In the epilogue of this excellent text we learn that Albert Einstein's uncle Jakob was an electrical engineer and electric light and power entrepreneur. We are reminded that the great physicist's famous paper ‘On the electrodynamics of moving bodies’ begins with a simple example of electromagnetic induction, and that Einstein's early work was done whilst he worked at the Swiss patent office examining designs of electrical machinery. The message is that even the most abstruse scientific theory was connected in multiple ways with the technologies of the long nineteenth century.
Drawing out these multiple connections is the theme of Bruce Hunt's admirable, and appositely titled, text. Pursuing Power and Light explores the development of steam technology, thermodynamics and kinetic theory; of cable telegraphy and the physics of electricity; and of the electric light and power industry and electromagnetism. Concise, up-to-date accounts of all these developments are offered, written in an easy style and drawing on the latest scholarship in the field. The target audience – undergraduate students in the history of science and technology – are very well served, and each of these chapters could be used in a stand-alone way. But the most important message of the book is developed cumulatively and concerns the importance of technical stimuli to scientific endeavour and of scientific inputs to technological change.
The scientific emergence and commercial use of electromagnetic waves can easily look like a linear story of the technological application of pure science. But Hunt will have none of this. Both the development of Maxwellian theory and the discovery of electromagnetic waves resulted from complex interplays of science and technology, as Maxwell himself observed in his Treatise (1873). The growth of the cable industry exposed theorists to new phenomena such as the retardation of signals on long telegraph cables. This stimulated both new scientific inquiries and further technological improvements. The character of British electrical inquiry, with its predilection for precision measurement and its preferential use of field theory, had clear foundations in cable telegraphy. Some might be tempted to interpret developments of these sorts in terms of ‘technoscience’, as John Pickstone does, for example, in Ways of Knowing (2000). However, Hunt resists this kind of venture into the epistemological consequences of the relations of science and practice. His interpretation remains concerned with the interaction, rather than with the merging, of science and technology and is thus primarily a matter of understanding how the rate and direction of activity in both fields are shaped by context.
The story of steam technology and the science of heat and energy is perhaps the least-complex example of science–technology interaction as Hunt tells it. I have argued myself that this should not be seen (pace Marx and Engels) as a case of an atheoretical technology subsequently stimulating scientific theory. Rather some of its engineers, and certainly Watt, theorized steam all along. But this was done in a way foreign to the thermodynamic conceptions that were allowed in the nineteenth century to obliterate earlier theoretical accounts retrospectively. One theory–practice couple supplanted another. But this is a specialized consideration, which need not, perhaps best not, appear in a text such as this.
One small want I did feel, however. Professor Hunt deals with the science–technology relationship by way of aperçus scattered through the chapters on scientific and technological development. The import of these, and not least their subtleties, are not properly driven home. Symbolically powerful and pertinent as the epilogue on Einstein is, the undergraduate reader might have been better served by a more substantive conclusion recapitulating and consolidating the astute insights into the interplay between science and technology which the body of the book makes possible. This would also have been an opportunity to present some of the literature on the historiography of the science–technology relationship, little of which is given an airing here. This lacuna aside, Pursuing Power and Light is a bravura performance that should inform and inspire many an undergraduate and general reader.
