Combining an innovative mix of methods and sharp analysis, Paula M. Pickering has written a cogently argued study on the microfoundations of postconflict reconciliation in Bosnia and Herzegovina (hereafter BiH). Pickering's book is a fine example of how in-depth fieldwork and methodological pluralism in a political science study can produce important results for social scientists, area specialists, and practitioners engaged in postconflict reconstruction. The book is also a valuable contribution to contemporary Balkan studies, where the bulk of the literature has focused on the breakup of the former Yugoslavia and the resulting wars, rather than on in-depth studies of the postwar transitions of the individual Yugoslav successor states.
Pickering argues that in spite of years of involvement by an extensive international apparatus and despite the anti-state-building efforts of BiH's nationalist elites, ordinary citizens, “in the mere acts of living their daily lives and formulating opinions on the events affecting them” (p. 50), navigate their way through the postconflict environment, thereby influencing peacebuilding in unexpected ways. She roots her argument in identity-based theories of ethnicity, which focus on individuals' “self understandings” (p. 58) and acknowledge that people “attach variable meanings to social categories and incentives” (p. 87). She successfully demonstrates that in BiH, these self-understandings may have as much to do with class, regional identity, individual experiences during the war, and workplace relations as they do with ethnicity. Indeed, Pickering sees Bosnian identities as “fluid, capricious, complex constructions” (p. 64). Ordinary Bosnians “quietly contest the official categories and identities that are promoted by the nationalizing state and minority activists” (p. 70), which is why some people who fled ethnic cleansing choose to return to communities where they might face discrimination.
Central to Pickering's argument and choice of method is the idea that such self-understandings cannot be assumed or derived from some innate characteristic; rather, they have to be discovered through ethnographic field research. The author's own research entailed months of participant observation, living with families in two BiH cities (Bihać and Sarajevo) for extended periods of time over several years. Her ethnographic work yields keen insights into why, for example, some people decide to return to their prewar homes rather than stay in “putative homelands,” and how they deal with issues such as employment and relations with neighbors while navigating through a “multilevel network” (p. 16) of nationalizing state officials in Sarajevo, national and local minority activists, transnational actors, and elites in external homelands (Croatia and Serbia), each with its own, and often conflicting, designs on the postwar Bosnian state.
To support the findings of her ethnographic work, Pickering uses statistical regression to analyze individual-level data from a number of public opinion polls, showing that attitudes on issues like ethnic relations are influenced by very personal experiences, such as whether an ethnic Serb stayed in Sarajevo during the war. Those who experienced personal tragedy are more likely to be intolerant of other ethnic groups. Thus, “disparate wartime experiences trumped shared ethnicity” (p. 77) in terms of defining attitudes and shaping decisions about where to rebuild one's life. Pickering points to the rural–urban split as a key factor shaping identity, describing the contempt many city dwellers felt toward the influx of their rural co-ethnics during the war. If anything, it is the pressure exerted by putative homelands and ethnic entrepreneurs that caused people to “collapse their self understanding to ethnicity” (p. 83). She suggests that transnational actors should design their programs so that they take account of “the varied meanings that ordinary people give to ethnic labels, the social divisions that sometimes trump and always complicate ethnic ones, and the concrete needs that common people desperately require new institutions to address” (p. 166).
In the fourth chapter, Pickering argues that organizations promoting peace and reconciliation work best when they are responsive to local needs and “supportive of interests that are not ethnically defined” (p. 125). She also finds that the workplace is a key venue for helping to develop “cross-ethnic identifications and cooperative relationships” (p. 127), unlike the local community, where discrimination is prevalent against minorities. The implication for foreign donors is that “broad based civic associations,” as well as traditional networks, are most effective in bridging ethnic differences and building social capital (p. 138).
Pickering devotes the fifth chapter, which does not flow so well from the previous ones, to describing and documenting the aversion felt by ordinary Bosnians toward politics and their political institutions. Although people throughout the Balkans express low levels of trust toward their leaders and governments, nothing approaches the antipathy of Bosnians toward their political system. These attitudes go far in explaining the current crisis of the BiH state, and further push ordinary citizens to rely on the informal and traditional networks highlighted by Pickering. She finds that minorities with supraethnic, inclusive social identities are most likely to vote for moderate parties, whereas those living as majorities are likely to opt for nationalist parties. She argues that encouraging civic identities by making political institutions more accountable can help overcome interethnic mistrust (p. 164).
In a final chapter, the author extends her argument to the other Yugoslav successor states and a number of multiethnic states in Eurasia. This is a useful starting point for applying her framework beyond BiH, but the accounts are too brief to begin to do justice to complex postconflict settings such as Afghanistan.
The book has some other shortcomings, starting with the title, which is somewhat misleading. Pickering covers only BiH in depth, not the entire region as the title implies. Moreover, the title suggests that the book is a study of peacebuilding, when it is really more focused on the factors that shape identities and how those identities influence key decisions, such as where one should live in a postconflict setting. Peacebuilding in BiH consists of much more than ethnic reconciliation and refugee return, on which the author focuses: There are other important processes, such as transitional justice, and particularly the role of international and domestic war crimes prosecutions, which she does not mention. After reading the book, one walks away with a strong understanding of the nuances of identity in BiH and how these nuances influence daily life and individual choices, but one does not get a sense of how Pickering evaluates the chances for peace and stability in Bosnia today. In part, this is because the bulk of her research was carried out six years or more before the book was published: An epilogue bringing the story to the present (or at least to the publishing date of 2007) would have been helpful in this regard. Finally, Pickering could have provided more historical context on nationality policies in the former Yugoslavia, which would have been helpful for the non-Balkan specialist in understanding BiH's post-Yugoslav transition.
While this is a rigorous work of social science, Pickering's methodology and interests do not lend themselves to precisely defined dependent variables and singular causality. However, the benefits of her approach far outweigh the drawbacks. It is rare to find a work of comparative politics these days that provides this degree of fine-grained analysis and “thick description,” combining ethnographic work with large-n analysis, all while addressing an important question for political science and policy. This book will serve as a model of how to design innovative research employing multiple methods, and will inspire graduate students in political science who are motivated to undertake extensive dissertation fieldwork with an ethnographic component.
