A myriad of reasons peripheral to the legal sphere are offered to justify the absence of armed groups in the development of the law applicable to armed conflicts. The assertions that armed groups undermine the state's authority by putting it in a position of inferiority and weakness, or that their influence on the territory and the population constitutes a tacit recognition of their importance and consequently gives them a green light to proceed with their actions despite violations of universal norms, are all based on one misleading premise: if states ignore armed groups threatening their sovereignty, they will just disappear. This ‘ostrich-like behaviour’Footnote 1 of states toward armed groups is in line with the Westphalian international order of discarding armed groups all together because, simply put, they are not states and only states can claim to be subjects of public international law.Footnote 2
In this article, I will try to evaluate the added value provided by the participation of armed groups in the development of legal norms applicable to armed conflicts by identifying reasons why armed groups should be involved. I will then examine the means and mechanisms that would allow armed groups to participate in the development of such law, in the creation of future norms as well as in the interpretation and contextualization of existing norms.
When discussing the possibility and the opportunity of armed groups to take part in the development of the law applicable to armed conflicts, it is important to first define the entities and subjects examined. Indeed, even though all parties to non-international armed conflicts, whether state actors or armed groups, are bound by the relevant rules of international humanitarian law (IHL), the term ‘armed groups’ is not itself defined in treaty law. ‘Parties’ to an armed conflict indeed vary widely in character. Organized armed groups, in particular, are extremely diverse, as explained by the International Committee of the Red Cross (ICRC):
They range from those that are highly centralized (with a strong hierarchy, effective chain of command, communication capabilities, etc.) to those that are decentralized (with semi-autonomous or splinter factions operating under an ill-defined leadership structure). Groups may also differ in the extent of their territorial control, their capacity to train members, and the disciplinary or punitive measures that are taken against members who violate humanitarian law.Footnote 3
For the purpose of this article, I will align myself with this broad description of ‘organized armed groups’; to this end, the expressions ‘armed groups’ and ‘non-state armed groups’ will use be used interchangeably. It should also be noted that, although transnational armed groupsFootnote 4 or private military companiesFootnote 5 could be considered specific forms of armed groups, this article will not focus on the potential linkage of such armed groups to a state. First, the ICRC's description meets the general requirements of the definition of ‘non-state armed groups’ as proposed by the United Nations’ Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) in its Manual on Humanitarian Negotiations with Armed Groups.Footnote 6 Second, many state-centric enforcement mechanisms found in IHL, human rights law, or public international law are already in place; although the question of the efficiency and relevance of those mechanisms is very much worth addressing, that is not the purpose of this article.Footnote 7 I will focus on the armed groups themselves, and explore the means at their disposal to engage in a legal order that has not involved them in its inception but has made them accountable for its violations.
Furthermore, reference to ‘the law applicable to armed conflicts’ should be interpreted liberally, as to include not only international humanitarian treaty law applicable to non-international armed conflict (with the different thresholds set by Common Article 3 of the Four Geneva Conventions and Additional Protocol II) but also customary law, soft law, and even some public international law and human rights law rules. Not all those bodies of law will be addressed in this article, but specifics will be provided throughout the text to distinguish the nature of the legal body referred to, when necessary. Finally, this article explores ways to engage non-state actors in law-making in a broad sense: systematically limiting the analysis to treaty law would impede finding creative solutions to curtail the practical and legal hurdles that are currently making this participation so difficult.
Why should armed groups participate in the development of the law applicable to armed conflicts?
A wide array of stakeholders would benefit from the participation of armed groups in the development of rules of IHL. It will be argued in the next pages that such participation is not only in the interest of the international community as a whole, but is also part of a normal evolution of the international legal order and IHL. Furthermore, such participation would address the needs of both the armed groups themselves and of the victims of violations of IHL.
Because it is in the interest of the international community
In a recent report to the United Nations Security Council on the protection of civilians in armed conflict, the Secretary-General identified ‘enhancing compliance by non-state armed groups’ as one of the five core challenges that the Security Council needs to address.Footnote 8 The focus is therefore not on condemning the actions, but on entering into a dialogue with the groups. The Secretary-General made it clear that the ‘name and shame’ mechanism by which the Security Council systematically condemns violations committed by armed groups, demands compliance, and applies targeted measures against leadershipFootnote 9 is a means of last resort. When engagement fails and proves futile, only then can sanctions enter the picture.Footnote 10
In a 2010 report, the Secretary-General provided an update on progress made in responding to the core challenges, and discussed the need to reach out to armed groups, although very diverse in their motivations and conduct. He re-stated that: ‘Improved compliance with IHL and human rights law will always remain a distant prospect in the absence of, and absent acceptance of the need for, systematic and consistent engagement with non-State armed groups’.Footnote 11 The report went on to mention that engagement is sought with armed groups in Afghanistan, Colombia, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, the occupied Palestinian territories, Pakistan, Somalia, Sudan, Uganda, and Yemen, but it did not specify the nature of the engagement. Even without those specifications, the international community, through its official political organ that is the United Nations, is recognizing the need to engage with armed groups in order to make a ‘tangible difference’ in the protection of victims.Footnote 12
Because the international legal order needs it
Armed groups, as non-state actors that compose the ‘invisible layer’ of public international law,Footnote 13 are not only challenging the way war is waged today: their interaction (or lack thereof) with state structures, sheds light on the flaws and the gaps in a state-centric international legal order. Without going as far as endorsing post-Westphalian logic, where the nation-state has lost its usefulness,Footnote 14 one needs to acknowledge that the state-centric model has substantially evolved.
Different indexes such as the Global Peace Index,Footnote 15 the Failed States Index,Footnote 16 the State Fragility Index,Footnote 17 and the United Nations’ Human Development IndexFootnote 18 are all showing that non-state armed groups are more and more present and active in the waging of war.Footnote 19 This assessment is not sufficient in itself to totally undermine the relevance of the Westphalian model in the twenty-first century. Indeed, threats posed by armed groups, although real and very challenging, are not necessarily meeting the threshold of disrupting the international legal order, but have merely created regional ripples.Footnote 20 Still, it cannot be disputed that the increasing threats posed by armed groups seriously challenge the traditional conception of such order. Lavoisier's formulation, ‘Rien ne se perd, rien ne se crée, tout se transforme’ speaks volumes about the fact that states are losing ground.Footnote 21 If states are failing, something or someone else is filling the gap. Without going into a critical analysis of the existing international relations paradigms, approaches, and theories, which is beyond the scope of this article, it is safe to say that the three major schools of thought in this domain – realism, liberalism, and constructivism – are all challenged, although at different levels, by the role and the place of armed groups in the international legal order.Footnote 22
Because the law needs it
Inclusion of armed groups in the development of legal instruments binding them could limit the possibility of excuses offered by such groups to justify their disregard of humanitarian law obligations. It would indeed, to a certain extent, ensure their adhesion to the law and generate greater compliance. In that sense, it would limit the potential violations of IHL and strengthen self-enforcement, hence limiting the need to put forward ‘external’ implementation mechanisms. In order to encourage self-enforcement by non-state armed groups, which is one of the mechanisms available to keep humanitarian law realistic and relevant, it is not just education that needs to take place; ownership of the rules of humanitarian law also needs to be fostered.Footnote 23
One of the key ideas behind the reinforcement of ownership is that it feeds into something positive and builds on a culture of compliance. Looking at positive experiences such as the one achieved by Geneva Call,Footnote 24 I optimistically believe that ownership of the rules of humanitarian law by armed groups is attainable through mechanisms outside the traditional state-centric model of the international legal order, which we will briefly examine later in this article. Indeed, the potential of compliance by armed groups with humanitarian rules is enhanced when reciprocal adherence, based on the possibility for the said armed groups to use their judgment and their reasoning to decide if and how they will be bound by rules, is nurtured.
Because armed groups need it
Recent research (discussed below) quoted by the United Nations’ Secretary-General identified the primary incentive for compliance with international norms to protect civilians as appearing to be the group's own self-interest, which has military, political, and legal aspects.Footnote 25 As further stated in the said research, the military arguments for compliance comprise both an element of reciprocity and strategic choices. The political arguments for compliance centre on the desire of many armed non-state actors, and/or the causes they may espouse, to be recognized as legitimate. Armed groups do not benefit from being classified as ‘outlaws’. If they were to take part in the development of the rules governing armed hostilities, it would be much harder for the state to consider itself free of any obligation and consequently to apply the most violent measures of repression.Footnote 26
Furthermore, the legal arguments for compliance are primarily the avoidance of international criminal sanction and other coercive measures, such as arms embargoes, travel bans, and asset freezes. The legal validity of such arguments could be discussed, as was done in the article by René Provost in the previous issue of the Review, through the concept of asymmetrical reciprocity and compliance with the laws of war, for instance.Footnote 27 Beyond that, however, we need to acknowledge and appreciate these arguments as a factual statement of the views of some armed groups waging war these days. From a humanitarian perspective (discussed in the next section), non-state armed groups already have something to gain by answering the ‘imperative call of civilization’Footnote 28 and complying with the law applicable to armed conflicts. If they are involved in the development of such norms, it will psychologically be even easier for individuals to accept them; and it will also increase ownership of the rules governing the way in which war is waged as a whole, and not only of the rules that they helped to create.
Because the victims need it
There are important humanitarian arguments for compliance by armed groups with humanitarian law that relate to the desire of certain armed groups to respect human dignity. This desire should not be underestimated, and may allow for opportunities to go beyond actual international obligations and hold such groups to standards that provide a higher level of protection for civilians than those strictly demanded by international law.Footnote 29
The genuine desire of some armed groups to behave in a humanitarian way should not be undervalued; indeed, just as with the utmost importance of unilateral application of some key humanitarian norms, it cannot be overstated. For a few core rules that speak directly to the heart of humanity, we can set aside the treaties, the negotiations, and even history, leaving us only with our common sense to honestly recognize their necessity for any human being, in any situation, especially in armed conflicts. What is referred to as ‘the universally recognized imperative call of civilization’ in the ICRC Commentaries to Common Article 1 of the Geneva Conventions also applies to those standard common-sense rules prohibiting the killing of the powerless and the exercise of violence in the form of rape, torture, and mutilation.Footnote 30 Indeed, when a party to an armed conflict, be it a state or an non-state actor, prevents violations of such a rule, it does so ‘as much because of the respect one has for it oneself as because of the respect for it which one expects from one's opponent, and perhaps even more for the former reason than for the latter’.Footnote 31
Nonetheless, humanitarian motivation does not exist in a vacuum, especially with respect to armed groups waging war for purposes that they consider to be just and valid. Involving these armed groups in the development of the rules of armed conflict would nurture and cultivate their desire to respect human dignity and achieve an acceptable balance between self-interest and ‘the respect one has for it oneself’. Indeed, such involvement would reinforce the idea behind the distinction between jus ad bellum and jus in bello, which ‘addresses the reality of a conflict without considering the reasons for or legality of resorting to force’.Footnote 32
Furthermore, from the victims’ perspective, engaging with all parties – state and non-state actors alike – involved in the armed conflict increases the likelihood of getting commitments from all of them to respect the limits within which they agree to wage war. Victims of violations of humanitarian norms need to be saved from harm and their perpetrators need to be accountable, independently of which side commits the violations; thus, the protection of victims could increase with the number of commitments.
With non-state actors, the humanitarian argument toward the respect of humanitarian law needs to be fostered and encouraged at all times and every step of the way. If ‘humanitarian action is inconceivable without close and permanent dialogue with the parties to the conflict’,Footnote 33 it should also be noted that a close and permanent dialogue with non-state parties to a conflict begins with their involvement in the development of the rules governing armed conflicts. Victims will be the principal beneficiaries of such a process.
How should armed groups participate in the development of the law applicable to armed conflicts?
In public international law, there is a disconnect between law-making and application of the law. If, for IHL to apply to an armed group, the latter need to be operating de facto in the context of an armed conflict (meeting one of the thresholds set up either in the Geneva Conventions or the Additional Protocols), such a requirement is not necessarily needed to participate in the development of the legal norms applicable to such conflict. As a matter of fact, there is no explicit framework around the participation of non-state armed groups in international humanitarian law-making, because non-state entities are systemically hindered from taking part in law-making per se.Footnote 34 Even though some headway has been made on broadening the definition of subjects of international law beyond states depending on ‘the needs of the community’,Footnote 35 the statist doctrine embodied in the Statute of the International Court of Justice (ICJ)Footnote 36 in regard to sources of international public law is still quite dominant in practice.Footnote 37 As mentioned by Anthea Roberts and Sandesh Sivakumaran, ‘[a] link has not generally been made between recognizing non-state entities as having rights, duties and enforcement capacities under international law, on the one hand, and their being able to play a role in international law-making, on the other hand’.Footnote 38A fortiori, when the non-state entity is an armed group, the likelihood of controversy is even higher than when discussing ‘state empowered bodies’,Footnote 39 such as the United Nations Security Council or the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia.
With those considerations in mind, the next pages will be devoted to identifying different ways in which armed groups can be involved in the development of norms governing armed conflicts. In my view, there is already an immense potential in the interpretation and contextualization of existing norms, so a few options in this direction will be examined. First, however, I will look at the possibility of armed groups taking part in the creation of future norms of IHL.
Looking ahead: feeding into the creation of future norms
The fact that formal law-making is still dominated by statist doctrine makes it extremely difficult to involve armed groups as formal participants in the drafting of multilateral treaties. The over-politicization of the treaty-making process, the practical difficulties and potential criminal implications of reaching out to armed groups considered illegal,Footnote 40 the possible enhancement of the status of the armed groups – against the will of the state – from a common criminal to an ‘equal’ interlocutor, the inappropriate legitimizing of armed groups, and the downgrading of humanitarian law protections (by amendment of the law to reflect actual practices that constitute infringement upon humanitarian norms) are just a few potential difficulties identified in recent contributions to the doctrine on the subject.Footnote 41 Even beyond those obstacles, the lack of a common denominator across all armed groups makes identifying which groups to involve seem insurmountable: ‘It would be almost impossible to reach agreement over which groups should be invited to participate in the respective diplomatic conferences drafting those treaties’.Footnote 42
That being said, history tells us a less pessimistic story. Armed groups did sit at the negotiation table when key treaties of humanitarian law were drafted. Eleven national liberation movements, including the Palestinian Liberation Organization (PLO) and the Southwest African Peoples Organization (SWAPO), took part, as observers, in the negotiations of the two Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions.Footnote 43 Furthermore, it is documented that some armed groups, such as guerrillas in Colombia, the Farabundo Martí para la Liberación Nacional (FMLN) in El Salvador, and the National Liberal Front in Vietnam, although they supported humanitarian standards in theory, did not accept international humanitarian treaty law applicable to the conflict they were waging since it was not negotiated directly with them.Footnote 44 Legally speaking, such an argument, which instrumentalizes the law, will never justify violations of humanitarian rules by armed groups since the rules bind all parties to the conflict, whether they agree or not. Nevertheless, the added value of gathering the input of all interested stakeholders, beyond just the states, in the creation of new rules of humanitarian law lies not only in making this body of law more realistic but also in adding a psychological incentive, and limiting the possibility for an armed group to justify violations by invoking their absence at the negotiation table.
For those reasons, I will briefly look into the hybrid treaties (‘hybrid’ meaning that non-states armed groups are involved) as a source suggested by Roberts and Sivakumaran to ‘allow for constructive engagement with armed groups in the creation of international humanitarian standards without treating them as akin to states or downgrading important legal standards’.Footnote 45
Armed groups playing an active role in the conclusion of hybrid treaties?
Roberts and Sivakumaran put forward two possibilities in regard to the role of armed groups in future treaty negotiation: a direct role or an indirect role. In my view, the indirect role intersects with the work of armed groups together with civil society and academia in order to interpret the existing norms, which will be discussed below. For that reason, I will focus on the formal direct role potentially given to armed groups. As proposed by the authors, this possibility leaves considerable room for armed groups to provide input, be active participants in the development and codification of IHL applicable in armed conflict, and interact with states and other armed groups present, but keeps the ultimate decision-making to the states. This mechanism seems to replicate the model of ‘observer status without voting rights’ adopted at the 1974–1977 Diplomatic Conference to which reference was made above. Apart from the fact that not all entities present are treated equally, one very interesting element here is that the format allows one common denominator to emerge: the conference itself. A diplomatic forum might just give the possibility to step back, re-focus on the humanitarian imperatives, and find common ground. Nevertheless, the ghost of over-politicization is still present, making this option controversial. Keeping in mind that a variety of approaches is needed to address a variety of situations, this approach might still work for some armed groups, although not all. Indeed, one might say that different roles and approaches are possible, even necessary.
Addressing the realities of armed groups: interpretation and contextualization of existing norms
Although is it challenging to find a common denominator between the different armed groups active in non-international conflicts, when it comes to improving the condition and treatment of people affected by armed conflict, one main element is vital in all situations: compliance with the existing legal framework. If new rules applicable to armed conflicts are to be negotiated and adopted, then the propositions presented above should be considered, to make sure that all the actors, including non-state armed groups, are represented. Strengthening IHL should nevertheless be the main concern.
As Dr. Jakob Kellenberger, President of the ICRC, recently said: ‘[o]ne can say with some certainty that if all the parties concerned showed perfect regard for humanitarian law, most of the humanitarian issues before us would not exist’.Footnote 46 With this approach in mind, I will now look at the best ways to address the realities of armed groups through the interpretation and contextualization of existing norms.
Feeding into the interpretation of existing norms: working together with civil society and academia
Interpretation and contextualization of existing norms is not the exclusive preserve of states; it could even be argued that it is the bread and butter of academia, which is even less a subject of international law than are armed groups, at least as far as enforcement is concerned. Indeed, engaging armed groups at that level would potentially enhance their compliance with the norms applicable to conflicts without any infringement upon the sovereign rights of states.
Initiatives where factual research is taking place, and where ‘emerging issues’ and ‘contemporary challenges’ to IHL are identified, are often led by independent organizations and civil society, providing a favourable opportunity to collect the views of armed groups. It is therefore surprising that they are so seldom invited to participate in such projects.Footnote 47
Of course, academia and armed groups have different motivations and intended outcomes for participating in discussions around the interpretation and contextualization of existing norms: professors and researchers have academic freedom and scientific objectivity to forewarn themselves against biases of political agendas and potential corruption,Footnote 48 which is not the case for armed groups. Nevertheless, that should not altogether discredit armed groups’ potential contribution to the discussions and, further down the line, to the evolution of the law applicable to armed conflicts towards a more realistic legal framework. What armed groups bring to the table is a necessary complement to the academic, humanitarian, civil society, and international community contributions. Their views and perspectives are based on their experiences, as parties to armed conflict, and they should be collected and documented as such.
It is of utmost importance to keep a record of the experience of engaging the armed groups and disseminate the non-sensitive information, wherever possible. New technologies now allow wide broadcasting, which could be both a blessing and a curse. To ensure that armed groups do not over-exploit these opportunities, organizations setting up such research initiatives need to make sure that their version of the story is also in the public domain: drafting a public report is a simple yet elegant solution. Even an organization such as the ICRC, which is universally known for relying on confidentiality as an essential operational tool, is very active in its contribution to the development of IHL. It can indeed issue general reports or documents on its interaction with armed groups, which would not constitute a breach of its confidentiality as long as it refrains from attributing instances of practice.
As a matter of fact, the ongoing ‘Strengthening Legal Protection for Victims of Armed Conflicts’ project, led by the ICRC, has great potential for initiating parallel dialogues with non-state actors in addition to the main bilateral discussions between the ICRC and states. This project initially produced an internal research study (not made public) and led, at the end of 2011, to the adoption by states and National Societies of a resolution bearing the same name at the 31st International Conference of the Red Cross and Red Crescent. This resolution provides a basis for strengthening IHL in two areas where gaps have been identified: the protection of people deprived of their freedom, and mechanisms to ensure compliance with IHL.Footnote 49 Although the project relies mostly on the co-operation and support of states, who are, according to the ICRC, the only ones that ‘can influence the evolution of international law’,Footnote 50 it provides an important chance to gather the views of armed groups on, for example, opportunities to conclude specific tailored-made agreements or declarations that expressly bind them to IHL, which could then potentially be reflected at future law-making negotiations.
A second example is the initiative ‘Towards a Better Protection of Civilians in Armed Conflicts’, led by the Geneva Academy of International Humanitarian Law and Human Rights. It provides another very interesting outlook on the capacity and willingness of armed groups to accept and take responsibility for the respect of norms intended to protect civilians. To make a link with the notion of indirect participation of armed groups in the negotiation of hybrid treaties, it is interesting to look at the seventh proposed good practice, addressing the engagement with armed non-state actors:
It is not realistic for armed non-state actors to participate formally in the drafting of multilateral treaties nor that such actors formally adhere to those treaties, but it is possible for their views to be reflected at future law-making negotiations. Armed non-state actors may sometimes argue that they are not bound by international norms as they had no role in their negotiation and adoption. Although this argument should be opposed, it is worth seeking to involve armed non-state actors in international discussions on new norms. Their views could, for example, be discerned by analysing relevant agreements or unilateral declarations. It may be easier to associate former members of armed non-state actors in such processes. In addition, greater efforts can be made to ensure that relevant international treaties address directly the behaviour of armed non-state actors.Footnote 51
The outcome of this project was to create tools respectively for armed non-state actors and the international community,Footnote 52 and for humanitarian actors and mediators who work towards strengthening compliance with norms by armed non-state actors.Footnote 53 Armed groups from different regions attended the meetings leading up to those reports; the areas represented included Colombia, Congo, Darfur, Kosovo Kurdistan, Malaysia, Nepal, Nigeria, Northern Ireland, Palestine, Sierra Leone, and Sri Lanka. One of those participants, the Patani United Liberation Organization (PULO), party to an armed conflict against the Malaysian state, made a public statement about their presence at that ‘international forum’:
This honour has put PULO in line with the liberation movements, recognised its existence among International Organisations, at the same time it has raised Patani liberation struggle to a level that is quite remarkable that has never happened before in the history of the Patani struggle. This shows that the international society has paid serious attention to the Patani liberation struggle and it be listed as one of areas that should be given particular attention and more serious international observation.Footnote 54
This example of an armed group's publicized participation in an international forum on respect for humanitarian law illustrates well the intricate operation of entering into dialogue with armed groups that aim to find a legitimate place in the ‘first layer’ of public international law: the content of the declaration made by the PULO may or may not be accurate; whether it creates political precedents on the international scene will be up to states members of the international community to decide. However, beyond that, it shows that this particular armed group publicly recognized its participation in the conference and, to some degree, the value, seriousness, and validity of such an initiative. From a humanitarian perspective, this in itself is a net gain.
One last successful example of engaging with a wide range of interlocutors including armed groups, documenting their views, and reporting on what is viable and feasible in engaging with armed groups is the ‘Viewpoints’ project of the Centre for Humanitarian Dialogue. This two-volume edited collection brings together first-hand accounts and observations from individuals with diverse connections and experiences, such as researchers, policy advisers, former members of armed groups, academics, NGO directors, mediators and consultants in peace processes, and former diplomats.Footnote 55 The reader will notice that the scope of this undertaking is above and beyond jus in bello: it addresses peace processes in a holistic way, by discussing weapons control, violence reduction, disarmament, demobilization, and reintegration. It does not specifically discuss IHL. When an armed conflict is raging, the distinction between jus ad bellum and jus in bello, and recognition of the autonomy of the two concepts, is fundamental in order to curb violence and better protect victims of non-international armed conflicts.Footnote 56 However, when engaging in an academic exercise aimed at information gathering beyond an operational framework, it might prove successful to address both bodies of law at the same time and allow the key actors to express their views without the legal restrictions necessary in an operational setting. We should not forget that, for some armed groups, the peace process is the end to which the respect or violations of rules of humanitarian law is the means.
Illustrations of formal undertakings of existing norms: special agreements, unilateral declarations, and parallel structures to the ‘treaty law’ mechanisms
Paragraph 3 of Common Article 3 urgesFootnote 57 parties to non-international armed conflict to declare their intention and mutual consent of applying all or part of the remaining provisions of the Geneva Conventions through the conclusion of special agreements. This mechanism promoted by the ICRC has been used on many occasions,Footnote 58 but it cannot be said to be a common tool. Although Common Article 3 makes it clear that concluding a special agreement in no way affects the legal status of the parties to the conflict, it is true that, politically, entering into a mutually agreed binding document without any legal necessity to do so might grant a certain level of legitimacy to the belligerent. Even the ICRC recognizes that:
in practice, special agreements could be more successfully attempted when a conflict is either seemingly intractable and/or taking place on more or less equal terms between the State and armed group(s), i.e. when an armed group exercises significant territorial control, has an effective chain of command, etc.Footnote 59
The second kind of formal undertaking that armed groups can make is a unilateral declaration (also referred to as a declaration of intention). These are a ‘second-best option’ for armed groups to ratifying or formally becoming party to IHL treaties. Nevertheless, unilateral declarations allow such groups to express their commitment to abide by the rules. Thus they are often used, and in different contexts: by the Front de Libération Nationale in Algeria (1956), by the Farabundo Martí para la Liberación Nacional (FMLN) in El Salvador (1988), by the National Democratic Front of the Philippines (1991), and by the Ejército de Liberación Nacional in Colombia (1995), to name just a few examples.Footnote 60 Politically, being able to show a declaration of intention to the population and to the international community is a viable procedure; however, they can hardly be enforced legally,Footnote 61 so there is a risk of instrumentalization.
A third undertaking, not to be confused with the unilateral declarations discussed above, is available only to national liberation movements. Indeed, a declaration made to the depositary pursuant to Article 96(3) of the First Additional ProtocolFootnote 62 by such a movement will create reciprocal rights and obligations between parties, which is not the case with declaration of intention.
Special agreements and unilateral declarations involving armed groups may have limited reach, but armed groups are not monoliths.Footnote 63 The interaction between the parties to the armed conflict and the ICRC that leads to the conclusion of such formal undertakings can nevertheless provide a basis for humanitarian action, access to victims, and opportunities to disseminate IHL to all actors waging war.
Moreover, the creation of parallel structures mirroring ‘treaty law’ mechanisms constitutes an interesting avenue for engaging armed groups in the development on humanitarian law by contributing to the existing norms. For instance, some armed groups will manifest their intention to adhere to international humanitarian treaty law directly to Switzerland, as the official depository of the instruments. One example (although not the best, since it considered itself a state at the time) is the Palestinian authorities that adhered to the four Geneva Conventions and the two Additional Protocols (although without a firm acceptance of such adherence by the Swiss Federal Council).Footnote 64 Another example is the Provisional Government of the Algerian Republic that acceded to the Geneva Conventions two years before Algeria gained independence as a state.Footnote 65 To my knowledge, the Swiss Federal Council does not make its correspondence public, so it is impossible to know who else submitted accession documents and, if so, what the content of the documents is. Yet this goes to show that some armed groups that are parties to a non-international conflict are proactively seeking to be engaged in the law applicable to armed conflicts. Of course, the armed groups will always have a political and strategic agenda: it is more often than not the main reason why they are waging war. However, deconstructing the negotiation of international instruments and the conclusion of legally binding documents through the study of egocentric and tactical considerations is not necessarily relevant, when the end result is positive in terms of commitment toward the spirit of IHL. What difference does it make to the civilian population crushed by armed conflict if, by fixing the technical limits for the use of certain projectiles in the St. Petersburg Declaration of 1868, Czar Alexander II may not really have wanted to ‘alleviat[e] as much as possible the calamities of war’Footnote 66 but, more probably, knew that he did not have sufficient funds to purchase the explosive projectiles that the Declaration banished? What negative impacts does it have on the civilian population that one of many armed groups who were all parties to a civil war signed the deed of commitment banning anti-personnel mines not just for humanitarian reasons but mostly because all of the other groups had joined before them?
Lastly, one other way of making the voices of armed groups heard on international humanitarian treaty law binding them is to set up an analogous mechanism to the reservation procedure accessible to states. As stated in the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, when a state ratifies (or signs, accepts, approves, or accedes to) an international instrument, it can formulate a reservation to some of the treaty's provisions in order to protect its sovereign will.Footnote 67 Such reservations modify the provisions in question to the same extent for other parties in relation to the reserving state. Hence, reservations are part of a fundamentally reciprocal mechanism and allow parties clearly to state their intention to apply and respect – or not – the provisions of a treaty. A reservation does not directly impact the treaty as an ‘institution’; rather it provides boundaries for the relationships that the parties build together around the treaty.Footnote 68
Under conventional IHL, reservations that are compatible with the object and purpose of the instruments are not prohibited per se by the Geneva Conventions and the Additional Protocols. In fact, twenty-two states parties to the Geneva ConventionsFootnote 69 and thirty-five states parties to the Additional ProtocolsFootnote 70 made reservations upon signature or ratification of those instruments. With that many reservations, relationships between states parties are bound to vary depending on the content of reservations made by each state.Footnote 71 Furthermore, it erodes the concept in non-international armed conflicts, since reservations are mechanisms accessible only to states. In fact, by not having the possibility of entering reservations, armed groups miss out on the possibility of influencing the application of the rules that they are otherwise requested to observe and respect. In this context, the less inclusive the process is, the less motivation there is to respect the emerging norms. Of course, as was said earlier in this article, legally speaking, lack of motivation will never justify violations of humanitarian rules by armed groups since the rules bind all parties to the conflict, whether they agree or not. Nevertheless, moral and psychological incentives might be lacking.
One would be right in arguing that the impact of the reservation mechanism in international humanitarian treaty law is considerably limited. The ICJ has taught us that a reservation has to be compatible with the object and purpose of the Convention; if not, it could be challenged by another party to the Convention, who will be in their own right to consider that the reserving state is not a party to the Convention.Footnote 72 This allows the ‘contesting’ state to free itself from the conventional bilateral obligations in its relation to the state formulating the reservation. In international humanitarian treaty law, several key sections qualify as erga omnes obligations.Footnote 73 Thus, even if a state party formulates reservations to those non-bilateralizable norms, these cannot be invoked by other state parties to modify their own obligations. Indeed, these obligations formulate basic norms that are owed to all states and to the international community as a whole. Even if a state party were to submit reservations to those key humanitarian obligations, it would have no significant impact. This levels the field between state and non-state armed groups, as neither can substantially modify the content of these humanitarian obligations.Footnote 74 Nevertheless, improved commitment to humanitarian standards could be achieved if a parallel mechanism mirroring the reservation process were available to armed groups.
Brief observations on the crystallization of customary norms
Once again, the application of the statist doctrine on customs as a source of international public law threatens the realistic application of humanitarian law to non-state armed groups. Under this traditional doctrine, customary IHL can be derived only from states’ practices and opinio juris. It is more or less along these lines that the ICRC customary law study has been edited, qualifying the legal significance of the practice of armed groups in the crystallization of customary norms as ‘unclear’.Footnote 75 As a minimum, it could be argued that the practice of armed groups is at least declaratory of existing customary rules.
Although I acknowledge the need for an expansion from the traditional approach to customary law to consider armed groups’ practices as a contribution to customary rules, the complexity of such an endeavour cannot be overlooked: the current intricate system supporting the creation and confirmation of customary norms in public international law is not necessarily designed to take into consideration views and practices of actors other than states. To open the door for input from other stakeholders would necessitate major adjustments in numerous areas. For instance, all the practices of ‘mutual interactions of a variety of international actors – states, substate actors, “people” and international organizations’Footnote 76 – might very well be needed in order to determine the existence of a customary rule, while keeping the coherence of the system. As mentioned by Arend, this would lead to the presence of multiple levels of customary norms in international law, as well as differently tailored boundaries of the rules, depending on who is involved.Footnote 77 For example, if an armed group's practice contributes to either the creation or the crystallization of a customary norm of humanitarian law, it could apply to relations between the armed group and any international organization.
However, what I perceive as the major impediment here is not necessarily linked to armed groups themselves or to difficulties of gathering their practices in a reliable and accurate fashion, although this is one of the problems that would need to be addressed; rather, it is related to the difficulty of gathering any kind of ‘real life’ practices, be it from state or non-state actors. Indeed, the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia stated in Tadić that:
When attempting to ascertain State practice with a view to establishing the existence of a customary rule or a general principle, it is difficult, if not impossible, to pinpoint the actual behaviour of the troops in the field for the purpose of establishing whether they in fact comply with, or disregard, certain standards of behaviour. This examination is rendered extremely difficult by the fact that not only is access to the theatre of military operations normally refused to independent observers (often even to the ICRC) but information on the actual conduct of hostilities is withheld by the parties to the conflict; what is worse, often recourse is had to misinformation with a view to misleading the enemy as well as public opinion and foreign Governments. In appraising the formation of customary rules or general principles one should therefore be aware that, on account of the inherent nature of this subject-matter, reliance must primarily be placed on such elements as official pronouncements of States, military manuals and judicial decisions.Footnote 78
This trend of avoiding the difficult question of practice by focusing more on opinio juris supports the proposition that the problem lies in the customary international legal system itself, not in the armed groups specifically. Indeed, in the Tadić decision quoted above, the Tribunal affirmed that the behaviour of insurgents among other actors, has been ‘instrumental in bringing about the formation of the customary rules’.Footnote 79
Without going further into an in-depth analysis of this specific issue, suffice to say that I follow in the steps of Arend,Footnote 80 Sassòli,Footnote 81 and McCorquodale,Footnote 82 and, to some extent, Roberts and Sivakumaran (with their concept of hybrid custom),Footnote 83 and agree that armed groups’ practice should contribute to new customary rules.Footnote 84
Opening the door to tailored and soft-law solutions
Before concluding this article, a few words are needed on the possibility to develop potential solutions to address the situation of armed groups. It should be noted that this is a field that in itself would necessitate a lengthier analysis than the one allowed here.
To build on ownership of already existing rules, one needs to rely on mechanisms that formalize the commitments of non-state armed groups, and also look for inspiration from analogous branches of international law where non-state actors are active: cyber-law, international sports law, are lex mercatoria are all bodies of law challenging the statist doctrine and created to address practical gaps that rendered existing law impractical and unrealistic for those key non-state actors.Footnote 85 The parallel with cyber-law, or lex electronica, is an interesting one. Cyberspace has its programming on one side and its interconnectivity on the other; war has its regulations on means and methods of warfare on one side and the protection of those who are not taking part in hostilities on the other, which makes them both a technical and a social construction where law almost comes as an afterthought. Technical imperatives and social norms have as much influence as, if not more than, legal obligations, for both the content creators in cyberspace and the parties in an armed conflict.Footnote 86 That being said, a major hurdle lies in the very nature of armed groups and the lack of a common vision for all. As Sassòli noted, ‘the greater difficulty is that armed groups … are not repeat players and are illegal under their domestic legislation … and do not fight worldwide against each other’.Footnote 87
Another example for potentially analogous applications is provided by soft-law solutions. Developing non-binding normative standards is, of course, a complementary solution to building ownership around the existing compulsory norms, but it does allow for the establishment of some sort of dialogue between the armed groups and the states, circumventing, to a certain extent, the concerns mentioned earlierFootnote 88 about involving armed groups in international law-making without challenging the current statist legal order. The Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights submitted by the Special Representative of the Secretary-General on the issue of human rights and transnational corporations and other business enterprisesFootnote 89 provide a good example of an analogous soft-law document. If would also be worth looking for inspiration in the Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development's Guidelines for Multinational Enterprises.Footnote 90 These Guidelines are ‘recommendations addressed by governments to multinational enterprises operating in or from adhering countries’.Footnote 91 The main difference – and it is a fundamental one – between multinational businesses and armed groups is that the latter are illegal under their domestic jurisdiction, so that the OECD model could not be replicated without major changes. It is not realistic to have states discuss the positive contribution of armed groups, but it could be feasible to have them reinforce the humanitarian imperatives in an updated and more relevant language to the realities of today's armed conflicts, or to provide a blueprint for armed groups on how to know and show that they are respecting international humanitarian norms. In the end, if a number of non-binding statements, because of their strong persuasive character (and maybe perhaps because of their limited enforceability), influence the actions of states and non-state actors, it is a win-win situation, as long as it is in line with the spirit of humanitarian law.
Conclusion
Contemporary non-international armed conflicts are more often than not waged asymmetrically between two groups with significantly different capabilities. The asymmetries, whether in the form of military power or general resources, are almost always in favour of the state. Terrorist attacks, namely acts used to frighten the population and influence the behaviour of a government or organization, provide an example of how armed groups attempt to overcome this imbalance by using unconventional methods for maximum impact when faced with a significantly larger state arsenal. In this situation (which should not be perceived as a new phenomenon of the twenty-first centuryFootnote 92), there are examples where state military forces are reacting by stepping further away from the practices enforced in symmetrical warfare,Footnote 93 although it could be assertively argued that theories on counter-insurgency advocate ‘winning the hearts and minds’ and the need to respect the law. In this latter case, the end would justify the meanings, as all parties to an armed conflict, states included, need to ‘walk the talk’ of humanitarian norms. This is an important element in order for armed groups to line up with the advocates of humanitarian ideas, even beyond the realm of conventional legal norms and treaty law. In order to build a culture of compliance toward international humanitarian norms, all parties to a conflict need to hear the ‘imperative call of civilization’ and act upon it. State actors must also actively contribute to this culture, given their privileged position in the international legal order.
One of the main purposes of this article was to show that it was possible and opportune to move away from the Westphalian model to include armed groups in the development of the law governing armed conflicts, without going as far as to give them state-like law-making prerogatives. Even today, states are the main actors in, subject of, and at the origins of the sources of public international law. However, with those prerogatives come duties as well. In order to halt violence against victims of armed conflicts, states need to do what only they have the power to do: their policies and legislations should never result in harm to the civilian population even if measures of economic isolation of certain armed groups are taken; they should adopt strategies for the protection of civilians in order to strengthen the normative framework, the operational response, and the national capacity; they should support more systematic data collection and analysis of the human costs of the use of explosive weapons; and finally, they should consider the potential humanitarian consequences of their legal and policy initiatives to avoid introducing measuresFootnote 94 that have the effect of inhibiting humanitarian actors in their efforts to engage armed groups for humanitarian purposes.Footnote 95 If they do all of that, then perhaps the urgency of engaging armed groups in the development of the law applicable to armed conflicts will be a little bit less pressing.
