In the acclaimed Israeli film Walk on Water (Eitan Fox, 2004), a macho, heterosexual Mossad agent realizes that the young German he “befriended” in order to investigate a Nazi family history is gay. The discovery comes halfway through the film, after the two have smeared sunscreen on each other, showered naked together, and sat shoulder to shoulder near a fire. The secret service agent, Eyal, is outraged and disgusted, and the film mocks his inability to read the signs that Axel is gay. Besides critiquing the heteronormative standards of Israeli masculinity (and society), the film attempts to ruffle more feathers in that the revelation scene comes after Axel engages in sex with Rafik, a Palestinian who then joins them on a day trip to Jerusalem. The budding amorous relationship annoys Eyal no end, eventually climaxing in an unjustified release of aggression that shows all—Axel, his sister Pia, and the Palestinians—who is the boss, who has power, and, ultimately, who is the real man. Fox, a seasoned filmmaker who addressed homosexuality in many of his previous films, attempts a complex attack on some of the holy cows of Zionism and Israeli identity (including homophobia and heteronormative masculine ideals). The film exemplifies many of the issues analyzed in Raz Yosef's book Beyond Flesh: Queer Masculinities and Nationalism in Israeli Cinema, and it is unfortunate that the release of the film coincided with the release of the book, so Yosef never had a chance to include an analysis of the film. Still, films like Walk on Water and Yossi and Jagger only make manifest the importance of a book such as Yosef's to uncovering the treatment of male homosexuality in Israeli culture.
The past fifteen years have seen the emergence of a substantial critical discourse on Zionist ideology and Israeli state institutions after the 1948 war. Researchers from social sciences, history, and the arts, to name just a few fields, have tackled different forms of inclusion and exclusion in the ways in which the Zionist narrative has manufactured itself as the quintessentially unified modern Jewish narrative. In film criticism alone, researchers have shown how the Zionist narratives exclude and subordinate the Mizrahim (Ella Shohat in her groundbreaking book Israeli Cinema: East/West and the Politics of Representation) and more recently how Palestinians, the naqba, and even Holocaust survivors are presented as “Othered” to the Zionist project (Yosefa Loshitzky, Identity Politics on the Israeli Screen). Yosef's book joins this good company as he analyzes the homophobic tendencies of Zionist thinking and its effects on Israeli cinema. At the same time, Yosef excavates homoerotic as well as overtly homosexual scenes in films that span some eighty years of Israeli productions. As such, the book serves as a dismantling tool of the myth of Israeli heterosexuality, reminding the reader that latent tendencies always circulate under the surface of (what seems to be) unified ideological commitment. Particularly striking is this analysis when the subject is the bastion of Israeli masculinity—the army films.
Yosef sets his theory as a binary of the exilic male Jew versus the new Israeli man; the diasporic (European) Jew was classified as effeminate, weak, and queer, and early Zionist thinkers, from Herzel to Nordau and others, aspired to see a new Jew—strong, muscular, and unmistakably heterosexual. However, the transition to this new ideal was fraught with contradiction, misgivings, and ultimately latent queer tendencies. Yosef spends much of the first chapter laying out this master narrative theory, and in many ways this chapter represents both the strength and the weakness of the book. The analysis is thorough and draws on many fields (early Zionist writing, Zionist and Israeli history, Jewish studies, queer theory, and more), and it is compelling—that is, within its own bounds. This theoretical paradigm is applied to an analysis of early Israeli films from the 1930s through the 1950s, films that assert Zionist ideology with intense commitment and yet exemplify those latent queer tendencies. The second chapter looks at nationalism, militarism, and masochism, and at the ever subversive presence of homoerotic tendencies in army films. This chapter—drawing much from Freudian and other psychoanalytic writings—carefully unravels complex psychological and emotional structures, which are in stark contrast to the overt commitment of the films to Zionist masculine ideals of both nationalism and heterosexuality. These two chapters are convincingly argued and are fascinating.
However, the theoretical reliance on a binary set of oppositions has a price, and that is the price of exclusion. In later chapters Yosef briefly examines the marginal representations of gay Mizrahi men and of gay Palestinians, and while he complains about simplistic, shallow, and stereotypical filmic representations, I would argue that his own theoretical configuration ends up marginalizing those same groups all over again. In the later parts of the book, Yosef repeatedly promotes the idea that class, ethnicity, and race should be accounted for in a multiplicity of gay identities, rather than all grouped under the title “Israeli gay men” (which represents Ashkenazi identity positions). Clearly, the aim of the book is to expose the problems of such a race/ethnic-blind approach, but because Yosef's own theory relies so heavily on unpacking the historical Ashkenazi binary of diasporic equals gay/Israeli equals straight, there is little theoretical room outside the margins. Yosef is accurate, of course, in the historical analysis of such marginalization, but he could, as others did (Shohat among them), postulate a theoretical framework that is more open and hybrid, in much the same ways he prescribes films to be.
Also nearly excluded from the discussion are women and most aspects of gender theories (beyond queer theory). It may not be surprising given the focus and scope of the book, but I would still argue that an analysis of how women fit in those masculine, heterosexual, nationalist structures would have enriched and complicated the binary thesis. Once we take into account masculine heterosexual men, homosexual men, and women (both heterosexual and homosexual), the dyadic limitations of the theory must be dissolved for a more nuanced approach. Yosef often refers to the queer Jewish man as described in feminine terms, and he always puts “feminine” in quotation marks, maybe to designate that the feminine is not an essential trait. However, he does not go further in an analysis of the position of women in Zionist ideology, the effects of masculinized nationalism on women, and the light such an analysis sheds on the presence and representation of gay men. Again, the focus of the book need not change, but the references to the representation of women are sporadic, specific, and hardly used to augment a generalized argument that could have strengthened and complicated the book's thesis.
Theoretically, and within its scope and aims, I find the book strong in its articulation of its arguments and the support material. Like many academic books, it is written in humanities-specific lingo. The film analysis is thorough, but because Yosef refrains from providing clear synopses of the films, the book seems to be intended for the culturally informed reader, which is unfortunate. Finally, the book could have used more thorough editing and proofreading. The typos are small but persistent and leave a bad taste of carelessness from the side of both author and press.
