The view of work in Western society has drastically changed in the last few decades. Work has a place in the life of a person that it has never had before. Therefore need has arisen for a theology that answers issues concerning work. A theology of work has undertaken this task, but it is still a new and undeveloped area. Darrell Cosden in A Theology of Work takes one step further in the development of a comprehensive theology of work.
Cosden's proposal is ‘to develop a more nuanced and insightful theological understanding of work's nature and ultimate meaning’ (p. 4). Although work has taken an enormous place in the lives of people and there is need for a new understanding for the meaning of work, there are just a few comprehensive theological researches on the theme. Cosden sees the need to change the understanding of work's meaning and he argues that resources for this change can be found in Christian theology. The author propounds a double hypothesis: to have normative theological understanding of work it needs to be viewed as threefold: as a dynamic inter-relationship of instrumental, relational and ontological aspects (p. 10). The first part of his hypothesis states that these aspects ‘exist together in a mutual and interdependent relationship’ (p. 10). The first part of the book deals with this issue. The focus of the second part of this hypothesis, as well as the second part of the book, is on the ontology of work. Cosden argues that if this part fails then all hypotheses are invalid. Therefore the main task of the book becomes to show the ontology of work.
Throughout the book Cosden sets out to explore his proposal through engaging in a dialogue with recent and contemporary thinkers. First, he uses the concept of the ontology regarding the work from John C. Raines's description of Karl Marx's understanding of work. Before he develops and explains his understanding of the ontology of work, Cosden shows that this aspect of work has been neglected or underdeveloped in theology. For this reason the author gives insight in the theology of work in the two Christian mainstreams in the West: Catholicism and Protestantism. To give a deeper and more exhaustive overview he engages in a dialogue with two theologians from both streams: Pope John Paul II with his Laborem Exercens and Jürgen Moltmann with his Theology of Play and On Human Dignity.
The Pope in his work moves forward the relational aspect of work as being central. That has created a hierarchical understanding of work. Cosden argues against a hierarchy among the aspects of work. He notes that hierarchy ‘is largely a result of an underdeveloped and thus inadequate ontological aspect of work’ (p. 26).
The author will continue his dialogue with Jürgen Moltmann at a deeper level later in the book, but for the purpose of the first part Cosden highlights that Moltmann in his books seeks for the meaning of work. Cosden writes ‘They [ideas of a meaning for work] suggest that Moltmann himself, knowing or unknowingly, is probing for some sort of ontological understanding of work by which he can both describe work itself, and provide the coordinates for its transcendent meaning’ (p. 26).
Cosden concludes that both theologians have some glimpses of the ontological aspect of work, but their understanding of it is insufficiently developed, and thus inadequate for providing an ontology of work.
Having recognised that there is a lack of ontological understanding of work in contemporary theology, Cosden in the second part of his book undertakes the task of giving an exhaustive description of the ontology of work. For this reason the author first gives a teleological framework, then explores theological anthropology and finally ends with an application of the threefold definition of work.
When Cosden deals with teleology he writes, ‘I propose that a revisioned teleological framework is both possible and necessary for theological ethics in general, and in particular for the project of establishing an ontology of work’ (p. 83). To develop a teleological framework that is suitable to his purposes, Cosden engages in a dialogue with two current thinkers: philosopher Alasdair MacIntyre and theologian Oliver O'Donovan. He values their contribution in rethinking and reapplying teleology, however he recognises that neither MacIntyre nor O'Donovan provide teleology adequate for Christian ethics and for an ontology of work.
Concerning teleology Cosden concludes: ‘An adequate teleological framework will recognise and accept the given in the created order, but it also, in open anticipation of the new creation that has already but not yet come, will allow for a further shaping of that created, and thus given order. Theologically, this means that an adequate teleological framework will approach nature and humanity from a dynamic interplay of both protological and eschatological perspectives’ (p. 100).
On a foundation of a new teleological framework Cosden then builds a Christian theological anthropology that is sufficient for an ontology of work. He selects and develops doctrines that support his ontology of work. First Cosden takes up the dialogue with Gunton about humans being created in the image of God, but he finds Gunton's view unsatisfactory for his ontology of work because Gunton's analogy between God and humanity is too close. Therefore he turns to Moltmann. Cosden uses Moltmann's theological anthropology because Moltmann's doctrines are eschatologically orientated, he provides a broader theology and his theological anthropology involves also a theology of nature.
In dialogue with Moltmann, Cosden shapes his doctrines on human purpose in initial creation and in the New Creation. He emphasises continuity between these two. He is particularly concerned with the doctrines that cover both the transition from this creation to the new one, and the eschatological eternal state.
Cosden bases his theological anthropology on these doctrines of Moltmann by locating and evaluating them, and ‘by demonstrating where one would go if one were producing a more comprehensive formulation of it’ (p. 127). He concludes that work was in the initial creation and will be in the New Creation as the active side of human purpose. In initial creation, work was given as an essential part of what it means to be a human being. ‘It [work] is a fundamental condition of human created existence. It is ontological’ (p. 144). He continues: ‘Human purpose in the new creation will be related to, although not in every way identical with, human purpose as found in the initial creation’ (p. 144). From this follows that work will continue to be an essential part of human existence and purpose in the New Creation. Finally, regarding work and its ontology, Cosden concludes: ‘Ontologically work is so fundamental to created and human existence that it is necessarily a part of both this life and the life to come’ (p. 175).
Having proved that work has an ontological aspect Cosden can give his theological definition of work:
Human work is a transformative activity essentially consisting of dynamically interrelated instrumental, relational, and ontological dimensions: whereby, along with work being an end in itself, the worker's and others’ needs are providentially met; believers’ sanctification is occasioned; and workers express, explore and develop their humanness while building up their natural, social and cultural environments thereby contributing protectively and productively to the order of this world and the one to come. (p. 179)
In the last chapter of the book he formulates the definition of work and shows how this definition functions and ‘what its implications are for both a theology and an ethics of work’ (p. 178). He demonstrates what difference ontology brings into the definition. He states: ‘The ontology of work suggests that work in its essence is more than the sum total to its instrumental and relational parts. “Ontology” indicates that there is a greater reality and telos to work than its instrumentality and relationality, either individually or combined, can capture’ (p. 184). Cosden concludes that the ontological aspect is essential for a comprehensive understanding of work. Nevertheless he does not really explain what the ontological aspect of work means practically. His description is very short and abrupt. After being on a journey of proving that work has an ontological aspect that is essential to it, when you close the book you are left with the question: ‘What does the ontological aspect mean for my work?’
Cosden has demonstrated that theology so far has failed to give a comprehensive meaning to work. By adapting and exploring the ontology of work, he has revealed that there is a new way to look at work and its meaning. His ideas could seem extraordinary but in the dialogue with other contemporary thinkers he demonstrates their validity. Cosden has opened a door for a new theological understanding of work and invites us to enter it by changing our view on work and living it out.
