Introduction
In the autumn of 1969, the British Broadcasting Corporation's School Broadcasting Council announced its intention to air sex education programmes for primary school audiences.Footnote 1 Controversy immediately ensued, with a storm of emphatic press headlines proclaiming, ‘Sex Education on Television at Last’ or, ‘Sex Lessons from Auntie BBC? – Oh Please, NO’.Footnote 2 While proponents praised the broadcasts for providing candid answers to children's questions, many opponents felt that televised sex education threatened to usurp the rights of parents or other responsible adults to control the sexual knowledge of children. The significance of television as a medium was highlighted by many observers; as the archbishop of Cardiff argued in a letter to The Times, these programmes were dangerous because they were ‘beamed directly to the children’.Footnote 3 The controversy surrounding the primary school programmes thus drew together significant contemporary debates regarding sexual morality and the media, the nature of childhood and the roles and responsibilities of adults in providing sex education to children.
This paper presents findings from a larger research project that addresses the production, content and reception of the primary school programmes and other sex education school broadcasts by the British Broadcasting Corporation (BBC) and Independent Television (ITV) in the 1960s and 1970s.Footnote 4 Throughout this project, I contend that broadcasts functioned as more than educational aids; they were vehicles of communication with explicit and implicit messages regarding sexual morality, gender, the nature of childhood and the practice of education. Correspondingly, educators and public commentators supported or contested these understandings. By focusing on the communicative elements of these programmes – the broadcast media and their modes of address to children – I question not only what messages were conveyed, but also how they were transmitted and why they became controversial. As Alison Bashford and Carolyn Strange argue in a study of mid-twentieth-century Australian radio, there is a significant historiographical gap regarding the media of sex education.Footnote 5 By examining how the visual and broadcast nature of programming shaped the tone, extent and practice of sex education, this paper employs a methodology that can address this gap.
After an overview of the historiography, this paper provides a detailed examination of the media and content of key sex education broadcasts from the 1960s and 1970s. First, I discuss how supporters and opponents of the programmes drew attention to broadcasting as a welcome solution or dangerous contribution, respectively, to the problem of sex education in the 1960s and 1970s. I then examine the form and content of the programmes, noting ways in which they emulated older conventions in audio-visual sex education while also incorporating modes of address specific to school broadcasting. Throughout this analysis, I pay specific attention to the visualities and vocabularies used to teach children of different ages about sex. Following Robert Eberwein's assertion that sex education films often ‘narrativi[se] the educational process’,Footnote 6 I also describe ways in which the broadcasts modelled teaching methods, thereby promoting particular educational theories and classroom practices.
As David Buckingham and Sara Bragg argue in a recent study of sex in the media, both sides in adult debates ‘invoke ideas about the “natural” form of sexuality, and about children's inherent needs or interests. . .While they may purport to speak on behalf of children, they also construct “the child” in ways that can be seen to reflect broader social and political considerations.’Footnote 7 This paper thus focuses primarily on adult understandings of childhood as revealed through the media of sex education broadcasts. At the same time, however, I acknowledge that the programmes had an uneven impact on the practice of sex education and the responses of individual children. Accordingly, following Harry Hendrick's contention that historians must distinguish between childhood (a concept) and children (historical people),Footnote 8 I also examine the sources for glimpses of children's experiences as audience members. Through the lens of the media, therefore, this paper connects sex education content with classroom practice and broadly questions how broadcasts portrayed and authorised certain images, types of knowledge and methods for teaching children about sex.
Historiography
The history of sex education is a quickly growing field within the broader historiography of sex and sexuality.Footnote 9 Until recently, much of the scholarly work on sex education and its history came from the disciplines of sociology, psychology and education.Footnote 10 However, Michel Foucault's theories on the discursive production of sexuality and feminist critiques of sex education as a form of social control have each contributed to growing historical interest in sex education.Footnote 11 As Lutz Sauerteig and Roger Davidson point out, much of this recent historiography focuses on official educational policies.Footnote 12 Similarly, many historians have examined the place of sex education within broader social climates and debates. Lesley Hall, for example, provides an overview of sex education in Britain from the nineteenth to the twenty-first centuries and argues that it has reflected changing social concerns regarding national health, morality, sexuality and childhood.Footnote 13 With regard to the period under question in this paper, James Hampshire and Jane Lewis examine how sex education was drawn into debates about sexual mores and ‘permissiveness’.Footnote 14 While such works provide useful insight into the broad contours of public debates, they generally neglect specific concerns raised about different forms of sex education and their roles in the classroom.
Indeed, British sex education films and visual sources have received limited treatment, and broadcasts appear only in scattered references throughout the secondary literature.Footnote 15 A detailed content analysis of British sex education broadcasts has not previously been attempted.Footnote 16 However, this paper draws on a rich theoretical and historiographical corpus from the fields of visual culture and film studies. Gillian Rose contends that the visual is ‘bound into social power relations’ that produce certain types of images and ways of seeing.Footnote 17 Indeed, historians of science and medicine have increasingly employed visual sources to question how scientific and medical power, operating through visual media, has produced knowledge about life and bodies.Footnote 18 Timothy Boon, for example, examines the role of science films and television as ‘vehicles of scientific communication’ between scientists, filmmakers and the public.Footnote 19 These films employed certain genre conventions and ‘modes of address’ in order to construct ‘particular relationships. . .between the authority they represented and their audiences’.Footnote 20 Thus, the form and content of health education films could assert medical expertise in order to prompt certain responses and behaviours in the viewing public.
Historians of sex education have similarly used images and films to examine the operation of medical power through visual culture. In an analysis of twentieth-century German sex education literature, for example, Sauerteig considers how visual materials defined or attempted to naturalise heterosexual identities and activities.Footnote 21 In addition to medical expertise, however, sex education materials also drew on pedagogical authority. In his comprehensive analysis of American sex education films, Eberwein finds that films for schools presented ‘accurate but incomplete’ information, carefully legitimised for classroom viewings.Footnote 22 Significantly, these films often employed ‘mise-en-abyme’ depictions: a class might view a sex education film portraying yet another sex education class.Footnote 23 In addition to providing information about sex, then, films also promoted particular educational methods and defined appropriate roles for teachers and pupils in sex education.
Although visual and cinematographic sources can provide rich historical material, it is important to note the limitations of these sources. As Kelly Loughlin points out, strict access requirements and lack of preservation often restrict the sources available to historians.Footnote 24 In the content analysis below, I refer to broadcasts viewed at the British Film Institute National Archive and Library as well as written descriptions found in production files and reports by the BBC and ITV companies.Footnote 25 I have also utilised information contained in pupils’ pamphlets and teachers’ notes published by the BBC to accompany broadcasts. In addition to television broadcasts, this paper will refer frequently to radiovision, or radio broadcasts that schools could record and use with accompanying filmstrips. In selecting these programmes, I have attempted to represent a range of genres and intended audience ages, while also focusing on programmes for which the most comprehensive contextual and descriptive data are available.
The educational problem of sex
Martin Lawn and Ian Grosvenor argue that an educational technology, such as school broadcasting, is ‘sold as a solution to an educational problem’.Footnote 26 In the case of sex education, such ‘problems’ were manifold. In 1964, the British Medical Association's (BMA) report on Venereal Disease and Young People influentially concluded that sexually transmitted diseases had risen markedly among young people.Footnote 27 The BMA report argued that this trend, along with rising illegitimacy and teenage pregnancy rates, resulted from liberalised sexual mores and promiscuous behaviour.Footnote 28 Among its recommendations, the BMA suggested that better training and materials for sex education should be made available to teachers and parents. In another influential study of the ‘sexual attitudes and behaviour of young people’, Michael Schofield questioned the idea of youth permissiveness and concluded that promiscuity was ‘not a prominent feature of teenage sexual behaviour’.Footnote 29 Nevertheless, Schofield maintained that sexual activity occurred often enough among teenagers to warrant better sex education, especially with regard to contraception and sexually transmitted diseases.Footnote 30 The Department of Education and Science (DES), however, took what Hampshire calls a stance of ‘non-decision-making’ regarding sex education throughout the 1960s and 1970s.Footnote 31 Preferring to leave choices regarding this sensitive matter to the local level, the Department provided periodic guidelines that were suggestive rather than authoritative.Footnote 32 Teachers, moreover, often lacked resources or were simply too embarrassed to broach the subject of sex education.Footnote 33
To producers and supporters of school broadcasting, the broadcast media held the potential to address this gap in education by reaching large numbers of pupils and providing professional, state-of-the-art aids to teachers. Following contemporary trends in education, broadcasters drew upon ‘child-centred’ theories to design programmes that could foster children's imaginations and curiosity.Footnote 34 Although child-centred approaches had been slowly gaining credence throughout the early twentieth century, they achieved particular prominence with the 1967 Plowden Report on primary schools. The report, prepared by the Central Advisory Council for Education, suggested that children's questions should be answered ‘plainly and truthfully’, but also with due regard to age appropriateness.Footnote 35 Child-centredness therefore promoted the expertise of certain adults (educationists or psychologists), who understood the stages of childhood development.
In line with such theories, broadcasters collaborated with experts in child development and education to produce programming for both BBC and ITV school broadcasts.Footnote 36 BBC school radio and television services were overseen by the School Broadcasting Council for the United Kingdom (SBC), an independent body representing education ministers, local education authorities and teachers.Footnote 37 Although ITV's entrance to the field of school television in 1957 prompted concerns from educationists and BBC officials alike about commercial motivations, ITV's companies also worked within a complex structure of liaison with the educational community.Footnote 38 By the mid-1970s, the efforts of broadcasters to collaborate with schools and teachers had indeed paid off; the 1977 Annan Report on the Future of Broadcasting estimated that 90 per cent of British schools used radio and 82 per cent used television.Footnote 39
Although the BBC had produced school radio programmes addressing aspects of human reproduction since the 1940s,Footnote 40 several changes in the provision of sex education broadcasting in the late 1960s and early 1970s brought increased public attention to these programmes. The first school television series on sex education, Understanding, was broadcast by the ITV company Granada in 1966.Footnote 41 In 1970, the BBC broke new ground by creating television and radiovision sex education programmes for primary school audiences as young as eight or nine. In defending their decision to target this young age group, producers attested to exhaustive collaboration with experts. The medical consultant for the programmes, a Health Education Department employee at the DES, noted that the primary school broadcasts addressed children in the ‘latency period’, in which they were curious about sex but not yet ‘emotionally involved in their own sexuality’.Footnote 42 While the programmes encouraged responsible behaviour, they did not stress issues of morality, love or marriage. Producers felt these were topics better reserved for older pupils who, moving beyond the phase of detached curiosity, began to have emotional concerns about sexuality.Footnote 43 In this way, producers used medical expertise and a framework of normal sexual development to authorise their programmes for different target age groups.
Public commentators, in turn, often confirmed or contested the ways that broadcasters defined and reached their child audience.Footnote 44 Indeed, these pioneering broadcasts came at a time when sex education was already gaining publicity as a heated topic of debate. As Hampshire and Lewis argue, opponents of sex education during this period drew on broader concerns about the ‘permissive society’ and argued that sex education was dangerous to the young – promoting, rather than preventing, social problems.Footnote 45 Although some detractors questioned the suitability of any sex education, many commentators raised concerns about the media employed. Significantly, mass communications blurred the boundaries between public and private by presenting the intimate subject of sex through the forums of the mass media.Footnote 46
Broadcasting intended for schools transcended another boundary: that between the home and the classroom. As David Limond argues, ideas about what constituted ‘explicit’ material depended not only on content but also on the physical location and makeup of the audience.Footnote 47 A 1972 report published by the Longford Committee Investigating Pornography, for example, cited concern regarding the viewership of the sex education broadcasts. Although careful to note that the BBC programmes should not be considered ‘pornographic’ as such, the report nevertheless maintained that sex education should be a ‘private affair’, tailored to individual children's needs.Footnote 48 Broadcast sex education, troublingly, transmitted the same message to all children who viewed it. Thus, in order to understand the contested nature of sex education broadcasts in the 1960s and 1970s, it is important to acknowledge the ways in which these programmes challenged moral boundaries in terms of medium and mode of address. The content analysis below, therefore, highlights the visual and broadcast nature of the programmes and the communicative methods they used to speak to children in schools.
Audio-visual genres in sex education
Although the sex education television broadcasts of the 1960s and 1970s were the first of their kind, they existed within a broader context and longer history of sex education films. Loughlin argues that content analyses of audio-visual sources should maintain ‘an awareness of particular forms or formats – the way they develop over time, [and] their association with and/or distinction from other modes of representation’.Footnote 49 However, the task of comparing broadcasts with other forms of sex education used throughout the 1960s and 1970s is complicated by the fact that classroom practices varied greatly. Hall notes that individual teachers, health education officers, visiting doctors, clergy and even hygiene product manufacturers often undertook sex education programmes with varying materials and methods.Footnote 50
Some insight into the use of sex education materials, however, can be gained from a 1967 Birmingham Education Committee report, which analysed sex education provision and included an extensive list of available textbooks, pamphlets, novels, visual aids and audio-visual resources.Footnote 51 Visual aids included graphs, diagrams and wall-charts covering topics such as reproductive anatomy, birth and human development. The report also listed eighteen filmstrips and thirty-one films, produced between the 1930s and the 1960s, that addressed topics ranging from animal and human reproduction, to growth and development, menstruation, venereal disease, dating and parenting. The Central Council for Health Education, British independent film companies and charities produced the majority of the films, although the list also included several American films.Footnote 52
Thus, by the late 1960s, broadcasters could emulate or modify conventions from a wide range of audio-visual sex education materials. Barbara Crowther points out that many of the earliest educational films displayed a notable absence of sexual information, thereby restricting sexual knowledge of the young in line with a ‘broader culture of opaqueness and evasion’.Footnote 53 Resources often literally took a ‘birds and bees’ approach by describing reproductive processes in plants or animals and referring euphemistically to human behaviour.Footnote 54 Filmmakers employed this ‘nature-analogy’ formula in The Mystery of Marriage (1932), in which images of animal ‘marriage’ rituals are intercut with scenes of human courtship.Footnote 55 Such films fall into a category that Eberwein calls ‘informational’ sex education, which makes use of documentary-style techniques such as voice-over narration and animated diagrams.Footnote 56 Notably, informational films could carry social as well as biological messages. In a later example of this genre, Learning to Live (1964), a male narrator's description of adolescent development is accompanied by anatomical diagrams and film sequences showing teenagers at home, in school and socialising at a dance hall.Footnote 57 Throughout this work, the importance of marriage and family is stressed; the narrator states that, with childbirth in wedlock, ‘the sex act has reached its intended end’.
While some films opted for politeness and metaphor, sex education resources could also challenge the cultural boundaries of appropriateness. Another informational film, Growing Up (1971), attracted considerable controversy for its explicit visual depictions, which include close-up shots of human genitals and film sequences of male and female masturbation and sexual intercourse.Footnote 58 Although a number of historians have focused on the radical nature of these portrayals,Footnote 59 this film also contains content that reflects more conventional aspects of the informational genre. The film's creator, Dr Martin Cole, states in his narration that women tend to be ‘maternal’ while men are more ‘inventive and creative’. Animated diagrams then portray hormonal pathways as Dr Cole explains that oestrogen is linked with ‘femaleness’ and testosterone with ‘maleness’. The film thus employs scientific terminology to depict the source of sex traits and, at the same time, naturalises gender distinctions and heterosexuality.
Ideological messages are often even more pronounced in another sex education genre: the narrative or ‘moral tale’.Footnote 60 Unlike films that focus on anatomical and mechanical aspects of reproduction, narratives use fictional formats to portray ‘the manifestations and effects of sexuality’.Footnote 61 A classic example of this genre is the venereal disease narrative, which gained prominence during the interwar period. As Boon notes, venereal disease films often carry heavy moralistic tones regarding sexual behaviour and stress ‘obedience to medical authority’ – typically in the from of a stern but knowledgeable doctor doling out advice to nervous patients.Footnote 62 Narrative films for young people likewise deal with issues such as teenage relationships, the pressures to have sex and the potential consequences of intercourse.Footnote 63 In a strikingly conservative example from 1973, Don't Be Like Brenda, seventeen-year-old Brenda falls in love with Gary, becomes pregnant and is forced to place her baby for adoption after Gary marries another woman.Footnote 64 The calm and uncompromising male narrator then admonishes Brenda for ‘spoil[ing] two lives – her own and her child’s’, and ruining her chances for marriage, ‘everyone's dream’.
Filmmakers employed informational and narrative formats in films for both school and general audiences; however, Eberwein also identifies a uniquely ‘schoolroom’ genre.Footnote 65 This style typically depicts classroom lessons, activities or lectures, thereby ‘narrativizing the educational process’.Footnote 66 Significantly, a number of these films portray groups of pupils discussing their concerns about adolescence and sexuality with an adult moderator. Such films thus evoke child-centred ideas of education based on participatory learning. However, it should be noted that the final film products were edited to reflect producers’ intentions rather than children's unmediated voices.
In addition to film genres, school radio and television producers could also draw upon the stylistic conventions of broadcasting. Boon notes that television science programmes often rely on ‘the personality factor’ of an engaging presenter, who communicates in a more conversational manner than traditional film narrators.Footnote 67 Indeed, school broadcasting producers alleged that children responded to the familiarity of well-known presenters and enjoyed the ‘intimate and personal’ character of television as opposed to film.Footnote 68 In practice, however, the media of broadcasts and films overlapped, as television programmes were made available on film or were recorded by schools.Footnote 69 Furthermore, as will be discussed below, many broadcasts emulated or reworked the informational, narrative or schoolroom film genres.
Primary school programmes
The BBC's Nature radiovision programmes and Merry-Go-Round television programmes represented the main contributions to sex education broadcasting for primary schools in the 1970s. A close reading of their dialogue, visuals and accompanying materials can provide insight into the formal means by which producers advanced child-centred objectives and attempted to address the gap in sex education for young children. As indicated by the title of the first radiovision programme, ‘Where Do Babies Come From?’, these programmes responded to children's common questions about babies and growing up. However, as Sauerteig points out, sex education materials that purported to answer children's questions also carried ideological underpinnings; they ‘directed children's attention to the relevance of a specific knowledge of reproduction’.Footnote 70 Accordingly, the BBC programmes portrayed particular answers and teaching methods as appropriate responses to primary school children's ‘natural’ curiosity.Footnote 71
The BBC radiovision programmes consist of two filmstrips and corresponding radio broadcasts.Footnote 72 Each of the filmstrips contains a series of colour illustrations, presented in a fanciful style reminiscent of children's picture books. Warm hues and a decorative background were intended to ‘soften the impact of reality’ for child viewers.Footnote 73 The radio portion provides narration by a calm female voice. Eberwein argues that sex education narrators typically represent male authority, and that female narration indicates a progressive agenda;Footnote 74 however, the use of a motherly female narrator in this case may reflect producers’ desire to foster a safe atmosphere for the young audience. This impression is further enhanced by gentle guitar and harp music following the narration for each slide. In practice, the music cued teachers to change the slides, but also allowed children a moment to look at the illustrations without narration. The format of the programmes thereby evokes the pedagogical idea that young children respond more to visual images than words.Footnote 75
The first programme, ‘Where Do Babies Come From?’, begins and ends with images of parents taking care of a young child. With the story thus framed in the context of family life, the programme addresses reproductive anatomy, conception, pregnancy and birth. The narrator's tone is direct and unemotional, and the vocabulary alternates between ‘homely’ and ‘scientific’.Footnote 76 In answer to the title question, for example, the narrator states, ‘from inside their mother's tummies, that's where babies come from’. The following slide, however, explains that the baby grows in the mother's ‘womb’, and emerges through the ‘vagina’. Male anatomy and conception are similarly treated with a mixture of familiar and anatomical language. The narrator describes an image of a nude man and woman embracing, depicted from the waist up, as: ‘the father lying very close to the mother, so that his penis can fit into her vagina’. Again, familial relationships (‘father’ and ‘mother’) are emphasised. Thus, explicitness is avoided in favour of simple language and stylised visuals that create a tone of domestic affection.
Despite this storybook quality, the programme also invokes medical authority through its reference to scientific ways of seeing and its depiction of birth. A slide that illustrates a foetus within the womb is accompanied by narration stating, ‘If you had X-ray eyes, this is what you could see.’ The programme thus provides a specific way for children to view a pregnant torso. In answer to the likely ensuing question, ‘how does the baby get out?’, the narrator explains, ‘Well, it comes out quite naturally, usually with a little help from a doctor or a nurse.’ The corresponding slide, from the viewpoint of someone standing at the mother's shoulder, depicts a women lying calmly in a hospital bed as a doctor assists with the birth.
Notably, the baby is the visual focal point of both the X-ray and birth slides. While emphasis on the family or medical expertise could serve to ‘authorise’ these images for use in schools,Footnote 77 the conceptual focus on babyhood also legitimises this programme for young audiences. Indeed, the SBC noted that children ‘identified mostly with the baby’.Footnote 78 Producers likewise used audience identification to justify the subject matter of the second Nature radiovision programme, ‘Growing Up’ (not to be confused with Dr Cole's controversial film, Growing Up), which was intended to address children's concerns about puberty.Footnote 79 The narration accompanying the first slide, depicting a newborn baby, associates the audience with the subject by means of a direct, second-person address: ‘You probably looked like this when you were born.’ The following slides illustrate male and female growth from childhood through puberty, and portray development as a natural but individually varied process: ‘All girls have periods like this from about 10 or 11, but like growing breasts, everyone is different.’ Intended for children of the age at which pubertal changes were just beginning, this programme thus legitimises its content by speaking to children's anxieties about their own bodies and growth.
Like the radiovision programmes, the BBC's Merry-Go-Round television series also presents content carefully tailored for a primary school audience. The sex education series consists of three broadcasts, ‘Beginning’, ‘Birth’ and ‘Full Circle’, initially transmitted in June 1970.Footnote 80 In a typical television format, animated diagrams and film footage are intercut with shots of a presenter in a studio. The male presenter was a ‘regular and popular’ persona from the Merry-Go-Round series and was chosen for his familiarity to children.Footnote 81 Following a ‘birds and bees’ sex education approach, each programme begins with images of animals and draws comparisons between humans and animals throughout. The accompanying teachers’ notes likewise suggest that teachers supplement the programmes with biology lessons and by keeping classroom pets.Footnote 82 The programmes also include footage from classrooms, in which children demonstrate these potential follow-up activities. Reflecting the ‘schoolroom’ film genre, the Merry-Go-Round programmes therefore establish a particular context for sexual information to be provided to schoolchildren.
The first programme in the series, ‘Beginning’, addresses foetal development and pregnancy. Like the Nature programmes, ‘Beginning’ provides children with specific ways of seeing life and development. Unlike the imaginative invocation of ‘X-ray eyes’; however, ‘Beginning’ notably focuses attention on scientific instruments themselves. In an introductory scene, the studio presenter sits next to a microscope and, as the camera zooms in to a close-up shot of the instrument, he explains that the audience will view a film depicting a rabbit egg through a microscope. The following footage uses microcinematography to display cells dividing, while a voice-over explains that ‘this egg has been filmed in a special speeded-up way’. Lisa Cartwright argues that microscopic films represent ‘a mechanism through which science reorganized its conception of the living body, ultimately rendering the physical body a more viewer-friendly site’.Footnote 83 In this case, the programme allows children a technical means of viewing embryonic growth while also describing it in a child-friendly manner.
A film sequence depicting pregnant women visiting their doctors further links foetal development with technology; one doctor uses a ‘ducktone’ to listen to the baby's heartbeat, and another helps a mother to listen with a stethoscope. While these scenes represent medical authority, they also serve a pedagogical purpose. In the following scene, children in a classroom are shown listening to their own heartbeats. Correspondingly, the teachers’ notes suggest that pupils should learn about their bodies in order to foster feelings of ‘kinship’ with the foetus.Footnote 84 The format and presentational style of the programme similarly direct children towards particular enquiries. Throughout, the presenter poses questions followed by brief pauses, presumably allowing children time to think about the answers. In the final scene, he holds a chick and gives his audience a precise task: ‘Where and how did he grow? You find out.’
Picking up where the first left off, the second television programme, ‘Birth’, begins with a chick emerging from an egg. The programme then addresses anatomical questions with a delicate ‘birds and bees’ approach. The presenter explains that other baby animals emerge from their mothers’ bodies through a ‘special opening’. A cat is shown giving birth, after which the presenter kneels next to a female dog in the studio and points out the dog's ‘special opening’. In a close-up shot, he distinguishes this opening from the anus, described tactfully as ‘where the dog goes to the lavatory’. This scene is necessary, according to the teachers’ notes, to dispel the common childhood belief that babies emerge from the anus.Footnote 85
Moving beyond animal birth, the programme utilises a series of increasingly explicit visual techniques to presage a film of a human birth. Following the ‘informational’ format, anatomical drawings and simple animation illustrate the birth process while the presenter provides narration. The programme next cuts to a pregnant woman in a hospital bed, and the voice-over explains that doctors and nurses are there to assist her. Then, from the viewpoint of the doctor, the film depicts the last moments of the delivery as the baby fully emerges. The mother appears happy, and the scene closes with the father holding the baby and talking affectionately with the mother. Looking back on the production of this scene, a BBC representative recalled producers’ struggles to depict human birth without frightening children or inciting public criticism.Footnote 86 This brief but visually explicit footage is thus framed with introductory depictions of animals and diagrams, and the actual birth takes place within an atmosphere of medical care and familial affection. The birth scene is further legitimised as a starting point for children's exploration of their own babyhood, as the following scene shows schoolchildren talking about their weights at birth and examining baby photographs.
The Merry-Go-Round series leaves the topic of conception – the ‘most difficult concept’ – until the last programme, ‘Full Circle’.Footnote 87 Like human birth, however, this potentially controversial subject is addressed following a meticulous progression of information that begins in the animal world. After a series of images of newborn animals, the presenter explains that babies inherit characteristics from both mother and father. In this way, a discussion of babies and families provides the background for a description of the roles of sperm and egg, which are illustrated with microscopic film.
As with the birth scene, producers of ‘Full Circle’ attempted to present information about sexual development and intercourse in an appropriate context. The programme addresses sex differences through a series of films showing nudity in ‘acceptable and natural’ environments: babies in a bath, nine-year-old children in a pool and nude male and female models in a life-drawing class.Footnote 88 Sexual intercourse, on the other hand, is not depicted visually. Instead, the studio presenter explains, ‘So the man lies close to the woman, and puts his penis into her vagina. This can give the man and the woman great pleasure, and is one of the ways in which they can show how much they love each other.’ The programme concludes with films of young animals and a family on the beach. Thus, while the programme provides information about intercourse (and, interestingly, acknowledges pleasure), it does so in a carefully delineated manner. The programme describes but does not illustrate coitus and sets this subject within a framework of love, family and the natural world. The teachers’ notes further suggest that, in follow-up, ‘the ideal of the family must be stated’.Footnote 89
Although the primary school radiovision and television sex education programmes differed in style, they provided similarly circumscribed information to children. In each case, content was legitimised through references to medical and pedagogical authority and focus on babies, childhood and family life. By thus associating educative material with children's experiences of growing up, producers reflected and endorsed a child-centred focus on children's developmental needs.
Secondary school programmes
In secondary schools, where sex education was more likely to be an established and accepted aspect of the curriculum,Footnote 90 broadcasts were numerous and took highly varied approaches to the subject. Emulating the ‘informational’ film style, several programmes from the 1960s and 1970s situated sex education within the subject of biology. In line with a ‘teenage-centred’ approach, other programmes emphasised young people's feelings and the social aspects of sex. However, as will be discussed below, these two general approaches often overlapped, and both contributed to an expert-authorised pedagogy that defined appropriate topics and teaching methods for adolescent sex education.
One of the earliest examples of televised sex education, Grampian Television's Living and Growing series (1968), serves as an example of the biological approach.Footnote 91 The series was intended for the early secondary school years and therefore is similar in content to the primary school programmes discussed above. Producers designed the series, consisting of eight programmes, to ‘give the facts of human reproduction’.Footnote 92 Its creators avoided addressing moral or social issues because these were considered ‘inappropriate in a television series for this age’.Footnote 93 Like the primary school programmes, then, Living and Growing provides information tailored to a specific age group and stage of development. The programmes describe animal and human life cycles, provide a ‘basic vocabulary of the sex organs’ and present diagrams of human pubertal development, fertilisation, foetal growth and birth.Footnote 94 Despite producers’ claims that social issues would be avoided, the programmes emphasise the importance of family throughout. Fertilisation, for example, is described as the result of ‘affection between parents’, and human birth is called ‘the culmination of the act of love 38 weeks earlier’.Footnote 95 The seventh programme of the series depicts a group of children asking questions about topics from the previous programmes; thus, Living and Growing models appropriate pupil responses to its own subject matter.
The BBC employed a similar biology-lesson approach in its programmes designed for young secondary school pupils. First broadcast in 1966, the BBC school radio programme, Reproduction and Growth (for ages eleven to thirteen), introduces human reproduction alongside information about cell division, fertilisation and growth in plants and animals.Footnote 96 Although the pupils’ pamphlet includes a diagram of human male and female reproductive organs, the text describes mammalian (rather than specifically human) reproduction. This programme's approach therefore corresponds with the idea, expounded by the Board of Education in 1943 and prominent throughout the 1950s and 1960s, that sex education should be incorporated into biology curricula so as to avoid ‘undue emphasis’ on the subject.Footnote 97
In 1972, the BBC replaced Reproduction and Growth with a new series, Life Cycle, which demonstrated a shift away from the strictly biological approach. According to a BBC press release, the series was intended to ‘put the Science of human physiology where it belongs, against the background of human experience’.Footnote 98 Its eight programmes employ an ‘imaginative and sometimes fantasy approach’, including a plot line in which the ‘Incredible Shrinking Man’ takes a cellular voyage into the human body.Footnote 99 The series also includes a radiovision programme, ‘Into the Wide World’, which specifically addresses sex education. This programme follows a typical informational format, with photographs and diagrams depicting development from conception through puberty.Footnote 100 In keeping with a teenage-centred approach, producers also attempted to ‘reassure all children about adolescence’.Footnote 101 Correspondingly, the pupils’ pamphlet mixes information about hormonal changes with discussion of dating and falling in love. Pupils are also directly identified with the subject matter; the pamphlet states, ‘You’re growing up now. You’re at the stage of your life called adolescence or puberty. And you can fall in love at any time after adolescence. So look out!’Footnote 102 Alongside its teenage-centred material, however, other elements of the programme maintained a more conservative emphasis on reproduction within the context of marriage. The pupils’ pamphlet, for instance, alleges that matrimony is the starting point for a couple to live ‘happily ever after’.Footnote 103
It is notable that all the programmes discussed thus far, for primary and early secondary school pupils, reassuringly depict human reproduction and growth in terms of normality. However, a number of programmes for older adolescents approach the potential negative consequences of sexual behaviour. Granada's 1973 ‘Love Now Pay Later’, part of The Facts Are These series for thirteen- to sixteen-year-old pupils, uses an informational format to address the topic of venereal disease (VD).Footnote 104 The programme begins with a physician sitting at his desk and discussing possible causes, symptoms and treatments for VD. Calmly and authoritatively, he explains that VD may be caused by ‘promiscuity’ or ‘ignorance’. A medical-scientific viewpoint is emphasised, as extreme close-up shots of gonorrhoea and syphilis symptoms accompany his descriptions. Afterwards, the programme shifts to a dramatised scene in which a man attends a VD clinic, learns that he has gonorrhoea and receives advice from a doctor about treatment and contact tracing.
Although this programme is expository, it employs many conventions from venereal disease narrative films, such as an authoritative doctor ‘breaking the bad news’.Footnote 105 Furthermore, in the final scenes, the doctor explains that ‘if people stick to one sexual partner, whether married or not, there is little or no risk’. While the programme thus avoids moralising about marriage, it nevertheless emphasises the dangers of promiscuity. By directly addressing the audience about the risks of sexual behaviour, the doctor also plays a pedagogical role. Essentially, he enacts a televised version of the lectures commonly provided to schools by visiting medical officers.Footnote 106
Other programmes for older secondary school pupils, such as the long-running BBC series, Scene, take less didactic approaches.Footnote 107 Most Scene programmes are dramatic plays, often written by prominent playwrights. The plays typically feature ‘ordinary young people’ facing difficult decisions, and were intended to promote classroom discussion.Footnote 108 Several of the plays address issues of adolescent relationships and sexuality, such as the aptly named ‘Consequences’ (1977).Footnote 109 The director envisioned this programme as ‘a realistic play about a real, believable love affair and what can happen to it’.Footnote 110 ‘Consequences’ thus explores common sex education topics, such as young love and the risks of sexual behaviour, through a wholly fictional and narrative format.
The protagonists of the play, Paul and Liza, are teenage school-goers who fall in love. Initially, sentimental montages portray their early courtship and a blissful camping trip. In an abrupt transition, however, the camping trip sequence is immediately followed by scenes in which Paul and Liza reveal to their parents that Liza is pregnant. Paul's father indignantly asks, in an interesting reference to the purpose of the play itself, ‘Don't they teach you sex education at your school?’Footnote 111 Both sets of parents contemplate the possibilities of adoption or abortion, but Paul and Liza insist on keeping the baby and planning a life together. Their initial optimism quickly fades, though, as they face difficulties finding employment and a flat that accepts children. Unable to cope with the situation, Paul eventually leaves to attend university and Liza raises the baby herself.
Unlike the expository sex education broadcasts discussed above, ‘Consequences’ does not provide any direct instruction. The camping trip is the only clue as to how Liza became pregnant and, in contrast to other programmes’ focus on children, Liza's baby appears only briefly in a montage. Instead, this programme concentrates on the impact of pregnancy on the young couple themselves. Although it does not fall into the category of ‘informational’ films, ‘Consequences’ nevertheless conveys a specific message: teenage pregnancy causes hardship and leads to difficult decisions for both parents. Significantly, by touching on issues such as sex education in schools, contraception and abortion, the programme also pinpoints topics for classroom discussion following the broadcast.
While Scene uses drama to foster dialogue, other programmes, reflecting the ‘schoolroom’ film genre, depict actual discussions among adolescents. Granada's Understanding, first broadcast in 1966, consists of a series of six programmes in which boys and girls between the ages of fifteen and sixteen discuss topics raised by their own questions.Footnote 112 Issues covered include puberty, childbirth, unmarried mothers, venereal disease, the sexual behaviour of young people and the family and marriage. Producers noted that neither abortion nor homosexuality was discussed because ‘the children themselves did not raise them’.Footnote 113 In this way, the programmes convey a teenage-centred focus on adolescents’ own interests and apprehensions about sex.
Although the discussions in Understanding are unscripted, a Granada interviewer and a doctor or specialist moderates each programme. In addition to spotlighting young people's concerns, therefore, the series also incorporates elements of a more traditional sex education approach in which teachers or medical authorities provide, moderate and authorise information. Furthermore, by depicting a select group of teenagers discussing a particular range of topics, the programmes exhibit appropriate content and methods of sex education. Indeed, producers hoped the programmes would provide a model for schools to emulate: ‘We felt that by. . .showing children talking freely and responsibly to adults, the same atmosphere might be carried into classroom discussions.’Footnote 114 Like other sex education broadcasts, then, teenage-centred discussion programmes invoked the authority of medical, educational and broadcasting expertise in order to promote certain sex education practices for the classroom.
Technology and practice
Despite many variations in approach, the sex education broadcasts examined in this paper all convey messages about how children should be taught about sex. As discussed above, these messages are inscribed in programme content through particular vocabularies, visual styles and depictions of educational processes. However, for the teachers who used the broadcasts, classroom practice was also affected by the material nature of the media. Lawn and Grosvenor observe that, as new classroom technologies were introduced, they ‘intervened in, complicated and yet became essential to the daily work of the teacher’.Footnote 115 Indeed, in the late 1960s and early 1970s, a number of technological developments changed the nature of broadcasts in schools. The introduction of radiovision, in 1964, required the use of audiotape recorders and filmstrip projectors. Furthermore, although school television was more than a decade old by 1970, a report the following year found that many schools had only recently procured equipment and still struggled to find suitable ways to use this technology.Footnote 116 In the early 1970s, video-recording equipment – which allowed teachers greater flexibility in using broadcasts – was also increasingly used in schools.Footnote 117
The introduction of such apparatus into the classroom materially altered the roles of teachers, who served as operators of these technologies. This was acknowledged in several publications that provided advice regarding the proper use of broadcasting equipment. A 1969 pamphlet distributed by the BBC acknowledged that teachers might be reluctant to use audiotape due to ‘fears of technical problems’.Footnote 118 According to the pamphlet, female teachers were especially nervous about this technology; although, the text states reassuringly, ‘the knowledge required is no more difficult than that required for using a kitchen food-mixer or a washing machine’.Footnote 119 Significantly, the use of broadcasts could also physically alter classroom layouts. For optimum viewing and listening conditions, teachers were advised to arrange desks at proper viewing angles, use curtains to avoid screen glare and ensure that sound was clear and audible.Footnote 120
In addition to providing technical guidance, broadcasters also produced literature that recommended methods for integrating broadcast media into the wider curricula. Teachers’ notes for the BBC primary school programmes, for example, contained numerous recommendations for creative and interactive projects following a child-centred model of education. As discussed above, the notes suggested that children could collect baby photographs, measure their own growth or raise animals. In its evaluation of the Nature and Merry-Go-Round programmes, the BBC indeed found that many teachers followed these suggestions and that collecting baby photographs was a particularly popular activity for engaging children with the subjects of birth and development.Footnote 121
It is important to note, however, that technical and educational advice from broadcasters did not seamlessly translate into classroom practices. As Lawn and Grosvenor point out, teachers often develop their own methods for incorporating technology into the classroom.Footnote 122 In fact, the SBC reported that some teachers provided their own commentary to accompany Nature radiovision filmstrips, rather than using the radio broadcasts.Footnote 123 Moreover, communication regarding the use of school broadcasts was collaborative, as producers actively encouraged teachers to provide feedback on their experiences. Compared with the moral panic in the media, the reactions of teachers were notably mild and, often, unreported.Footnote 124 Indeed, nine years following the initial broadcasts of the Merry-Go-Round sex education programmes, a producer observed that ‘in spite of the invitation in the teachers’ notes, there have not been a great many reactions from schools and teachers’.Footnote 125 However, among those teachers who did respond to the BBC programming, feedback was generally favourable throughout the 1970s.Footnote 126
Broadcasters were also concerned with reactions from pupils themselves. Children sometimes wrote to producers about their experiences with the programmes, and producers carried out detailed audience research.Footnote 127 It should be noted that, even where researchers quoted children's verbal or written reactions, these examples were selected and possibly edited by adults.Footnote 128 However, certain clues to how children felt as they watched these programmes can be glimpsed from the data. An unpublished report on the BBC's secondary school series, Life Cycle, for example, noted that audience attention tended to diminish throughout the programmes and that some children expressed unexpected questions and critiques.Footnote 129 Producers of the series had decided to stress the importance of marriage in response to complaints about sex education from the moral right; however, several students raised queries about birth control, and one girl complained: ‘You are always telling us how to get a baby, but what we want to know is how to stop one.’Footnote 130 As Hall notes, ‘adolescents themselves. . .seldom get a chance to have any input into [sex education] programmes deployed for their supposed benefit’.Footnote 131 Such reactions therefore represent discrepancies between adult conceptions of child- or teenage-centred sex education and children's own interests and ideas about sex.
The primary school broadcasts also elicited unanticipated reactions from children. In a survey of responses to the Merry-Go-Round programmes, psychologist Rex S. Rogers found that between 85 and 88 per cent of children reported favourable immediate reactions.Footnote 132 The ‘Birth’ programme drew the most unfavourable responses and, contrary to adult expectations, pupils tended to dislike the kitten birth more than the human birth.Footnote 133 The SBC's education officers likewise noted that some pupils, especially boys, appeared bored by the ‘Growing Up’ filmstrip on puberty, and other children expressed embarrassment or nervousness.Footnote 134 In the case of the Merry-Go-Round programmes, images of breast-feeding, male nudity, birth and the newborn baby – which some children disliked due to its ‘sliminess’ – were the most common sources of distress.Footnote 135 Some children also critiqued the visual style of the programmes. The ‘X-ray’ view of a pregnant woman was confusing to several children, and others felt the ‘imaginative’ background of the radiovision slides was too unrealistic.Footnote 136 Indeed, several children complained that flowers (shown in the background of multiple slides on pregnancy) improbably ‘stayed fresh for nine months!’.Footnote 137
Despite such critiques, reports by social scientists and education officers overall tended to corroborate producers’ understandings of their audience; children were frequently described as engaged and eager to discuss the information provided. However, it should be noted that the power relations of the classroom, in which pupil behaviour was highly regulated by adults, might have prevented children from acting out or voicing their full reactions. As a critic of the ITV series, The Facts Are These, argued, children viewed such programmes without choice and were prevented from criticising them due to ‘the formal group situation’ in which they watched.Footnote 138 Furthermore, instances where children sniggered, paid little attention or critiqued the broadcasts suggest that producers could never completely understand or anticipate the child audience. As Buckingham et al. explain, children ‘in different ways. . .are seen to resist and evade the definitions that are imposed upon them’ by the adults who attempted to construct their nature as an audience.Footnote 139
Conclusion
Through a close examination of the media and content of these programmes, I have taken the approach that sex education broadcasts must be understood as complex exchanges between educationists, producers, members of the public, teachers and pupils. Producers, educationists and public commentators attempted in different ways to define the needs of the child audience; at the same time, teachers and pupils responded to producers regarding their experiences. Thus, the communications involved in sex education were multi-directional, and reflected both support for and resistance to the aims of school broadcasting.
By focusing on the communicative elements of these programmes – the media and modes of address – I have attempted to move beyond an analysis that views programme content as either strictly traditionalist or progressive, permissive or anti-permissive. Rather, a close reading reveals that most broadcasts incorporated traditional content and styles (often borrowed from older sex education film genres), with more progressive, child-centred elements. It follows that these programmes communicated on more than one level; they carried ideological messages regarding sex and morality, certainly, but they also expressed ideas about the needs and nature of childhood and appropriate pedagogical methods. Asserting medical, technological and pedagogical expertise, these programmes thus delineated appropriate vocabularies, visualities and practices of sex education.
While this paper addresses a significant gap in the historiography regarding school broadcasting in Britain, the methods employed may be useful in studies on the impact of other emerging media in the history of sex education. Indeed, a focus on the media can raise significant questions about how sex education materials defined and addressed their audiences and how they affected educational settings and practices. Too often adult discussions of sex education – whether in academia or in public debates – take a generalised view that neglects the specific impact of different forms of sex education, actual classroom practices and real children's experiences.
