At first sight it is strange that Kathryn Lowerre's study of music and musicians in the London theatres begins in 1695, since that was the year of Henry Purcell's death, and Purcell is the only Restoration composer whose theatre music has been studied, edited, and performed to any great extent in modern times. In fact, as she argues in the Prologue, the starting point of her study makes a lot of sense: 1695 was the year in which a group of actors led by Thomas Betterton set up a company at Lincoln's Inn Fields in competition with the Patent Company at Drury Lane and Dorset Garden, whereas 1705 was the year in which an Italian opera company was established at the Haymarket Theatre, permanently changing London's theatrical scene. Lowerre's study builds on the work of Curtis Price's Music in the Restoration Theatre (1979) and Henry Purcell and the London Stage (1984), and is a useful supplement to Judith Milhous's classic book Thomas Betterton and the Management of Lincoln's Inn Fields, 1695–1708 (1979).
Lowerre's book is laid out in a simple but effective way. After the Prologue, which sets out the musical and theatrical background, there are chapters describing the various types of music used respectively in comedies and in “Musical Tragedies and Dramatick Operas”—the last being the type of play with elaborate operatic scenes that is often called semiopera today, best known from Purcell's King Arthur (1691) and The Fairy Queen (1692). Then follow blow-by-blow accounts of the theatrical seasons, divided into “Initiation, 1695–1697,” “Competition, 1697–1700,” “Power Shift, 1700–1703,” and “Realignment, 1703–1705.” There are also appendixes devoted to a “Glossary of Musical Terms and Concepts” and “Composers Active in the London Theaters, 1695–1705.” These will be more useful to those with a background in literature or the theatre rather than music.
These appendixes are indicative of Lowerre's approach as a whole. Her focus is on the role of music in plays rather than on the music itself, and she seems to be writing for the theatre historian rather than the musician, though the latter will undoubtedly find it useful to know what music survives for particular plays, and how particular pieces of music contributed to the effect of the drama. Furthermore, most of Lowerre's writing on the music is disappointingly mundane: she typically offers simple descriptions of individual pieces, more or less confined to naming the key, identifying the genre, and mentioning any particularly striking features. One longs for the sort of penetrating writing used so effectively by Price in Henry Purcell and the London Stage, which locates individual pieces in their musical as well as theatrical context, and seeks to explain in detail the composer's compositional choices. With Lowerre we do not get a clear idea of the style of even the most important theatrical composers of the decade, John Eccles, Daniel Purcell, and Gottfried Finger, and there is little attempt at a proper critical evaluation of the repertory, distinguishing good from bad.
The two main types of Restoration theatre music—the songs performed during plays and the suites of instrumental music played before plays began and between the acts—are treated rather differently in the book. It is good to have facsimiles of a number of the early prints of the songs, allowing one to assess them for oneself. However, the instrumental music, typically written for four-part strings, survives mostly in sets of individual parts, and therefore has to be put into score to be intelligible. None of it is illustrated in the book, with the single exception of the fine chaconne for two recorders and strings from Eccles's Rinaldo and Armida, unsatisfactorily represented by a facsimile of the separate parts of a two-part ‘skeleton’ version rather than the full score. Lowerre's brief and vague comments on the theatre suites make me suspect that she sometimes writes about music she has not seen in score, though there are some mysterious references to editions of some of them in Music in the Productions at London's Lincoln's Inn Fields Theater, 1695–1705. This item is not listed in the bibliography, though an Internet search reveals it to be Lowerre's 1997 Ph.D. dissertation from Duke University. Her failure to engage properly with theatre suites is unfortunate, since they are an important element of plays of the period, are frequently of high quality, are of interest to modern performers, and are in urgent need of informed critical appraisal.
There are some errors and omissions. Charles Dieupart is wrongly described as a violoncellist (he played the harpsichord and violin); Giuseppe Fedeli alias Saggione was a double bass player rather than a trombonist; Nicola Matteis senior is confused with his son, also Nicola; and the account of British Library, Add. MS 24889 is flawed (pp. 163–4). The parts for John Lenton's suite for “The Moor of Venice” (i.e., Othello) are autograph, which means that its alternative title, “Venice preserv'd,” in Royal College of Music, MS 1144, is likely to be an error. Also, Add. MS 24889 is a collection of unrelated sets of parts, not a single manuscript, so Lowerre's assumption that their position in the source can help with dating is unwarranted. The next item in the manuscript, an anonymous suite for Boyle's play Mustapha, Son of Solyman the Magnificent, was probably written for the original production in 1665 or for a revival soon after rather than in the 1690s. In general, Lowerre's treatment of the manuscript musical sources is perfunctory and sometimes out of date.
I do not wish to give the impression that Lowerre's book is fatally flawed. It is well written and generally well researched, and students of English literature will find it a useful corrective to the depressing tendency to regard Restoration plays just as spoken texts, while musicians will be led to some fine music suitable for performance, and to a deeper understanding of their function in the parent plays. Whether it will result in any stage productions of the works discussed is more doubtful. Perhaps, as with much French opera of the period, this fascinating repertory will find a new lease of life on CD.
