The press looms large over the history of Peronism and, indeed, over the study of Latin American populism and twentieth-century mass politics more broadly. Not only have historians relied heavily on newspapers and other print media to investigate these subjects, but in Argentina the press occupied a central place in the political clashes that dominated the Peronist era (1943–55). As a consequence, scholarly debates over Peronism's democratic and authoritarian features have often revolved around questions of cultural policy, state censorship and propaganda, and freedom of expression. Recent showdowns between the state and media in Argentina, as well in other Spanish American countries, most notably Hugo Chávez's Venezuela, have sparked new interest in the historical origins of such conflicts. Peronismo y prensa escrita wades into these controversies by investigating how newspapers in the Peronist era reflected and shaped the era's political contests. As the latest contribution to a growing literature, this useful collection of essays seeks a ‘panoramic’ view that spans diverse ideological positions and journalistic perspectives.
The book is divided into two parts: the opening half probes the role of domestic newspapers, while the second delves into foreign reporting. The first cluster of case studies analyses competing expressions of sympathy and antipathy toward Peronism that circulated in Argentina's vibrant print culture. These essays share a similar methodology, as each author supplies a close reading of an individual newspaper, usually by targeting a celebrated moment in the period's history (such as the lead-up to the 1946 and 1951 elections). The pieces on El Laborista and Democracia, for instance, illustrate the press's role in consolidating support during Peronism's early years, but also the pressures of conforming to an increasingly rigid official line. The bulk of the first section, however, focuses on the contortions of anti-Peronist observers, especially Argentinian leftists perplexed by the sudden eruption of a mass movement. Claudio Panella's contribution on La Vanguardia argues that the Socialist Party was ultimately unable to see Peronism as anything other than creole fascism; by contrast, Marcelo Fonticelli's essay shows that Argentina's Communists assailed the Perón government's foreign policy while seeking a rapprochement with the movement's working-class base. Liberal opponents feature in a pair of essays on the clashes between the government and venerable press institutions like La Nación and La Prensa (shut down by the regime in 1951). A study of Tucumán's El Intransigente takes a welcome detour away from the Buenos Aires-based media to examine anti-Peronism in the provinces. Each of these closely cropped portraits employs extensive quotations from articles, editorial pages and the declarations of state representatives, to foreground the views of public protagonists. The issue of how audiences engaged with the press remains an unanswered question: the formation of journalistic opinion is emphasised over popular reception and media dissemination (this is unsurprising, given the sources readily available to researchers).
The book's second section investigates accounts of Peronism in newspapers from the United States, Great Britain, Spain and Israel. Taken together, these essays offer valuable insights into how foreigners greeted Peronism with a mixture of fascination, amusement and anxious concern. Nicolás Quiroga's essay departs from the prevailing methodology through biographical profiles of New York Times foreign correspondents, including Herbert Matthews of subsequent Sierra Maestra fame. It highlights the professional bonds that linked correspondents to their sources and fellow reporters in Argentina, which all but guaranteed negative coverage of Perón and Evita as their government intensified restrictions on the domestic press. In general, the authors stress the importance of political divisions abroad in shaping interpretations of Argentina's internal affairs: leftist and liberal papers decried Peronist mass authoritarianism; pro-business conservatives privileged issues of post-war commercial exchange; and the nationalist Right in Spain asserted commonalities under the banner of Hispanidad. In this regard, Raanan Rein's piece on the Israeli press identifies an intriguingly complex case. There journalists weighed Argentina's international reputation as a Nazi haven against the fact that Perón's government established early diplomatic relations with the state of Israel. While these cases are all treated with skill, the volume's contributors agree that reporting on Argentina outside the region was frequently shallow and based on information gleaned from wire services. Still, one wonders how journalists in neighbouring Latin American nations grappled with the implications of Peronism and perhaps forged more extended comparisons between Argentina and their own societies.
A number of important themes cut across the two halves of this edited volume, although the lack of a conclusion leaves it to the reader to tease out interconnections. Principal among these is the press's obsession with categorising Peronism. Domestic and international observers alike latched onto existing categories – fascism, of course, but also concepts such as caudillismo, the ‘welfare state’ and ‘totalitarianism’, which were gaining currency in the post-war world – to render Peronism comprehensible to their readers, even while they acknowledged that these labels were not a perfect fit. For foreign commentators, the task of assessing Peronism's distinctive characteristics blurred at times with efforts to depict its ‘Latin’ exoticism. As this volume's essays demonstrate, the use of ready-made labels limited the creativity of journalistic analysis, but categorisations became potent weapons in the war of public opinion, as newspapers sharpened antagonisms that endured long after the end of Peronist rule.
