Occasionally, the New York Times runs an article about young hipsters, steeped in locavore and “foodie” culture, leaving cities and white-collar employment for the intensive labor and dirt-encrusted fingernails of upstate farms. This narrative centers on idealistic youth in search of themselves, and looking to improve the world around them. When such articles historicize this trend, they root the movement in “back-to-the-land” projects of the 1960s and 1970s. In her new book, Back to the Land: The Enduring Dream of Self-Sufficiency in Modern America, Dona Brown pushes beyond this simple understanding of the history, goals, and meanings of a century of going “back.”
There has been a movement to go back to the land, Brown argues, ever since Americans started trading that farmland for city life. Brown traces these “back-to-the-land” impulses to the very early twentieth century. These back-to-the-landers were not the environmentalists of the 1970s. They relied on pragmatic how-to manuals like Ten Acres Enough, not the romanticism of Walden Pond. These men (and some women) were from the middling classes. They were surviving, but not thriving, in an urban setting. Their interest in going back to the land was typically motivated by economic and political reasons, an escape not from destitution but from the daily “grind.” These modern pioneers looked forward, not backward, Brown argues. They embraced electricity, modern transportation, and planning, in rural settings. Above all else, she argues, these new farmers were more pragmatic than nostalgic. Farm life offered the dream of economic self-determination to city dwellers who felt trapped by the burgeoning consumer market, gritty cities, and tedious jobs.
Brown, a historian, culls most of her evidence from extremely close readings of a hundred years of magazines and newspapers, memoirs, and farming manuals. She also delves deeply into the archival papers of two major back-to-the-land writers, David Grayson (a.k.a. Ray Stannard Baker) and Bolton Hall. The “fan” letters to American Magazine columnist (and back-to-the-land enthusiast) Grayson make for especially fascinating source material. Brown weaves together Grayson's beliefs, the beliefs espoused in his column, and readers’ interest in and interpretation of his stories.
These letters are great material not only because they allow Brown to move beyond a focus on prescriptive literature. They also grant Brown the opportunity to consider the place of gender relations at this early moment in going back to the land. She discovers that some women found that the land and the less formal sex roles of the West offered them unusual freedoms. Some women lived in relatively open homosexual relationships; others escaped the social ostracizing of divorced women and single mothers. And yet Brown explains that the overwhelmingly male back-to-the-land writers rarely thought to encourage city women (or “bachelor-maids”) to take up the hoe. This lapse was not mere oversight, I would imagine, but instead rooted in how notions of masculinity influenced the back-to-the-land concept. Brown briefly discusses how one writer calls the movement “a venture in masculine renewal” and another describes discovering his “primitive” self while working the land.
The actual analysis of back-to-the-land masculinity is unfortunately limited, taking up less than two pages of Brown's discussion of the early twentieth century and not continuing beyond that. More attention to this issue would not only add interesting stories, something this book already has plenty of. Rather, more attention to gender relations would also strengthen the author's argument concerning economic and political autonomy. The uncommonly close relationship between ideas about masculinity and about political and economic struggle at the turn of the century has been established by studies like Gail Bederman's Manliness and Civilization (1996) and Kristen Hoganson's Fighting for American Manhood (1998). Whether back-to-the-land dreams were about escaping the boss, supporting one's family, or a general search for “liberty,” these dreams were deeply embedded within the understanding that manliness meant autonomy. By understating the centrality of masculinity to the politics of autonomy, Brown loses the opportunity to determine just how much back-to-the-land appeal came from a desire to trade urban emasculation for a burly frontier fantasy.
Going “back” meant different things, and looked incredibly different, based on the era, gender, race, geography and motivations of different people. At its heart, though, Brown convincingly argues, going back to the land was about trying to assert power in a country that increasingly made its citizens feel powerless. Brown's cast of colorful characters and their competing visions of what it meant to be an American make for a rich intellectual history. They also provide much-needed context for understanding the contemporary back-to-the-land impulse as more than a fringe movement.
