This book is a welcome addition to the textbook literature for introductory courses in music education. For readers unfamiliar with the course for which this text is designed, some context will be helpful. In many North American Schools of Music, students are admitted to a degree programme in music education as freshmen or sophomores. Chronologically and psychologically, these students are much closer to the high school music learners they were than to the professional teachers they will become. Some are uncertain about whether teaching is for them but are reluctant to commit to a career in music performance or studio teaching. Many have come from high-school programmes with excellent offerings in choir, band, orchestra and jazz ensembles and wish to replicate those programmes in their own careers. Others are acutely aware of deficiencies in their preparation as musicians, and express a strong desire to do much better for their future students. In either case, their frame of reference tends to be parochial, shaped by the 12 years of ‘early field experience’ they bring with them when they enter the university.
It is for this audience of learners that courses called ‘orientation’ or ‘introduction’ to music education are designed, and they are typically intended to serve multiple goals. First, such courses ask students to begin thinking and perceiving like teachers, rather than students. Classroom observations and interviews with working teachers are often included towards this end. Second, such courses require students to examine their assumptions about the purpose of school music, the nature of musical learning, the meaning of comprehensive musicianship and the various expectations made of music teachers from pre-kindergarten through secondary schools. The goal is to broaden their understanding beyond their personal experience of school music, and to widen their understanding of music education in general. Third, such courses often have the tacit goal of challenging the cultural reproduction model that many pre-service music students find most comfortable – i.e. becoming replacements for the teachers they had in schools like the ones they came from.
Musician and Teacher offers several unique strengths as an introductory text, both in content and design. First, music education itself is very broadly defined throughout the opening chapters, the section that author Patricia Shehan Campbell describes as the theoretical half of the book. Chapter 3 explicitly defines music learning as a continuum that includes formal, non-formal and enculturative styles. The chapter provides descriptions of six music learning traditions exemplifying parts of the continuum: the Schola Cantorum of Western chant, Japanese koto and shakuhachi, West African song, dance and drumming, Irish family centred music making, North American jazz, and First Nations’ view of music as indigenous knowledge. Students are invited to discuss examples from their own history as music learners to identify music they learned formally and informally. They are asked such questions as: Who were the teachers/transmitters of these styles? Did you learn or retain it well enough that you can still play it or sing it? What strategies did you use to learn this music? (p. 43). For students who have spent years acquiring the notation skills necessary to participate in large ensemble choirs and bands, the assertion that music acquired through other means is a legitimate form of musical learning is illuminating.
In my experience, undergraduate students initially see musical literacy as a hierarchy, with the ability to read notated music at the top and learning aurally as a lesser accomplishment; similarly notated repertoire is valued above aural traditions. They are often diffident about acknowledging or valuing their own participation in rock bands, guitar played ‘just by ear’ or their family and folk traditions. Expanding their view of what it means to be musical, and the many ways in which music may legitimately be taught is a valuable contribution of Musician and Teacher.
Inclusion of international and indigenous music traditions and repertoire throughout the discussion is another clear strength of this text. As one might expect from Patricia Shehan Campbell, world musics and their associated learning practices are embedded throughout the narrative, as an assumed part of a complete curriculum. Thus, there is no separate chapter on ‘multicultural’ or ‘folk’ music. Rather, references to a variety of musics and international teaching traditions are embedded throughout the first half of the text. The chapter on musical standards offers cross cultural examples from 11 different countries. The discussion of music learning includes a selection of cultural and historical contexts to illustrate the many ways that music may be transmitted and the teaching strategies associated with each one. In a description of a fictional ‘local’ middle school in Chapter 5, the choir is described as performing songs from Africa, arranged show tunes, works by Bach, Brahms, an African American spiritual and a Cameroon processional (p. 98).
Similarly, reference to jazz ensembles is evident throughout the text. The role of jazz in the education of preservice instrumental music education students varies across institutions, and jazz has sometimes been seen as the forgotten stepchild of an instrumentalist's training. As Stephen Morrison notes: ‘Formal educational institutions played little part in the development and transmission of the jazz style and actively excluded jazz from the acceptable musics of the academy’ (p. 175). Musician and Teacher through explicit inclusion of jazz when other topics are addressed helps establish jazz repertory and learning as a musical basic in contemporary North American school practice. Jazz is routinely mentioned when curriculum offerings are discussed, when repertoire and programmes are detailed, in references to local school cultures (Chapter 5), choral ensembles (Chapter 8) and instrumental ensembles (Chapter 9).
Another strength of this text is the chapter devoted to ‘All the Rest of the Music’. We know that in North American schools, about 10% of the student body in high school chooses to participate in what are considered standard offerings: choir, band, orchestra and jazz bands. While large ensemble performance has been a mainstay and source of excellence in school music programmes, the perception that music is just for the talented, or for those with a specific musical taste places music programmes at risk in an era of increasing financial and curricular pressures on school districts. Musician and Teacher offers many concrete suggestions for including a much wider body of repertoire, and kinds of performing and learning opportunities, such as mariachi groups, steel drums, African drum circles, vocal jazz and others. Attention to the other 90% of the student body is one way this text fulfils the stated intention to ‘balance the strong traditions of school music programmes with the programme transitions that are unfolding, just as society expands into technology and mediated popular culture’ (p. xiii).
No one textbook is perfect and users of this one will need to augment content in some areas that are not as well elaborated as others. Given the dramatic ways technology is changing the way musicians compose, perform and teach, the impact of technology deserves more space than it receives in one short chapter. A notable omission is mention of the ubiquitous Garageband for arranging, remixing and composing projects. Common practices such as musical sharing via posting on public websites and the attendant copyright issues are important matters not addressed here. The chapter includes reference to a few software packages but does not explore the many ways technology can extend learning into the social spaces students already inhabit. A computer with internal video camera is a quick way to record what students are doing in class, and to make it available immediately on a class website for parents and students to share. Social networking such as wikis and blogs can provide students with opportunities to extend their music learning outside of class time (see Ruthmann, Reference RUTHMANN2009).
In general there is relatively little reference to student composition and listening in the discussions of elementary, middle and high school curricula. Readers would need to consult additional sources such as the Vermont Midi project (2004), or Jackie Wiggins’ (Reference WIGGINS1990) Composition in the Classroom as basic resources for engaging young musicians in song writing and instrumental composition experiences. A curiosity in a 2008 publication is that there are very few website references included either within the narrative or in bibliographic lists. But taken as a whole, Musician and Teacher lives up to its title and offers a fresh, culturally inclusive perspective on the world of music education.
