)I've tasted—a wretch—the guts of my children.
How could I look at a roast pig-snout now?
Initially, it seems natural that Thyestes would be revolted by meat, but the specificity of the cuts is where the real humour lies. Dohm rightly suggests that χορδή works as a double entendre signifying gut-strings and sausages,Footnote 70 rather than choice sacrificial innards (σπλάγχνα).Footnote 71 This accords with Wilkins’ distinction: ‘Where Aeschylus pictured the eating of children in the feast of Thyestes in an analogy with a sacrificial division of an animal into vital organs, flesh and entrails, Aristophanes has Thyestes speak of the tripe sausages and snouts of his children.’Footnote 72 Thus Thyestes’ meal is especially gruesome, because it alludes to the vital organs of his sons as butcher's cuts rather than as sacrificial offerings.
The sausages (χορδή) not only reduce the sacrificial pathos of innards to gluttonous bathos, since preserved meat would not have been eaten after a sacrifice,Footnote 73 but also present the preparation of the children's innards. Unlike cuts of offal, sausages are ground and spiced,Footnote 74 which suggests an absurd culinary interest in Atreus’ preparation of the children as food. Thus Aristophanes imposes mundane culinary preparation on Atreus’ revenge feast for his brother and adds gruesome detail to the cannibalism: he exploits grotesque elements of the tragedy to comic effect by associating them with the everyday tone of comedy.Footnote 75
As a result the sausages made from the children are not simply eaten but tasted (ἐγευσάμην).Footnote 76 This provides a pun on a tragic use of the word, meaning to sample a punishment, in the way Herakles ‘tastes’ his labours, or Admetos ‘tastes’ grief, and the commonplace use of the word to mean sampling, or ‘tasting’, food.Footnote 77 Thus tasting his children deters Thyestes from eating pig snout, either because he is too aggrieved to eat or, more perversely, because snout is a lesser delicacy than his children's innards.Footnote 78 In either case, what to eat next is the least of Thyestes’ problems! Again Aristophanes oscillates tragic emotion and comic gluttony to create humour.
We can only speculate as to how Diokles presented the cannibalistic feast in his mythic burlesque, but Philetairos’ Tereus mocked the tragic cannibalism as a gastronomic feast in the way Aristophanes’ Proagon presents prepared sausages in his paratragedy.Footnote 79 This grotesque presentation of the children as a delicacy was taken up by Seneca, whose Atreus butchers, boils and roasts Thyestes’ children.Footnote 80 Meltzer has suggested that the Senecan Atreus’ ‘fastidious concern with the culinary details of the banquet is eerily consistent with his requirement that Thyestes enjoy the meal.’Footnote 81 But Meltzer has overlooked the parallel between this scene and Aristophanes’ Proagon fragments, and the testimony to Diokles’ Thyestes B altogether, neglecting the fragmentary comic tradition that Seneca manipulates.
Seneca's main departure from the Proagon is that Atreus prepares sacrificial cuts of the children, roasts the livers and explicitly saves not only the heads but also their hands, paralleling the maschalismos (μασχαλίζω)Footnote 82 mutilation of Agamemnon's corpse in Aiskhylos’ Khoephoroi.Footnote 83 So although the Senecan Thyestes’ feast includes the dramatic irony of the Proagon, the offal is sacrificial and suitably tragic. Nonetheless, Aristophanes’ subversion of the innards from a token of tragic pathos to comic bathos becomes more striking if, instead of considering animal parts, we consider the ancient belief in the emotional function of internal organs for humans. For example, in Aristophanes’ Wealth, Karion describes emotions seated in these organs, as he chides Hermes for complaining about the lack of sacrificial innards dedicated to him by turning to Hermes’ own belly-aching:
ὀδύνη σε περὶ τὰ σπλάγχν᾿ ἔοικέ τις στρέϕειν.
(Plut. 1131)You seem to be turning some ache round in your own innards.
Aristophanes specifies σπλάγχνα here to denote the sacrificial offal Hermes expects: the ‘liver kidneys heart etc., of the victim (but not the stomach or the intestines)’,Footnote 84 given to Thyestes in the Proagon. Nonetheless, Karion's wordplay humanises Hermes in his irreverent address, by suggesting that the god experiences visceral, human emotions in his innards, albeit in different organs than those from which Thyestes’ χορδή are made.
Aristophanes’ other Thyestean Proagon fragment echoes the comedy of Hermes’ visceral emotion, as Thyestes demands to know what he has eaten:
οἴμοι τάλας τί μου στρέϕει τὴν γαστέρα
βάλλ᾽ἐς κόρακας· πόθεν ἂν λάσανα γένοιτό μοι;
(Ar. 477 Kassel and Austin)I'm wretched, what's turning my stomach? Go to hell! Where's the toilet?
Here Thyestes stomachs sausages made from his dead children's innards and feeds his pain with theirs in a display of dramatic irony. In this instance, even the comic stock phrase ἐς κόρακας takes on dramatic irony, since it literally translates as ‘go to the crows’: carrion birds that feast on corpses, as Thyestes has just done! This fragment also reiterates the visceral focus of comedy, because it reduces what would have been an emotional reaction in tragedy to a series of bodily functions. Thyestes’ churning stomach could be presented as comic, rather than horrific, using the visual humour of the comic costume with the overhanging gut and the toilet humour that immediately follows.Footnote 85 Layering the humour in this way allows Aristophanes to present his hallmark comic suffering as a mimesis: role-playing a tragic Thyestes in the Proagon must explode presentiments of a tragic performance with a comic suffering scene.
Though no fragment from Euripides’ Thyestes describes the feast itself, its production three years before Aristophanes’ Proagon and the testimony claiming that Euripides featured in this play suggest that Aristophanes’ fragments parody Euripides’ tragic feast.Footnote 86 Nonetheless it is clear that Seneca's Thyestes picked up on Aristophanes’ parody again since, as Meltzer points out, the burp of Seneca's Thyestes ‘belongs to the sphere of comedy, especially Aristophanic comedy.’Footnote 87 But Meltzer makes no specific reference to the ‘Thyestes’ of Aristophanes’ Proagon, instead noting parallels in Euripides’ Kyklops. Though this highlights parallels between Seneca and satyr play, the testimony of Diokles’ tragicomic burlesque and Aristophanes’ paratragic Proagon presents a more direct tradition of Thyestean comedy from which Seneca, I would argue, draws.
Furthermore, when we compare both of these fragments from Aristophanes’ Proagon, the pig snout must also assume a second function as a stage property that substitutes for Thyestes’ recognition of his sons’ severed heads. If we position the toilet humour in fr.477 after Thyestes’ realisation that he has eaten his children in fr.478, then Thyestes does not associate his teknophagy with these physical side-effects; but if we trust Kannicht's positioning of fr.477 before fr.478, then Thyestes’ stomach pains trigger the recognition of his teknophagy. The latter is a more likely sequence, given that the questions provoke an ideal tragic recognition:
πασῶν δὲ βελτίστη ἀναγνώρισις ἡ ἐξ αὐτῶν τῶν πραγμάτων, τῆς ἐκπλήξεως γιγνομένης δι᾿ εἰκότων, …
(Arist. Poet. 1455a16f.)Best of all is a recognition that emerges from the events themselves, where the emotional impact comes from a realistic source, …
Given that Aristophanes’ Proagon parodies Euripides’ recent Thyestes we might speculate that Thyestes recognised his children's heads in Euripides’ tragedy.Footnote 88 Indeed Euripides used Pentheus’ head as a recognition device for his mother Agave in Bakkhai, as she recognises that she has beheaded her own child and not a lion.Footnote 89
What we can more readily suggest is that the heads revealed to Seneca's Thyestes follow a similar series of questions to those in the Proagon:
quis hic tumultus uiscera exagitat mea?
quid tremuit intus? sentio impatiens onus
meumque gemitu non meo pectus gemit.
adeste, nati, genitor infelix uocat,
adeste. uisis fugiet hic uobis dolor—
unde obloquuntur?
(Thy. 999–1004)What is this tumult that shakes my guts? What trembles inside? I feel a restless burden, and my breast groans with groaning not my own. Come, sons, your unhappy father calls you, come! Once I see you this pain will disappear. From where do they interrupt?
Therefore, Seneca's recognition scene drew from either Aristophanes’ paratragic Thyestes in Proagon or the tragic adaptation that Aristophanes parodied, given the close parallels between the questions of Aristophanes’ and Seneca's Thyestes. Though the Proagon specifically mocked tragic performances,Footnote 90 suggesting that the recognition scene itself parodied an earlier Thyestes tragedy, Seneca's scene employs the same dramatic irony as Aristophanes’ comic paratragedy with a grotesque effect.
Nevertheless, when Aristophanes’ Thyestes contemplates eating pig snout, this parodies a tragic recognition scene with the snout as a child's head. This case is strengthened by reflection on Wilkins’ translation of fr.478:
πῶς ἐσίδω ῥύγχος περικεκαυμένον;
(Ar. 478 Kassel and Austin)How can I gaze upon their charred snouts?
(tr. Wilkins [Reference Wilkins2000], 21)Wilkins inserts the possessive pronoun here and mistranslates ῥύγχος as a plural. Thus his translation associates the snout(s) with the sons because the sausages in the preceding line are made from the children, without noting how this may have travestied tragic recognition scenes. There is no deictic pronoun to indicate a gesture to the snout as a stage prop and the subjunctive of the verb ‘to look’ (ἐσίδω) suggests that Thyestes is considering eating pig snout again hypothetically, without necessarily rejecting a snout onstage. Nonetheless, the facial significance of the snout, following Thyestes’ description of his children's alleged innards as prepared sausages (χορδή), suggests that the snout plays on a recognition of his own sons’ faces, debasing another tragic device: the recognition scene.
The association of the children with pigs through the recognition snout (ῥύγχος) also subverts tragic expectations by emphasising the worthlessness of Thyestes’ sons. If we compare Thyestes’ sons’ snout to the Megarian's daughters in Aristophanes’ Akharnians, their status becomes clear:
ἐγώνγα καὐτός ϕαμι. τίς δ᾿ οὕτως ἄνους
ὃς ὑμέ κα πρίαιτο, ϕανερὰν ζαμίαν;
ἀλλ᾿ ἔστι γάρ μοι Μεγαρικά τις μαχανά·
χοίρους γὰρ ὑμὲ σκευάσας ϕασῶ ϕέρειν.
περίθεσθε τάσδε τὰς ὁπλὰς τῶν χοιρίων·
ὅπως δὲ δοξεῖτ᾿ εἶμεν ἐξ ἀγαθᾶς ὑός·
ὡς ναὶ τὸν Ἑρμᾶν, αἴπερ εἱξεῖτ᾿ οἴκαδις
ἄπρατα, πειρασεῖσθε τᾶς λιμοῦ κακῶς.
ἀλλ᾿ ἀμϕίθεσθε καὶ ταδὶ τὰ ῥυγχία,
κἤπειτεν εἰς τὸν σάκκον ὧδ᾿ εἰσβαίνετε.
(Ach. 736–49)So I say myself. But who'd be so senseless as to buy you, an obvious waste of money? But, I've got a Megarian trick: I'll dress you up and say I've got piggies. Put on these pig hooves, and see that you look like a fine swine. Because by Hermes, if you come home unsold, you really will find out what hunger is! Put on these snouts too, and then get into this sack here.
Here the comedy is seated in the inverted values of the hungry Megarian, who views pigs as a commodity and daughters as a financial burden, dehumanising his children for his own gain. Thyestes’ children are similarly dehumanised by their father's greed. Though they are male, Thyestes’ sons are presented to be as worthless as the Megarian's daughters because they are not heirs to the throne, despite Thyestes’ attempt to usurp Atreus.Footnote 91 As a result Atreus uses Thyestes’ children as a means to an end, killing them to exact revenge on his brother, though there is no suggestion that the murder would have been made explicit in the comedy, given the euphemistic reference to snout in place of the heads.
So although we can only speculate as to whether this reference to snouts parodied an existing recognition of the children's heads in Euripides’ Thyestes, we can more confidently suggest that this recognition was adopted by Seneca. Much like the questioning that precedes Thyestes’ recognition of the children, Seneca's recognition scene exploits the same dramatic irony found in the Proagon.Footnote 92 Meltzer points out that ‘Atreus puns on ora when he tells Thyestes he will soon see the faces of his children’ when of course Thyestes will be shown the heads.Footnote 93 But, here too, Meltzer overlooks the significance of the Proagon as a precedent: both the snout as a parody of recognition and Thyestes’ comic indigestion are reimagined as grotesque elements in Seneca. Thus Seneca's ‘black humour’ is not only led by Atreus as a reflection of his sadism, as Meltzer suggests, but also draws on Aristophanes’ Proagon and perhaps Diokles’ lost Thyestes; thus it allows Atreus to orchestrate the performance of Thyestes’ tragic demise as his own comic happy ending.
In sum, the Thyestean fragments of Aristophanes’ Proagon parody the teknophagy myth by emphasising the gruesome physical comedy of cooking and eating children like animals. To achieve this, Aristophanes combines the mundane with the mythical: Thyestes eats specific, prepared meat from his children like a comic gourmand, his colloquial cursing (ἐς κόρακας) provides dramatic irony, and his alleged cannibalism causes toilet trouble. In metageneric terms, Aristophanes plays on the audience's familiarity with Thyestes’ story as a tragedy to invert tragic pathos to comic bathos. Thyestes’ emotional gut reaction would have been horrific in tragedy, but is diminished to toilet humour and undermined by the comic paunch. His ‘tasting’ (ἐγευσάμην) of the children reduces the tragic use of the verb to mean ‘to sample a punishment’ to its literal meaning ‘to eat’, asserting the comic preoccupation with food, and his refusal to look on pig snout suggests a parody of a tragic recognition scene.Footnote 94
As a result, Aristophanes’ Proagon provides compelling circumstantial evidence for how parody of tragedy could incorporate teknophagy into comedy. Although in Aristophanes’ case Thyestes’ feast provided jokes in a play about tragedies rather than framing the overall plot of the comedy, it illustrates how inseparable the myth of Thyestes’ feast is from the tragic genre. When we compare Aristophanes’ parody of Thyestes’ feast to the title of Diokles’ Thyestes Β, it suggests a sustained engagement with the Thyestes myth, drawing on Sophokles’ three Thyestes plays, including the feast, and Euripides’ Thyestes, which was based on the feast. The little evidence we have argues that Diokles’ Thyestes was not simply a mythic burlesque, in that it followed a mythic plot, but perhaps also a komoidotragoedia that travestied the tragic scenes and devices that Aristophanes had parodied. What we can conclude with greater certainty is that Aristophanes’ paratragedy in Proagon influenced the feast in Seneca's Thyestes, suggesting that comic adaptations of myth shaped later tragedies.
Conclusion
Having examined all of the surviving fragments of the Tereus and Thyestes comedies, it is clear that the teknophagy featured in all of them and was made light of. Though it is more difficult to pinpoint exactly how the teknophagy was mocked, Aristophanes’ parody of the tragic precedents in his Proagon and Birds respectively provides a useful gauge, in that the Proagon features Thyestean jokes in a comedy about promoting tragedy and in that the Tereus of Birds identifies himself as Sophoklean. Where Aristophanes parodies tragic features such as elevated diction and the recognition scene in a non-mythic setting, the mythic burlesques also mock tragic diction and invert pathos to bathos in order to travesty myth.
However, the mythic plots of the Thyestes and Tereus burlesques demand a greater degree of comic interaction between tragic characters than Aristophanes presents in his comedies. There is no evidence for how this dynamic may have worked in Diokles’ Thyestes, but both Kantharos’ and Anaxandrides’ Tereus present a comic battle of the sexes, which Thyestes’ fraternal feud could not have provided. Whereas in Birds Aristophanes had inverted audience expectations by presenting Prokne and Tereus as honeymooners, the mythic burlesques include the sexual objectification of Philomela in Anaxandrides fr.46–8 and Kantharos fr.4f., thus allude to Tereus’ rape. Whilst Aristophanes had not only normalised cannibalism as carnivorism but also transferred it to Peisetairos’ wedding feast rather than Tereus’ marital breakdown, the burlesques show a feast amongst the tragic characters themselves in Anaxandrides fr.46 and Philetairos fr.15. So the marital problems of Prokne and Tereus, alongside the resolution of the metamorphosis that is apparent in Sophokles’ tragedy, provide a feast episode that allows for food-and-sex-based humour in mythic burlesque.
Nonetheless both the indirect evidence for Diokles’ Thyestes in Aristophanes’ Proagon and the extant Tereus fragments of Anaxandrides and Philetairos refer to the butchery or offal of children. Much of the comedy we find in the fragments suggests a visceral representation of the feasts, though we cannot determine whether they were reported or staged. Ultimately the mythic burlesques of Thyestes and Tereus are tragicomic because they travesty the tragic plot and performance modes in order to distance teknophagy as a fantasy and exploit the visceral gore of the cannibalism by integrating it into a comic feast. Though this tragicomic tradition is now fragmentary, the overlap between Aristophanes’ paratragic Proagon and Seneca's Thyestes highlights the potential influence of tragicomedy on later classical tragedy.
