This book challenges the conventional perspectives of state formation and state–society relations in the Sudan. Abdullahi A. Gallab sets out to reinterpret the conventional analysis of the Sudanese encounters with Ottoman, Egyptian, and British rule, encounters that unleashed widespread religious and anticolonial uprisings between 1821 and 1956. He asserts that unremitting conflicts pitting the postcolonial “center” of power against rival contenders in the “margins” were shaped by earlier British policies seeking to counter the popularity of anticolonial Sufi leaders. The author argues that the Mahdiyya—the religious and nationalist revolt against Anglo–Egyptian domination of the Sudan—should be understood as an expression of civil society's defense of its religious grounding in the face of alien rulers. Gallab's approach to the subject matter is interdisciplinary, and he demonstrates a deep knowledge of the historical, economic, and theological elements that produced contemporary Sudan's state–society. Gallab also brings to the foreground long-neglected oral histories embedded in local folklore, which provide the reader unique insight into the sentiments of those who experienced the many wars that led to the emergence of modern Sudan.
Gallab's book offers a panoramic view, at times dizzying in its detail, of the various local traders known as jallaba as well as the regional and international middlemen and brokers known as Khartoumers, who are engaged in the devastating slave trade and in political and military alliances with rival Sudanese power brokers. The work's originality emerges in the three chapters centered on the role of three cities, Omdurman, Khartoum, and Cairo, in the formation of modern Sudanese identity. The author brings to life Khartoum as a symbol of colonial (British) prowess, Omdurman as a citadel of (Mahdist) resistance, and Cairo as the source of external threat and a unifying inspiration for the Arab revolt against alien rule (pp. 66–138).
In the first chapter, the author addresses the social construction of a Sudanese identity by outsiders, which has led to “denials of . . . complex and multilayered identities.” Ensuing chapters focus on the role of British policymakers, who bequeathed to this giant nation a legacy of “aberrant constitutions” (p. 41). In Chapters 4, 5, and 6, Gallab narrates the emergence of elites linked to slave-raiding “warrior-merchants” (Khartoumers), the Ansar, who are followers of the Mahdi, and Arab nationalists who sought to dislodge alien rule. In Chapters 7 and 8, the author relates how local, regional, and international actors involved in the slave trade sowed the seeds of future resource wars and identity conflicts that pit the elites of the riverine center against their opponents in the margins (p. 183). Gallab's focus remains on the policies of external actors, and thus he does not address the role of the Sudanese elites who benefited from the violence visited upon the disenfranchised communities subordinated to Khartoum's economic and political clout in the postindependence period. He also excludes the role of hierarchical social norms and institutional legacies in the production of societal violence.
Gallab has produced a fascinating book but one that leaves the question of the deferred role of Sudan's civil society unresolved. He concludes rather lackadaisically that despite the dynamism of civil society, the deployment of violence as a form of rule has continued to enable contemporary elites of both the Umma Party and the Unionist Party to retain their hegemonic grip inherited from the colonial period (p. 191). Nevertheless, Gallab at least raises the important question of why Sudanese civil society remains disempowered, the answer to which would unlock the Sudanese dilemma.
