The historiographical consensus on the evolution of the women's movement in the nineteenth century has positioned the creation of two separate, and competing, woman suffrage organizations in 1869 as a defining moment. There is much less consensus on the causes or the lasting effects of that divide. The passage of the Fifteenth Amendment is generally understood as central to the unraveling of the loosely knit woman's suffrage movement and its association with the better-organized antislavery groups. This dispute triggered open hostilities within the nascent American Equal Rights Association (AERA), ostensibly pitting Elizabeth Cady Stanton's apparent racism, abetted by her colleague Susan B. Anthony, against Lucy Stone's and Wendell Phillips's support for the “Negro's Hour.” Whatever the varying perspectives on the nature of this divide, racism has figured as the prism through which all events were viewed. Faye Dudden, professor of history at Colgate University, offers a different perspective in Fighting Chance, asserting that the race-gender split was not just the result of nineteenth-century racism. Dudden has crafted a different lens through which to examine the rift, weaving a panoply of political and monetary factors together to demonstrate that Stanton's and Anthony's belief in the prospects for success in the fight for suffrage coupled with a desperate lack of resources to achieve it, drove them to their expedient, if ill-fated, choices. Among these choices was tapping into the pervasive racism that marked the nineteenth century, even among slavery's opponents.
Dudden sets the stage for Stanton's and then Anthony's entrance into a complex political arena with a brief historical overview and stipulates that these women were the drivers and spokespersons of the movement. Minimally addressing women's experiential ladders in the antislavery and temperance movements, Dudden skillfully portrays the complexity of the numerous relationships of key reformers like Lucy Stone, Henry Blackwell, and Frederick Douglass with consummate politicians who had their own agendas. She argues that Stanton and Anthony were politically savvy and strove to move beyond disparate women's conventions to an organized campaign, hampered not only by public opinion, but also by the reality of women's lack of political ingress and minimal control over resources. The generosity of two benefactors whose trust funds were designated to be used in both the antislavery and women's rights movements promised to radically change this landscape. The continual scurrying for recognition and funding appeared to be over at last. By 1860 Stanton had devised a New York campaign for the vote. The prospect of managing statewide campaigns with paid lecturers and printed materials was exhilarating.
The outbreak of the Civil War interfered with the women's plans, but much worse was to come with the change of heart of their ally, Wendell Phillips, who headed the trustee groups that controlled the vital funds. His postbellum redirection of the funding to black suffrage causes, in direct contradiction to the terms of the bequests, left Stanton and Anthony with perceived opportunities, campaigns designs, and willing volunteers, but no financial resources.
By 1866, Phillips promoted a hierarchy of rights in which the black man's vote was positioned as the paramount goal, one that he supported so strongly that he used procedural technicalities to prevent the American Anti-Slavery Society (AASS) from even considering a proposal to support rights for black men and all women. Dudden demonstrates how the chicanery of New York politics, combined with Phillips's financial maneuvering, pushed Stanton to disparage the black vote in an effort to resurrect the inclusion of the woman's vote in the AASS's position. A brief reconciliation occurred during their shared opposition to the Fourteenth Amendment, but prospects for continued cooperation dimmed as the campaigns in New York and at the New York Constitutional Convention withered without funds, thanks to Phillips's allocation of the monies exclusively toward the fight for black male suffrage.
Stanton and Anthony redirected their energies to Kansas, where the legislature had voted to strike “white” and “male” from the definition of eligible voters and had scheduled referenda on the vote for each. While the women took up a crusade for both woman and black suffrage, Phillips increasingly opposed concurrent campaigning, believing that it doomed the chances of the black man to obtain the vote. Once again, his control over the trust funds starved the AERA's efforts. Both women demonstrated political savvy in dealing with the New York and Kansas politicians, but without resources they were doomed to failure. In response to these devastating disappointments, both women, but most especially Stanton, began to voice concerns over the black man's qualifications for and use of the suffrage. In a vicious cycle, the more Phillips abandoned woman's suffrage and the tighter he controlled the purse strings, the more racist Stanton's rhetoric became. Defeat in the Washington, D.C., campaign to secure woman suffrage and the bitter battle over the Fifteenth Amendment complete the picture.
Dudden's meticulous research is revealed in her endnotes, which comprise a comprehensive bibliography of the movement, including newly available sources. Moreover, she engagingly presents the frustration of missed opportunities and the despair of betrayal, exacerbated by ongoing privation. The Stanton and Anthony counterattack of racist slurs cannot be excused, but Dudden locates their racism in a visceral response to the ongoing sexism of Wendell Phillips. She may overestimate Stanton and Anthony's political acumen, given the limits of nineteenth-century political activity for all but white men. However, she powerfully demonstrates how the aggregation of capital into the hands of one man, and the political vagaries of a postwar party system still fundamentally rooted in the local but striving to become national, doomed a movement that affected half of the population.
