Ingrid Monson's Freedom Sounds is a wide-ranging account of the role of jazz and jazz-identified musicians in struggles over civil rights in the United States between 1950 and 1975. These struggles played a crucially important role in the formation of the contemporary American sociopolitical landscape, and this book offers a needed resource to academic courses and public intellectual/media musings that tend not to include jazz-identified musics in standard accounts of 1960s counterculture.
The most common explanation for this erasure is that jazz's 1950s ejection from the Hit Parade rendered the music a cultural footnote in an era when newer forms of popular musical expression were said to serve as anthems for “youth everywhere.” For example, cultural historian Andrew Ross has maintained that “soul music” had forged “a more successful cultural union,” while “avant-garde jazz” had “gone beyond the realm of popular taste.”Footnote 1 This view is complemented by the rise of a 1980s strain of jazz criticism, still influential at the turn of the twenty-first century, that danced in toe shoes along the razor's edge of irony, simultaneously lamenting the decline in jazz's mass popularity, while at the same time regarding that lack of popular influence as a marker of excellence.
A larger irony, and one of greater import, concerns the short shrift given by these public counterculture narratives to the sociomusical aspects of the struggles of African Americans, at a time when virtually every activist formation drew inspiration and instruction from the sounds of the civil rights and, later, the Black Power movements. In that light Monson's observation that “jazz musicians were among the most active supporters of civil rights causes and were substantially more outspoken than R&B musicians in the early 1960s” (219) is particularly salutary. Seen in this context, perhaps the fact that jazz-identified musicians had already “gone beyond the realm of popular taste” allowed them greater freedom to perform other transgressions, such as supporting a civil rights movement that was still controversial and possibly career threatening.
Thus, rather than a renewed search for the era-defining anthem, a preoccupation that routinely renders invisible many black communities of sonic culture, Monson shows us forms of sonic activism that didn't make the papers, but that had an unarguable impact. The case is certainly not controversial, but rather, makes plain the need for further research, and the great gift of Freedom Sounds is how these “hidden histories” (to gloss George Lipsitz's alliteration) are made accessible to wider debate. Along the way, as with the best scholarship, the book raises many more questions than could be tackled in a book twice its length and provides an effective mycelium for future scholars.
Firm in the conviction that black music, as a part of black life, must be reckoned with to understand black struggle, Monson concentrates on jazz (and struggle) as work, and on jazz-identified artists as workers. This turn of discourse allows her to connect the race-inflected goals and demands of cultural workers with other labor struggles that civil rights organizations supported—for example, the struggle to desegregate the American Federation of Musicians (57). On the other hand, somewhat less attention is paid in this monograph to issues of gender and sexuality than one might hope, perhaps in part because males constituted a supermajority in the art world Monson is chronicling. Thus, the pronounced gender disparity between the virtually all-male community of jazz musicians performing northern civil rights benefits and the complement of performers in southern grassroots musical presentations—Bernice Johnson Reagon, Odetta, Joan Baez, Mahalia Jackson—may have seemed too prosaic for comment.
The topic of the book, the role of jazz musicians as activists, indicates a usefulness for music beyond the art pour l'art stance of jazz (and contemporary classical) modernism. In this way, Freedom Sounds can profitably be read alongside Eric Porter's important work on the aesthetic and critical writing of jazz-identified musicians and composers of the 1960s and 1970s, as well as Penny von Eschen's 2004 book Satchmo Blows Up the World: Jazz Ambassadors Play the Cold War, which highlights the role played by public, international jazz performance in the attempted assertion of the American Century during the 1950s and 1960s. Monson's narrative does overlap and dialogue with the von Eschen work.Footnote 2
I would like to call attention to that aspect of Monson's work that one could call “musician-centered” scholarship. Whether in an ethnographic vein as with her singular 1996 book Saying Something: Jazz Improvisation and Interaction or in this latest, historically oriented work, Monson's most important work gives voice to musicians' goals, aspirations, aesthetics, and philosophies. Swimming against the current (and equally important) tide of scholarship on consumption in popular music studies, Monson's work, like Porter's, makes a ringing case that the voices of musicians still matter. Her close attention to the movements of musicians, from the small and large jazz benefit concerts for civil rights groups to the international State Department itineraries (now, as I was recently told, administered by none other than Jazz at Lincoln Center), result not only from a close relationship with the archive, but also from a deep understanding of the ways in which archive and repertoire recursively produce each other.Footnote 3
One hopes that future historians and ethnographers of jazz will more deeply address what Monson calls “structural white privilege,” or what George Lipsitz called the “possessive investment in whiteness” that is still being asserted (despite the election to the U.S. presidency of Barack Obama) in virtually every corner of the United States—and in the European West as well, where minority candidates of national stature, positioned to assert an Obama-like leadership of the political system, have yet to be identified.Footnote 4 Monson's rejection of colorblind critical and historical perspectives recalls Cheryl I. Harris's pioneering 1993 Harvard Law Review article “Whiteness as Property.” As Harris maintains, “Whites are not an oppressed people and are not at risk of becoming so. Those whites that are disadvantaged in society suffer not because of their race, but in spite of it.”Footnote 5
Thus, as Monson notes, even as “black musicians experienced structural racial discrimination, no matter what their individual relationship to Western modernism and mainstream culture” (73), the obverse, as Harris makes plain, concerns the role of expectation—namely, the expectation by whites that the structural advantages of whiteness should continue indefinitely. Here whiteness becomes a powerful, and at times overdetermining, form of symbolic capital in the field of cultural production, particularly when combined with a form of denial that such privileges existed—as symbolized by the emergence of the baleful jazz narrative of “Crow Jim” or “reverse racism.” As Monson notes, “Many [white musicians] were not aware of the impact of white privilege on their ability to cross the color line, get a meal, or find employment in a band that worked on television” (7)—or, at least, such ignorance was regularly professed.
The effect of structural white privilege is certainly on view in the vast asymmetries in infrastructure between jazz and classical music production, differences that place considerable pressure on the hopeful representation of jazz as a kind of “black classical music.” Monson's key finding here is that among jazz-identified musicians who desired recognition for their cosmopolitan engagement with Western classical music, their exercise of what Monson calls “aesthetic agency” demonstrates the cultural and social power of aspiration. Here the author presents us with historian Robin D. G. Kelley's understanding that “the conditions and the very existence of social movements enable participants to imagine something different, to realize that things need not always be this way” (306). At the same time, however, Monson's narrative shows us the limits of musical self-fashioning. Infrastructure is socially achieved, and as Monson notes, “an individual's aesthetic choices . . . cannot by themselves alter the underlying social condition” (74).
This section of the book can be taken as encouraging further research in jazz studies on the relationship between aesthetically imbued social networks and infrastructure distribution. The classic study in this regard is anthropologist Georgina Born's 1995 study of IRCAM, the famous French computer music institute, Rationalizing Culture: IRCAM, Boulez, and the Institutionalization of the Musical Avant-Garde. Footnote 6 I would observe here that a newer approach to this topic might involve cross-disciplinary work among ethnographers, historians, and economists.
Such work could also be comparative, following up on the anecdotal comparisons that already exist between jazz and classical infrastructures. Certainly one would want to know more about the decision processes of William Schuman, Virgil Thomson, and Paul Henry Lang regarding the worthiness of jazz musicians to represent the United States, briefly explored by Monson (112). Because Monson discusses the FBI's unseemly interest in Abbey Lincoln and Max Roach, one would also want to know a bit about possible involvement of the Central Intelligence Agency in the State Department jazz tours. CIA-aided marketing and dissemination of U.S. contemporary music during the 1950s has already been explored by historian Frances Stonor Saunders (with reference to the mid-1970s Senate hearings led by Senator Frank Church that brought the whole business into the Congressional Record) and later by musicologist Amy Beal.Footnote 7
The international purview of the book's research findings provides a needed expansion on the admittedly New York–centric historiography of jazz, while recognizing New York's leading role as a staging point for jazz careers. The national and international character of the civil rights movement is reflected in Monson's archival research, which shows that civil rights benefits were performed by jazz-identified musicians all over the United States. Also relevant in this context is Jason Stanyek's 2004 account of an emerging postcolonial consciousness among musicians of the 1940s, fueled by face-to-face, intercultural contact between U.S. musicians such as Dizzy Gillespie and Cuban musicians such as Chano Pozo and Frank “Machito” Grillo.Footnote 8 As Monson points out, the internationalist meme turns up in the hard bop of Art Blakey, Horace Silver, and many others.
The conclusion of Freedom Sounds functions more as a pause in the narrative around 1965, a point at which jazz's nonfunctionality as a mass music rendered benefit concerts of the sort Monson chronicles increasingly untenable. As the book points out, jazz-identified musicians were becoming “notably absent from the front lines of the Southern grassroots civil rights campaigns” (219). Moreover, the absence of now-legendary late modernist “free jazz” figures such as Albert Ayler, Sun Ra, and Cecil Taylor from the benefit-concert narrative is telling. By the late 1960s, musicians still gave benefit concerts for black causes—most notably AACM cofounder and former Sun Ra trumpeter Phil Cohran's founding in Chicago of the short-lived but well-remembered Affro-Arts Theater, which attracted the alacritous attention of both the African American community and the local police “Red Squad” by bringing in radical sociopolitical figures such as the Rev. Albert Cleage, Amiri Baraka, and Stokely Carmichael.Footnote 9
As the number of black political organizations increased, however, the object of benefit events mirrored the diversity of sonic and political viewpoints. Rather than the broadly based intentions of earlier years, benefits became a form of narrowcasting, intragroup gift exchange, or implicit protests against the U.S. health care system's treatment of musicians. These events, related to the beginnings of the AACM, the Black Artists Group in St. Louis, the UGMAA in Los Angeles, and other musicians' collectives that sprang up around the United States, were evidence of the emergence of new forms of musical activism, in which musicians, in addition to working with nonmusical activists or supporting their efforts with musical labor, became civil rights and Black Power activists themselves.
As Monson's earlier work has shown us, improvisations are actually “saying something,” and in pursuit of that belief, Freedom Sounds provides resynthesizable transcriptions (i.e., transcriptions that can serve as performance scores to reproduce essential aspects of the original music) of performances by Abbey Lincoln and Max Roach, George Russell, and others. However, the transcription-resistant music of Ayler, Jeanne Lee, late Coltrane, and many others who were active and influential during the latter days of the period of Freedom Sounds offers a methodological challenge to the traditional view of the efficacy of transcription, because with these later musical methodologies it is doubtful that traditional theoretical methods can result in resynthesizability.
If, as Monson notes, we intend to think about how “keys, harmonies, rhythmic patterns, melodic styles, textures, timbres, genres, and forms” also “carry symbolic associations that are key to generating a deeper expressive power” (176), we will need to develop a new kind of theoretical writing that can account for affect in a post-transcription music—or, indeed, any improvised music. In thinking about these possibilities, we can draw on the recent insights of a newer generation of music theorists, such as Fred Maus and Marion Guck, as well as the work of literary theorist Fred Moten.Footnote 10
In the end, however, those most vitally concerned with the need for new understandings of sonic affect in jazz-identified and improvised musics will need to accept the greatest share of responsibility for taking full theoretical advantage of the opportunity Monson has identified. Such writing would need to develop new ways of theorizing our encounter with sound, perhaps beginning with evocative neologisms that go far deeper than the wan duo of “hearing” and “listening.” Just as literary scholars have for decades drawn new ideas from exploring the “textuality” of social practice, a similar freedom of reference should encourage scholars to develop new insights about larger-scale societal organization and interaction through a well-theorized “musicality” that deploys sound as both subject and critical tool.
By interrupting the public intellectual narrative regarding whose sounds might best represent the social and cultural climate of the time, Freedom Sounds points the way to these possible worlds of theory. One hopes that this and later accounts might spark a debate that, in the critical discourse of Down Beat magazine, would definitely be “deserving of wider recognition.”
