There is much we might learn about the internal dynamics of nineteenth-century African societies during the so-called suppression era when Atlantic slaving was outlawed. The Political Economy of the Interior Gold Coast promises to offer a ‘reanalysis of the history of the Asante people and the Gold Coast … during the suppression era and how this group was involved in the closing of the slave trade and establishing what became known as legitimate commerce’ (xviii). We are also promised ‘new evidence’ to answer a set of ghost-like questions that hauntingly cast a shadow over the book, questions the author never really articulates (2–3). Through seven chapters, the closest we come to an argument lies in the conclusion: ‘This work has … proved that as demand for commodities changed, the region of Greater Asante and the Asante people met the external market demands … . Ultimately the Asante were able to impact trading both to its North and South in throughout the nineteenth century and along the way and dramatically alter the value of the illegal Trans-Atlantic Slave Trade from the Gold Coast during the era’ (187–8).
Judged against this stated destination, the journey along the way disappoints and ultimately the book reads as an insufficiently reworked dissertation. The first chapter provides a basic and unimaginative overview of the European presence on the coast between the late fifteenth and seventeenth centuries, while the second chapter on the formation of the Asante polity does much of the same with a litany of unsupported claims and spelling errors (for example, ‘Oseit Tutu’ [Osei Tutu]). Chapter Three argues for a correlation between Asante expansion and the export of Gold Coast captives, while Chapter Four focuses on British and American naval forces off the West African coast and the Kru of Liberia. The author argues, ‘the period between 1770 and 1820 … encompasses the initial spread of the Asante state … [when] there was a substantial increase in the numbers [of captives] taken from the Gold Coast’ (72–3). We are not shown how Asante was the largest Gold Coast supplier of captives for the transatlantic market, nor does the author cast a wider net inclusive of other Gold Coast actors who had a stake in the nefarious commerce. For instance, as the trade in gold and captives intensified, the central but contested Gã trade terminus of Accra was notionally ruled by Akwamu, Akyem, and Asante between 1681 and 1750. Asante was never an omnipresent force; it had to contend with other polities, resulting in a mixed policy of warfare, negotiation, and diplomacy. In Asante's engagement with external forces, the political and economic relationship between foreign naval squadrons, the role and presence of the Kru, and the Asante polity remains unfortunately unclear.
Chapter Five focuses on the transition to ‘legitimate trade’ (an idea never challenged), claiming, falsely, that the Gold Coast was uniformly ‘an area which depended solely on trading captives’ (122). The heart of Chapter Six is the treaties and subsequent conflicts between the Asante and British. In it, Asante's expansionism of the eighteenth century, its consolidation of subjugated territories and quelling rebellions in the nineteenth century, and its strident use of diplomacy in both periods are misunderstood. Though these features of the Asante state were crucial in the nineteenth-century treaties and conflicts with the British and their Gold Coast allies, they do not figure into the author's understanding of the 1817–74 period, nor is there any explanation for their absence. Finally, the conclusion summarizes what preceded it, with a tangential view toward the ‘Akan diaspora’ and memory of the ‘slave trade’ – neither of which are fleshed out.
By narrowing our gaze to focus exclusively on Asante, an opportunity is missed to explore the various Gold Coast polities and their shifting interactions over time. For instance, the coastal Fante secured firearms in pursuit of regional conquest and control of trade routes in the seventeenth century, whereas in the eighteenth century, they became brokers between the coast and Asante while transforming themselves into a centralized polity. The Fante also became important consumers of captives, gold, and European trade goods between Asante and European parties, while pursuing an internal policy of not enslaving their own ‘full citizens’ unless for crimes or debt. Even if we focus on Asante, we historians must engage the large body of published Dutch, British, and Danish sources for the period, as well as the corpus of Arabic sources, Asante stool histories, and other oral histories archived at the Institute of African Studies (Legon). Attention to these materials and to the kinds of nuanced analysis suggested here (and simply taking the time to develop and copyedit the text) could have indeed provided some new perspectives on this important period.
