Professor John McGuckin has given students and scholars a fantastic resource in this trim (228 pages), densely packed, informative and even inspiring reference work on the incomparable Origen of Alexandria (c. 186–255). Representing the best of the Origenic renaissance in the last half of the twentieth century, and continuing up to the present, McGuckin has drawn together a set of more than thirty expert collaborators (many of whom are regular participants in the Colloquium Origenianum) to write almost ninety crisp articles on topics ranging alphabetically from ‘Allegory’ to ‘Worship’. The volume also provides beginning and seasoned readers with an indispensable list of critical editions and translations of Origen's writings (always a complex issue, because of the both censored and haphazard nature of our extant remains (‘only a smoldering ruin of the monumental body of work this creative writer produced’ (p. 25)), and the need in many cases to work from Latin translations of the now-lost original Greek texts), as well as a Bibliography of important secondary literature. And at various points along the way, McGuckin inserts gentle pedagogical pointers to readers about how they can wade into and absorb these resources in the most logical and feasible manner to help them understand all the complex threads that face one who seeks to understand the controversial figure of Origen.
But this handbook is no modern stromateis (‘miscellanies’), for McGuckin himself has provided a coherent vision and methodological centre for the volume in his lively and most insightful introductions to Origen's Life (pp. 1–23) and Scholarly Works (pp. 25–44), and his editorial hand is evident throughout the volume, to the effect that topics such as Origen's education and schooling or his eschatology recur at various junctures in recognisably similar forms. And, above all, it is McGuckin's portrait of Origen – which builds on recent research into his educational pedigree, his exegetical prowess and a host of theological and philosophical topics (from the Soul to Hades and back again), together with a sound, extended view of Origen's influence from antiquity to today – that animates this volume. These enticing introductions, which do more than summarise current scholarship, but reach independent judgements on various topics while creating their own distinct portrait, are so good that they will captivate readers to join the engagement with the late antique figure McGuckin variously terms ‘a fussy and text-obsessed thinker’, ‘the Christian church's first and greatest biblical scholar’, and ‘the Christian church's first great mystic’ (all on a single page, ix). After describing the utter wrecking of Origen's body under torture during the Decian persecution, McGuckin applies his own epitaph to Origen, lying in state on his deathbed, as ‘the greatest Christian of his age’ (p. 23).
Origen, for McGuckin, is above all a ‘philosopher-didaskalos’ who in his First Principles achieved no less than ‘a new birth for systematic theology conceived in the manner of an organized manual of philosophic instruction’ (p. 8). This picture of Origen's great work becomes for McGuckin, one senses, also a lasting potential blueprint for the Christian intellectual: ‘the professor is the high priest of Christian mysteries’ (p. 8). Origen's work as biblical scholar, teacher par excellence, travelling theological consultant and builder of the library at Caesarea all are united in this picture of the philosopher-didaskalos. Biographically, McGuckin insists on the methodological principle that Eusebius' account of his Caesarean hero is never to be preferred to Origen's own writings (p. 6); thus he argues against the historicity of Origen's putative self-castration, taking it as an ancient tale fabricated by Origen's own friends and purveyed by Pamphilus, to account for his run-in with Demetrios of Alexandria. He further notes the pervasive influence of Paul (as well as John) on Origen's thought, rightly (in my view) declaring him ‘one of the earliest and greatest of the church's Pauline theologians’, and observing how Origen often read Old Testament passages through a Pauline or Johannine lens (pp. 10–11). Along with many modern scholars, McGuckin doubts that Origen had much knowledge of Hebrew, and thinks the Hebrew teacher Origen mentions was most likely a ‘Judaeo-Christia’. McGuckin places Origen in the company of the philosophers of his day, noting that, though ‘technically a Christian Middle Platonist’ Origen was also influenced by Aristotle and Pythagoras (we might add also the Stoics, who had already much impacted Christian ethics), seeing ‘at the heart of his life's work the weaving together of the philosophic and mystical imperatives’ (p. 5).
McGuckin's short introductions to Origen's major works combine attention to historical context with high praise for Origen's achievement in biblical exegesis and homiletics, as well as in apologetic and doctrinal writings. The most important of the former, contra Celsum, McGuckin regards as pushing Christian apologetic literature onto a whole new plane and purpose, and he proposes the work is meant as a kind of charter document for Origen's ‘Christian Schola’ at Caesarea to use in its ‘missionary outreach to contemporary Hellenist society’ (p. 33). In that spirit he lauds it as evidence of ‘Origen's serious engagement in honest intellectual debate’ (but then does admit in a telling parenthesis: ‘(as much as any ancient apologia was ever such a thing)’!). Origen's earliest writing, Peri archon (On First Principles), is judged by McGuckin to have provided the ‘point of departure’ ‘behind all the theological arguments of the next three centuries’ (p. 37).
‘The whole business is contagious’, McGuckin exclaims, in reference to how readers can track cross-references around the book until they start to know the terrain of Origenic studies by heart. Indeed! Very highly recommended.
