Since its publication in 1961, Martin Esslin's The Theatre of the Absurd has dominated critical reception of those playwrights he designated “absurdist.” While many scholars have qualified, revised, and even completely repudiated Esslin's claims, The Theatre of the Absurd perseveres as a landmark text in dramatic scholarship. In Reassessing the Theatre of the Absurd: Camus, Beckett, Ionesco, Genet, and Pinter, Michael Bennett turns Esslin's text on its head to offer more nuanced, more hopeful analyses of these canonical playwrights. Ultimately, he suggests that instead of being labeled “Theatre of the Absurd,” the works of these artists should be classified as “parabolic drama” (3). This move, he argues, refreshes the discourse on these plays by approaching them with an eye toward the structure, metaphor, and paradox of parables.
In “Introduction: Reassessing the Theatre of the Absurd,” Bennett points out two critical flaws in Esslin's formulation. First, he argues that Esslin mistranslates and miscontextualizes a quote by Ionesco, resulting in the misstatement of one of Esslin's core “absurdist” criteria. Second, he argues that Esslin misreads Camus as an existentialist. In outlining this second point, Bennett turns to Camus's The Myth of Sisyphus, an essay foundational to Esslin's thinking. For Bennett, the purpose of the essay is the reminder that, “[i]f we accept our situation as absurd . . . then we can revolt against the absurd and create meaning and purpose for ourselves” (11). In offering this alternative reading of Camus, Bennett makes theoretical space for his construction of a parabolic drama of perseverance and meaning making.
Bennett breaks his study into four chapters that address each of the playwrights (with the exception of Arthur Adamov) given previous chapter-length treatment by Esslin; in order, these are “The Parable of Estragon's Struggle with the Boot in Samuel Beckett's Waiting for Godot”; “The Pinteresque Oedipal Household: The Interrogation Scene(s) in The Birthday Party”; “The Parable of the White Clown: The Use of Ritual in Jean Genet's The Blacks: A Clown Show”; and “Berenger, the Sisyphean Hero.” Each of these chapters begins with information about the given play's initial production and reception, as well as a discussion of Esslin's treatment of each in The Theatre of the Absurd. From there, Bennett moves into a thematic textual analysis focusing on parable.
Of the plays discussed by Esslin in The Theatre of the Absurd, Waiting for Godot is perhaps the most well known and oft analyzed. Indeed, the prominence given by Esslin to this play is reflected by its position in scholarly literature more generally. Because of this prominence, Bennett's first chapter offers, perhaps, the most significant example of his “parabolic” reworking of the canon. Furthermore, it serves to orient the reader to Bennett's implementation of parabolic analysis. Bennett opens the chapter with a brief look at the symbolism of the absent Godot. He points out that while there is no agreed-upon reading, the figuration of Godot as God is perhaps most prominent. Bennett argues that, “If God or a savior is not just hinted at and never comes, but is actually present in this play, . . . then life has not lost all meaning and the Theatre of the Absurd does not necessarily represent the absurdity of the human condition” (29). For Bennett, the idea of a god/savior is ultimately not found in the character of Godot, but rather in the companionship of the two tramps—each one acting as savior for the other. This mutual relationship, says Bennett, is represented by the two-part structure of the boot parable: the first part, the orientation, finds the audience sympathizing with Estragon's desire to remove the boot, to free himself from “that which ties him to the base earth” (37). The second part of the parable, the turn, is the lesson that the abstract concept of “hope” (represented by the desire to remove the boot) is a dead end; instead, the two tramps need to find in each other that which makes life meaningful.
In this chapter and those that follow, Bennett employs parabolic logic to offer a hopeful rereading of the canonical Theatre of the Absurd. His “Conclusion: Theorizing a ‘Female Absurd’ in Beth Henley's Crimes of the Heart as a Means of Reassessing the Theatre of the Absurd,” extends his parabolic framework to more contemporary dramatic literature. Furthermore, it demonstrates the effectiveness of his work in opening the Theatre of the Absurd to, among others, female playwrights. Following his conclusion, he also offers two addenda—“Defining the Parable” and “Parables in Drama”—designed, seemingly, to avoid weighing down the body of his text and his argument with supplemental information. In one sense, these addenda act as primers for those who have limited experience with parable: they track related changes in scholarship and point to how these changes have broadened the term's definition to such an extent that it has started to lose meaning. Additionally, the addenda serve to contextualize and define Bennett's use of parable as a concept throughout. Even without these additions, Reassessing the Theatre of the Absurd is an accessible study; their inclusion, however, expands its potential readership and allows for different levels of reader engagement with, and points of access to, the text.
Bennett's hopeful rereading of the Theatre of the Absurd is largely successful. Not only does he offer provocative, convincing readings of these plays, he also broadens his analysis to include works by contemporaries of the original “absurdists,” and by those of different historical moments and/or gender. This move not only extends his interpretive framework beyond the oft covered territory that is the focus of this book, it also extends the life of his analysis.
Bennett's work is strengthened by the fact that his writing style is approachable and his work well signposted. My one reservation about this study is that he focuses almost entirely on close readings of dramatic literature. Throughout, I wondered how his analysis would change with more consideration of theatre as a living art; the inclusion of such a perspective, however, might be well outside the scope of his stated project. Previously, when discussing this style of theatre, I was guilty myself of resorting to tired aphorisms about the absurdity of existence. Though I knew these to be troubling oversimplifications at best, I had no other vocabulary with which to discuss these works. Bennett's text offers this alternative vocabulary, along with a much richer, more hopeful perspective on the subject.
