Video games have become a familiar genre of entertainment, education, and community building since their very humble beginnings circa 1958. Sound and music have evolved alongside the technology as video games turned into a multi-billion-dollar industry. Despite the prevalence and excellence of video game music, public opinion remains undecided on the cultural value of video games and video game music's status as art. Academic literature on video game music—ludomusicology—only entered the fray at the turn of the millennium and gained traction in the past decade. Routledge published the first significant edited volume of video game music analysis in 2014, the same year Oxford University Press published William Cheng's monograph Sound Play.Footnote 1 Books on video games and performance, such as Music Video Games (2016), and the history and theory of game music like Game Sound (2008) and Playing with Sound (2013), respectively, fill fundamental niches.Footnote 2 Until William Gibbons's Unlimited Replays, though, ludomusicology lacked a definitive take on the relationship between classical music and video game music.
Unlimited Replays defines the many types of connections video games have with classical music, and how composers, game developers, concert programmers, and consumers interact and react. As Gibbons frames it, “What happens when the irresistible force of entertainment [video games] meets the immovable object of art [classical music]” (18)? To answer, Gibbons spotlights the numerous ways video game music and classical music are intertwined, and what that might mean for scholars, classical music buffs, and gamers. A book exploring this intersection has been a long time coming, and Gibbons has tackled the challenge with the thoroughness and eloquence of a scholar and the open-minded explorative attitude of a gamer. Gibbons has proven himself a formidable figure in both opera history and ludomusicology, and Unlimited Replays is the perfect marriage of his primary subjects.
Gibbons begins with how video games employ classical music to signify setting. Some game designers choose to appeal to what players think they know about music history. Infamously, Sid Meier's society-building Civilization series (MicroProse, Activision) uses classical music to set the wrong period; for example, Beethoven is played during the Renaissance era, and Palestrina is played during the medieval era, to name just two. Paradoxically, the “wrong” music is suitable to suggest the “right” setting in a video game, much to any musicologist's chagrin; it is effective for the player, but by all rights, it should not be. However, Gibbons finds many examples of games in which these effects are used to the game designers’ advantage. For instance, in Bioshock Infinite (Irrational Games, 2013), parallel universes in 1912 rub against one another with wild results. Music holds a key position; classical and pop song selections reflect the characters’ moods, but anachronism (such as Cyndi Lauper arranged for calliope) gives the scene an uncanny Twilight Zone sheen that is befitting of the narrative. Rather than failing to present historically accurate sounds, the player experiences the sonic disjunction as a key element to understanding and enjoying the game.
Gibbons also draws attention to the fraught relationship between video games and film as art. He challenges the traditional terms of film and cinema and the artistic metrics they establish. Gibbons notes that many games’ soundtracks rely on chains of thematic allusions to garner credibility as art in the same vein as film. For instance, Grieg's In the Hall of the Mountain King (1876) evokes an underground cavern in Manic Miner (Bug-Byte, 1983). Allusions and references can be secondary or tertiary, too. Elite (Acornsoft, 1985) quotes the Blue Danube Waltz (1866) not to evoke connotations of Strauss directly, but instead to reference 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968). Connecting to Gibbons's overarching question, I read this distancing from the source as a polite buffer between “high” classical music and “lowly” entertainment.
Taking this phenomenon to task, Gibbons dedicates the fourth chapter to Kubrick's A Clockwork Orange (1971) and its use in video games as ode or parody. According to Gibbons, when classical music appears in a film, it “loses its concert hall associations and transforms into film music—or perhaps it becomes a kind of hybrid, existing as both simultaneously” (74). Always keeping the debate of classical music versus video games as art, some game makers lean into the old prejudices, while others attempt to discourage it. In Kubrick's film, classical music symbolizes high culture. In the video games Gibbons introduces that reference Kubrick's use of classical music, the association is between the game and the filmic context, not the original classical piece and its context. Gibbons also asserts that even when a player misses a specific allusion, the games take a page from Kubrick to reassign or convolute the connection of culture and morality.
In the following chapter, Gibbons explores the opposite effect, that some games do make direct references albeit with substantial changes. In the early years, remixes were necessary due to technical limitations. Gibbons references Mark Katz on digital sampling and claims that “to become something new, it must first be recognizable as something old” (88).Footnote 3 Nowadays, remixes can harness the cultural value attached to the music while resituating it into the video game. For example, Gyruss (Konami, 1983) showcases the cutting-edge technology of 1983 with an 8-bit remix of Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D Minor, BWV 565. Richard Vreeland emphasizes a retro aesthetic with Chopin remixed to ’80s-style synths for FEZ (Trapdoor, 2012). Whether necessary or purely cosmetic, composers in these examples use remixes to connect games to classical music's accepted cultural value while simultaneously fronting their own artistic or entertainment value.
Following remixes, Gibbons leads us into an exploration of the carnivalesque, “the unresolved clash of incompatibles” (102), in remixed music in games. His case study, Catherine (Atlus, 2016), employs classical remixes during nightmarish battle scenes, and more palatable popular music during lucid, calm scenes. The game visually, narratively, and sonically presents throughout themes of parenthood, relationships, and the (grotesque) female. As of 2018, in all the games I have played, Catherine epitomizes juxtaposition between classical and popular styles and between art and social commentary with sensationalism.
Classical music juxtaposition may also be a diegetic and “live” element in a game. In Fallout 3 (Bethesda Softworks, 2008), classical music is added to the game only if the player undergoes a harrowing side quest to rescue a character's violin and sheet music. Gibbons notes how unlike other quests with monetary rewards, the only reward is “live” classical music (mostly Bach and Dvořák). The transaction set in a dystopian landscape is simultaneously culturally relevant and subversive.
In the same vein as “live” performers in video games, Gibbons turns to a curious subgenre of video games in which Chopin is the protagonist. At first blush, Chopin seems an unlikely hero; Gibbons points out that books and films present Chopin as a frail man. However, video games emphasize Chopin's incredible music as his identity, going so far as to dress him as a rock star. Each game Gibbons references ties back to previous chapters from the book. For example, in Eternal Sonata (Namco Bandai, 2007), diegetic Chopin pieces contrast Motoi Sakuraba's background music to distinguish reality and fiction, much like the musical delineation in Catherine. Other games like Frederic: Resurrection of Music (Forever Entertainment S. A., 2014) lean on incorrect historicism á la Civilization, or secondary connotations leaping from classical source to film.
In the penultimate chapter, Gibbons reveals how classical music educators are turning to video games to reach wider audiences. Music has entered the app store in the form of Benjamin Britten's Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (YPGO) and Steve Reich's Clapping Music, giving anyone with a smartphone a gamified space to engage with classical music. However, Gibbons notes that their impacts on their users are profoundly different and sometimes problematic. In particular, YPGO supports the long-standing and controversial assumption (which Gibbons continually broaches) that only classical music is high art. Modern composers and musicologists tend to reject this assumption—and it turns out, so do audiences.
Gibbons ends on the hot-button topic of canon. What if video game music is just as classical as Beethoven or Brahms? Gibbons does not give a definite answer (how could he?) but instead lays out many points of view and facts to consider. To me, one fact stands out: when given a chance to rewrite the canon through listener polls and concert feedback, listeners overwhelmingly include video game music composers. To the majority of classical music listeners, the scores of Final Fantasy by Nobuo Uematsu and Everybody's Gone to the Rapture by Jessica Curry are valid candidates for the classical canon.
In the burgeoning field of ludomusicology, this modestly sized volume is the perfect entry point for curious readers, and for scholars involved in ludomusicology an excellent stepping-off point to expand the fields of ludomusicology, music and narrative, and music reception. Gibbons asks many questions and provides few concrete answers. Like a good gamer, he is optimistic that his and his fellow ludomusicologists’ quest for answers and acceptance may be more important than its resolution.
