The Austrian Federal Ministry of Unterricht, Kunst und Kultur in Vienna offered the perfect frame for the symposium “Rechtsfragen der Restitution von Kulturgut” on October 12, 2007. Under the direction of Gerte Reichelt, member of the Institut für Kunst und Recht (IFKUR) advisory board, the Ludwig Boltzmann Institut für Europarecht dedicated this day for the UNESCO convention in 1970 and the UNIDROIT convention in 1995.
The symposium was conducted by Kurt Siehr, University of Zurich, Max-Planck Institute of Hamburg and also member of the Heidelberg Institute of Art and Law (Institut für Kunst und Recht e.V., IFKUR) advisory board. Christoph Bazil, assistant leader of the department of conservation of monuments and historic buildings of the Austrian Federal Ministry of Education, Art and Culture and IFKUR member, opened the first Round Table on the 1970 UNESCO convention.Footnote 1 His talk, “The Ratification of UNESCO Convention 1970” dealt with different national aspects of implementation. At the same time, he exemplarily pointed out the single arguments of the ministry that speak, from the view of Austria, for and against a ratification or later implementation. On this occasion he found out that today many arguments for an implementation of the 1970 UNESCO convention exist; the ratification of the UNIDROIT conventionFootnote 2 must be postponed in Austria, but the ratification is desirable. Gabriele Eschig, secretary general of the Austrian UNESCO committee spoke next. Affected by the events in Iraq that concerned objects as well as important archives, in her contribution “Efforts of UNESCO for the Protection of Cultural Assets,” Eschig pointed to the urgent requirement of the implementation: All signatory's states should quickly fulfill their obligation. To clarify the meaning of UNESCO for the protection of culture, she introduced again the single measures of UNESCO. She started with the protection of the physical inheritance, underwater protection agreements, preservation of the immaterial heritage, and finally discussed the explanation concerning the intentional destruction of cultural heritage.
After a short break, Yves Fischer, head of the specialist department International Transfer of Cultural Objects of the Swiss Federal Office for Culture, indicated in his contribution, “The Implementation of UNESCO 1970 from a Swiss View,” the reactions of the art market in Switzerland after more than 2 years since the convention's enforcement. He expressly highlighted the positive import balance of cultural assets of Switzerland, so more cultural assets are imported than exported. This is a good sign that the initial doubts of the art market participants before implementation were unfounded. However, he informed, in connection with the implementation of the convention in Switzerland, it is important that the police officers and especially the toll keepers be trained, particularly with regard to archaeological cultural assets. The implementation of convention as well as the initiative of a state for the protection of cultural asset are important. He made this clear with the example of the Iraq order of Switzerland, which entailed an embargo for Iraqi cultural assets, with the result that these are not tradable today.
Subsequently, Matthias Weller, Mag.rer.publ., from the University of Heidelberg and one of the directors of the German Institute of Art and Law IFKUR e.V. Heidelberg, made a presentation on the forthcoming implementation of the 1970 convention in Germany. The transformation legislation has already been enacted; however, the ratification is still pending. The convention's framework will presumably enter into force in early 2008.Footnote 3 Weller observed a rather limited scope of the implementation legislation that seemed mainly caused by the legislator's aim to parallelize the UNESCO framework with the already existing implementation of Directive 93/7/EECFootnote 4 but also to the multilateral application of the UNESCO convention.
The second Round Table, the 1995 UNIDROIT convention,Footnote 5 was held by Walter H. Rechberger, University of Vienna and head of the Ludwig Boltzmann Institut für Rechtsvorsorge und Urkundenwesen. The afternoon was opened by Herbert Kronke, UNIDROIT secretary general, Rome, with the contribution, “UNIDROIT—Convention 1995 in the Dialog of the Implementations—History of the Origin.” He clearly indicated the reasons of the origin of UNIDROIT and its meaning for the future. Looking back on the questions after the first Round Table, he demonstrated the different national aspects of the bona fide acquisition in the countries, starting from the complete absence of such a possibility and working up to the complete exclusion and the difficulty following from it. Gerte Reichelt followed. She discussed the “Principles of the UNIDROIT—Convention 1995” individually. Gerte Reichelt spoke of the important meaning of the synchronization of definitions and, within the scope of the bona fide acquisition, the regulation of the due diligence as a starting point. Afterward she spoke on other problems. Thus, the regulation is difficult to apply with frescoes that qualify either as movable or immovable objects. Furthermore, she made clear the “ensemble principle” and asked for a privilege for cultural asset. Next, Georg Kathrein of the Federal Ministry of Justice showed in his report, “The Ratification of the UNIDROIT—Convention in 1995 in Austria” a skeptical view toward current implementation. Furthermore, he expressly emphasized the fact that this is a political decision, and the deliberations are not yet ready. Rather, it requires careful decision-making processes to move to UNIDROIT. In return, Nikolaus Kraft, lawyer and also member of the IFKUR, by his talk “The Ratification of the UNIDROIT—Convention 1995 by Austria: Chances for a Contemporary Exportation Right for Austria” took position to the necessary ratification of UNIDROIT. He clearly pointed to the necessary change of the Austrian legal situation, for UNESCO as well as UNIDROIT. At the same time he indicated that the cultural asset concept of the UNIDROIT convention deviates from the Austrian constitution, which could have unexpected results. It is necessary for a regulation doing justice to cultural asset protection by implementing both conventions, to classify certain cultural assets as res extra commercium, and to create for this the legal basis. But also other areas, such as in the legal regulations for the protection of cultural heritage, must be thought of an amendment. At the same time he pointed the defects in the transparency and the duty of information of the ministries within the scope of the implementation of UNESCO 1970.
As an end of the second Round Table, Nicolai Kemle, attorney and director of the German Institut of Art and Law (IFKUR), reported about “Voluntary Restitution Versus Legal Claim to Return.” In this connection he reported on the history and indicated the example of the Federal Republic of Germany and aspects that can be raised for and against the return of art. Besides the voluntary return, the voluntary renunciation is important, he discussed; and besides the legal claim, the legal exclusion of claims is possible. Direct regulations concerning the art can entail exclusion. Just periods of limitation and the bona fide acquisition are those exclusions “indirectly” excluding the return of cultural asset. However, crucial role also plays the time factor. This can be called a “voluntary involuntary loss,” because the recollection of objects by former owners gets lost. The final lecture was given by Wolf-Dieter Heilmeyer (Antikensammlung Berlin). He discussed the fate of the cultural asset in the future and questioned the explosive effect of topical considerations. In the diversity of the single subjects, the symposium showed that the implementation of the UNESCO convention shows action for the protection of cultural assets, but the future lies in the implementation of the 1995 UNIDROIT convention.
