Surveying the antebellum United States in Democracy in America (1835), Alexis de Tocqueville observed that the theatre was the most vital art form in democratic societies because its audiences demanded works in everyday speech that reflected their own lives, which felicitously also allowed cultural critics to gauge the direction of the country by the content of the stage. Historians have taken de Tocqueville's observation to heart: in the past decade, books examining the performance culture of the antebellum period—an era dominated, like our own present moment, by public health emergencies, financial panics, and decades-long controversies over racism—have proliferated. Continuing this trend, Juliane Braun, with Creole Drama: Theatre and Society in Antebellum New Orleans, and Laura L. Mielke, with Provocative Eloquence: Theater, Violence, and Antislavery Speech in the Antebellum United States, have produced vital new works of US theatre history.
Braun's study of Francophone theatre in New Orleans has been badly needed for some time, especially since Joseph Roach's Cities of the Dead (1996) situated New Orleans at the imaginative center of the circum-Atlantic. Braun, through her remarkable use of archival material and keen readings of plays by Louisianan authors, has reconstructed in detail the history of Francophone Louisiana onstage by encapsulating the struggles of both its white and free Black populations to retain their identities amid an increasingly segregated, crisis-ridden American democracy. The result is a tale full of “Creole drama” indeed.
Rather than taking a purely chronological approach, Braun moves through a set of geographical contexts that inexorably draw the theatre from its colonial roots to the outbreak of the Civil War, examining New Orleans theatre in “circum-Atlantic, local, hemispheric, national, and transatlantic” frameworks (10). Her first chapter begins with the roots of French colonial theatre in the eighteenth-century Caribbean, where entertainment also ensured cultural Frenchness among the audience members, then rapidly progresses to the 1792 founding of the Théâtre de la Rue St. Pierre by the Henri brothers, immigrants from Paris, and its various theatrical successors. From this point, the first two chapters illustrate the close relationship between the theatre and local politics, as Spanish (or American) government officials, theatre owners, and playwrights jockeyed for preeminence in the Crescent City. Of particular interest is the second chapter's reading of three different plays (one of them in English) about the abortive 1768 Creole rebellion against the Spanish as a historical metaphor for Francophones’ attempts to preserve their culture against the encroachment of US American Anglophones. Chapters 3–5 test the very meaning of Francophone community in the United States (and later, the Confederacy). The third chapter—of particular importance for the state of US theatre studies as a whole, given the critical role that race has come to play in historiography—considers the way that the free Black population of New Orleans used theatre in their increasingly segregated city “to explore ideas of communal belonging, liberation, and resistance” to a state of legal affairs where American rule continued to eat away at their traditional rights and liberties (74–5). The fourth chapter documents the variety of challenges placed in the way of Francophone identification with the United States as they played out in the theatre: the rise of Francophobic nativism, the attempt by Anglo-Americans to whitewash the term “Creole” to exclude free people of color, and the Mexican–American War. All of these events had profound effects on the New Orleans theatre, not the least among them the cultural shift that led to the 1846 premiere of Louis Placide Canonge's adaptation of Dumas's Le Comte de Monte Cristo, which “succeeded in turning one of France's most popular contemporary novels into a vehicle for American patriotism” (128). In her final chapter, Braun considers the increasing tensions between French and American identities for Francophone Louisianans through the antebellum diaspora of free people of color emigrating to France, including Victor Séjour, who would eventually gain French citizenship and become one of the leading playwrights of Paris. (Meanwhile, white Francophones, including the playwright Canonge, fatefully attached themselves to the Confederacy.) The book ends, appropriately enough, with a fire that consumes the city's last Francophone theatre in 1919, effectively bringing down the curtain on a theatre that self-consciously represented a people struggling to maintain both their French and American identities.
As Laura L. Mielke's powerful Provocative Eloquence makes clear, however, the very nature of the US American identity to which the Creoles were forced to adapt themselves was fraying badly during the course of the antebellum period due to the question of slavery. Mielke is in good company here; recent studies involving race and the theatre in the antebellum United States include works by Heather Nathans, Gay Gibson Cima, Jenna Gibbs, Elizabeth Maddock Dillon, Amy Hughes, and Douglas A. Jones Jr. (Indeed, Mielke has a remarkable ability to incorporate the work of others without diluting her own arguments.) In her Introduction, Mielke reads the eloquence of the abolitionist orators—an example of what Kenneth Cmiel calls “middling style” (8)—as a performance that necessarily generates a violent response, one either rhetorical or, quite often, physical. As a result, “The theater's engagement with the heroic orator and the violence provoked by eloquence made it a charged rhetorical resource as those opposed to slavery pondered whether the peculiar institution could be overturned without physical force” (18). Indeed, as Mielke notes, violent responses to antislavery performance were necessary for raising the performance to new heights of eloquence in the eyes of the audience (18–19). Not for nothing is the 1856 caning of Senator Charles Sumner by Congressman Preston Brooks a touchstone for Mielke's argument. For abolitionist performers, the stakes were deadly serious.
Mielke begins in Chapter 1 with the American star Edwin Forrest, whose career depicted a “vexed relationship between speech and physical power,” especially in his famous role as the slave rebellion leader Spartacus (26). Mielke impressively explicates the irony inherent in Forrest's ability to portray violent rebellion in plays seemingly divorced from any context except the rise of the white working class under Andrew Jackson, while also drawing out the actor's sympathies with the progressive “Locofoco” wing of the Democratic Party. The tensions inherent in Forrest's public persona culminated in his 1838 Fourth of July speech in New York, which in its emphasis on unrestricted free speech as an inherent American right “performed obliquely a Jacksonian defense of antislavery speech” (54).
The rest of the book outlines a more direct performance mode that Mielke dubs “dramatic suasion: a rhetorically strategic recasting of the antislavery lecture into the drama,” which “called attention to its own necessity through an emphasis on antislavery speech's provocations of violence” (56, 58). Mielke surveys an impressive range of abolitionist performances, both theatrical and oratorical, to emphasize the physical danger faced by abolitionist speakers both real and fictional. The second chapter covers dramas by the escaped slave and abolitionist speaker William Wells Brown and literary readings performed by Mary Webb, the daughter of an escaped slave, which incorporated her taking on white characters from Harriet Beecher Stowe's highly theatrical novel Uncle Tom's Cabin. The third chapter, which begins with the theatrically inflected speech that prompted Congressman Brooks to cane Senator Sumner, further analyzes Stowe's theatricality by explicating the relationship between abolitionist speech and violent retribution in adaptations of her 1856 novel Dred—one of which featured a blackface performance by the originator of the “Jim Crow” minstrel character, T. D. Rice, as a loyal slave.
While Chapters 2 and 3 stress the vulnerability of abolitionist speech to violence, Mielke's Chapters 4 and 5 examine the possibility of abolitionist retribution. The fourth chapter constructs an antebellum performance genealogy of Portia's role in the trial scene of The Merchant of Venice as a rhetorical position adopted by abolitionist readings of the Constitution, one in which ironically literal readings of the law hoist those who would do violence against free speech with their own legalistic petard. By invoking Portia's textualist approach to an unconscionable contract, and not infrequently the character's own words, Mielke contends that abolitionist activists thus constructed an ironically feminine rhetorical performance mode that reclaimed “belligerent Northern manhood” from a caricatured position of passive martyrdom (134). Chapter 5 analyzes various stagings of the ultimate figure of abolitionist force: John Brown. Mielke performs a detailed reading of a melodrama about Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry, tying it to the essential theatricality of Henry David Thoreau's abolitionist speeches, especially “A Plea for Captain John Brown” (1859), which ends with a prophecy of revenge for Brown—one that arrived two years later with the Civil War.
Mielke's work ends with the historical oddity of John Wilkes Booth attending Brown's 1859 execution and a reading of a speech that Booth had penned intending to raise an antiabolitionist mob in Philadelphia during 1860. Whereas the 1919 theatre fire in New Orleans that concludes Braun's work marks the end of an era, Mielke's conclusion marks the beginning of a new one that started in 1861 at Fort Sumter and intensified with Booth's 1865 assassination of Lincoln. At the time of this writing, with marchers in the streets of American cities demanding racial justice, that era is clearly not yet over.
