The tradition of writing histories of dynasties goes back two millennia in China. The most elaborate example of this genre in the West is the Cambridge History of China series, which has both political narrative and topical volumes. That enterprise has depended on a host of scholars to each contribute a chapter, a sign of the expansion of the field that specialization has entailed. The History of Imperial China series, edited by Timothy Brook, challenges that trend. Dieter Kuhn has presented his view of the Song dynasty (960–1279) in the broader context of the decline of the Tang (618–907) and rise of the Khitan and Jurchen states north of the border. It is not an easy task, for the primary sources available for the Song are beyond the capability of most to command and at this point reading the secondary scholarship in Chinese and Japanese would take several lifetimes. Kuhn's solution is to offer four chapters of political narrative, from the Tang to the Mongol conquest, and eight topical chapters, on philosophy and religion, education and office holding, marriage and death, literature and art and some technology, the capital as urban environment, agricultural economy and mining, the fiscal system, and lifestyle. This well-written book is more informative than analytic, more a textbook than an argument.
The dynasty is one framework for the analysis of China's history. Dynastic governments institutionalized the extraction of resources from society, projected power, and distributed patronage far more effectively than any other group. Buddhist institutions taken as a whole came close, but they did not constitute a centralized system. However, many historical developments were neither coterminous with dynasties nor controlled by them. Kuhn's work shows that this was so in a number of ways: the two-tax system, which taxed household wealth rather than the person and recognized private landownership; the breakdown of restrictions on commerce; the ci lyric; ancient-style prose; and even the switch from sitting on mats to chairs all began in the Tang dynasty. His excellent chapter contrasting the capitals of Tang Chang'an, a planned and intensively regulated administrative city dependent on tax revenues, and Song Kaifeng, a commercial and transportation hub converted into a capital, gives us a sense of the difference between an aristocratic Tang and a more meritocratic Song, but it also shows that the Song government was riding larger economic trends that it could not fully control, even in its own capital, when it repeatedly failed to force the highly commercialized Kaifeng into what some at court considered the normative model for a capital. Here too the breakdown of top-down authority over urban life begins in Tang, as Kuhn points out.
The promise of the subtitle, “the Song transformation of China,” promises that the reader will learn about why Song was important in China's history. But what should importance mean? Kuhn does have an argument—that Song set the course for later periods and was in many ways the foundation for what we today see as “traditional” China. The use of examinations to select men for government service, Neo-Confucianism, a national elite of scholar-officials rather than an aristocratic oligarchy, the this-worldly nature of literature and art, and the importance of commerce are more characteristic of Song and later periods than Tang. One might also argue that the inability of Chinese dynasties to prevent the peoples to the north from forming states was a Song legacy as well, and it is much to Kuhn's credit that he gives sustained attention to the northern states of Liao and Jin in both the political and topical chapters. Notably, he does not argue that Song marks the point at which the political system becomes increasingly autocratic, but he does not challenge it either, although it is still a powerful trope in the historiography of later imperial China.
It seems to me that the author is too willing to assert that all these developments did transform China rather than arguing the case, perhaps because he is intent on giving a comprehensive picture of the Song as a world of its own, much in the manner of his earlier Die Song-Dynastie (960 bis 1279): eine neue Gesellschaft im Spiegel ihrer Kultur (Weinheim: Acta Humaniora, 1987). Here I will raise four issues that ought to enter into such an argument.
First, there needs to be a discussion of the reconstitution in the twelfth century of the national elite as an assemblage of local elites, not just office holders, who were tied to the state weakly through examination participation and to each other strongly through lateral connections of marriage, culture, patronage, and so on. This has been the exceptionally fruitful contribution of social historians to our understanding of Song history. Yet we should ask whether the behavior of this stratum in Song was in fact the same as what we see in the fifteenth century, for example. Although I am inclined to see continuity, a contrary argument can be imagined by considering the second issue. Second, the Song was one of the few periods in Chinese history before the twentieth century which saw per capita economic growth beyond inflation. Why did this not continue? If Song elites were so invested in the commercial economy and so concerned about maintaining the money supply necessary to commercial expansion that they came to accept paper currency, as Kuhn notes, then would this not make them rather different from the rural, agriculturally focused gentry of the fifteenth century? Third, those rural gentry lived in a world in which the state had failed to maintain Song's ability to effectively tax commerce at the same time it supported the infrastructure necessary to economic growth. Evidence for this view of Song abounds in Kuhn's book, but it makes Song quite different. Finally, we face the problem of which Song we are talking about. The Song was unique among China's dynasties in that it fell twice, first in 1126 when it lost the north China plain to the Jurchens' Jin dynasty and finally in 1279 when it lost the south to the Mongols' Yuan dynasty. A division between north and south was not new, but Song in the south was a very different place from Song when it held the north. It was in the south that local elites emerged as the national elite, that Neo-Confucianism took hold as an elite ideology over the opposition of the court, that the lineage based on an apical ancestor was on its way to becoming the dominant social formation, and that private commerce rather than a state-regulated economy gained sway. It may well be that the development of the south as a social, economic, and cultural system different from the north was in fact how China's history was transformed in the Song period, but if so our analysis perhaps should not treat Song spatially or temporally as a single entity.
