In The Spanish Craze, Richard Kagan elaborates on his 1996 article that assessed the historian William H. Prescott and the pervasive influence of the Black Legend. In this view, Spain and its people were different, even “half-African,” in the words of French novelist Victor Hugo (136). They had engaged in cruel and unusual practices, from the brutalities of conquest to the horrors of the Inquisition, and their national character made them especially well-suited to a despotic and corrupt form of government. Racially, they remained distinct from Anglo-Saxons. But the tarnished image of a retrograde Spain began to crumble under the weight of romanticized notions found in the pages of Washington Irving as well as poets, travel writers, and intellectuals. Conquistadores received a rehabilitation as strong, proud men who spread civilization to the primitive peoples of the New World. Christopher Columbus, Juan Ponce de León, and Francisco Vázquez de Coronado became immortalized atop monuments and in festivals that celebrated their heritage, from Washington, D.C., to St. Augustine and Santa Fe. During the Gilded Age, Americans imagined Spain as a land of fantastical and picturesque villages that preserved folklore, traditional dances, and customs like bullfighting. Seen through this lens, Spaniards were exotic and alluring. Drawing on an arsenal of resources, from personal correspondence, newspaper articles, archival papers, and a deep knowledge of history and art, Kagan extends his analysis backward into the Enlightenment and forward to the onset of the Spanish Civil War. He argues that by the late nineteenth century, a more positive vision of Spain had emerged in the United States that led to what Luis de Onís later called “a collective fever, the desire to know Spanish and everything relevant to the peoples who speak the language” (194). This new trope even survived the Spanish-American War relatively unscathed. By the early decades of the twentieth century, wealthy Americans, including unlikely figures such as William Randolph Hearst, had begun to collect Spanish art, buy historic Spanish properties, and even imitate the plateresque style of architecture that had developed in the Iberian Peninsula in the sixteenth century. A veritable Spanish craze ensued.
In thematic chapters, Kagan reveals that Spanish intellectuals recognized this shift in attitudes. In 1906, Miguel de Unamuno noted that “one can honestly say that the United States … is today the nation in which the things of Spain are studied most and best” (170). In 1885, few American universities hired scholars of Spain. By 1900, a sea change had swept through higher education, with most institutions offering classes in the Spanish language as well as its literature and history. In addition, between 1892 and 1914, a series of public events and ceremonies commemorated Spain's contributions to American history and ushered in a wave of pan-Americanism. Starting with the centennial of Columbus's arrival and ending with the opening of the Panama Canal, Americans celebrated Chicago's Columbian Exposition of 1893 and the 1901 Pan-American Exposition in Buffalo with millions of visitors learning about the legacy of Spain. And with the advent of the Great War, the study of German suffered a “catastrophic collapse,” opening the way for Spanish to achieve an even greater level of popularity (187). Of course, these are the origins of our academic fields today, although Kagan wryly notes that his own university, Johns Hopkins, “dragged its feet” in terms of teaching Latin American and Spanish history (489).
Unamuno, among others from the Generation of ’98, had channeled the idea that rural Spain, juxtaposed against decadent urban centers, embodied the heart and soul of the nation. This, in turn, became a selling point for those who, like Archer Milton Huntington, wanted to capture Spain's essence and put it on display. Doing so highlighted what one writer called the religious nature of the Spanish character (247). While the Boston Athenaeum hosted the first major Spanish art exhibition in the 1870s, Huntington opened the Hispanic Society of America in New York City in 1908 with a vast library of more than 50,000 volumes and a museum showcasing treasures and art from Spain and the Spanish American world. Huntington had to compete with other collectors as they bought any and all works by Spanish masters like Bartolomé Murillo, Diego Velázquez, El Greco, and Francisco de Zurbarán, although in later years many would be determined to have been misattributed. With titles like Crucifixion and Virgin of Mercy, the paintings presented a devout and humble society to the American public. Yet the Spanish Cortes interpreted the sell-off as a looting of its cultural patrimony and passed stringent laws to prevent further losses by the early 1930s.
Urban design also reflected the aesthetic turn toward Spain, especially in parts of the American South and Southwest with a Hispanic colonial past. Architects in towns such as Ojai, Santa Barbara, and Coral Gables, Florida constructed buildings with white stucco walls and tiled roofs in imitation of small Andalusian towns. For advocates, Spanish revival (or mission style) architecture represented the “tradition, history, and romance” of Spain (326). But it became quintessentially American as well, spreading to Midwestern hubs like Hastings, Nebraska; Cleveland, Ohio; and Kansas City, Missouri. By the end of the 1920s “both Montgomery Ward and Sears Roebuck & Co. offered customers inexpensive home-building kits for Spanish-style houses and bungalows” (353).
The book concludes with a chapter on music and dance that drove American audiences, even in New York, to hysterics and critics to hyperbole. Operas, symphonies, ballet performances, plays, and even silent films with Spanish themes inspired enthusiastic receptions. The influence of Spain could be heard in chart-topping songs with titles like “In Old Madrid.” More might have been said about flamenco, especially in a text that extends over five hundred pages. But Kagan definitely makes his case that by the early twentieth century, Americans, including luminaries like Gertrude Stein and Ernest Hemingway, had embraced all things Spanish.
