This book attempts to provide a narrative history of the traditional Persian code of ethical behavior known as javānmardī (Ar. futuwwa, often translated into English as “chivalry”) over the past 1000 years. This code, which is prominently but not exclusively expressed within the context of Sufism, is based on such qualities as “generosity, compassion, humility, seriousness, patience, hospitality and courtesy” (in the words of the 11th-century scholar Abu Rayhan Biruni, quoted on p. 22). Ironically, from the early Islamic period futuwwa was associated by many writers with the banditry and licentiousness held to characterize the ayyār (lit. vagabonds), of which the 9th-century Persianizing rebel Yaqub ibn Layth al-Saffar was considered to be one. A similar prejudice has survived into modern times regarding the traditional athletic clubs known as zūrkhānehs.
The author rightly points out that it is somewhat natural for society's elites to look with suspicion upon any kind of popular movement having the potential to muster large numbers of disciplined followers. From pre-Islamic times up to even the present day, the kind of brotherly ethical system represented by javānmardī has been called upon to serve a wide range of expressions and contexts, some of them benevolent and others patently antisocial. Notwithstanding the hospitality, generosity, and other qualities often promoted by Sufi and non-Sufi javānmardī organizations over the centuries, the fraternal solidarity aspect (ʿasabiyya) of these social networks could have a down side, particularly when rivalries between various groups would lead to outbreaks of violence, as was the case between the Haydari and Niʿmati associations during the Safavid period.
Ridgeon seems to place himself among those historians who see precedents for the Islamic javānmardī tradition in pre-Islamic Iran. Indeed, it is not hard to see similarities in other cultural contexts as well, from the various types of brotherhoods found across the Roman Empire (notably Mithraistic ones in the Roman army), to the decidedly ambivalent phenomenon of college fraternities in the contemporary United States. If the impulse for young men to band together on the pretext of promoting a shared ethical system appears to be universal, Ridgeon's work narrows the context to that of the Iranian cultural environment over the past thousand years, focusing primarily on the world of the institutionalized Sufi orders and the texts on javānmardī composed by some of their more notable masters including the Malamati apologist Abu ʿAbd al-Rahman Sulami (d. 1021), the Sufi master Shihab al-Din Abu Hafs Suhravardi (d. 1234), and the late Timurid poet Husayn Vaʾiz Kashifi (d. 1505). Another stage of transformation occurred during the Safavid period, as the enforced Shiʿization of Iranian society made Sufi orders suspect and gave rise to sublimated forms of esoteric spirituality such as ʿerfan. Ridgeon opines that the popularity of ʿAli (seen as a prototypical exemplar of futuwwa) among many of the javānmardī organizations made them relatively acceptable to many of the Shiʿi clergy (p. 130), and in any case the fact that they were recognizable institutions made them taxable and easy to keep an eye on.
The author does not limit his scope to the Sufis, but also addresses to some extent specifically javānmardī-based fraternities that promoted a kind of “soft Sufism,” in the view of some (including Kashifi, for example, in his Futuwwat-nama-yi Sultani; p. 100). These fraternities were associated mainly with the working classes—perhaps less apt than those of elite background to follow the demanding spiritual disciplines and deep philosophical reflections required by the Sufi orders—and were usually tied to specific professions (butchers, bakers, tanners, etc.). The entire sixth (and final) chapter of the book is devoted to a discussion of the culture of modern Iran's zūrkhānehs (houses of strength), a kind of heavily ritualized gymnasia where (usually working-class) men combine body building and character building in an environment permeated with both Shiʿi and nationalistic Iranian symbols (such as references to the pre-Islamic heroes of the Shah-nameh).
Ridgeon's narrative flows nicely across more than a millennium of Iranian social history, stringing together in a coherent progression the development of the javānmardī tradition from its loose beginnings in pre-Islamic Iranian society through its institutionalization in the medieval period and up to the forms in which it can be observed today. His choice of key transformative figures and source texts is judicious and appropriate. The author's assessments regarding particular aspects in the development of javānmardī (which he usually places into the mouths of Classical Islamic scholars) are cautious, even-handed, and reasonable. One finds little to object to in this book, though perhaps little that is surprising either. The story, in any case, is well told, and it is a story worth hearing for anyone interested in the social history of Iran and the more worldly aspects of Sufi practice.
