Conducting research and writing about identity is a strenuous process and a topic close to the hearts and minds of people who, because of personal background, have the urge to tackle this issue. When it comes to handling issues of identity for Armenians, the task of defining parameters and categorizing factors influencing Armenian identity is complex and hence difficult. Levon Abrahamian has taken on the challenge in his book Armenian Identity in a Changing World.
Written from an anthropological perspective, the book maps the development of Armenian identity in contemporary Armenia by exploring various factors influencing and shaping that identity in a post-Soviet setting. Arguing that Armenian identity is a sum of many factors (the author calls these “paths” within a “garden” of identity), the book looks at the impact of these “paths” on the (re)shaping and (re)defining of Armenian identity. What makes this endeavor different from previous works on Armenian identity is that it focuses on identity in the Republic of Armenia rather than Armenians in the diaspora, even though the author has devoted a chapter toward the end of the book on the duality of Armenians living in Armenia and abroad.
The author mentions sixteen different paths of identity formation in the book (naming, language, music, faith, violence, monuments, and traditions, to mention a few). The problem, however, is that some of these paths are very similar (such as the paths of naming and renaming; the path of tyrants and fools and the royal path; the path of ancestors and the path of prehistory) although others have so many “subpaths” that their classification seems arbitrary. Toward the end of the book, the author admits that what he classifies as a garden or a path could as well be a labyrinth of overlapping, crosscutting, and superimposing factors influencing Armenian identity.
The language of the books is sometimes confusing because it is apparent that the work was either translated or edited by someone not equipped for that task. At times run-on sentences make it difficult to follow the author's thoughts, and at other times verbatim translation obscures the ideas.
Most of the references and sources used in the book are either Russian or mainstream Western (Benedict Anderson, William Safran, and so forth).! Although the selection could be viewed as a handicap, it has advantages because it provides excellent insight into the Russian and former Soviet academic landscape dealing with issues of language, history, and identity. Utilizing anecdotal stories to elucidate some of his points, the author provides a glimpse into a transitional period in Soviet Armenia and the ways people negotiated their “new” identities.
Some of the “paths” influencing Armenian identity are quite modern, and the author has done an excellent job tackling those. For instance, he juxtaposes modern “rabiz” music and the stereotype of a “rabiz” singer with traditional Armenian music, explaining how they influence and shape contemporary Armenian identity. In the process of elaborating concepts related to identity, the author is careful to define the origins of words and their usage in various settings. The author's zeal in deconstructing commonly used words in Armenia and examining their origins is enlightening; it allows the reader to track the development and appropriation of words vis-à-vis their everyday usage by a people in the process of redefining their identity.
The book could easily be expanded to include more detail and in-depth analyses, especially utilizing theories and concepts of state-led development of identity (on conscious or subconscious levels). It should also be reorganized to reflect clearer distinctions among the “paths” of identity. Despite the few linguistic and structural flaws mentioned previously, the book is an excellent addition to the scholarship dealing with identity formation in the post-Soviet space, especially national identity within the confines of the Armenian nation–state. The changing sociopolitical conditions in Armenia and their impact on Armenian identity are dealt with rigorously and in their entirety, providing those interested in this issue with an invaluable source for research on identity in Armenia.
This book is strongly recommended to anyone dealing with issues of changing identity in the post-Soviet space. The simple language of the author makes his research accessible to nonacademics and experts alike and gives the reader a chance to explore the process of post-Soviet transition. Overall, this is a great book that also lays the groundwork for further research on a little explored topic.
