It is often asserted that Indonesia is the world's largest Muslim nation, and indeed it is. That said, however, it is only recently that the imagining of this modern construct—a palimpsest of Dutch borders laid over the shifting boundaries of petty coastal sultanates, memories of an Indianized imperial past, and a small galaxy of local Austronesian traditions—has begun to be asserted ever more noticeably in terms of an overarching narrative of Islam.
In large part this has been due to the deposition of Soeharto, the strongman general who ruled the archipelago from 1966 to 1998 in the name of his “New Order” government and who crushed any form of opposition voiced in the name of Islam. This is not to say that Islam was the named enemy. Rather, his was a military regime that thrived on the fear of international communism, having come to power in the wake of a failed putsch led by the Indonesian Communist Party on the night of 30 September 1965. The putsch itself had seen the massacre of most of the generals who then led the nation's armed forces, and naturally enough the subsequent regime actively linked itself to the glorious struggle for independence undertaken by those same martyrs alongside the since marginalized founder–president, Soekarno.
Much like the so-called “Old Order” that had preceded it, the quasimilitary New Order also claimed the inheritance of a territory identifiable with that of the great Hindu–Buddhist Empire of Majapahit in the 14th century. It is this fused inheritance of postcolonial and precolonial empires whose architectural traces were emulated in the modern concrete in every village and whose victories were celebrated in national textbooks that is the subject of Michael Wood's Official History in Modern Indonesia. Originally an archaeologist by training, and following doctoral fieldwork in Indonesia in the final years of Soeharto's rule, Wood has sketched a straightforward narrative. Chapter 1 draws mainly on Bernard Lewis' (somewhat utilitarian) conceptions of the use of the past, whether “remembered,” “recovered,” or “invented,” to align the New Order with past constructions of Indonesia's valorized Indic past. Chapter 2 seeks to link the stories of past empires—in part that of Sumatra's Srivijaya, but primarily that of Java's Majapahit—to the New Order. Chapter 3 is an account of the remembered heroism of the revolution of 1945–49, and then the shock of the coup of 1965, linking the murdered generals in a continuum to the empire and anticolonial revolution. Chapter 4, “Histories in Waiting—Counterviews to the New Order's Version of the Past,” is essentially a more Islam-centric outline penned before by such national figures as the reformist Hamka and, later, Roeslan Abdulgani.
In sketching his main argument, Wood dwells at length on the writings of the New Order script-writer Nugroho Notosusanto and pays closest attention to the texts he composed for the national school system. Throughout Wood ponders the implications of archeological findings as they impacted both forms of history—New Order and Islamic “counterviews.” In the main this is a solid study, although it might have made more use of more primary sources, including other Old Order histories destined for the school system (such as that of Muhammad Kasim and Uyeng Suwargana, Zaman Dahulu, Sekarang, dan Yang Akan Datang: Buku Peladjaran Ilmu Sedjarah Indonesia Untuk Sekolah Rakjat, Bandung, 1953).
Wood's argument is clearly put and logical, yet despite his contention to the contrary (p. 6), this study has been somewhat stranded by other works that have often gone into greater depth in terms of the role of Nugroho (e.g., there is the 2002 thesis of Kate McGregor, published later, whose work was known to Wood). Nor is this book especially luminous theoretically. The author might have drawn comparisons from his expertise, or the broader literature on nationalist historiography, but there is too little and too late. It is furthermore problematic at times in its use of secondary literature; for example, the author used two versions of the primary text referring to the empire of Majapahit (that of Pigeaud [1960–62] and Robson [1995], which has supplanted it), but Wood prefers the former and its erroneous title. Moreover, although he tries to link New Order narratives to a defensive view to be wielded against those shaped by outside scholars, particularly those of the influential Cornell School, Wood makes little considered reference to what is arguably the strongest, and most suppressed, counternarrative in Indonesia to have inflected foreign scholarship on Indonesia, that of the late Pramoedya Ananta Toer, who is treated as a writer of novels more than a shaper of ideas.
Overall, my primary contention with this book is its notion of the New Order as an unchanging regime rather than a period encompassing an evolving set of practices and, perhaps more importantly, Wood's apparent disinclination to consider the Islamic narrative as being as much of the New Order as against it. It would have been worth treating how the role played by Soeharto himself in validating the counternarrative in the 1990s or allowing the space for its expression once the process of Islamization on university campuses and within the body politic, not to mention the growing dissatisfaction of sections of the military, forced him to bend from a previous commitment to Javanist spiritualism and to emulate the practice of an increasing number of his subjects. History will show, in all likelihood, that the New Order was in fact a period crucial to the makings of a more consciously Muslim nation.
Beyond the limited range of primary materials and the lack of attention paid to arguably the most symbolic of New Order narratives, the dioramas in the nation's numerous museums, and most especially in the base of Jakarta's National Monument (described briefly as an “Indian-influenced” structure, p. 17), this study has been compromised by the sad fact that Brill so clearly places all the onus of editing on the shoulders of the author alone. In the end though, it remains a useful piece of research and sheds light for the general reader on the reading of Indonesia once favored by its former general. Still, for greater historical depth readers may want to explore some of the other counternarratives available on a nation that is increasingly being constructed as Islamic.
