Modern economic theory plays an increasingly important role in discussion of the ancient economy, but doubts persist in some quarters as to the validity of such approaches, while the hyper-rational image of the ancient world that these theories occasion sits uncomfortably for some scholars. Colin Elliott's book, written in a conciliatory tone, offers a new approach that seeks to use economic theory not as a model for the past, but as a heuristic tool that can lead to a more human understanding of the Roman world.
The first two chapters are principally historiographic. In ch. 1, E. gives an admirably concise overview of the major debates in Roman economic history. After outlining the primitivist/modernist and substantivist/formalist divides, E. comes to the chief paradigm for many works of economic history today, new institutional economics (NIE). While welcoming the contribution of NIE in introducing concepts such as bounded rationality and transaction costs, he highlights that many of the old divides still remain: ‘Despite its promise, the agenda of new institutionalism has thus far not materialized as a true “third way” between either primitivism and modernism or substantivism and formalism’ (18).
Ch. 2 explores three crucial debates around the nature of the Roman monetary system. First, in a subsection entitled ‘Embeddedness’, E. looks at previous scholarship on the nature of Greek and Roman money and highlights the importance of pre-existing mindsets in creating differing approaches to money. Secondly, he sets out the scholarly divide about the nature of value, specifically whether money has value because the state enforces that value (chartalism) or whether value arises from monetary objects themselves (metallism). E. sensibly concludes that the Roman monetary system included elements of both paradigms. The final section of the chapter is dedicated to the roles of markets and the state, a topic much discussed in previous scholarship. E. presents a picture of the Roman economy as dominated by the state, yet with ample room for market activity and growth; in short, his Roman economy is one of ‘both complexity and contradictions’ (49).
The two following chapters are the intellectual core of the book and represent E.'s attempt to develop a rigorous methodology that facilitates the use of economic theory to understand those complexities and contradictions. Firmly grounded in epistemological theory, E. begins by outlining the shortcomings of both inductive and deductive empiricism. While trying to draw out conclusions from sources or data in an inductivist manner can lead to radically different or even opposing conclusions about the same material, testing the ancient data against a hypothetical economic model runs into the problem that there is no a priori means of establishing the validity of said model. As an alternative, E. proposes following in the footsteps of Wilhelm Dilthey, Max Weber and R. G. Collingwood, who all advocated approaches that seek to get inside the thought-world of historical actors. He adopts Dilthey's terminology of Verstehen (understanding) for this idea.
Central to E.'s attempt to apply a Verstehen approach to economic theory is the concept of ‘purposefulness’, by which he means, following Ludwig von Mises, ‘the use of means to attain chosen ends’ (79). He argues that by examining the choices made by historical actors, historians can learn about how value was perceived and constructed in the past. This naturally leads to a strongly contextualised approach to ancient economic action: ‘Rather than ask “do these prices confirm/falsify the existence of a capitalistic labor market?” for example, scholars might instead seek to identify and understand the factors which shaped the value preferences of the individuals who made exchanges at certain prices at specific times, in specific places and within specific cultural and social contexts’ (96).
Within this methodological context, E. argues that economic theory can help to create Weberian ideal-types against which to compare the purposeful choices of people in the past. The final two chapters contain a series of case-studies in which this approach is applied. The first example is the case of Octavian's cash gifts in the aftermath of Actium. Rather than blindly accepting the effects on prices and interest rates prescribed by the Fisher equation, E. proceeds more contextually and highlights the inequalities in time and space of Octavian's distributions. His second example examines the link between coin quality and prices, particularly in second-century a.d. Egypt, using an ideal-typical metallist mindset to evaluate the choices made by users when faced with coins with varying metal contents. Finally, E. comes to the debasement of the Roman silver coinage in the third century a.d.; he uses Gresham's law to set up counterfactual possibilities that allow a greater understanding of the choices made by both coin users and coin issuers in this period. He is clear that his case studies are only intended to illustrate the potential of his approach, and indeed that one could usefully redeploy economic theory to the ancient world in a number of other ways, but the final chapters do demonstrate that proceeding as he suggests can lead to new insights on much-discussed topics.
Despite the irritation of all-too-frequent typos, this small book has a lot to offer. While not everyone will want to follow E.'s approach, there can be little doubt that he has opened up new possibilities for understanding ancient economic action. Moreover, anyone interested in historical methodology more generally will benefit from his thoughtful engagement with thinkers like Weber and Collingwood and his careful application of their ideas.
