Todd Decker's Show Boat: Performing Race in an American Musical provocatively muddles popular and academic habits of segregating Broadway histories by race, arguing instead that a recalcitrant ‘dynamic of the color line’ binds musical theatre historiographies (p. 4). Decker traces this dynamic across Edna Ferber's 1926 serialized novel and Oscar Hammerstein II and Jerome Kern's musical adaptation of 1927, as well as through the numerous film adaptations and theatre revivals that follow. Meticulously reconstructing the creative and rehearsal processes for several productions, Decker is able to disclose an array of racial codes and meanings that emerge through performances of this interracial musical.
Decker divides his book into two parts: Part I explores Show Boat's construction, giving attention to the performing bodies that inspired the literary and musical development of the work; Part II traces the many incarnations that the work has received in theatre, film and studio recordings. By Decker's account, it is the performers who ‘shape’ the musical throughout its nearly century-long history, ‘forcing historical consideration of each version on its own terms’ (p. 6).
Decker follows two consistent threads in his readings of Show Boat to measure its relation to the colour line. He tracks the first, ‘Hammerstein's popular music plot’, across various Show Boat revivals, assessing whether Hammerstein's Act II plotlines concerning white appropriation of black cultural expressions are engaged or left aside. His second narrative thread, ‘Magnolia's black voice’, follows the implications of Show Boat's female (white) lead supposedly having ‘learned to sing … in unconscious imitation of the soft husky Negro voice of her teacher’ (p. 2), the boat's cook Queenie. In his consideration of each thread Decker evaluates how copresentations of black and white actors onstage, in diegesis and mimesis, allow musical and performance styling to be a factor constructing race rather than its performative product.
With relative accessibility and refreshing succinctness, Decker offers his reader a detailed portrait of how Show Boat has repeatedly invoked a discourse on race across the twentieth century. Along with the familiar characters of Show Boat's world (Florenz Ziegfeld, Arthur Freed, Paul Robeson, Helen Morgan, Ava Gardner, Irene Dunn and Hattie McDaniel), we meet an array of actors, singers and dancers whose performances have shifted the racial terms through which the musical was – and is – received. Using methods of music analysis, media ethnography and performance theory, the author displays the ways in which the inclusion of black and white casts in Show Boat have marked it ‘with the potential to address history as it passed by’, offering material evidence of how musical theatre creates and indexes its own racial archive (p. 249). Decker's contribution to theatre and drama studies, musicology, performance studies and critical race studies are many, and the possibilities that this work affords deserve recognition. The book provides a space to consider the intricacies of racial performance while never losing sight of the influence of theatrical representation and the limitations of the vocabulary of ‘black’ and/or ‘white’ casting.
