Early in George Eliot's Daniel Deronda , Daniel's life is set on a decisive new path by his fleeting attraction to an object in a shop window. He is turning into a side street off Holburn Road when:
his attention was caught by some fine old clasps in chased silver displayed in the window at his right hand. His first thought was that [his aunt] Lady Mallinger, who had a strictly Protestant taste for such Catholic spoils, might like to have these missal-clasps turned into a bracelet; then his eyes travelled over the other contents of the window, and he saw that the shop was that kind of pawnbroker's where the lead is given to jewellery, lace, and all equivocal objects introduced as bric-a-brac. A placard in one corner announced – Watches and Jewellery exchanged and repaired. (344; bk. 4, ch. 6)
Daniel then moves across the street to avoid the shopkeeper, and it is only from this new vantage point that he notices the name “Ezra Cohen” above the window – the name he's been seeking while wandering Jewish neighborhoods in London in the hopes of reuniting his protégée Mirah with her family. He will return to the pawnshop later and become acquainted with the Cohens, eventually finding through them his mentor and Mirah's actual brother, Mordecai. Although some discussion of the silver clasps ensues, they are neither purchased nor used in the space of the novel. Still, this seemingly inconsequential trinket proves to have a long history, one that raises questions about the lingering remains of the past, the equivocality of the object, and the dispossessions that haunt Daniel Deronda.
In this article I trace the trajectory of the silver object from its medieval origins as part of a Catholic book to its potential future as jewelry, uncovering along the way episodes in English religious history, as well as developments in Victorian fashion, anthropology, and architecture that can enrich our understanding of Eliot's last novel. The multivalent missal clasps reverberate with the half-ruined Abbey at Topping, the setting for key scenes in Daniel Deronda; together these “Catholic spoils” register a culture built on the fragments of history. As she shifts from eulogizing to modernizing Judaism in her writings, Eliot asks how to heed the claims of the past and how to remake its legacies for the future.Footnote 1 When we pause over this relic reimagined as a bracelet, we find that some objects are taken up and given new life, while other remnants litter the background of the novel, marking the loss that inheres in every reinvention. This pattern of appropriation and dispossession governs the relations between characters in the text – each one disinherited in turn – as well as the formal structure that has long troubled critics of Daniel Deronda.Footnote 2 In this novel, every narrative development is built on the broken objects and buried bodies that came before.
The Catholic Spoil and the Jewish Relic
If we reconstruct the history of the silver clasps, we learn that they once held shut a missal, or liturgical book, produced in the Middle Ages.Footnote 3 The parchment pages of medieval books crinkled easily and had to be held closed by wooden boards, which were in turn secured with metal clasps – commonly made of brass, though silver grew in popularity over time (“Clasps”; Dahl 107–24; Burgess 121–22). Silver clasps were used on later Anglican and secular volumes as well, but the narrator specifically informs us that these are Catholic objects – as if that could be immediately ascertained. And it can be: their origin is manifest in their very presence in the pawnshop. Their separation from the books they once held shut makes obvious their status as “Catholic spoils,” immediately placing the clasps among the loot of the English Reformation and signaling Eliot's interest in the checkered lives of objects. The Dissolution of the Monasteries left massive ruins across the country and dispersed countless material goods, including books: as one Victorian journal described it, “jewels, and gold and silver clasps [were] torn off the volumes and kept aside, whilst the books themselves were sold for waste paper” (“Fall” 324).Footnote 4 Surviving inventories list service books with “claspys of copper” and “claspe of sylver” among the loot of Thomas Cromwell's commissioners (Nixon and Foot 19). Our silver clasps, then, easily tap into this period in English history, and the Dissolution serves as the most immediate reference evoked upon the reader's, and Daniel's, first encounter with the object.
The clasps’ provenance will be complicated later in the chapter, however, when Daniel returns to the shop. The Cohens quote him a price of three guineas, and Ezra declares the clasps are “worth twice the money; only I got ‘em in a bargain from Cologne” (350; bk. 4, ch. 6). A site of Catholic pilgrimage and home to many famous relics, Cologne was also a major trade emporium, reputed for its crafts and metalwork. It remained a stronghold of Catholicism even as reformation swept Europe, so it was only in 1794, when the city was briefly occupied by the French in the wars following the Revolution, that the church assets suffered some plundering. As one 1846 article reports, “Perhaps the most serious loss was the destruction of its cathedral archives. . .carted away in six loads from the cellars of the cathedral – including, no doubt, many of the books of Bishop Hildebold – and dispersed as old rubbish” (“Cathedral” 576). By the mid-nineteenth century, Cologne was attracting attention across Europe for another reason: the recently revived construction of the cathedral. A grand enterprise in medieval architecture, the cornerstone of the cathedral had been laid in 1248, but work stalled in the sixteenth century. The structure was left unfinished until the 1840s, when the city took up construction again. This project, finished just a few years after the publication of Daniel Deronda, took place in a context of lively debate about the preservation of architectural ruins, a debate we will revisit when we turn to another Catholic remnant in the novel, the Abbey at Topping. By contextualizing the missal clasps we thus enter the nineteenth century's conversation about its medieval inheritance, and the silver object emerges as a rich repository, storing the Gothic legacy of Cologne and the nearer cultural memory of the Dissolution.
But why does Eliot's “Jewish novel” concern itself with the vestiges of Catholicism at all?Footnote 5 Why is it a Catholic object that draws Daniel into the home and business of the English Jews who will unite him with Mordecai? As I will show, the ubiquity of Catholic relics in the English landscape and their renewed relevance in Victorian culture are key to developing Eliot's view of history as a damaged yet malleable presence and, crucially, to disrupting her tendency to treat Judaism as dead matter, at a sacred distance from modern life. As her letters and journals reveal, Eliot had a tendency to portray Judaism as a relic of itself. In her notebook for Daniel Deronda she emphasizes the apparently unanticipated survival of Hebrew prayers: “How a language may sleep & wake again” (Notebooks 301). Attending services in a synagogue in Portugal, she “fairly cried at witnessing this faint symbolism of a religion of sublime, far-off memories”; going further, she declares, “the skulls of St. Ursula's eleven thousand virgins seem a modern suggestion compared with the Jewish Synagogue” (Letters 4: 298). While in Cologne, Eliot had visited the church of St. Ursula, which was built on a Roman mass grave and contained a lively display of bones found on the site—bones exhibited as the remains of the martyr Princess Ursula and her eleven thousand companions, all killed, according to legend, by the Huns in the fifth century. Eliot is using here an apocryphal tale of barbarism, commemorated in a twelfth-century Catholic reliquary, to hyperbolically underscore the impossibly ancient roots of the Jewish tradition.
Indeed her primary figure for Judaism is the remnant, the thing that lingers from the past. A long history of violence and diaspora has left its mark, and Judaism's material presence in Europe is necessarily fractured. But Eliot sees wreckage even where it is not, describing a Jewish burial-ground in Germany as an architectural ruin, “with a multitude of quaint tombs in all sorts of positions, looking like the fragments of a great building, or as if they had been shaken by an earthquake” (“Munich” 41). She betrays a tendency to eulogize Judaism, and her emphasis on ruins implies that the religion survives in objects, but no longer thrives in communities.Footnote 6 Like Eliot, Daniel for many years “regarded Judaism as a sort of eccentric fossilized form,” and it is only in getting to know Mirah that he confronts “the hitherto neglected reality that Judaism was something still throbbing in human lives” (326; bk. 4, ch. 5). But Mirah's own faith is still deeply tied to the past, consisting mostly of her memories of childhood and her allegiance to a dead mother. She even situates her suffering as an inheritance, “[her] part in the long song of mourning that has been going on through ages and ages” (190–91; bk. 3, ch. 2).
Soon after meeting Mirah, Daniel spends a day in the Frankfurt Juden-gasse, an experience that “set him musing” on two poetic aspects of history: “the faint beginnings of faiths and institutions, and their obscure lingering decay.” As Eliot's sentence expands, those distant “beginnings” shift seamlessly into persistent signs of life, despite the “dust and withered remnants with which they are apt to be covered.” The grime of the past only enhances for the appreciative mind “the impressiveness either of a sublimely penetrating life, as in the twin green leaves that will become the sheltering tree, or of a pathetic inheritance in which all the grandeur and the glory have become a sorrowing memory” (329; bk. 4, ch. 5). In this early reflection, we find a set of alternative readings of Judaism as either “lingering decay” or the subtle promise of the growing leaf. Over the next few hundred pages Daniel will continue to engage the legacy of Judaism through encounters with both the living and the dead. His task is to decide what meaning this ancient institution will have in his own life and the contemporary world: what must be mourned and what might be revived. It is not the burgeoning plant, however, but the residual object that most clearly addresses the novel's questions about remaking the remains of the past. Eliot routes her concerns about Judaism through the familiar, checkered history of Catholicism in England, exploring the continued life of the religious remnant in the secular present. Setting a Catholic artifact in a Jewish pawnshop and pointing to its future refashioning as a Protestant woman's piece of jewelry, Eliot suggests the sometimes-unsavory possibility of repurposing the spoils of history. In their journey from sacred medieval space to pawnshop and potentially beyond, the missal clasps model the long equivocal life of the object through plunder, trade, ruination, and renovation, offering a path forward for history's bequests.
Diversion, Fashion, and Fetishism
The phrase “Catholic spoil” not only permits us to reconstruct the history of the missal clasps, but also reminds us of their former unspoiled, even sanctified, condition. When we encounter them, the clasps have travelled across countries and centuries through trade, but they were once protected from commodity status by the church – what Arjun Appadurai calls “enclaving” (23). According to Appadurai, religious rites like the Catholic mass provide “one sort of moral and cosmological framework within which commoditization is restricted and hedged [and in which certain objects are] not permitted to occupy the commodity state (either temporally, socially, or definitionally) for very long.” In this analysis, a thing is never inevitably or absolutely a commodity, but only positioned as such for a given period in its social life. An object that was previously enclaved must be diverted into the commodity state: before the missal clasps reached the pawnshop, itself a common starting point for diversion, they were drawn into commodification under violent circumstances and eventually made their way into more conventional circuits of trade.Footnote 7 The act of diversion that wrests an object from protected status, Appadurai argues, is “always a sign of creativity or crisis” (23–26). Or both: if the crisis of religious and political conflict released the missal clasps from the enclaved space of the church, it is the force of fashion that drives their continued circulation in 1870s London. Daniel's first thought is to set the clasps into a bracelet for his aunt, granting them new life as jewelry thanks to this particular moment in Victorian culture. The nineteenth century's renewed interest in the medieval period gave rise to trends in fashion, architecture, and the decorative arts, and Augustus Pugin himself designed jewelry inspired by medieval architectural motifs. Lady Mallinger's “strictly Protestant taste for Catholic spoils” is thus situated well within her cultural context.Footnote 8
The phrase is worth pausing over, however, as it suggests that her aesthetic preference both acknowledges the object's once-sacred status and implicitly dismisses it. While the Victorian period saw a genuine revival of the Catholic faith within England, that revival also reverberated throughout the culture unsaddled by the details of religious doctrine. In fact, this “strictly Protestant taste” for Catholic objects could be said to follow from common Protestant critiques of the church's use of things. Consider the many examples catalogued by Maureen Moran in her monograph on Victorian representations of Catholicism: in Seven Lamps of Architecture, Ruskin condemns the “tinsel and glitter” and “imitated gems” of the Catholic service, while Dickens, in Picture from Italy, deprecates a shrine as a “toy-shop of little objects” and altar decorations as “the veriest trash and tinsel” (qtd. in Moran 235; 240). The sensory overload of the Catholic ritual was considered by many Protestants to be an improper use of objects, incompatible with theological instruction. The subsequent adoption of this iconography for solely aesthetic purposes is a logical extension of that very critique: the response to perceived fetishism consistently expresses itself as a superior claim on the object.Footnote 9 It is the accusation of fetishism that makes possible the act of diversion.
Meaning is “fixed (or fixated)” by the fetish (Pietz 7); by contrast, fashion, the force behind many acts of diversion, comes to signify change itself (Jones and Stallybrass 4–6). Fashion fuels its continual reinvention with the repurposing of things from unexpected milieus, thriving on what Appadurai calls the “aesthetics of decontextualization”: diversion in which “value, in the art or fashion market, is accelerated or enhanced by placing objects and things in unlikely contexts” (28). This dissonance is heightened if the object previously operated outside the market altogether, as did the missal clasps. Over the course of the object's journey, the church's “fetishism” of the missal is neutralized by the commodification of its parts – movable silver fastenings in a shop display – and their refashioning for fashion. The clasps are stripped of religious significance, but their Gothic associations are deliberately preserved in their new life as jewelry or trinket. And yet, an object can resist such substitutions, exhibiting instead a peculiar “multivalence” (Kinney 57). The process of diversion, Appadurai argues, “always carries a risky and morally ambiguous aura”: the “spirit of entrepreneurship and that of moral taint enter the picture simultaneously” (27). Cleft from a book, waiting in a pawnshop, the missal clasps might now be linked in a bracelet; their violent history lingers in their aesthetic reinvention; they equivocate.
Equivocal Objects
The missal clasps sustain multiple meanings at once, as we saw in our opening passage: the object's past is acknowledged in the same moment as its future is imagined. But in between these stages – after their detachment from a missal, and before their potential incorporation into a bracelet – where do the clasps belong? Eliot lumps them together with the “equivocal objects introduced as bric-a-brac” on sale at the Cohens’ pawnshop. Indeed, one 1881 guide to women's handiwork and home decorating includes missal clasps in the collection of baubles a bride ought to bring to her new house, along with cameos, apostle spoons, miniatures, and mourning rings – all representative objects of the Victorian woman's presumed love of trinkets (Harrison 142). These “equivocal objects” are difficult to classify: the deliberately catch-all phrase bric-a-brac, derived from the French expression “à bric et à brac,” or “at random,” signals the absence of logic in arranging the collection (“bric-à-brac”). The trinket draws meaning primarily from its proximity to other small, pretty things. Bric-a-brac suggests uselessness: the objects are aesthetically pleasing and may have sentimental significance, but most importantly they belong to that ephemera with which a woman is supposed to surround herself.Footnote 10
Outside the scene at the pawnshop, Eliot uses the word equivocal – to have “different significations” and be “capable of double interpretation” (“equivocal”) – only to describe women in morally dubious situations.Footnote 11 Flirting with a man at a party, the female protagonist Gwendolen Harleth is overheard speaking in “equivocal terms,” proving to the hostess that the young woman is “double and satirical” (41–42; bk. 1, ch. 5). Toward the end of the book, Daniel thinks fleetingly and even dismissively of “Gwendolen and her equivocal fate” (565; bk. 7, ch. 1), shortly before meeting his actress mother, Leonora Halm-Eberstein, with her own “double consciousness” (571; bk. 7, ch. 2).Footnote 12 Perhaps most tellingly, two of Eliot's other uses of equivocal refer to Lydia Glasher entering the condition of a demi-mondaine when she leaves her husband for Henleigh Grandcourt (305; bk. 4, ch. 3). Lydia keeps her married name, but poses as a widow, and is all the while financially supported by Grandcourt. She continues to hold out hope that he will eventually marry her, or, at least legitimize her wide-eyed children; Lydia refuses to release her grip on respectable society. As her example demonstrates, there is a clear sexual stigma associated with these equivocal figures as they drift out of prescribed roles for women.Footnote 13 Indeed, their feminine corruption resonates with our previous characterization of bric-a-brac – things uncategorized, in excess, and trifling – and accounts for the note of mockery in the description of Lady Mallinger's blithe, secular interest in repurposing religious artifacts for the sake of fashion.Footnote 14 We find a connection between the moral stain Appadurai has identified with diversion – the sullied appropriation of an object for aesthetic purposes – and the sexual taint of having uncertain or multiple significations. One is the impurity of forcibly changing an object's meaning; the other, the impurity of being changeable, of an equivocalness that signals weakness if not worse.
Things That Linger
The object's capacity for ever-renewing significations can fuel growth and narrative; Katherine Dunagan Osborne has argued that the repurposing of objects becomes an act of freedom and moral resistance for Eliot's female characters.Footnote 15 But objects also bear a stubborn persistence, not only carrying traces of their former meanings, but lingering hauntingly in the landscape long after they have fallen out of use or value. Given their long lives and long memories, objects are necessarily multivalent. Repurposed and discarded, things remain, sharing, as political theorist Jane Bennett puts it, a “trending tendency to persist” (2). The material residue of the past functions in this novel much like the cultural remnants described by Victorian anthropologist Edward B. Tylor. Margueritte Murphy has shown that Eliot's perspective on history was influenced by Tylor's book Primitive Culture, which she read while writing Daniel Deronda. In Primitive Culture Tylor proposes a theory of “survivals” – those “processes, customs, opinions” that derive from an “older condition of culture out of which a newer one has been evolved” (16–17).Footnote 16 Tylor sees survivals as proof of the “mere permanence of culture,” the way “an idea, the meaning of which has perished for ages, may continue to exist simply because it has existed” (70–71). While Tylor examines the symbolic and figurative afterlife of outdated cultural forms, I suggest that his theory applies to the material world as well: the endurance or “mere permanence” of the residual object. And though, Tylor acknowledges, any particular survival may be hard for us to discern, in the words of another Eliot heroine, “it is still there – it is only hidden” (Romola 194; bk. 1, ch. 20).
As the name suggests, survivals are resilient: “Transformed, shifted, or mutilated such elements of art still carry their history plainly stamped upon them.” They have passed through “progress, degradation . . .revival, [and] modification” (Tylor 17) – much like the missal clasps and other material remnants. These fractured survivals of the past make visible the compromised condition of any heritage. This is history as we have access to it: riven with loss, continually remade, haunting the present in damaged, equivocal forms.Footnote 17 Indeed, as much as Eliot dramatizes the inescapable claims of the past, she also questions “the durability of inheritance itself”: according to Adrian Poole, “the extended historical perspective of [her] later novels suggests that ‘shreds and patches’ may be all that anyone inherits” (294). In Eliot's work, history appears as a field of broken things. The forward-looking Daniel Deronda is littered with these remnants and ruins, as Eliot asks how we might erect new structures on the debris of history – and at what ethical cost.
Restoring Ruins
The question of how to deal with ruins was actively contested in the mid-nineteenth century, a debate staged in Daniel Deronda during the chapters that take place at the Abbey at Topping. This former Catholic estate was involved in most of the major conflicts in English history and offers what Murphy calls a “material embodiment” of Tylor's “layered view of British culture” (198). One of many noble families to benefit from the Reformation, the Mallingers took over Monk's Topping after the eviction of its monastic community under Henry the Eighth (147; bk. 2, ch. 6). Some hundred years after the Dissolution, Puritan troopers in the English Civil War briefly occupied the Abbey and turned its choir into stables with the “pious satisfaction” of defacing the Anglican church and any lingering Catholic influence. Finally, the Mallingers themselves knocked down and altered much of the original building. Sir Hugo, however, has preserved the Abbey to the extent that it has been convenient to do so. Roughly midway through the novel, Sir Hugo leads his houseguests on a walking tour of the estate, showing them the Gothic arches, a “beautiful pointed doorway,” and the cloistered court that is “the finest bit of all.” These original features survive amidst more recent (and less elegant) additions, but Sir Hugo declares he would never attempt to salvage some authentic version of the Abbey – a remark that alludes to a lively contemporary discussion in Victorian architecture (376-80; bk. 5, ch. 1).
For thirty years prior, the popular course of action with damaged medieval buildings had been “restoration,” what Charles Dellheim describes as a clumsy process of recovering the “original design” and bringing the structure “back to an alleged state of architectural purity by sweeping away all historical accretions,” often with great damage to the building (79–82). On the Continent, as we noted earlier, Cologne had been engaged since the 1840s in the completion of its cathedral, left unfinished for centuries with a medieval crane still lingering on the site. The construction was continued according to two competing plans, with one façade an imitation of the original work, while the opposing façade followed a neo-Gothic design (Wolff 23). This “juxtaposition of the ‘real old’ and the ‘old-style new,’” like other restoration projects, sought a “pure” and often imagined version of the past to serve as a “symbol of German national unity” (Glendinning 78–83). By the 1870s, however, a policy of “preservation” came to the fore in England, promoting the maintenance of buildings rather than their artificial recovery. The Society for the Preservation of Ancient Buildings would be founded by William Morris one year after the publication of Daniel Deronda. If additions had been made after the original construction, preservationists (known as “Anti-Scrape”) would leave those pieces in place, rather than damage the building further. Sir Hugo appreciates the practice of preservation as “more truly historical”: “Additions ought to smack of the time when they are made and carry the stamp of their period,” he declares. While he rejects the “romanticism” of “reproducing the old,” he “wouldn't destroy any old bits,” preferring to acknowledge the many phases in English history that have left their mark on the Abbey (376; bk. 5, ch. 1).
Repurposing Judaism
In Daniel Deronda, Eliot is concerned with another renovation project: the modernization of the Jewish tradition. Judaism's place at the foundation of Western culture makes the religion a matter of vital historical significance, as Eliot declares to Harriet Beecher Stowe on the publication of Daniel Deronda. In an 1876 letter she writes of her disdain for those whose anti-Semitism reveals them to be:
empty of any real knowledge as to the relation of their own social and religious life to the history of the people they think themselves witty in insulting[.] They hardly know that Christ was a Jew. And I find men, educated, supposing that Christ spoke Greek. To my feeling, this deadness to the history which has prepared half our world for us, this inability to find interest in any form of life that is not clad in the same coat-tails and flounces as our own, lies very close to the worst kind of irreligion. (Letters 6: 301–02)
Here historical awareness becomes a kind of religion for Eliot – or the lack of it, irreligion. Understanding Judaism is to understand Christianity, after all, and Eliot makes a case for the relevance of Jewish history to Anglican Victorians in coat-tails. But can Eliot imagine the continuing life of Judaism in the late nineteenth century or grant it significance beyond the historical value suggested in her letters and journals? In writing Daniel Deronda, she sets herself the challenge of imagining a living Jewish present through an array of contemporary characters. One of these characters, the philosopher-prophet Mordecai, advocates the study of the Jewish past in the service of its future revitalization: Mordecai calls for the unification of the diasporic community, a project in keeping with the nationalist fervor of the age.
The novel is set during the Risorgimento, and many of the English characters keep close watch on the nationalist struggle in Italy. Shortly after the publication of Daniel Deronda, Eliot begins her essay “The Modern Hep! Hep! Hep!” with the declaration that “every patriotic restorer” has been inspired by “the preservation of national memories”: she refers to the modern examples of Greece and Italy to demonstrate that the “revival” of memories “is a sign of reviving nationality” (143). Indeed, Mordecai seeds memories, planting Hebrew verses in the mind of a child in the hopes that they will bear fruit in the years ahead (432; bk. 5, ch. 4). Living as if “in an invisible past and future” Mordecai charges his protégé Daniel with a mission at once radical and rooted in tradition: the establishment of “a republic where the Jewish spirit manifests itself in a new order founded on the old” (483–87; bk. 6, ch. 2). While restoration projects such as the Cologne cathedral, were increasingly “instrumentalized” by nineteenth-century nationalist fervor (Glendinning 78–83), Mordecai does not seek to recreate the past, but to “purif[y and] enrich[]” it. He compares his new order to the emergence of the United States, which he sees as an improvement on European tradition: “What had they to form a polity with but memories of Europe, corrected by the vision of a better?” (487; bk. 6, ch. 2). Through nationalism, Mordecai offers Daniel an intellectual and political approach to Judaism that situates an ancient tradition in the contemporary world.
Linked to other nationalist movements, Mordecai's particular ideology is granted global relevance – vital for a character like Daniel who is always concerned about being too “narrow” (656; bk. 8, ch. 3). Daniel responds to the political and intellectual implications of Mordecai's vision, if not exactly sharing his friend's spiritual motivations. Daniel has personal reasons to embrace his identity and accept Mordecai's charge: he is adrift, longing for a vocation, in love with a Jewish woman, impressed by Mordecai's fervor, and compassionate toward his frailty. Nevertheless, he cannot promise “that I shall profess to believe exactly as my fathers have believed” (658; bk. 8, ch. 3), and he does not expect to shed his Christian “sympathies” (600; bk. 8, ch. 2).Footnote 18 The novel permits Daniel to embrace his identity and take up the cause of a Jewish nation without fully espousing his mentor's beliefs or turning himself into his grandfather, as his mother fears he will do (600; bk. 8, ch. 2). Daniel will not simply reproduce the old. His version of Jewish identity is “emancipated, liberalized, nationalized, secularized” and thoroughly modern: E.S. Shaffer has argued that for Eliot, Judaism was the ideal “Feuerbachian milieu,” “saturated with religion, yet essentially secular and modern, where she could unite the primitive ground of religion with the most advanced consciousness of it” (244).Footnote 19 In other words, Daniel repurposes Judaism, bringing a “strictly secular taste” to the religion of his ancestors.
A Melancholy Object
And yet, the novel also suggests that history cannot be neatly packaged as inspiration for the future: every reinvention somehow gets entangled in the weeds of the past. Daniel's own life has long been troubled by painful reminders of what came before. Indeed it is the Abbey, the “historical, romantic, and home-like” estate where he grew up, that serves as the backdrop for Daniel's growing sense of displacement (146; bk. 2, ch. 6). “Among the falling rose-petals” of the beautifully preserved cloister, the adolescent Daniel becomes “acquainted with his first sorrow”: the stigma surrounding his dubious parentage (381; bk. 5, ch.1). Widely assumed to be the illegitimate son of Sir Hugo (and the rightful but dispossessed heir to the Abbey), Daniel grows up blissfully ignorant of such rumors – until, one day, the suspicion of illegitimacy comes suddenly into his consciousness, “as if something had stung him” The young Daniel is reading on the grass during lessons when he begins wondering about the many “nephews” of popes and cardinals in his history book: “there. . .darted into his mind with the magic of quick comparison, the possibility that here was the secret of his own birth, and that the man whom he called uncle was really his father.” In this monument to English history and Mallinger authority, he understands for the first time the shadowy aura around his origins: “there came back certain facts which had an obstinate reality, – almost like the fragments of a bridge, telling you unmistakably how the arches lay.” The facts which disturb Daniel's sense of self take the form of architectural remnants – not because of their disintegration, but because of their stubborn, if incomplete presence, the lingering remains of a difficult past (146–49; bk. 2, ch. 6).
Midway through the novel, the tension around Daniel's parentage once again bubbles to the surface during Sir Hugo's house party at the Abbey. The centerpiece of Sir Hugo's tour is the choir that was turned into stables by seventeenth-century Puritan troopers. The choir presents a striking scene, with barn animals and modern equipment set against the glass and stone of an erstwhile sacred space. Delighted by this unusual sight, Gwendolen unthinkingly alludes to her future role as mistress at the Abbey; catching Daniel's eye, she blushes at this oblique reference to his marginal status on the Mallinger estate. It is apt that this awkward encounter, a reminder of how Gwendolen's future triumph seems to depend on Daniel's past dispossession, takes place in stables that have been forcefully converted from a sacred past. In the three hundred years since its conversion, the sanctuary has been “gutted” and suffered disfiguration: “walled in with brick and covered with ivy,” the exterior “was much defaced, maimed of finial and gurgoyle, the friable limestone broken and fretted” – the violence of the conversion echoed in the friction of Eliot's crowded consonants (378–79; bk. 5, ch. 1). The church has been transformed by the passage of time as well as the actions of intervening occupants, its original glory bricked up, netted with wires, and overspread with vegetation.
The marks of disrepair have not obscured the sacred site, however, but fused with it, the stone “lending its soft grey to a powdery dark lichen,” inorganic and organic matter mingling in smoky shades. Among the stalls, horse boxes, and modern draining, “there still gleamed patches of crimson, orange, blue, and palest violet” from the “dusty glazing of the windows,” and, looming over the whole, the roof “showed its lines and colors mysteriously through veiling shadow and cobweb,” an ethereal canopy of cobwebs suspended from the springing arches of the church. What remains is a ghostly architectural pastiche, which, in the low winter light, has “still a scarcely disturbed aspect of antique solemnity.” The “soft light” falls equally on the “sleek brown or grey flanks and haunches,” the “mild equine faces,” and the “pale golden straw,” as on the stained glass and stone angels; indeed, Gwendolen wishes there could be a horse in every stall. Similarly moved by the “piquant picturesqueness” of the site, Daniel involuntarily removes his hat, “holding it before him as if they had entered a room or an actual church”; when asked mockingly if he shows deference to the horses, he merely responds, “Why not?” The strange combination of sacred and profane produces the scene's affective power and earns it a central place in the chapter (378-80; bk. 5, ch. 1). The choir is stunning because of, not despite, its desecration: it holds the memories of a long, complex history within its still space.Footnote 20
Eliot represents the half-ruined Abbey at Topping as a site of both beauty and pain, of powerful juxtapositions and haunting survivals. Given that Eliot visited many historic churches and synagogues on the Continent, her poetic depiction of the stables is especially interesting in the context of letters and journals documenting her actual discomfort with such challenges to aesthetic purity. Her 1854 visit to the Cologne cathedral was in fact marred by “the sight of the ugly wall which shuts out the choir – the proper vista of the nave,” which “shocked me as one would be shocked by an ugly wooden arm attached to an exquisite marble torso” (“Weimar” 18) – a remark that seems to evoke the leftover medieval crane hanging, like an ugly wooden arm, over the cathedral. Elsewhere, she records her dismay at “sadly confused” buildings, all “hideous altars of bastard style” (“Munich” 41), and at stucco “desecrating” the “beautiful small brick” and “exquisite inlaid work” of Spanish homes and churches (Letters 4: 339). At the same time, she finds herself moved by these incongruous sites: the Cologne cathedral “melancholy as ever in its impression upon me!”; the Prague cathedral, with its muddled interior and incomplete construction, “a melancholy object on the outside – left with unfinished sides like scars” (“Recollections of Berlin” 257; “Munich” 41). It is the scars – the unfinished, the ruined, and the vandalized – that produce this stirring, melancholy effect on Eliot.
In an 1876 letter to her friend Barbara Bodichon, Eliot uses the image of an altered cathedral as an illustration of her belief that the ugly incongruities of life are also evidence of its unavoidable attachments: “Life tends to accumulate ‘messes’ about one, and it is hard to rid one's self of them because of the associations attached. I get impatient sometimes, and long, as Andrew Fairservice would say, to ‘kaim off the fleas,’ as one does in a cathedral spoiled by monuments out of keeping with the pillars and walls.” In this allusion to a spoiled cathedral – and to Walter Scott's Rob Roy – Eliot acknowledges the artistic impulse to clean up the mess and comb out the fleas. But she also knows these messes cannot be removed “because of the associations attached” – because they belong to the historical process. What is exceptional about this line in Eliot's letter is that it immediately follows a paragraph on the reception of Daniel Deronda, which had just been published. Expressing irritation with “readers who cut the book into scraps and talk of nothing in it but Gwendolen,” she declares: “I meant everything in the book to be related to everything else there” (Letters 6: 290). Eliot insists on the interrelation of what contemporary reviewers and later critics alike deemed the novel's “two plots.” The line of thinking indicated by her letter suggests that she sees the muddled cathedral as a figure for history's necessary encumbrances and for her novel's structuring principles. The letter confirms the author's preoccupation with the uncomfortable but indispensable presence of the past and its role as a motivating force in Daniel Deronda. In this final section, I will show how the lingering, equivocating object clarifies the relationship between the novel's supposedly disconnected sides.
Where the Bodies Are Buried
As we've seen, Gwendolen Harleth is sensitive to Daniel's displaced status, having staked her own future on the dispossession of the woman who came before her in Grandcourt's life. But this sensitivity – a mixture of pity, discomfort, and fear for her own safety – precedes her acquaintance with both Daniel Deronda and Lydia Glasher: Gwendolen has always suffered from what Eliot calls a “susceptibility to terror” and what she herself experiences as “a brief remembered madness” (53; bk. 1, ch. 6). Early in the novel, Gwendolen has a public breakdown over the painting of a dead face hidden in her family's new home at Offendene. The image is discovered by her half-sister Isabel who “held open a hinged panel of the wainscot” in the drawing room that “disclosed the picture of an upturned dead face, from which an obscured figure seemed to be fleeing with outstretched arms” (20; bk. 1, ch. 3). Gwendolen demands that the panel be locked up; months later, it flings open spontaneously, causing her performance of a tableau vivant to end in hysterics. Her audience at Offendene discusses the strange occurrence in the terms of Victorian spiritualism, speculating that there must be a medium among them (51; bk. 1, ch. 6). The narrator later attributes the event to Isabel's mischief, but even if we pause over the supernatural explanation, we must conclude that a medium would be superfluous to the situation: the disturbance was caused not by summoning visitors from the spirit world, but merely by uncovering the dead where they lie. After all, it is very well for Gwendolen to lock up the door and ask her sister, “How dare you open things which were meant to be shut up?” (20; bk. 1, ch. 3). But if the door is shut up and locked, the dead face is “still there – it is only hidden.” Gwendolen does not fear what a ghost might represent or communicate, but simply its proximity to her: the presence of death in the walls of the house.Footnote 21
Murphy accounts for Gwendolen's superstitions through Tylor's theory of survivals, tracing many of her vague anxieties back to archaic beliefs mentioned in Primitive Culture. According to Murphy, the morbid painting is a survival of “the ancient rite of laying the foundations of a building on a human victim” (197). Tylor explains this rite in great detail, perhaps because it is a myth about hidden, lingering forms, like survivals, that itself survives dormant in the culture. In his book, he tells dozens of dark legends of medieval edifices built up around still living children, as well as tales of sacrificial substitutions: live horses, empty coffins, and “a lamb walled in under the altar” of a Danish church. Tylor asserts that both folklore and local chronicle confirm the widespread conviction that “church or wall or bridge want. . .human blood or an immured victim to make the foundation steadfast” (94-96). But when placed in the context of Daniel Deronda, this gruesome rite becomes a model for culture itself: structures and societies built on the buried; foundations laid on something or someone that was already there. New edifices demand blood.
Gwendolen may have a vague belief in old myths, but she is responding to a material world quite plainly littered with relics of the past, and she remains alert to the bodies hidden in buildings. At the Abbey, Sir Hugo teasingly tells her, “There used to be rows of Benedictines sitting where we are sitting. Suppose we were suddenly to see the lights burning low and the ghosts of the old monks rising behind all our chairs!” But she doesn't enjoy the joke: “Please don't!” she tells Sir Hugo. “It is very nice to come after ancestors and monks, but they should know their place and keep underground.. . . I suppose the old generations must be angry with us because we have altered things so much” (368–69; bk. 5, ch. 1). Afraid of becoming a target, Gwendolen is always keen to the justified anger and resentment of the dispossessed. Though the monks may stay underground at the Abbey, a legacy of violence and loss certainly lingers in this space; like the equivocating missal clasps, the Abbey reminds us of the taint brought on by every appropriation. If Gwendolen is uneasy, it is because she recognizes the contaminations that accompany processes of change.
What she fears in Lydia Glasher and her children is the possibility of laying her own foundation atop human sacrifices – but that is only a more vicious, palpable version of what has already happened all around her. Recall Grandcourt's perverse decision to bury his superfluous women in coal country. He keeps Lydia at Gadsmere while marrying another woman; then, in his will, he upgrades Lydia and her children to the family estate, and swaps in Gwendolen at Gadsmere. This substitution very clearly extends Lydia's tainted, equivocal status to Gwendolen; even Sir Hugo sees this as “banishment.. . . It's quite clear Grandcourt meant that his death should put an extinguisher on his wife, if she bore him no heir” (652; bk. 8, ch. 2). It is the woman's fate of being immured, “put in a frame and tortured,” that Daniel's mother, Leonora, violently resists (601; bk. 7, ch.4). She long resented that her spirited young mind and body were curbed by her father's plans, which he “thrust on my mind that I might feel them like a wall around my life – my life that was growing like a tree” (578; bk. 7, ch. 2).
The Pawned Ring
To be free from these “bonds,” in defiance of her dead father, Leonora asks Sir Hugo to raise her son as an English gentleman (580; bk. 7, ch. 2). To save her own feelings, she denies the adult Daniel any further relationship after their meeting in Genoa, accusing him of being “on [his] grandfather's side,” against her. In a burst of indignation, Daniel takes up this schema of opposition, declaring allegiance to his grandfather: “You renounced me – you still banish me – as a son,” and, as a result of divine will, “I shall be all the more the grandson whom also you willed to annihilate” (599-602; bk. 7, ch. 4). Daniel is grieving his mother's rejection of him, but this moment of pique also expresses a sustained dynamic in the novel: a series of alternatives he must face between relationships and legacies. Daniel has always hated to choose, because he hates to exclude. Growing up, he never imagined who his parents might be, because “wishing. . .was a disowning by anticipation” (561; bk. 7, ch. 1). But after his family background is revealed, he will be compelled to disown, or at least release, some ties. His journey toward a vocation requires shutting out alternatives; as he crafts his new identity, Daniel must adopt certain relationships and shed others. This choice between familial legacies is dramatized through two inherited objects, the trajectories of which help bring the novel to a close: the grandfather's chest and the father's ring.
If we return to the Cohens’ pawnshop, we recall that although Daniel does not carry away the missal clasps, he does leave behind a diamond ring – the pledge that gives cover to his continued inquiries at the Cohens’. Murphy has noted the irony that “by pawning his father's ring, Daniel gains” an acquaintance with Mordecai that ultimately “enables him to embrace his patrimony” (192). But in fact the act presages a choice Daniel will make between patrimonies at the novel's end. After its stay at the pawnshop, the diamond ring reappears at his mother's request: she asks Daniel to wear it to their first meeting in Genoa and takes his hand to examine the ring, saying, “It was your father's” (575; bk. 7, ch. 2) We know Daniel's father was eclipsed by his wife, and it is Leonora who seems to value the ring, entrusting it to Sir Hugo when he adopts her son. Despite the ring's connection to his newly revealed parentage, however, it means little to Daniel – much like the father who is barely registered in the text.
This meek, uxorious father scarcely compares to the iron-willed maternal grandfather who also left Daniel an heirloom, a chest full of documents. Osborne has noted Daniel's “indifference” to the ring compared to his “genuine cathexis” in the chest (488). Daniel Charisi's chest is heavy, ornate, and inscribed in Arabic; despite Leonora's impulse to destroy her past, she found the chest “difficult to burn” (578; bk. 7, ch. 2). “Though it has been lying these twenty years,” in the safekeeping of his grandfather's friend, Daniel is anxious to retrieve it as soon as possible (652; bk. 8, ch. 2) and vows to “be more careful of this than any other property” (655; bk. 8, ch. 3). Irritated that this attachment to his grandfather's bequest will carry Daniel away from the newly widowed Gwendolen, Sir Hugo grumbles that Daniel should not “set a dead Jew above a living Christian” (652; bk. 8, ch. 2). The remark is prescient, though Sir Hugo does not yet grasp, as the reader does, that Daniel is not just curious about his long-deceased grandfather, but has also already accepted “the brief remnant of [Mordecai's] fervid life” as his personal “charge” (494; bk. 6, ch. 3). Indeed, Mordecai and Charisi are linked by their intellectual interests and spiritual temperaments: both scholars and visionaries, these two men profoundly shape Daniel's sense of what it will mean to be Jewish.
Upon his return to England, Daniel rushes from the station straight to Mordecai's home, eager to “deposit the precious chest” with his mentor (677; bk. 8, ch. 6). Shortly afterward the two men are poring over the documents together when Daniel loses his diamond ring altogether. Daniel never exactly rejects his father's ring, but he has been careless with it before, putting it up as collateral for a loan he doesn't need, indifferent to Ezra's undervaluing the diamond. In this scene, he takes the ring off in irritation and leaves it on a table along with his cravat – his déshabille a sign of his comfort with Mordecai and his gradual rejection of the trappings of the rich English gentleman. The ring is too heavy for the summer and “superfluous,” Daniel feels, to his “Eastern” plans. While Mordecai and Daniel carry on with Charisi's papers, the ring sits on the table behind them, accessible to the compulsive and greedy Lapidoth, the father of Mirah and Mordecai. The ring “suddenly shone detached and within easy grasp” of Lapidoth's sticky fingers, which seem to move on their own, despite his resolve to extract money from Daniel some other way (717; bk. 8, ch. 11).
This very theft, however, will accelerate developments between Daniel and Mirah (an engagement without a ring). In professing his love, Daniel offers to take Mirah's shame in her father as his own (719-20; bk. 8, ch. 11). But rather than binding them closer to this vulgar parent, the incident actually rids them of Lapidoth altogether. A new, chosen family, Daniel, Mirah, and Mordecai are relieved of the disgraceful duty that is Lapidoth. This turn of events is in keeping with the novel's sense that not everything or everyone will be redeemed or reinvented: the “ugly and “vulgar” (176; bk. 2, ch. 8) elements of Jewish life may not have a place in the romantic and epic register of Daniel's future. Recall Daniel's eagerness to exchange the “wrong” Ezra Cohen – the pawnbroker – for the right one – the prophet.Footnote 22 So, at the story's close, Mirah's father forestalls any possibility of redemption and leaves, along with Daniel's material link to his own father. The diamond ring is one object from Daniel's past that won't make up part of his future; Lapidoth is planning to sell it for passage on board a ship. The last we hear of the ring, in other words, it is headed to a pawnshop, to be picked up by someone else, or left to linger.
Conclusion
And what of the “living Christian”? Daniel's sudden inheritance occurs almost simultaneously with his rejection of Gwendolen and Grandcourt's disinheritance of her. In addition to acquiring from Lydia the status of the banished wife, Gwendolen also switches places with Daniel as the dispossessed figure of the novel. “The very form of the novel confirms her marginalization” by turning away from Gwendolen to Daniel's new family and destiny at its close (Levine 58).Footnote 23 Daniel winces at his friend Hans's astute quip that Daniel is shutting Gwendolen out of his future without allowing her to have one of her own: “Do you want her to wear weeds for you all her life – burn herself in perpetual suttee while you are alive and merry?” (727; bk. 8, ch. 12). Gwendolen may not be set ablaze, but she does appear as a kind of wreck at the novel's end, calling out with a “smothered voice” (732; bk. 8, ch. 12) and appearing as a “melancholy statue” (700; bk. 8, ch. 8) and “the unhappy ghost” of the woman Daniel once knew (625; bk. 7, ch. 7). Her last words are in the future tense, pointing to her potential to become something better than she was – but the novel does not linger to see her through this hoped-for renewal, if it ever comes. We see now why Eliot declares every part of the book to be related to everything else there: Daniel's momentous future offstage is not possible without burying Gwendolen at Offendene. The novel closes as a tale of reinvention, with haunting.Footnote 24
Through the “equivocal” missal clasps and the dilapidated Abbey at Topping, we encounter a past that lingers in broken objects, only some of which can be refurbished for present purposes. These remnants register the novel's concern with the ethical necessity of heeding the past and the ethical uncertainty of living with its losses. At the same time, the missal clasps model the fate of all novelistic things, to be endowed with meaning one moment and discarded the next. Like Gwendolen's potential redemption, the object's future as jewelry is evoked and then aborted, or at least left undetermined. Back in the pawnshop, Ezra flatters Daniel's taste, remarking, “You understand silver-work, I see.” Before moving on to more pressing concerns, Daniel disavows his knowledge of and interest in the object: “’A little,’ said Deronda, taking up the clasps a moment and laying them down again” (352; bk. 4, ch. 6). In this brief scene, the missal clasps evoke a narrative of consecration, despoliation, and reinvention, making present the fractured condition of the past. But the missal clasps also demonstrate the ease with which these remains come into our lives and out again: taken up for a moment and laid back down, among the other spoils of history.
