Given the plethora of books on the Anglo-American relationship, it is not unfair to ask whether there could possibly be anything new left to say. Kori Schake's Safe Passage: The Transition from British to American Hegemony convincingly answers Yes. Schake's central focus is why the transition from British to American hegemony—defined as “the ability to set the rules of international involvement, and to create order among states by enforcing those rules” (1)—was, unique among such transitions, a peaceful one. To accomplish that task, her tightly-packed narrative explores nine key Anglo-American “inflection points” (7): the Monroe Doctrine; the Oregon boundary dispute; recognition of the Confederacy; the process of late nineteenth-century national self-defining (what she calls “Manifesting Destiny”); the Venezuelan debt crises; the Spanish-American War; the First World War; the Washington Naval Conference; and the Second World War. The episodes Schake unpacks revolve primarily around political and military affairs (the 1901 political cartoon, Columbia's Easter Bonnet, which adorns the dust jacket is quite apropos of the overall thrust of the book), but her analysis also takes into account the much broader category of political culture, which she asserts is fundamental for understanding how and why transfers of hegemony occur.
Although Schake makes use of the central elements of the documentary record as well as contemporary periodical and newspaper sources, her narrative is not driven by those sources and instead relies heavily on a wide array of secondary sources, in the disciplines of both history and international relations, fairly equally divided between the British and American sides of the story. Her use of those sources is adroit, particularly when it comes to digging for meaning and nuance, and several interpretive or methodological aspects of the book are particularly noteworthy. One is Schake's ability to see patterns and trends in historical developments, particularly over the long sweep of time. Another is the book's implicit reminder of the importance of domestic imperatives in the making of foreign policy (a point first made on the U.S. side by the Wisconsin school but not one Schake directly addresses). Readers expecting a book steeped in deep archival research will be disappointed. But Safe Passage is nevertheless a worthwhile work, enjoyable, easy to read, and with much to offer readers with a wide variety of interests.
The details of most if not all of Schake's case studies will likely be familiar to this journal's readers. Safe Passage’s importance, however, comes not in the factual tidbits it reveals but in the way Schake combines them into a unique tale of Anglo-American hegemonic transfer. As she sees it, the transfer of hegemony occurred in three stages. The first developed over the first three of the book's case studies (the Monroe Doctrine, the Oregon boundary dispute, and the Civil War), when hegemonic Britain eschewed potentially deleterious confrontation with a weaker United States for more beneficial cooperation that suited its national interests. The 1870s, chronicled in the one chapter of the book that Schake explicitly admits “does not focus on a singular event or crisis between Great Britain and the United States but instead attempts to grasp the two societies’ sense of themselves as they underwent hugely disruptive political, social, and economic changes” (118), mark the period when the Anglo-American relationship began to shift. Expansions of the franchise drew British political culture more into line with prevailing American norms while the experience of consolidating a continental empire drew the United States closer to Britain's international outlook. The resulting “sameness” made it possible for Britain to contemplate the cession of world hegemony to the United States in confidence that little would change. The final four episodes of the book move through the hegemonic transfer process itself: Britain recognized American power during the Spanish-American War; it became reliant on that power during World War I; it was forced to accede to American military and political demands at the Washington Naval Conference (“the moment,” Schake asserts, “at which Britain ceded primacy to the United States” [236]); and it saw the wholesale application of the American rules of hegemony in the 1941 Atlantic Charter and subsequent application of them to the postwar world. Not only were British hopes that American hegemony would be little more than a continuation of their own dashed, but British officials found themselves increasingly shunted aside after World War II, desperately—but futilely—attempting to sell their vision of a transatlantic special relationship to American officials who favored a world “in which Britain was not uniquely advantaged” instead (283).
As befits her experience as a policy analyst—at the time of the book's publication, she was a research fellow at the Hoover Institution and in the fall of 2017 she assumed the deputy directorship of the International Institute for Strategic Studies in London—Schake sees utility in the study of history and uses the final pages of Safe Passage to ruminate on what a possible transfer of hegemony from the United States to China might look like. The prospects for a peaceful transition, she concludes, are not auspicious, given the political and economic gulfs that separate the two nations’ worldviews. “China lacks an ideology likely to appeal to America in the seductive way America's ideology appealed within Britain and beyond,” Schake asserts. “Without such an ideology, any hegemonic transition will require imposition by force” (292). In other words, the sameness that allowed for the safe passage from British to American hegemony is lacking from a potential transition from American to Chinese hegemony. Readers who might be tempted to question the efficacy of this sort of the discussion will be pleasantly surprised at Schake's skill in making the connections work. Safe Passage is thought-provoking history and historically informed policy analysis. It deserves a wide readership.
